You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > It's time for Wilf to go
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

It's time for Wilf to go


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Dangermouse Flag Hastings 04 Jan 17 7.51pm

Originally posted by cpj

The problem with a lot of fans (ours in particular) is that they think their players are better than they are. Zaha is a case in point. Yes, he scored a wonder goal yesterday, but other than a couple of wasted crosses and a couple of fouls on him, he was invisible for most of the game against the bottom side in the division. And that's why he hasn't been called up for England. Now he's gone off to Africa in a huff and leaves us short of payers for a month or so. Yes. he's improved this season, but he still needs to improve his decision-making. Perhaps a bigger club would suit him, but it could be another Man Utd for him.

Complete bollocks IMO.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 04 Jan 17 7.53pm

Originally posted by cpj

Perhaps if he'd been more consistent, played with a bit more intelligence re deciding when to cross / shoot, not fallen over quite so easily, not spent half the game arguing with officials, he'd have been picked by England and this wouldn't be an issue. By choosing to change to the IC he's putting his career ahead of the club who have given him that career.

Even more bollocks IMO.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Painter Flag Croydon 04 Jan 17 8.24pm

Originally posted by cpj

The problem with a lot of fans (ours in particular) is that they think their players are better than they are. Zaha is a case in point. Yes, he scored a wonder goal yesterday, but other than a couple of wasted crosses and a couple of fouls on him, he was invisible for most of the game against the bottom side in the division. And that's why he hasn't been called up for England. Now he's gone off to Africa in a huff and leaves us short of payers for a month or so. Yes. he's improved this season, but he still needs to improve his decision-making. Perhaps a bigger club would suit him, but it could be another Man Utd for him.

We generally go on about how good players are, after we have sold them, we said they were rubbish when they played for us.
Zaha has talent no doubt, but not the application. I don't think he has ever had a good game against one of the top teams, they deal with him easily. they put in a couple of early fouls, wind him up, then job done.
Not the finished article yet. That's why he wont go for big money, not as good as Bolasie was.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 04 Jan 17 8.27pm

Originally posted by cpj

The problem with a lot of fans (ours in particular) is that they think their players are better than they are. Zaha is a case in point. Yes, he scored a wonder goal yesterday, but other than a couple of wasted crosses and a couple of fouls on him, he was invisible for most of the game against the bottom side in the division. And that's why he hasn't been called up for England. Now he's gone off to Africa in a huff and leaves us short of payers for a month or so. Yes. he's improved this season, but he still needs to improve his decision-making. Perhaps a bigger club would suit him, but it could be another Man Utd for him.

Spot On !

 

taylors lovechild Flag 04 Jan 17 9.46pm

He has one of the highest assist rates in the league plus some goals in a massively under performing team. Imagine what he could do in a team where he is not the only real outlet on the pitch. Most teams have realised that if they can block Zaha out of the game then we are pretty flat.

No, he is not world class, but he is bloody good and I really don't understand anyone who questions his ability - how long have you actually been watching Palace? I was really unhappy to lose Bolasie. I'd be devastated to lose Wilf. Not since Ian Wright left have I wanted a player to stay as much as Wilf.

Screw the clueless pundits who berate him. He's one of our own. He's one of our own. Wilf Zaha, he's one of our own

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 04 Jan 17 10.28pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

He has one of the highest assist rates in the league plus some goals in a massively under performing team. Imagine what he could do in a team where he is not the only real outlet on the pitch. Most teams have realised that if they can block Zaha out of the game then we are pretty flat.

No, he is not world class, but he is bloody good and I really don't understand anyone who questions his ability - how long have you actually been watching Palace? I was really unhappy to lose Bolasie. I'd be devastated to lose Wilf. Not since Ian Wright left have I wanted a player to stay as much as Wilf.

Screw the clueless pundits who berate him. He's one of our own. He's one of our own. Wilf Zaha, he's one of our own

Oh not that long ~ 49 years ~ you ???

Do yourself a favor and watch real quality Palace players like Sansom , Wright , Taylor , Cannon , etc etc ~ Players that are quality every week ~ Actually youy can add one current player to that list ~ James McCarthur .

 

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 05 Jan 17 12.17am

Originally posted by Mr. Talons

Your (vaguely racist) comparison is unfair, imo.

Notwithstanding his exceptional close skills, Wilf's kicking is imperfect.

Rogers had everything.


Please believe me, I was making a joke about racial doo-dahs. It was an attempt to send up social attitudes.

i promise you i don't think that way way

ahem.....


do you really think people of my generation are really like that? I was messing around wth stereotypes


Come on mate, some of my best friends make massive generalisations..for comedy purposes


 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Jan 17 3.12am

Originally posted by cpj

Perhaps if he'd been more consistent, played with a bit more intelligence re deciding when to cross / shoot, not fallen over quite so easily, not spent half the game arguing with officials, he'd have been picked by England and this wouldn't be an issue. By choosing to change to the IC he's putting his career ahead of the club who have given him that career.

Good post.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Jan 17 3.15am

Not convinced he'd make it even 2nd time round at a top 6.
He just hasn't quite got the footie brain for that level.
But it's a close call

 

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Jan 17 8.36am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Oh not that long ~ 49 years ~ you ???

Do yourself a favor and watch real quality Palace players like Sansom , Wright , Taylor , Cannon , etc etc ~ Players that are quality every week ~ Actually youy can add one current player to that list ~ James McCarthur .

The fact that you have to go back to 1991 to find a player worth mentioning in your list is telling. McArthur is great but he is a totally different type of player. I only have 27 years under my belt, but that's long enough to know that (in modern history ) Zaha is one of the best players we've had.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 05 Jan 17 4.03pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The fact that you have to go back to 1991 to find a player worth mentioning in your list is telling. McArthur is great but he is a totally different type of player. I only have 27 years under my belt, but that's long enough to know that (in modern history ) Zaha is one of the best players we've had.

Your right McArthur is totally different
He plays well every week
Zaha is exciting when he is ON ,
BUT this is the premier league , you gotta consistently cross well and finish well and NOT give the ball away easy .

Better palace wingers than Zaha in history ?

Peter Taylor , Don Rogers .

As much as I loved Vince Hilaire , Zaha and him are too similar , flattered to deceive .

 

taylors lovechild Flag 05 Jan 17 4.37pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Your right McArthur is totally different
He plays well every week
Zaha is exciting when he is ON ,
BUT this is the premier league , you gotta consistently cross well and finish well and NOT give the ball away easy .

Better palace wingers than Zaha in history ?

Peter Taylor , Don Rogers .

As much as I loved Vince Hilaire , Zaha and him are too similar , flattered to deceive .

I can't really comment on Taylor or Rogers as I wasn't born until 1979. Thinking on it in my lifetime we have had Lombardo (briefly) and Salako who are up there, but I think that's about it.

Anyway, the key for me is that Zaha looks like he's starting to progress this season and I don't think it would take much to push him on even further. I think I just get annoyed when people talk as if Palace would be better off selling him.

 

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 05 Jan 17 5.52pm

One thing Wilf has, that neither Rogers or Taylor could match, is there sheer range of ways he can go past a player.

Sometimes, he beats them through his first touch, flicking the ball one way but body swerving the other, leaving the defender flummoxed.

Against Brighton (in the 2-0 away victory in the play offs) he beats his defender without even touching the ball. As pass is played into him and he lets it run and turns past his marker, who's still three seconds behind in thought processing. Zaha leaves his for dead. ends up. (Watch the goal on Youtube.) He actually makes it look easy, but its his timing and movement are incredible.

Then he's got all manner of tricks for sending the defender one way, then the other.

Rogers was brilliant, and very fast too, but I still think Wilf is even better.

 

Tim Gypsy Hill '64 Flag Stoke sub normal 05 Jan 17 6.24pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Your right McArthur is totally different
He plays well every week
Zaha is exciting when he is ON ,
BUT this is the premier league , you gotta consistently cross well and finish well and NOT give the ball away easy .

Better palace wingers than Zaha in history ?

Peter Taylor , Don Rogers .

As much as I loved Vince Hilaire , Zaha and him are too similar , flattered to deceive .

Johnny Salad.

 


Systematically dragged down by the lawmakers

johnallen Flag Weston-super-Mare, born in Croydon 05 Jan 17 6.52pm

Wilf is good with some amazing trickery he uses to beat players but Don Rogers was a class above. He played on ploughed fields and still went past opponents with consummate ease. He was also considerably faster than Wilf with phenomenal acceleration over the first 4 or 5 metres which just left opponents for dead. He also finished with either foot. At the time he was playing he was having to do it on his own, quite often from a deep position, but you always got butterflies when he got the ball because you sense he could do it on his own. His only real fault was that he sometimes went missing in away games.

 


I am determined to live until I am as old as I look.

Mr. Talons Flag Southampton 05 Jan 17 11.12pm

Yes, he's not the finished article, but of course we should try to keep him. He's by far our most dangerous player.

What am I saying? He's our ONLY dangerous player. Just get him on the ball as much as possible, preferably in the box.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 05 Jan 17 11.53pm

Originally posted by cpj

The problem with a lot of fans (ours in particular) is that they think their players are better than they are. Zaha is a case in point. Yes, he scored a wonder goal yesterday, but other than a couple of wasted crosses and a couple of fouls on him, he was invisible for most of the game against the bottom side in the division. And that's why he hasn't been called up for England. Now he's gone off to Africa in a huff and leaves us short of payers for a month or so. Yes. he's improved this season, but he still needs to improve his decision-making. Perhaps a bigger club would suit him, but it could be another Man Utd for him.

Was going to post this. He's not as good as we all think. Against the Swansea's and the like he is decent. Against the big boys he disapppears. He is certainly good enough to have another go with one of the bigger clubs though to see if he can rise to the occasion playing in a much better team.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

General Flag 06 Jan 17 8.26am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Was going to post this. He's not as good as we all think. Against the Swansea's and the like he is decent. Against the big boys he disapppears. He is certainly good enough to have another go with one of the bigger clubs though to see if he can rise to the occasion playing in a much better team.

And which players for palace play or have played amazing against the big clubs!?

Hmm if only wilf played like the others a we'd be top 4

Dig out the most exciting player who clearly works at his game alot and has improved loads recently in baffled


 

.TUX. Flag 06 Jan 17 8.49am

Originally posted by OhthisbloodyPC

One thing Wilf has, that neither Rogers or Taylor could match, is there sheer range of ways he can go past a player.

Sometimes, he beats them through his first touch, flicking the ball one way but body swerving the other, leaving the defender flummoxed.

Against Brighton (in the 2-0 away victory in the play offs) he beats his defender without even touching the ball. As pass is played into him and he lets it run and turns past his marker, who's still three seconds behind in thought processing. Zaha leaves his for dead. ends up. (Watch the goal on Youtube.) He actually makes it look easy, but its his timing and movement are incredible.

Then he's got all manner of tricks for sending the defender one way, then the other.

Rogers was brilliant, and very fast too, but I still think Wilf is even better.

Really?
Maybe you should watch it again.

 


Buy Litecoin.

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 06 Jan 17 9.27am

Reckon it'll be interesting how we'll play while he's at the AFCON.

He's improved a Lot this season - but still trys to do way too much every time he gets the ball, he seems to lose the ball alot.
Perhaps, while he is away, we will be forced not to rely on him so much, and the team will be better for it. We have Andros who is a ready made replacement on the right - who may actually benefit from Zaha not being there, and a gaping hole on the left, which will most likely be filled by Mutch Or Lee.
you never know!

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > It's time for Wilf to go