You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jedi


Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 06 Jan 17 9.35am

I love Jedi, him and Wilf were my favourite players and as a moral boost for the fans he'd be great to see in a Palace shirt again but he is not the way forward sadly. We should never have sold him, his replacement should be an upgrade on him which Ledley is not.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 06 Jan 17 10.04am

Mutch is here earning a crust. How the hell anyone can brush over that and kick up a stink about Jedi coming back is ridiculous.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

The Dolphin Flag 06 Jan 17 10.27am

Good point - I only wish I had brought it up myself!
Jedi for the rest of the season would be the dogs gonads!

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 06 Jan 17 10.29am

I'd take him back.

 


[Link]

Johnny Byrne Flag Pinner 06 Jan 17 10.37am

It's been a case of "be careful what you wish for" as far as the board and former manager felt at the start of this season.

Back to the heart of CPFC, guts, fight, togetherness, as one with the fans. Been lost this past 2 years. Time to regain this is now.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 06 Jan 17 12.14pm

I'd have him back, seems to be highly rated at Villa as well.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 06 Jan 17 12.41pm

Out of the 6 players we currently have at the club that have played central midfield...

McArthur
Cabaye
Ledley
Puncheon
Flamini
Mutch

...I wouldnt choose a single one of them in front of Jedinak if it was to play holding midfielder.

I would only choose McArthur and Cabaye ahead of Jedinak in a slightly more forward central position.

Jedinak is not just more combative...he would immediately start to help the teams set piece defending. He would bring with him a confidence and he would be able to lift the whole team.

He would give Dann a kick up the ass that he has needed for a while because his form has been a let down since becoming captain.

 

Sherlock Holmesdale Flag Milton Keynes 06 Jan 17 1.32pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

We would not be any worse off than we are now.
Tell us the last game that Cabaye influenced and won for us ?

If I could be bothered to look , I suspect Jedi has probably been on the pitch at the end of 90 minutes and won more recently than Cabaye. In a league game for Palace.

Being on the pitch at the end of a winning game is a meaningless statistic. Chungy would probably have some of the best stats in that regard due to being brought on after 88 mins quite frequently towards the beginning of this season. How many games have we lost where Cabaye has been substituted off? A game Cabaye influenced - well he scored against Watford. Had Benteke not missed that penalty we might well have got 3 points from that match.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not chairman of Cabaye's fan club, but I do recognise that he is technically our best midfielder and a player we should be looking to get the best out of by altering our formation/personnel alongside him.

Jedi was a warrior and a great captain and player for us, but he was past his best. What he had in drive and physical presence he lacks in mobility and ability to pass (even simple balls at times). There is a reason he is now playing in the Championship and not a different Premier League team. I was sad to see him leave but I think that was due to nostalgia rather than what he could bring to the team now.

 

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 06 Jan 17 1.41pm

Having Jedi Back could be a fantastic psychological boost.

 


[Link]

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 06 Jan 17 1.46pm

Defending set pieces with Jedi in the team would change the whole mindset. We're talking about stopping the sh1t teams constantly scoring winners against us, ie: Swansea... not the top 6. He'd be okay against the bottom 10. That's where our survival is - beating the lower teams. I could go on...get him back...good business.

 


[Link]

Username Flag Horsham 06 Jan 17 1.55pm

People talk about his help at defending set pieces, but that's very risky to assume he'll be as effective as he was.

He defends in the Damien Delaney mould. He gave away a penalty last season (Watford at home) for being too hands on and referees are far quicker to award those this season.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 06 Jan 17 2.11pm

Originally posted by Sherlock Holmesdale

Being on the pitch at the end of a winning game is a meaningless statistic. Chungy would probably have some of the best stats in that regard due to being brought on after 88 mins quite frequently towards the beginning of this season. How many games have we lost where Cabaye has been substituted off? A game Cabaye influenced - well he scored against Watford. Had Benteke not missed that penalty we might well have got 3 points from that match.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not chairman of Cabaye's fan club, but I do recognise that he is technically our best midfielder and a player we should be looking to get the best out of by altering our formation/personnel alongside him.

Jedi was a warrior and a great captain and player for us, but he was past his best. What he had in drive and physical presence he lacks in mobility and ability to pass (even simple balls at times). There is a reason he is now playing in the Championship and not a different Premier League team. I was sad to see him leave but I think that was due to nostalgia rather than what he could bring to the team now.
Y

If Cabaye is our best Midfielder prefer Mac myself it's time for him to show it.
He gave away a needless foul for Swansea to score .
Diabolical defending against Hull,Man City and Chelsea.
In fact the two best things I can remember him doing was the cross last season against West Brom for Bolasie and the Watford goal.
Sam will sort him out or offload him.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Username Flag Horsham 06 Jan 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by alaneagle1

If Cabaye is our best Midfielder prefer Mac myself it's time for him to show it.
He gave away a needless foul for Swansea to score .
Diabolical defending against Hull,Man City and Chelsea.
In fact the two best things I can remember him doing was the cross last season against West Brom for Bolasie and the Watford goal.
Sam will sort him out or offload him.

To me that highlights the issue with the way some look at him.

You're only happy if he's done something special, and you only notice mistakes. He's had a number of games, including a few in the last couple of months where his work rate, passing and reading of the game have been very good.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

paperhat Flag croydon 06 Jan 17 3.32pm

we need a real Jedi, not an Australian one

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 06 Jan 17 3.45pm

Originally posted by Sherlock Holmesdale

Being on the pitch at the end of a winning game is a meaningless statistic. Chungy would probably have some of the best stats in that regard due to being brought on after 88 mins quite frequently towards the beginning of this season. How many games have we lost where Cabaye has been substituted off? A game Cabaye influenced - well he scored against Watford. Had Benteke not missed that penalty we might well have got 3 points from that match.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not chairman of Cabaye's fan club, but I do recognise that he is technically our best midfielder and a player we should be looking to get the best out of by altering our formation/personnel alongside him.

Jedi was a warrior and a great captain and player for us, but he was past his best. What he had in drive and physical presence he lacks in mobility and ability to pass (even simple balls at times). There is a reason he is now playing in the Championship and not a different Premier League team. I was sad to see him leave but I think that was due to nostalgia rather than what he could bring to the team now.

Fair point Sherlock . Still of the 4 games we have won this season he only played in one.

The second bold point is interesting , this is what I keep asking and no one can seem to answer clearly, what position / job is he supposed to be doing out there ? When we bought him , I thought and I think many others did that the team would function and revolve around his talents. It may have done in small spells or patches, but just hasn't happened or produced for a long while. Is it down to Pardew ?
Anyway we have to all hope , as you say , that Sam finds a way to get the best out of him for the team, because we are going to need him playing at his best to get out of this.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Jan 17 4.23pm

Originally posted by Username

To me that highlights the issue with the way some look at him.

You're only happy if he's done something special, and you only notice mistakes. He's had a number of games, including a few in the last couple of months where his work rate, passing and reading of the game have been very good.

Quite - Cabaye is a better player all round, but McArthur I think generally suits our more 'robust' style of play in midfield.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Jan 17 4.27pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

The same ratings that a lot of people use to justify Cabaye , the problem with them is that they do not actually show what the player really brings to the team.
Jedi's influence influence on the team was immense , we miss his stature and sheer will to win and his desire to it for Palace.
I would rather we had kept Jedi and sold Cabaye.

I'd rather rely on the mathematical analysis than opinion. Jedi, who I love as a player, wasn't particularly influential in the last half of the previous season (and barely featured in the first half that saw us reach the dizzying heights of 5th at Christmas).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Painter Flag Croydon 06 Jan 17 4.43pm

Jedinak, Gayle and Murray are all playing in the Championship for a reason, we all know they aren't good enough for the Premier. There wasn't any interest from other Premier managers for them.
Why do you all think our old players are better once they leave, when they failed to perform whilst here.

 

Hudsoneagle Flag 06 Jan 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by Painter

Jedinak, Gayle and Murray are all playing in the Championship for a reason, we all know they aren't good enough for the Premier. There wasn't any interest from other Premier managers for them.
Why do you all think our old players are better once they leave, when they failed to perform whilst here.

I totally disagree with you...I could not disagree with you more!

Murray - He is good enough to play for a prem team but he doesn't want to be a bench player. He is an honest bloke who wants to play a key role for a club and so he would rather play for Brighton regularly...but that doesnt mean he isn't good enough.

Jedinak - exactly the same thing...he wants first team football and Pardew said he couldn't ask him to sit on the bench for us week in week out (but Ledley and Mutch are ok for bench roles). It says a lot about his ability that he was more sought after than either Ledley or Mutch don't you think?

To say Gayle isn't good enough for the prem just shows what a plonka you are...top scorer for us 3 years running or something like that??? After barely starting a game? On fire in the Champ??? He is prem quality all day long but he didn't suit our system...in some respects we were not good enough for him because we couldn't play with a front two.

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 06 Jan 17 7.09pm

Completely agree with Hudsoneagle.

To say Gayle out of all of them isnt good enough is pretty funny considering how well he is doing and it isn't the first time is it? With the right system he gets goals consistently. Benteke isn't exactly setting the world alight with us is he at £30 mil.

 

Page 3 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi