This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I think the question is would they still come. After all Buckingham Palace is what they see, not the queen. Without the Queen, you could be making a killing on tours of the entire building all year round. Even people in the UK would probably be up for a trip round Buck Palace. Its not like the Tower of London has got less interesting to tourists over the years. In reality, they're pretty much cosmetic, reasonably popular and do no harm with no political power. The only real damage they do is to their own gene pool
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
I think the question is would they still come. After all Buckingham Palace is what they see, not the queen. Without the Queen, you could be making a killing on tours of the entire building all year round. Even people in the UK would probably be up for a trip round Buck Palace. Its not like the Tower of London has got less interesting to tourists over the years. In reality, they're pretty much cosmetic, reasonably popular and do no harm with no political power. The only real damage they do is to their own gene pool I think Charles's secret letters, the ones he fought so hard to hide, are proof he isn't as neutral as he makes out.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JL85
I think Charles's secret letters, the ones he fought so hard to hide, are proof he isn't as neutral as he makes out. The interesting thing about this, I think, is that he was so concerned about them, that most people expected to find out they alluded to raping and murdering children, rather than his attempts to 'influence politics'. Its a classic case of negative spin, in which the actions of trying to control an issue, actually results in far more people taking an interest. I doubt many people who are 'pro-royal' really gave a s**t, they probably would like to see the royals doing more 'of that kind of thing'. As for the republicans, they wasted a s**t load of money and time, on something only republicans would actually give a s**t about. But then they couldn't really kick up much of a fuss when they protest that monarchs do nothing, and then complain about them involving themselves in politics. Someone in the media or PR should have read the letters, and told Charlie boy, that no one would actually give a t*ss, except the people who want to end the monarchy.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
But they also cost a lot as well. Possibly they do, but maintaining a Presidency would probably cost about the same and no one would come to this country just because we have a President. One of the attractions of this country id that it has living history in the form of the monarchy. It's romantic and people like it and it's often a big factor in attracting tourists. If we have to have a figurehead as Head of State, I'd rather it was HM than some time-serving, grubby, washed up, ex-politician as President. The benefits of keeping HM and the panoply of monarchy far, far outweigh the advantages of getting rid.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Possibly they do, but maintaining a Presidency would probably cost about the same and no one would come to this country just because we have a President. One of the attractions of this country id that it has living history in the form of the monarchy. It's romantic and people like it and it's often a big factor in attracting tourists. If we have to have a figurehead as Head of State, I'd rather it was HM than some time-serving, grubby, washed up, ex-politician as President. The benefits of keeping HM and the panoply of monarchy far, far outweigh the advantages of getting rid. Nail on head.
Time to move forward together. |
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Possibly they do, but maintaining a Presidency would probably cost about the same and no one would come to this country just because we have a President. One of the attractions of this country id that it has living history in the form of the monarchy. It's romantic and people like it and it's often a big factor in attracting tourists. If we have to have a figurehead as Head of State, I'd rather it was HM than some time-serving, grubby, washed up, ex-politician as President. The benefits of keeping HM and the panoply of monarchy far, far outweigh the advantages of getting rid. Not sure why, considering your head of state would be someone democratically elected. I'd prefer choice than Charles. I'd also argue that she holds almost no relevance to visit numbers. The history wouldn't just disappear if the Monarchy were abolished. In fact, if they were gone, we'd probably see more visitors due to the accessibility of all the residences and Palace's. It's not like she's that popular that she'll influence people to come here: Edited by JL85 (20 Apr 2016 7.41pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by JL85
Not sure why, considering your head of state would be someone democratically elected. I'd prefer choice than Charles. I'd also argue that she holds almost no relevance to visit numbers. The history wouldn't just disappear if the Monarchy were abolished. In fact, if they were gone, we'd probably see more visitors due to the accessibility of all the residences and Palace's. It's not like she's that popular that she'll influence people to come here: Edited by JL85 (20 Apr 2016 7.41pm)
Ironic, that if you put out a vote for abolishing the monarchy, it would, be a close vote, but, if you suggested replacing it with a republican structure, it would fail. Just like it did in Australia.
Most certainly not European. |
|
|
Originally posted by susmik
Your wrong as the DO bring a lot of dosh !! Go on then show me - figures...??? What the Royal family are are the Apex predators of a system designed to keep us in our place. They are the ultimate parasites
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014 |
|
|
Originally posted by moylerg
Ironic, that if you put out a vote for abolishing the monarchy, it would, be a close vote, but, if you suggested replacing it with a republican structure, it would fail. Just like it did in Australia. Obviously, if the public wanted it, not just because. Republic/democracy, don't they mean the same thing in different languages? Just want a democratically elected head of state/law makers etc. Edited by JL85 (20 Apr 2016 8.19pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by JL85
Obviously, if the public wanted it, not just because. Republic/democracy, don't they mean the same thing in different languages? Just want a democratically elected head of state/law makers etc. Edited by JL85 (20 Apr 2016 8.19pm) Australia has an elected prime minister, thereby is a democracy. It just refuted the opportunity to have a president instead of a head of state. The Governor General acts as the queen's representative, but, basically does not do too much. Unlike Prince William
Most certainly not European. |
|
|
Slacker or not, would you swap your life for his? I wouldn't. Poor blokes team just got relegated for starters.
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
Slacker or not, would you swap your life for his? I wouldn't. Poor blokes team just got relegated for starters. Probably - Its not a bad life really, although surely he supports 'Queen of the South' or Reading (from Royal Berkshire). Or Brussia Dortmond.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Originally posted by jamiemartin721
Probably - Its not a bad life really, although surely he supports 'Queen of the South' or Reading (from Royal Berkshire). Or Brussia Dortmond. I think Prince Edward is Queen of the South
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014 |
|
|
Originally posted by JL85
Obviously, if the public wanted it, not just because. Republic/democracy, don't they mean the same thing in different languages? Just want a democratically elected head of state/law makers etc. Edited by JL85 (20 Apr 2016 8.19pm) Who would be on your short list? Or can any bugger apply?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by susmik
I will reiterate once again seeing a you did not get it first time round. The Royals bring in millions of pound on their own both with visitors who do really like to see royalty and Buck house and all the pageantry that goes with it.... While this is true as an isolated fact, it doesn't support your argument because it presumes that if the Royals were disbanded, those tourists would no longer come. But the last time I looked, Versailles was jam-packed with tourists (in the absence of a French monarchy), the Winter Palace still packs them in (in the absence of the Romanov Dynasty) etc. etc. The plain truth is that the removal of Phil the Greek and his family would not end interest in Buckingham Palace, Windsor Castle, etc. Originally posted by susmik
Some of the Royals actually do go abroad to drum up business which AGAIN brings millions of pounds in and also creates jobs. As an added note they do pay taxes as well ..... Yes, they do but again, the problem is that your argument assumes there are no alternatives. There are, and possibly better ones. I mean, there are great many countries that have no Royal family (America comes to mind) that seem to manage to drum up rather more trade than Britain. In fact, you could argue that given the paucity of overseas investment we're generally able to atract, the Royal Family are not particularly effective performers in this role. And as for "they pay taxes..." well, they take handouts and pay some of their swag back. Can I have a job like that too, please? Originally posted by susmik
The part where I said you should go back to school is because you obviously did not pay attention to your history lessons when you were there or while you are there whatever the case may be. Books are a good source of knowledge to I'm not sure what you're implying here but history provides no argument for the continuation of the Royalty. Study it and you will learn about good monarchs and bad monarchs and, mostly, countries that have dispensed with an outdated monarchical system. But as ever with the English, we adopt the view of the world that best suits our traditional self-image, misplaced as that may be.
Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God. |
|
|
Originally posted by JL85
Obviously, if the public wanted it, not just because. Republic/democracy, don't they mean the same thing in different languages? Just want a democratically elected head of state/law makers etc. Edited by JL85 (20 Apr 2016 8.19pm) That's why we are having a EU referendum!!
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
Who would be on your short list? Or can any bugger apply? Who would be on my list? Whoever best represents the things I believe in. I'd happily accept President Cameron, so long as the electorate put him their.
|
|
| Hoof Hearted 21 Apr 16 3.30pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by JL85
Who would be on my list? Whoever best represents the things I believe in. I'd happily accept President Cameron, so long as the electorate put him their. .... put him their.... what?
|
|
|
Originally posted by JL85
Who would be on my list? Whoever best represents the things I believe in. I'd happily accept President Cameron, so long as the electorate put him their. Any politician would be a far less popular choice with the majority than the situation is now. Mental proposal.
Optimistic as ever |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.