You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Fifa and the poppy saga
November 22 2026 12.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Fifa and the poppy saga


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 03 Nov 16 7.01pm

This year, I will wear a poppy for the last time

[Link]

 

corkery Flag Cork City 03 Nov 16 7.11pm

Looks like the FAI are getting fined for something similar.

 


We'll never die

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 03 Nov 16 10.05pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

This year, I will wear a poppy for the last time

[Link]

Well bully for you.

The fact is that Governments in the West particularly have realised that huge war casualties are not acceptable to the public. Vietnam was probably the final straw.
Many men were sacrificed in needless ways during a number of wars, particularly WW1 and their sacrifice should not be forgotten in order to make some political point. While humans exist there will always be conflict.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 03 Nov 16 10.08pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Well bully for you.

The fact is that Governments in the West particularly have realised that huge war casualties are not acceptable to the public. Vietnam was probably the final straw.
Many men were sacrificed in needless ways during a number of wars, particularly WW1 and their sacrifice should not be forgotten in order to make some political point. While humans exist there will always be conflict.


Whoosh. Read the link.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 03 Nov 16 10.19pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


Whoosh. Read the link.

I did.

Let's be honest. Wearing the poppy or not wearing the poppy or any other act or lack of it can be construed as political.
I don't blame any veteran for being resentful. I bloody would be. We must all do what we feel is appropriate. We all have ou own sentiments about war and that is fine. There is no high ground on this as far as I'm concerned.

 

HeathMan Flag Purley 03 Nov 16 11.55pm

Sadly, poppies have become must have items, rather than decision items. Personally, I like to decide to buy and wear a poppy in recognition of the fallen - and those whose lives have been changed so they need Royal British Legion help. Seeing public images of people who have been dressed (news readers, actors in soap operas, anyone providing sporting entertainment) is a disappointment.

I would far rather see people showing individual (individually purchased) poppies whether pinned to shirts, shorts or temporarily tattooed to skin as an indication of respect for the fallen, instead of a poppy that has been provided.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Nov 16 12.11am

It only takes a very cursory bit of investigation to find that the rules aren't drawn up by FIFA at all, but actually by a body called the International Football Association Board (IFAB).

It turns out that IFAB is made up of four representatives of FIFA and one member each from the four British football associations (England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland). So that's 50% of the votes for British football officials, and 50% of the votes for the rest of the footballing world combined!

Given that it takes a 75% majority decision to introduce or amend a rule of the game, it's absolutely beyond doubt that British football officials approved the rule to ban political symbolism from international football fixtures, which makes Theresa May's xenophobic "how dare these pesky foreigners tell us what to do?" rhetoric look more than a little bit thin
[Link]

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 04 Nov 16 12.12am

Originally posted by HeathMan

Sadly, poppies have become must have items, rather than decision items. Personally, I like to decide to buy and wear a poppy in recognition of the fallen - and those whose lives have been changed so they need Royal British Legion help. Seeing public images of people who have been dressed (news readers, actors in soap operas, anyone providing sporting entertainment) is a disappointment.

I would far rather see people showing individual (individually purchased) poppies whether pinned to shirts, shorts or temporarily tattooed to skin as an indication of respect for the fallen, instead of a poppy that has been provided.

Along the same lines...
[Link]

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Nov 16 12.24am

Originally posted by Mapletree

My grandad got blown up at Vimy Ridge, they patched him up and sent him back to war. Afterwards he said it was an awful waste and deeply resented having been sent to war and losing the use of his leg.

My father got shrapnel wounds at Monte Casino.

It was important to them to remember lost comrades. And they respected the 'enemy's' right to do the same.

To me this is not political, it is remembrance without critique. Decrying the concept is like saying you can't do anything special for the Day of the Dead in Mexico.

It's what we do, it isn't advertising, it isn't political and it's important.

Edited by Mapletree (03 Nov 2016 4.33pm)

Monte Casino. Tough old gut.

Tough men. Real men. Respect to him and all.

My Grandad volunteered at nearly 30 and was captured at Tobruk. POW on the South German/Poland border. Stalag 8. Made to walk all the way home virtually, eating grass and people dying on the roadside on the way. This should be remembered. If it wasn't for them there would be no FIFA. Just fixed results for Germany to win and Austria to come 2nd.

Some do see it as a show of national pride rather than remembrance and respect though.

 


COYP

Hoof Hearted 04 Nov 16 8.44am

Originally posted by Mapletree

My grandad got blown up at Vimy Ridge, they patched him up and sent him back to war. Afterwards he said it was an awful waste and deeply resented having been sent to war and losing the use of his leg.

My father got shrapnel wounds at Monte Casino.

It was important to them to remember lost comrades. And they respected the 'enemy's' right to do the same.

To me this is not political, it is remembrance without critique. Decrying the concept is like saying you can't do anything special for the Day of the Dead in Mexico.

It's what we do, it isn't advertising, it isn't political and it's important.

Edited by Mapletree (03 Nov 2016 4.33pm)

Exactly Maple..... Remembrance.... plain and simple....

Glad to see that "steeleye20" has now stopped his provocative petty sniping on this thread.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 04 Nov 16 9.27am

Originally posted by steeleye20

Fifa right.

Nothing to stop swastikas and other nasties if they allow it.

The black arm band denotes the captain there is no need for anything more.

Playing to the gallery PM.

Poppy police stopped me this morning I am still not wearing one, cheap gimmicks.

You are either being deliberately antagonistic or a t***, probably the latter

Poppy's are not political, they are a symbol (one of many) for Remembrance & Armistice Day. Many other countries also use the poppy. Many other countries also commemorate Armistice, Veterans, Remembrance day whatever you want to call it throughout November.

There is an argument that the wearing of a poppy has been politicised over recent year, FIFA have just successfully politicised it even more.

The cheap gimmick you refer to is used to raise millions every year [Link]

So while you may disagree with them you don't have to be a complete f***ing arse

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Nov 16 9.41am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Well bully for you.

The fact is that Governments in the West particularly have realised that huge war casualties are not acceptable to the public. Vietnam was probably the final straw.
Many men were sacrificed in needless ways during a number of wars, particularly WW1 and their sacrifice should not be forgotten in order to make some political point. While humans exist there will always be conflict.

Oddly Vietnam, for a full scale war, had surprisingly low casualties, given the length of deployment the US had there. Around 55,000 US servicemen were killed. Vietnam I think was a major issue though, not because the numbers, but because the US lost the war - effectively meaning those young men died in vain.

The problem is the sacrifice is important to remember but so is the reason why. Whilst WWII and WWI (to a lesser extent) were 'necessary' for the direct survival of the country, modern conflict tend to have been for far more abstracted reasons - often that seem to have more with foreign policy influence, markets and corporate interests, than the security of the UK and the country.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Nov 16 9.43am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

You are either being deliberately antagonistic or a t***, probably the latter

Poppy's are not political, they are a symbol (one of many) for Remembrance & Armistice Day. Many other countries also use the poppy. Many other countries also commemorate Armistice, Veterans, Remembrance day whatever you want to call it throughout November.

There is an argument that the wearing of a poppy has been politicised over recent year, FIFA have just successfully politicised it even more.

The cheap gimmick you refer to is used to raise millions every year [Link]

So while you may disagree with them you don't have to be a complete f***ing arse

These days, if your in the public eye, not wearing a poppy throughout the period of their sale is very much a political issue, with media and social network groups very quick to jump on the idea of 'not supporting the troops' etc - which is a tragic shame.

That said, FIFA are wrong. The option to wear a poppy should lie with each individual player, and be their choice.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 04 Nov 16 9.47am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Oddly Vietnam, for a full scale war, had surprisingly low casualties, given the length of deployment the US had there. Around 55,000 US servicemen were killed. Vietnam I think was a major issue though, not because the numbers, but because the US lost the war - effectively meaning those young men died in vain.

The problem is the sacrifice is important to remember but so is the reason why. Whilst WWII and WWI (to a lesser extent) were 'necessary' for the direct survival of the country, modern conflict tend to have been for far more abstracted reasons - often that seem to have more with foreign policy influence, markets and corporate interests, than the security of the UK and the country.

Well over a million died.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 04 Nov 16 9.52am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

These days, if your in the public eye, not wearing a poppy throughout the period of their sale is very much a political issue, with media and social network groups very quick to jump on the idea of 'not supporting the troops' etc - which is a tragic shame.

That said, FIFA are wrong. The option to wear a poppy should lie with each individual player, and be their choice.


I think it was Jon Snow who always bought a poppy, but didn't wear it on tv.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Nov 16 9.53am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

These days, if your in the public eye, not wearing a poppy throughout the period of their sale is very much a political issue, with media and social network groups very quick to jump on the idea of 'not supporting the troops' etc - which is a tragic shame.

That said, FIFA are wrong. The option to wear a poppy should lie with each individual player, and be their choice.

But those who choose NOT to wear one when the rest of the team are adorning them are villified and pilloried. I am thinking of James McClean of WBA.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 04 Nov 16 10.02am

Originally posted by npn

Perversely, I was really pleased that FIFA didn't back down, purely because it gives the FA and SFA a chance to do what they believe is right anyway, and to hell with the consequences.

Let's be honest, the next World Cup was sold by the corrupt-to-the-core FIFA anyway, and I'd be perfectly happy to not take part in Russia.

So I say we say "thanks for your opinion FIFA, we are doing it anyway - let us know what the punishment is when you've decided and we'll decide whether we are paying any fine later"

I really hope that we do go ahead and wear them and I'll be interested to see what FIFA slap us with after. Probably a heftier fine than some other European countries get for making monkey noises at black players or organised hooliganism.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Nov 16 10.17am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Oddly Vietnam, for a full scale war, had surprisingly low casualties, given the length of deployment the US had there. Around 55,000 US servicemen were killed. Vietnam I think was a major issue though, not because the numbers, but because the US lost the war - effectively meaning those young men died in vain.

The problem is the sacrifice is important to remember but so is the reason why. Whilst WWII and WWI (to a lesser extent) were 'necessary' for the direct survival of the country, modern conflict tend to have been for far more abstracted reasons - often that seem to have more with foreign policy influence, markets and corporate interests, than the security of the UK and the country.

Jamie, it was the 1st war with the coverage. If not it wouldn't have had so many objectors.

 


COYP

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 04 Nov 16 10.36am

I actually view our tinpot dictator PM's making political capital of this as 'outrageous'.

Wear your poppy with pride or not its nothing to do with her.

I am sniping again this time at Dodgy Dave looking for his Tory war in Syria - he didn't get it thanks to parliament.

The price of peace eternal vigilance - not just abroad but at home too.

Thank you to Harold Wilson for keeping us out of Vietnam.


 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 04 Nov 16 10.45am

Originally posted by chris123

Well over a million died.

55,280 US Servicemen according to US statistics, of which 40,934 were killed in Action and an additional 122 presumed dead (of which 32 have been confirmed). Of the 55280 1201 were declared dead (MIA's etc).

178 died in Thailand!

An additional 5299 died as a result of wounds received in action (to the 40,934).

The state in the US with the highest number of casualties was California (5575)

[Link]

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Fifa and the poppy saga