You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The importance of Ledley and McArthur
November 16 2026 11.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The importance of Ledley and McArthur


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Mr_Flow Flag London 07 Dec 16 12.29pm

It's just dawned on me that we've only won one point this season (Bournemouth) when Joe Ledley and James McArthur haven't been played together this season. I was quite surprised with this. Whilst McArthur gets lots of plaudits, and rightly so, Ledley always seems to slip under the radar. Does this make them our two most important players?

It also made me wonder if this team is still only able to play with two defensive minded centre midfielders playing in front of the back four? Holloway tried to change this in the promotion season and the defence looked shaky to say the least. Pardew seems to be trying to change that style as well, and results have had a similar turn.

N.B This isn't a slant on Yohan Cabaye by the way. I think he's a great player, we just haven't quite got the system to work for him.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 07 Dec 16 12.36pm

I think i'm right in saying that the win % with Ledley instead of Cabaye is much higher.

I've also noticed that Puncheon is a different player when Cabaye is not on the Field, he was Superb against Southampton and Wilfs tracking back was fantastic.

I reckon we try an sell Cabaye in the Window, give someone else a go.

Never really done it for us, despite the reputation, and if we appear to play better without him, cash in while we can.

Put it this way, I'd be selling him before Ledley, or Jimmy Mac.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 07 Dec 16 12.39pm

And in the last Wales game (vs Serbia) Joe Ledley took corners and some free kicks with his deadly left foot. Says a lot about his quality - just play him!!!!

 

East Ren Eagle Flag Glasgow 07 Dec 16 12.43pm

Agree wholeheartedly. That's not to say Cabaye is a poor Player but it really hasn't worked for Palace. We always play better with Ledley & Jimmy Mac starting, and Punch is always MOTM when Cabaye doesn't play.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 07 Dec 16 1.26pm

Have to say I think the critism of cabaye is a bit harsh. First half of last season he and macarthur were great playing as a defensive midfield pair. It wasn't until macarthur got injured that cabayes form dropped, plus I think he was carrying an injury 2nd half of season. This season I don't think APs new tactics have suited him as he doesn't seem to know when he should be going forward or defending and has often been caught out of position. I think if he and macarthur were to go back to being a defensive partnership (much as they did against man city) he'd come into his own again.

Edited by spartakev2 (07 Dec 2016 1.28pm)

 

Sherlock Holmesdale Flag Milton Keynes 07 Dec 16 1.44pm

If Cabaye is fit I'd drop Ledley in a heartbeat. He is a class above Ledley and I think it was more the change of style/shape employed against Southampton rather than the change of player that resulted in us getting the win.

Cabaye has been playing well recently and I thought he, Puncheon and McArthur all played well in the City match together.

I don't understand all the sudden Ledley love in. Works hard and is decent in the air but is limited going forward.

The lack of movement further up the pitch stifles Cabaye as he often has few options ahead of him to release the ball to

 

Mad4palace Flag 07 Dec 16 2.10pm

Ledley can become very exposed against teams that press high and play quickly. Against Liverpool he was awful. Southampton suited him because they didn't press and played the ball around quite slowly. I think against a 4-5-1 we can play Ledley, against 4-4-2 or 4-3-3 he can struggle as those formations are generally geared towards a higher press. Moving McArthur back to CM/CDM has improved us defensively, Swansea game aside, but we still do need a proper CDM in my opinion. Right now I'd accept selling Cabaye to bring in Dembele or Schneiderlin.


I find it interesting how often Ledley looks around him, checking for the opposition and space. It's become sort of a catch 22 as it makes him more aware of his surroundings but at the same time it means he takes his eye off the ball, leading to players pressuring him, stealing the ball and forcing him to panic. I think that is part of why he struggles against the high press added to his sometimes laughable lack of athletism.

Edited by Mad4palace (07 Dec 2016 2.18pm)

 

salop-eagle Flag 07 Dec 16 2.23pm

On Holmesdale Radio they said we hadn't won a point this season when Ledley didn't start.

Equally we haven't won a point this season when Cabaye did start!

An interesting stat?

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 07 Dec 16 2.36pm

Cabaye looked quite a bit improved against Swansea, and it's undeniable that he has greater technical ability than Ledley - but we really can't justify changing the team at the moment. In the long run, it'll be a real shame if we're so incapable of getting the best out of Cabaye that Ledley is preferable (no offence to Ledley) - but for most of his time here, Cabaye has looked like he lacks the class we know he has.

 

Mad4palace Flag 07 Dec 16 3.21pm

Originally posted by salop-eagle

On Holmesdale Radio they said we hadn't won a point this season when Ledley didn't start.

Equally we haven't won a point this season when Cabaye did start!

An interesting stat?

Incorrect, Cabaye started the Sunderland match which we won 3-2. I think it is that he's not finished the full 90 minutes where we've won this season or something like that.

Didn't play in the wins against Middlesborough or Stoke, suspended for Southampton and didn't finish the game against Sunderland.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 07 Dec 16 3.32pm

As posted previously about Cabaye not being on pitch at end of a Palace win :-

We beat Stoke last December when he was suspended.
I think the last game we won when he was on the pitch at the end was the 1-0 Home win against Norwich.
Then we beat Stoke at home coming from behind when he went off at half time. That was all last season.

He did not feature against 'Boro or Stoke , and went off before we staged the comeback against Sunderland.
This is correct.
Nearly a year since last December and he has only been on the pitch at the end of a Palace league win
twice.

Now we can add the Southampton to the list.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 07 Dec 16 4.01pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

As posted previously about Cabaye not being on pitch at end of a Palace win :-

We beat Stoke last December when he was suspended.
I think the last game we won when he was on the pitch at the end was the 1-0 Home win against Norwich.
Then we beat Stoke at home coming from behind when he went off at half time. That was all last season.

He did not feature against 'Boro or Stoke , and went off before we staged the comeback against Sunderland.
This is correct.
Nearly a year since last December and he has only been on the pitch at the end of a Palace league win
twice.

Now we can add the Southampton to the list.

Very good post MKCPFC.And poor old AP has taken all the blame.!!
Lets hope he is off the pitch at 90 minutes Saturday.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Mr_Flow Flag London 07 Dec 16 4.15pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Incorrect, Cabaye started the Sunderland match which we won 3-2. I think it is that he's not finished the full 90 minutes where we've won this season or something like that.

Didn't play in the wins against Middlesborough or Stoke, suspended for Southampton and didn't finish the game against Sunderland.

Cabaye also started against Bournemouth where we got a point.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 07 Dec 16 4.36pm

Originally posted by Mr_Flow

Cabaye also started against Bournemouth where we got a point.

But not a Win.He also had a penalty saved.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

salop-eagle Flag 07 Dec 16 4.37pm

Just goes to show you can't trust Holmesdale Radio!
And there I was believing they knew what they were talking about!
Is the Ledley bit correct?

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 07 Dec 16 4.44pm

McArthur is the key here
Not fussed about Ledley
But Mc never ever has a bad game

 

Mad4palace Flag 07 Dec 16 4.47pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

As posted previously about Cabaye not being on pitch at end of a Palace win :-

We beat Stoke last December when he was suspended.
I think the last game we won when he was on the pitch at the end was the 1-0 Home win against Norwich.
Then we beat Stoke at home coming from behind when he went off at half time. That was all last season.

He did not feature against 'Boro or Stoke , and went off before we staged the comeback against Sunderland.
This is correct.
Nearly a year since last December and he has only been on the pitch at the end of a Palace league win
twice.

Now we can add the Southampton to the list.

Cabaye rarely finished 90 minutes last year, he seemed to have a lot of injuries. We also did lose a lot of points due to Cabaye going off in games last season.

It's a little misleading to only use the lack of wins with him on the pitch at the end of the game and not take into account the scorelines when he's come off etc.

He did come on in the West Ham game and was a considerable improvement to Ledley who he replaced. At the moment you'd start Ledley but both he and Cabaye haven't really excelled this season and it is a position I'd like to see strengthened. I don't see either as having the right mix to play in the defensive midfield role.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 07 Dec 16 4.49pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

McArthur is the key here
Not fussed about Ledley
But Mc never ever has a bad game

Yeah, he's either excellent or merely good.

As for Cabaye, I just wish he could stop yapping to the ref for five minutes. It must antagonise the ref and detract from his own concentration.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 07 Dec 16 6.23pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Cabaye rarely finished 90 minutes last year, he seemed to have a lot of injuries. We also did lose a lot of points due to Cabaye going off in games last season.

It's a little misleading to only use the lack of wins with him on the pitch at the end of the game and not take into account the scorelines when he's come off etc.

He did come on in the West Ham game and was a considerable improvement to Ledley who he replaced. At the moment you'd start Ledley but both he and Cabaye haven't really excelled this season and it is a position I'd like to see strengthened. I don't see either as having the right mix to play in the defensive midfield role.

Just stating some facts.

I think it is a little bit more misleading to make out he has significant positive impact on games that we lose. West Ham , came on and made us better ? Our
two best chances were in the first half when Benteke missed a pen and a great headed chance when Cabaye was not on the pitch .
Some people even claiming he did well against Spurs when he came on, it was 0-0 , he missed the best chance of the game and we lost 1-0.

What games did we lose due to him coming off ?
Be interesting to prove that.
Remember facts not speculation.


 

Mad4palace Flag 07 Dec 16 6.44pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Just stating some facts.

I think it is a little bit more misleading to make out he has significant positive impact on games that we lose. West Ham , came on and made us better ? Our
two best chances were in the first half when Benteke missed a pen and a great headed chance when Cabaye was not on the pitch .
Some people even claiming he did well against Spurs when he came on, it was 0-0 , he missed the best chance of the game and we lost 1-0.

What games did we lose due to him coming off ?
Be interesting to prove that.
Remember facts not speculation.



I'm not suggesting that you're being misleading, just that no one has laid out all of the facts; scorelines, stats from every game he's played. There are more permutations than simply the final score and the team that finished the 90 minutes in those games.

I distinctly remember a trend from last season where we ended up losing points when Cabaye (or incidently McArthur) was subbed off, I'm not going to go trawling through the results to back that up.

I was just pointing out that no one had shown all the facts so it is unfair to simply disregard a player on one selected stat.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The importance of Ledley and McArthur