This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Gayle would have been great to have on the bench, but he didn't want to sit on the bench. He got many opportunities, but he didn't make the most of them.
What would you have wanted him to do? What did he need to do to get recognition?
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
...he's no manager. Last time I commented on this site was 6-8 months ago when I begged you guys to support Gayle and push the coach into using him. I don't know how happy you guys are about Benteke, some feel he has started well, but Gayle is a huge loss. Now please, listen to me. This guy (Pardew) is impressive at being bad. You can't win many games with Kelly and Ward as full backs. Not even Souare is match winning material, but at least he was a left footed left back. Why in God's name doesn't the team have a left footed backup for the left back position? What was the manager thinking? And keeping Townsend soo long on the bench in the Chelsea game when Puncheon was soo out of it... The man wasn't even trying to run on the pitch, he had even sustained an injury!! Townsend needs to play as LEFT WING every match. He can cross amazingly fast for the striker. Yet, Pardew kept sending him in as right wing (even in the Chelsea game). Townsend doesn't have the technical ability to play on the opposite side of his favourite foot. All he knows from that position is to cut in and shoot. And Zaha is like that too. Playing Zaha and Townsend as inverted wingers destroys the team. They're not Robben, Messi, Ronaldo, Neymar or Mahrez to be able to do that. They're fast and athletic. Use them to run past defenders and cross!! I've read some saying that the team played well against Chelsea and that Pardew should stay. Honestly, from an impartial point of view, Palace was awful. It was one of the worst displays of a home side I've seen. You are so scared of Chelsea, but outside of having a good run, that team hasn't got much. They might not finish in the top 4. They only have 3 attacking players (Hazard, Costa and Willian/Pedro), the rest are all defenders.
On balance, fair to say you haven't been missed...
Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it.. |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
What would you have wanted him to do? What did he need to do to get recognition? Gayle made little impact in 1st halves of Prem football.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Gayle has had 15 goals and 2 assists in 2.700 minutes in the Premier League. Nevermind the Championship and the Cups, where he rocked. IN the last 2.800 minutes in the PL Benteke has had 17 goals and 4 assists. That MAY seem better than Gayle, but 3 of his goals were penalty kicks, therefore I only leave him at 14 goals and 4 assists in 2.800 minutes, very much as Gayle. Anyway, I WAS RIGHT when I told you Gayle is too good to keep on the bench. Now he's gone, he's the star of the Championship, the goalscorer, on his way up with Newcastle and he's wanted by half the Premier League clubs. Good for him! Who lost in this?
Newcastle knew this, you don;t Did you miss the bit in my post when I stated 'in less minutes'?
Wickham can lead the line, he can link play. He's quick and powerful and he can score goals. Dwight Gayle is quick finisher who never once looked like he could operate as a single striker in the Premier League. He had his chances. He had plenty of them. He needed to drop down a division and play week in, week out. If he was as good as you say in the Prem, there would have been 6/7 Prem clubs after him. Edited by Username (20 Dec 2016 12.55pm)
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Gayle made little impact in 1st halves of Prem football. Unless that impact was on West Ham players of course...
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Originally posted by james03
Really? People are still going on about Gayle? The lad can score goals we know that. In the Championship he was always going to get 20+ in a season, especially when he is with the leagues top team. His problem is that he does nothing else, he does not contribute to the team in any other way thus we were effectively a ten man team when Gayle played - we rarely dominated games so his chances of scoring were limited. I believe he should have been loaned out to a Championship club two tears ago. The only chance we had was to get him playing regularly and understanding/learning the need to improve his all round game. Remember he only played a handful of games at Championship level when we signed him - before that it was non-league football. Too much too soon. If Newcastle keep him next season back in the Premier League I can see him losing his place after a couple of months and being on the bench thereafter. That is UNLESS his all round game has improved. We will have to wait and see but keeping banging on about a player who has gone is pointless - we cannot wind back the clock even if we wanted to. I don't understand what you guys mean by all round game. "He should improve his all round game" wtf does that mean? Does a tall immobile striker have a better all round game? Modern football is more about running than anything else. That's why we have seen in the last 10 years a trend with the disappearance of the "brute" striker and the using of the "false 9" there. Yes, it's not always good, it doesn't always work. But it worked AT TIMES, FOR SOME TEAMS. Which is astonishingly more than how teams played football in the past, 20, 30, 40 years ago. The tall striker was untouchable, it was a "must". So how on earth could Benteke or Wickham have an all round game better than Gayle??
If a guy like Benteke was publicly promoted, if his value has reached these heights and is a marketing asset as well, it means that he had good managers. He's managed to trick an entire country into thinking he's worth all that. I've known him since before the Aston Villa days, since he was 17. I know what Benteke can do and I'm telling you- there are 50 strikers worth less than what you paid for him who could have offered more.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
I don't understand what you guys mean by all round game. "He should improve his all round game" wtf does that mean? Does a tall immobile striker have a better all round game? Modern football is more about running than anything else. That's why we have seen in the last 10 years a trend with the disappearance of the "brute" striker and the using of the "false 9" there. Yes, it's not always good, it doesn't always work. But it worked AT TIMES, FOR SOME TEAMS. Which is astonishingly more than how teams played football in the past, 20, 30, 40 years ago. The tall striker was untouchable, it was a "must". So how on earth could Benteke or Wickham have an all round game better than Gayle??
If a guy like Benteke was publicly promoted, if his value has reached these heights and is a marketing asset as well, it means that he had good managers. He's managed to trick an entire country into thinking he's worth all that. I've known him since before the Aston Villa days, since he was 17. I know what Benteke can do and I'm telling you- there are 50 strikers worth less than what you paid for him who could have offered more. Two of the most ridiculous things I've ever read on this forum. Well done.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time. |
|
|
Stopped reading at the Gayle part. Never good enough at this level. Trying to use that as part of the argument renders the rest not worthy of reading!
|
|
|
Originally posted by VKR1888
Stopped reading at the Gayle part. Never good enough at this level. Trying to use that as part of the argument renders the rest not worthy of reading!
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
What would you have wanted him to do? What did he need to do to get recognition? Well he seemed to have a pattern of scoring as a sub, then getting a start and doing zilch. So back to the bench he would go. He didn't cut it as a lone striker, so under Pulis, Warnock, Pardew he sat. He also seemed to get injured a lot (but then what Palace player doesn't I guess). I remember him scoring piles in cup games against weak sides. I like the guy, and am not surprised he's doing well against much weaker competition. But like Murray, in the Prem, when there was a lot less space, and faster, bigger CBs, he had a much harder time affecting the game. His stats are good, but they are small sample size.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
|
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
Bite me, Dave. You're the troll. You speak of me like you're some kind of Crystal Palace "born on the stadium" fan
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Well managers need strikers who can play whole games. He has good numbers per minute, but sorry, I'd take everyone on your list before Gayle. I wanted him to do well last season, but he didn't. 3 Prem goals in 16. I know he was injured a lot, but the narrative on why we sucked second half of last season was our strikers could not score. Season before that 5 goals in 29 games. Forgive me for not being excited --MacArthur already has 5 this year. Something like 5 Palace managers ran the rule over him and decided that while he was a great natural goal scorer, the rest of his game was wanting. All the best to him in the Championship.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Ward and Souare haven't had 2 crosses turned into assists in a PL season SINCE EVER either!! Whatever Kelly's history isn't the point ,where we are now is what matters and that is that Kelly is used as a full back and he is better than anything else at the club bar Ward of current fit players .
|
|
|
Originally posted by ThatPetrolRelation
Well managers need strikers who can play whole games. He has good numbers per minute, but sorry, I'd take everyone on your list before Gayle. I wanted him to do well last season, but he didn't. 3 Prem goals in 16. I know he was injured a lot, but the narrative on why we sucked second half of last season was our strikers could not score. Season before that 5 goals in 29 games. Forgive me for not being excited --MacArthur already has 5 this year. Something like 5 Palace managers ran the rule over him and decided that while he was a great natural goal scorer, the rest of his game was wanting. All the best to him in the Championship.
Gayle was similar to Chicharito and Wellbeck a t United. He seems to have played many games. But, in truth, the manager only sent him in a few minutes. Therefore, what do we count? Keeping in mind ONLY THE MINUTES, Gayle was awesome for a mid table team like Palace. Yet, Utd's manager never made him a starter. Did he not cement himself? Was he not good enough? No. He was and beyond. It's just that the manager insisted with someone else. His faith was given to another player. Unjustified, unfair, but managers do that. Bad managers. And there is a plethora of them. And Gayle's and Chicharito's styles are very similar: hard working, kind of average height strikers, very fast, not amazingly technically but all heart. Loosing Gayle wasn't Palace's only mistake in the last seasons. There were more though: 1. Puncheon was a great player 2-6 years ago, he was a contender for the England shirt. He should have been selected the entire 2014/25 campaign. Do you know what position Puncheon played when he was that good? He was a winger. Either on the left or on the right. Puncheon stats:
2. Still, Crystal has 3 left footed wingers: Townsend, Puncheon and Sakho. I like all 3 of them, but Townsend's pace is something special. Only Puncheon is technically gifted enough to play as inverted winger. 3. There's the fullback issue. Honestly, the best thing right now would be to use Lee as right back in the matches against low half sides, while Ward could be used in matches vs top 6 teams. On the left, keep one of Souare (sell him while he still has value, I'm not impressed by him) or Fryers and get an offensive left back, fast!!
Because I understand this game, I know things other people don't, I can see them in advance. Now I'm rambling, but if you want or don't want to believe me, it's up to you.
Edited by mattteo (21 Dec 2016 10.29am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Gayle was similar to Chicharito and Wellbeck a t United. He seems to have played many games. But, in truth, the manager only sent him in a few minutes. Therefore, what do we count? Keeping in mind ONLY THE MINUTES, Gayle was awesome for a mid table team like Palace. Yet, Utd's manager never made him a starter. Did he not cement himself? Was he not good enough? No. He was and beyond. It's just that the manager insisted with someone else. His faith was given to another player. Unjustified, unfair, but managers do that. Bad managers. And there is a plethora of them. And Gayle's and Chicharito's styles are very similar: hard working, kind of average height strikers, very fast, not amazingly technically but all heart. Loosing Gayle wasn't Palace's only mistake in the last seasons. There were more though: 1. Puncheon was a great player 2-6 years ago, he was a contender for the England shirt. He should have been selected the entire 2014/25 campaign. Do you know what position Puncheon played when he was that good? He was a winger. Either on the left or on the right. Puncheon stats:
2. Still, Crystal has 3 left footed wingers: Townsend, Puncheon and Sakho. I like all 3 of them, but Townsend's pace is something special. Only Puncheon is technically gifted enough to play as inverted winger. 3. There's the fullback issue. Honestly, the best thing right now would be to use Lee as right back in the matches against low half sides, while Ward could be used in matches vs top 6 teams. On the left, keep one of Souare (sell him while he still has value, I'm not impressed by him) or Fryers and get an offensive left back, fast!!
Because I understand this game, I know things other people don't, I can see them in advance. Now I'm rambling, but if you want or don't want to believe me, it's up to you.
Edited by mattteo (21 Dec 2016 10.29am) What a plonker you really are, Rodney...
Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it.. |
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Gayle was similar to Chicharito and Wellbeck a t United. He seems to have played many games. But, in truth, the manager only sent him in a few minutes. Therefore, what do we count? Keeping in mind ONLY THE MINUTES, Gayle was awesome for a mid table team like Palace. Yet, Utd's manager never made him a starter. Did he not cement himself? Was he not good enough? No. He was and beyond. It's just that the manager insisted with someone else. His faith was given to another player. Unjustified, unfair, but managers do that. Bad managers. And there is a plethora of them. And Gayle's and Chicharito's styles are very similar: hard working, kind of average height strikers, very fast, not amazingly technically but all heart. Loosing Gayle wasn't Palace's only mistake in the last seasons. There were more though: 1. Puncheon was a great player 2-6 years ago, he was a contender for the England shirt. He should have been selected the entire 2014/25 campaign. Do you know what position Puncheon played when he was that good? He was a winger. Either on the left or on the right. Puncheon stats:
2. Still, Crystal has 3 left footed wingers: Townsend, Puncheon and Sakho. I like all 3 of them, but Townsend's pace is something special. Only Puncheon is technically gifted enough to play as inverted winger. 3. There's the fullback issue. Honestly, the best thing right now would be to use Lee as right back in the matches against low half sides, while Ward could be used in matches vs top 6 teams. On the left, keep one of Souare (sell him while he still has value, I'm not impressed by him) or Fryers and get an offensive left back, fast!!
Because I understand this game, I know things other people don't, I can see them in advance. Now I'm rambling, but if you want or don't want to believe me, it's up to you.
Edited by mattteo (21 Dec 2016 10.29am) Ha ha ha, this is a windup, right?
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Ha ha ha, this is a windup, right? Either that, or he's living in his Gran's cellar after his parents kicked him out.
If you come to a fork in the road, take it. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.