You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tony Blair
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tony Blair


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Oct 16 1.06pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

Higher rate tax was 40%, now its 45%.....although the headline today is that the tax lock promised by Cameron was made 'on the hoof'...hmmm

You must be struggling - that's 45% on earnings over 150k.

 

JohnyBoy Flag 29 Oct 16 1.11pm

Originally posted by chris123

You must be struggling - that's 45% on earnings over 150k.

There were also working family tax credits under Blair, helping many families

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Oct 16 1.31pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

There were also working family tax credits under Blair, helping many families

We still have working tax credits don't we?

 

JohnyBoy Flag 29 Oct 16 1.38pm

Originally posted by chris123

We still have working tax credits don't we?

Yes we do thanks to Blair introducing them. Like i said i have my issues with Blair like i do with most PM's but my point is that he did many good things as well as making some mistakes. He was also the Labour party's most successful leader

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Oct 16 2.00pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

Yes we do thanks to Blair introducing them. Like i said i have my issues with Blair like i do with most PM's but my point is that he did many good things as well as making some mistakes. He was also the Labour party's most successful leader

My query was on your comment that taxes were lower, I don't think they were - and you are entitled to any opinion on TB you wish.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 29 Oct 16 2.44pm

Originally posted by collier row eagle

Trying to get another referendum so people can change their mind over brexit, listen mate, the ship has sailed, get over it, yesterdays man and war criminal, f**k off

What gets me about his latest outburst is that before 23rd June he never once said that if we voted to leave we would need another referendum to approve - or reject - the terms. Now that he's lost, he tries to make having a second vote sound the most obvious and reasonable thing in the world.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 29 Oct 16 4.03pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

Uk declared their zone of conflict of 200miles but never decalared 'war', therefore making it at best 'excusable' legally but 'intent' to send 200 sailors to their deaths is a war crime

I think you need to study the sinking in more detail as you have got it all wrong:

The area where General Belgrano sank is classified as a War Grave under Argentine Congress Law. In August 1994, an official Argentine Defence Ministry report written by armed forces auditor Eugenio Miari was released which described the sinking of the Belgrano as "a legal act of war", explaining that "acts of war can be carried out in all of the enemy's territory" and "they can also take place in those areas over which no state can claim sovereignty, in international waters". Argentinian veterans were said to be dismayed at the conclusion about the Belgrano and the President of the Federation of Argentine War Veterans Luis Ibáñez hoped to produce more witnesses to show that the sinking was a war crime.
In 1999, Sir Michael Boyce, First Sea Lord of the Royal Navy, visited the Puerto Belgrano naval base and paid tribute to those who died. In 2003 a search team aboard Seacor Lenga, crewed by Argentine and British veterans, was sponsored by National Geographic to find the sunken cruiser but failed to locate the ship.
In 2000, lawyers representing the families of the sailors killed onboard General Belgrano attempted to sue the British Government in the European Court of Human Rights on the grounds that the attack took place outside the exclusion zone. It was an attempt to pressure the Argentine government to lodge an action against the UK in the International Court of Justice, but was ruled inadmissible by the Court of Human Rights on the grounds that it had been submitted too late.
La Nación published a reader's letter from Admiral Enrique Molina Pico (head of the Argentine Navy in the 1990s) in 2005 in which Pico wrote that General Belgrano was part of an operation that posed a real threat to the British task force, but was holding off for tactical reasons. Pico added that "To leave the exclusion zone was not to leave the combat zone to enter a protected area". Pico explicitly stated that the sinking was not a war crime, but a combat action.
General Belgrano's captain, Héctor Bonzo, died on 22 April 2009, aged 76. He had spent his last years working for an association called Amigos del Crucero General Belgrano (Friends of the Cruiser General Belgrano) whose purpose was to help those affected by the sinking. Captain Bonzo also wrote his memories about the sinking in the book 1093 Tripulantes del Crucero ARA General Belgrano, published in 1992. In this book he wrote that it is "improper to accept that (...) the attack by HMS Conqueror was a betrayal".During an interview in 2003 he had stated that General Belgrano was only temporarily sailing to the west at the time of the attack, and his orders were to attack any British ships which came within range of the cruiser's armament.
In late 2011, Major David Thorp, a former British military intelligence officer who led the signals intercept team aboard HMS Intrepid, released the book The Silent Listener detailing the role of intelligence in the Falklands War. In the book he stated that despite the fact that General Belgrano was observed by Conqueror sailing away from the Falklands at the time of the attack, she had actually been ordered to proceed to a rendezvous point within the Exclusion Zone. A report prepared by Thorp for Thatcher several months after the incident stated the destination of the vessel was not to her home port as the Argentine Junta stated; the report was not released because the Prime Minister did not want to compromise British signals intelligence capabilities.
In 2012 the President of Argentina, Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, referred to the sinking of General Belgrano as a "war crime". However, the Argentine Navy has historically held the view that the sinking was a legitimate act of war, a position that was asserted by the Argentine Navy before various courts in 1995."

So as you can see even the Argies say it was not a war crime so how you can see it differently JohnyBoy is way beyond me and millions of others including the Argentines!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

JohnyBoy Flag 29 Oct 16 4.42pm

Originally posted by susmik

I think you need to study the sinking in more detail as you have got it all wrong:

The area where General Belgrano sank is classified as a War Grave under Argentine Congress Law. In August 1994, an official Argentine Defence Ministry report written by armed forces auditor Eugenio Miari was released which described the sinking of the Belgrano as "a legal act of war", explaining that "acts of war can be carried out in all of the enemy's territory" and "they can also take place in those areas over which no state can claim sovereignty, in international waters". Argentinian veterans were said to be dismayed at the conclusion about the Belgrano and the President of the Federation of Argentine War Veterans Luis Ibáñez hoped to produce more witnesses to show that the sinking was a war crime.
In 1999, Sir Michael Boyce, First Sea Lord of the Royal Navy, visited the Puerto Belgrano naval base and paid tribute to those who died. In 2003 a search team aboard Seacor Lenga, crewed by Argentine and British veterans, was sponsored by National Geographic to find the sunken cruiser but failed to locate the ship.
In 2000, lawyers representing the families of the sailors killed onboard General Belgrano attempted to sue the British Government in the European Court of Human Rights on the grounds that the attack took place outside the exclusion zone. It was an attempt to pressure the Argentine government to lodge an action against the UK in the International Court of Justice, but was ruled inadmissible by the Court of Human Rights on the grounds that it had been submitted too late.
La Nación published a reader's letter from Admiral Enrique Molina Pico (head of the Argentine Navy in the 1990s) in 2005 in which Pico wrote that General Belgrano was part of an operation that posed a real threat to the British task force, but was holding off for tactical reasons. Pico added that "To leave the exclusion zone was not to leave the combat zone to enter a protected area". Pico explicitly stated that the sinking was not a war crime, but a combat action.
General Belgrano's captain, Héctor Bonzo, died on 22 April 2009, aged 76. He had spent his last years working for an association called Amigos del Crucero General Belgrano (Friends of the Cruiser General Belgrano) whose purpose was to help those affected by the sinking. Captain Bonzo also wrote his memories about the sinking in the book 1093 Tripulantes del Crucero ARA General Belgrano, published in 1992. In this book he wrote that it is "improper to accept that (...) the attack by HMS Conqueror was a betrayal".During an interview in 2003 he had stated that General Belgrano was only temporarily sailing to the west at the time of the attack, and his orders were to attack any British ships which came within range of the cruiser's armament.
In late 2011, Major David Thorp, a former British military intelligence officer who led the signals intercept team aboard HMS Intrepid, released the book The Silent Listener detailing the role of intelligence in the Falklands War. In the book he stated that despite the fact that General Belgrano was observed by Conqueror sailing away from the Falklands at the time of the attack, she had actually been ordered to proceed to a rendezvous point within the Exclusion Zone. A report prepared by Thorp for Thatcher several months after the incident stated the destination of the vessel was not to her home port as the Argentine Junta stated; the report was not released because the Prime Minister did not want to compromise British signals intelligence capabilities.
In 2012 the President of Argentina, Cristina Fernández de Kirchner, referred to the sinking of General Belgrano as a "war crime". However, the Argentine Navy has historically held the view that the sinking was a legitimate act of war, a position that was asserted by the Argentine Navy before various courts in 1995."

So as you can see even the Argies say it was not a war crime so how you can see it differently JohnyBoy is way beyond me and millions of others including the Argentines!!

Very good analysis Susmik. I would have liked to see an inquiry (similar to Chilcott) on this issue as there are differing opinions and because there are many (argies and Brits) who believe it was a war crime. Whilst i agreed with the Falklands war, i do not agree with killing servicemen outside the exclusion zone. We may have to agree to differ

 

elgrande Flag bedford 29 Oct 16 4.55pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

Very good analysis Susmik. I would have liked to see an inquiry (similar to Chilcott) on this issue as there are differing opinions and because there are many (argies and Brits) who believe it was a war crime. Whilst i agreed with the Falklands war, i do not agree with killing servicemen outside the exclusion zone. We may have to agree to differ

Number 1,the Chilcott inquiry was a complete waste of time and a huge amount of tax payers money.
Number 2, who are all these British people who think it was a war crime.
I suppose it's Corbyn and his merry band of hating everything british brigade.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 29 Oct 16 4.58pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy

Very good analysis Susmik. I would have liked to see an inquiry (similar to Chilcott) on this issue as there are differing opinions and because there are many (argies and Brits) who believe it was a war crime. Whilst i agreed with the Falklands war, do not agree with killing servicemen outside the exclusion zone. We may have to agree to differ

It was not an analysis it was the actual facts and having been there with 41 Cdo RM I do know what I am talking about. If you had bothered to read my post you would have seen the Belgrano was sunk whilst doing a pincer movement on our ships. You are not an Argie by any chance are you????

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

JohnyBoy Flag 29 Oct 16 5.25pm

Originally posted by susmik

It was not an analysis it was the actual facts and having been there with 41 Cdo RM I do know what I am talking about. If you had bothered to read my post you would have seen the Belgrano was sunk whilst doing a pincer movement on our ships. You are not an Argie by any chance are you????


Err no i am not an argie...and i read way back that the Belgrano had been ordered back to buenos Aires although the intention was that it would return. There are many differing accounts. But i am not saying that those who went to the Falklands are in any way culpable, just the order that came directly from Downing street

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 29 Oct 16 7.22pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy


Err no i am not an argie...and i read way back that the Belgrano had been ordered back to buenos Aires although the intention was that it would return. There are many differing accounts. But i am not saying that those who went to the Falklands are in any way culpable, just the order that came directly from Downing street

Just stop mate. Youre an embarassment.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 29 Oct 16 7.35pm

Originally posted by JohnyBoy


Err no i am not an argie...and i read way back that the Belgrano had been ordered back to buenos Aires although the intention was that it would return. There are many differing accounts. But i am not saying that those who went to the Falklands are in any way culpable, just the order that came directly from Downing street

I say again READ THE FACTS which you can find online yourself and it is not very hard to find. I lost a good few mates and saw some great ships with crews get hit and go down. The Belgrano was out to kill even more of our blokes and was not going back top base at all, it was doing a pincer movement to which the top Naval Argentine admiral has admitted many times and has said that we did not commit any crime in sinking the their ship.
Please stop telling us we did a war crime because we did not, and Maggie was quite right in telling our sub to sink it as she did.

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

nhp61 Flag Goring-By-Sea born, now in Brackne... 29 Oct 16 9.38pm

All this stuff about the General Belgrano ( Which I personally think was justifiably sunk) doesn't alter the fact that Tony Blair is a self serving lying deluded c***.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 30 Oct 16 8.20am

Originally posted by nhp61

All this stuff about the General Belgrano ( Which I personally think was justifiably sunk) doesn't alter the fact that Tony Blair is a self serving lying deluded c***.

I agree with you on that one I really do!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Hoof Hearted 30 Oct 16 9.17am

I'm sorry Johnny, but Blair's term in office as PM was an unmitigated disaster for our country that we're still paying for now!

The worst thing he did was to waive the 7 year veto on allowing Poles and other East Europeans to move to the UK. Germany and other larger nations didn't.... that's why we have such a large population of Polish people here now which has caused problems with infrastructure and has driven down wages. Both of these problems have hit the poor/working class - that's why they voted for Brexit.

The schools/hospitals that he sanctioned to be built were funded by PFI. See the attached link.

[Link]

He was responsible for the commissioning of the Millennium Dome - what an expensive white elephant that was!

The fact is, that by the end of the 13 years Blair and Brown ran this country, it was ran into the ground... despite them taking over a healthy economy and having favourable economic conditions early on in their tenure. But instead of saving something for a rainy day, they sold our gold reserves cheaply and saddled us with debt.

I won't even bother to go into the details about his lies "sexing up" the weapons of mass destruction that led to us going to war with Iraq and the problems that has now caused us.

The bloke is/was an arsehole continually lying and looking out for himself and his family - he couldn't give 2 fcuks about the welfare of this country and it's people.

I mostly blame the people of Sedgefield that voted him in as an MP in the first place!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 30 Oct 16 10.34am

I am glad that Blair wants another referendum because he is the best example yet of the self serving scum that want to overturn democracy so they can get richer than they already are at our expense.

Thanks for making it plain for the doubters Tony.

 

Hoof Hearted 30 Oct 16 10.50am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I am glad that Blair wants another referendum because he is the best example yet of the self serving scum that want to overturn democracy so they can get richer than they already are at our expense.

Thanks for making it plain for the doubters Tony.

Sadly he's not alone Hrolf.

Tim Farron (had to look his name up he's that popular) the leader of the LibDems is angling for this too putting them on a "war footing" for a General Election and make gains in MP seats.

Not sure about a desire to be richer, but Nicola Sturgeon (aka wee Jimmy Krankie) is angling for this too with a view to strengthening her and the SNP's claim for Scottish Independence.

All sorts of chancers and opportunists have surfaced or will surface to make capital of this situation for their own ends.

I must admit I agree with you though and Blair's endorsement of the need for a 2nd referendum should clarify the fact that it is NOT required in the minds of at least 90% of the UK population.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Oct 16 10.56am

Blair....the minimum wage helped low paid working people but then he totally screwed them by large scale immigration.

He would have had us in the Euro as well.

I don't blame him for supporting the US in the Iraqi and Afghanistan wars but I do partly blame him for their inept handling.

We had to run out of Basra .....No British army should have to run out of anywhere.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 30 Oct 16 5.18pm

Nobody speaks unkindly of 'Desert Storm' but isn't it rich that Bush Senior and John Major ended the campaign letting Sadaam go scot free to continue the mayhem in Iraq?

I heard Mrs.Thatcher give this view 'the job not done' and unfinished business it turned out to be.

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tony Blair