This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Tomkins
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
speediej Northampton 29 Oct 16 11.15pm |
|
|
In my opinion, Delaney should start over him. I don't think Tomkins is very good at all. Not trying to find an excuse for yet another loss, but I have thought this for weeks, he is rubbish...
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 29 Oct 16 11.19pm |
|
|
He is a decent defender but it turns out as I suspected he let his marker escape him for the goal from the corner and the final goal debacle. He needs sorting out. They either need a defensive coach or someone who demands high standards and concentration.
COYP
|
Mad4palace 29 Oct 16 11.34pm |
|
|
Poor today, poor against Leicester but we can't keep chopping and changing it at the back. Need to build a partnership between him and Dann.
|
slubglurge welling 29 Oct 16 11.39pm |
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
He is a decent defender but it turns out as I suspected he let his marker escape him for the goal from the corner and the final goal debacle. He needs sorting out. They either need a defensive coach or someone who demands high standards and concentration.
He was no worse than Dann who also lost his man at a corner for their 2nd goal
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 29 Oct 16 11.48pm |
|
|
No presence and slow.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 29 Oct 16 11.56pm |
|
Originally posted by Mad4palace
Poor today, poor against Leicester but we can't keep chopping and changing it at the back. Need to build a partnership between him and Dann.
Right.
COYP
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 29 Oct 16 11.58pm |
|
Originally posted by slubglurge
He was no worse than Dann who also lost his man at a corner for their 2nd goal
Dann didn't lose his man. It looked looked like he was underneath him but it looks as though he had his shirt pulled and was jumped on top of.
COYP
|
Inapickle South West 29 Oct 16 11.59pm |
|
Originally posted by speediej
In my opinion, Delaney should start over him. I don't think Tomkins is very good at all. Not trying to find an excuse for yet another loss, but I have thought this for weeks, he is rubbish...
..west Ham fans liked him and many were very sad to see him go.
|
Dixie Eagle Chatham 30 Oct 16 12.02am |
|
|
He wasn't very good at West Ham and they let him leave for a reason. I still prefer Dammo over him.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 30 Oct 16 12.12am |
|
Originally posted by Dixie Eagle
He wasn't very good at West Ham and they let him leave for a reason. I still prefer Dammo over him.
Let's not sign anyone then in the league we're in.
COYP
|
palace chick South Croydon 30 Oct 16 1.03am |
|
|
Our defence is the problem for sure. We have let goals in badly for most of this season due to the back four making mistakes. I don't believe Tomkins and Dann are a good pairing. Dann is the better of the two and should be playing alongside Delaney. That's until we get a decent centre back to play alongside Dann. Perhaps we should put Tomkins at right back for a few games with Ward at left back. However a new centre and left back is urgently required in the next window. Until then we will struggle with our current defenders. It's no good playing well going forward as we have done in our last two and a half matches and shipping eight goals. Delaney and Dann need to stay as our main pairing in the middle but I do realise Delaney is coming to the end of a great Palace time - One of our best servants in recent times.
|
pieceofcake Cell 36,HMP Albany 30 Oct 16 1.44am |
|
|
I think it's a tad early to assess Tomkins,but IMHO he is a quality centre back who,I hope,will soon show his worth.
He has still yet to get much gametime with Dann,and yesterday had to contend with a weakened left defensive flank.I don't think I'm alone in my assessment of Kelly as a left back,and playing Chungy in front of him weakened the left flank further.This is not a critisism of Chungy,as this was not his best position and certainly not his best role.
I think if Delaney had played he would probably have given away a couple of penalties in the first half alone. He is now too slow and too many of his passes go astray.
|
sprites Auckland 30 Oct 16 2.32am |
|
|
Guys guys guys...Delany is last year's news. Love him. But we've got the look forward. Tomkins got blocked by a bunch of players today and couldn't get round in time. Was unfortunate and a mistake which I'm sure he'll learn from. But he's the future with SD...so let's persist. We could do with a special defense coach though.
|
louis01 Llandudno 30 Oct 16 6.30am |
|
|
West Ham didn't want him to leave. He wanted to go as he wasn't guaranteed first team football. I think he is a good ball playing defender. He just needs a few games to form a partnership with Dann.
It's all fun and games until someone loses an eye!
|
Elpis In a pub 30 Oct 16 6.41am |
|
|
I don't think the questions about Tomkins ,Dann or any other defender (I think they are all very good -competent ) would arise if the Goalkeeper did his job. It seems like a modern trend for all keepers that they don't come and deal with corners. Come on both Liverpool goals from corners ended with headers from six yards out I would suggest someone has a word with Woodman .
|
Nobbybm Dartford 30 Oct 16 7.41am |
|
Originally posted by Elpis
I don't think the questions about Tomkins ,Dann or any other defender (I think they are all very good -competent ) would arise if the Goalkeeper did his job. It seems like a modern trend for all keepers that they don't come and deal with corners. Come on both Liverpool goals from corners ended with headers from six yards out I would suggest someone has a word with Woodman .
A few of us were saying this at the game - considering his reputation for punching the ball back yo the half way line, Steeeve really doesn't seem to want to come for crosses/corners.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!
|
phillanth London 30 Oct 16 2.41pm |
|
|
Obviously our defending yesterday was atrocious, but I hope Punch, Cabaye Townsend etc will be studying videos of Coutinho's corner-taking technique. He fires his at pace into the penalty area but curling away away from the the keeper while ours just seem to be floated gently into the six yard box into the grateful hands of the opposing keeper.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Oct 16 2.53pm |
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
A few of us were saying this at the game - considering his reputation for punching the ball back yo the half way line, Steeeve really doesn't seem to want to come for crosses/corners.
He certainly seems to be very much a "Line goalkeeper" and maybe this is the reason we have been conceding from set-plays. Just my opinion - I have not yet seen anything to suggest that he is an improvement on Hennessey.
|
Petereagle Brockley 30 Oct 16 3.18pm |
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
He is a decent defender but it turns out as I suspected he let his marker escape him for the goal from the corner and the final goal debacle. He needs sorting out. They either need a defensive coach or someone who demands high standards and concentration.
The CB defending yesterday was woeful. Its gotta improve. Both Tomkins and Dann have been injured, and maynot be matchfit for a while, so lets hope they get much better pdq
|
sickboy Deal or Croydon 30 Oct 16 3.57pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
He certainly seems to be very much a "Line goalkeeper" and maybe this is the reason we have been conceding from set-plays. Just my opinion - I have not yet seen anything to suggest that he is an improvement on Hennessey.
Couldnt agree more. WH never stood a chance with some as he took the place of speroni, now he has to fight against the steeeeve mentality. Wouldnt blame the bloke for moving on.
|