You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > One of our own
November 16 2026 10.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

One of our own


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Philombardo Flag Tunbridge Wells 18 Dec 16 10.22am

I expect to be vilified for criticising fan favourite and first name on AP's teamsheet, but love of the shirt and Nandos is no longer enough. Punch wastes free kicks, has stopped scoring, floats corners into arms of oppo's keeper,gives up possession lightly, gives away unnecessary free kicks and generally flaps around pointing at everyone. Please go to a Championship club in the window and leave us with memories of goals at Wembley and v Norwich.

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 18 Dec 16 10.28am

Harsh. He had an off day and I too wanted him substituted earlier. Usually our most creative player, the stats after 10 games showed he'd created more chances than anyone in Europe except Neymar. In essence, he's class but lacks consistency, and since being pushed back, goals.

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 18 Dec 16 11.04am

Originally posted by rawpalace05

Harsh. He had an off day and I too wanted him substituted earlier. Usually our most creative player, the stats after 10 games showed he'd created more chances than anyone in Europe except Neymar. In essence, he's class but lacks consistency, and since being pushed back, goals.

Protoge!!! There's stats about everything nowadays.
Opta have a new one on farts per player per match!!
How are you.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Bangell Flag Oxford 18 Dec 16 11.10am

Wasn't great yesterday and was struggling with an injury before he came off - but he's one of our most forward-thinking players and we look much better with him controlling the game.

I do think that an attacking midfielder, along with a left-back, should be a priority in January - but getting rid of Punch would be stupid.

 

glaziermart Flag 19 Dec 16 10.19am

Ridiculous thread. He has still been one of our best players. Ashley Cole even said on Sky that Punch should have been considered for an England squad place by now

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 19 Dec 16 10.28am

I believe he has created more goals than any other play in the team. Vital player for us, always has been since he came in - Ok, he's not Zaha or Eden Hazzard, but he is a premiership class player who has proven himself again and again.

Even on Saturday he had a decent game.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

cpj Flag Kent 19 Dec 16 10.32am

Very poor Saturday. Gave the ball away countless times and missed our best chance.

But please explain why he keeps being referred to as 'one of our own'? We are his 12th (I think) club. He didn't come through our academy. Just because he used to live near the ground does not make him one of our own.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Dec 16 10.43am

Originally posted by cpj

Very poor Saturday. Gave the ball away countless times and missed our best chance.

But please explain why he keeps being referred to as 'one of our own'? We are his 12th (I think) club. He didn't come through our academy. Just because he used to live near the ground does not make him one of our own.

Disagree. If he's from a 5 minute bus journey from selhurst he's one of our's, as long as pictures of him in Arsenal shirts don't start surfacing. Unlikey to be Chelsea seeing as they were shyte when he was a boy and predominantly supported by white bald men with a carling in their hand.

He was on our books. Don't know how long but he was.

He looked leggy today and even if he was dropped for a better incoming player he'd be a good back up. Better than Mutch and Lee.

 


COYP

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 19 Dec 16 10.49am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Disagree. If he's from a 5 minute bus journey from selhurst he's one of our's, as long as pictures of him in Arsenal shirts don't start surfacing. Unlikey to be Chelsea seeing as they were shyte when he was a boy and predominantly supported by white bald men with a carling in their hand.

He was on our books. Don't know how long but he was.

He looked leggy today and even if he was dropped for a better incoming player he'd be a good back up. Better than Mutch and Lee.

He was at Wimbledon, never signed for us. Had trials, I think it was when he left MK Dons but it never worked out.

I like Punch, slows things down a bit too much at times but has been very good for us. I do find the one of our own chant a bit odd though.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Username Flag Horsham 19 Dec 16 12.32pm

Wasn't his best game, thought he started well but tailed off.

Still rather him on the left than Townsend at the moment.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

slubglurge Flag welling 19 Dec 16 12.45pm

He has to up his goal ratio. For a number 10 and as one of our attacking players it is appalling. Seven or eight per season should be a minimun requirement

 

cols123 Flag beckenham 19 Dec 16 12.52pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

He has to up his goal ratio. For a number 10 and as one of our attacking players it is appalling. Seven or eight per season should be a minimun requirement

I'm not being funny, but our top scorer has had 7 goals all comps for the last 2-3 seasons.. so you are in absolute dreamland if you think any of our current crop are suddenely going to bang that many goals in regularly.

Let's concentrate on getting Benteke more than 15+ before that eh...

 

Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 19 Dec 16 12.56pm

Originally posted by Philombardo

I expect to be vilified for criticising fan favourite and first name on AP's teamsheet, but love of the shirt and Nandos is no longer enough. Punch wastes free kicks, has stopped scoring, floats corners into arms of oppo's keeper,gives up possession lightly, gives away unnecessary free kicks and generally flaps around pointing at everyone. Please go to a Championship club in the window and leave us with memories of goals at Wembley and v Norwich.

One of the few players that holds the ball and tries attacking the opposition. The only one outside of Wilf who has an impossible job.
Cabaye is the most appalling free kick taker we have ever had and Punch misses one of not many opportunities and he gets slated.
Rather see someone trying to create something than see an overpaid player jog around the pitch not caring about our predicament.
Were you also a get rid of Jedi merchant?
That has really put us up 8888 street without an oar.
The team is in free fall without a leader and decent manager and limited numbers of players.
Something has to change or its all over.

GT

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

Username Flag Horsham 19 Dec 16 1.18pm

Originally posted by Geoff Thomas

One of the few players that holds the ball and tries attacking the opposition. The only one outside of Wilf who has an impossible job.
Cabaye is the most appalling free kick taker we have ever had and Punch misses one of not many opportunities and he gets slated.
Rather see someone trying to create something than see an overpaid player jog around the pitch not caring about our predicament.
Were you also a get rid of Jedi merchant?
That has really put us up 8888 street without an oar.
The team is in free fall without a leader and decent manager and limited numbers of players.
Something has to change or its all over.

GT


Cabaye's delivery was better on Saturday than Punch. Punch was floating in corners that were too easy for Courtois to claim. Cabaye put over a couple of really threatening balls that were well defended.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Painter Flag Croydon 19 Dec 16 1.49pm

Originally posted by Philombardo

I expect to be vilified for criticising fan favourite and first name on AP's teamsheet, but love of the shirt and Nandos is no longer enough. Punch wastes free kicks, has stopped scoring, floats corners into arms of oppo's keeper,gives up possession lightly, gives away unnecessary free kicks and generally flaps around pointing at everyone. Please go to a Championship club in the window and leave us with memories of goals at Wembley and v Norwich.

You seem to think our squad is bursting with quality, we can afford to ask Puncheon to leave.
Creates more chances than anyone else, so let's sell him.
You Sir are a Dickh__d.

 

cpj Flag Kent 19 Dec 16 1.55pm

Re his goalscoring - 3 in his last 51 games is not a good return for someone of his ability. Should be chipping in with at least 5 a season, as he was when he first got in the team.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 19 Dec 16 2.45pm

Needs to score more, but still our most creative player.not his best game saturday but played on the wing when he's much better in the middle.

 

CJr94 Flag Holmesdale Road 20 Dec 16 12.36pm

Originally posted by Geoff Thomas

One of the few players that holds the ball and tries attacking the opposition. The only one outside of Wilf who has an impossible job.
Cabaye is the most appalling free kick taker we have ever had and Punch misses one of not many opportunities and he gets slated.
Rather see someone trying to create something than see an overpaid player jog around the pitch not caring about our predicament.
Were you also a get rid of Jedi merchant?
That has really put us up 8888 street without an oar.
The team is in free fall without a leader and decent manager and limited numbers of players.
Something has to change or its all over.

GT

Agreed. Didn't think his FK was that bad. Loook at Townsends -.-'

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Dec 16 12.48pm

'One of our own' song is more apt than 'We're the boys from SE25.'

WTF is that about? Cringe. Most singing it have never lived further north than CR8 or CR2.

 


COYP

eagle184 Flag Sutton 20 Dec 16 12.49pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Disagree. If he's from a 5 minute bus journey from selhurst he's one of our's, as long as pictures of him in Arsenal shirts don't start surfacing. Unlikey to be Chelsea seeing as they were shyte when he was a boy and predominantly supported by white bald men with a carling in their hand.

He was on our books. Don't know how long but he was.

He looked leggy today and even if he was dropped for a better incoming player he'd be a good back up. Better than Mutch and Lee.

And Sako

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > One of our own