You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Deserved defeat
November 16 2026 10.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Deserved defeat


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
cardiff eagle Flag 21 Jan 17 6.46pm

Whilst a draw wouldn't have been an unfair result, we only had 1 shot on target that I remember and only maybe 1 more chance than that. In contrast, Everton had numerous chances and had Barkley not been so wasteful they could've had 3 or 4.

We were clearly setup to not concede and get that confidence back and to be fair we nearly did it. However, you're not gonna get the points required unless you score goals so we need to find the balance and quick!

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 21 Jan 17 6.55pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Whilst a draw wouldn't have been an unfair result, we only had 1 shot on target that I remember and only maybe 1 more chance than that. In contrast, Everton had numerous chances and had Barkley not been so wasteful they could've had 3 or 4.

We were clearly setup to not concede and get that confidence back and to be fair we nearly did it. However, you're not gonna get the points required unless you score goals so we need to find the balance and quick!

Thank goodness he was, because that's was all that was missing from his game. The only player we have of his attacking ilk is currently in Africa.

 

leejaneagles Flag 21 Jan 17 6.56pm

You don't think perhaps the Management weren't looking at the future fixtures when setting up for this game? You're saying in isolation, going for 1 point at home isn't going to keep us up and you're right but you also touched on why it was done in your post - to build confidence.

If we'd of taken a point today and a crucial clean sheet we may have gone on to beat Bournemouth and Sunderland, potentially keeping a further clean sheet.

7 points from those 3 games and 0 goals conceded was probably the highest hope Sam had but a realistic hope nonetheless.

Thanks to the ref allowing a goal with 11 vs 10 we now have no point, no clean sheet and probably no confidence. So fans can come here and say we shouldn't only be having 1 shot on target but if that 30 second of events hadn't taken place after the throw in we'd all be praising the performance.

You can see Sam is absolutely desperate for a Premier League game without conceding, even if we don't come close to scoring ourselves. Only then can we look to start winning. Today was supposed to be that game for him and he's suffered the Palace curse that it wasn't. Because that goal wouldn't have come with Schlupp defending down that left hand side.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 21 Jan 17 6.58pm

Bentekes header hit the post, dann had a great header denied by a fantastic save. Either of which goes in we could easily have won the game. Everton had more chances but hennessey probably had one difficult shot to save, rest were pretty routine. So how about getting behind thd team rather than saying we deserved to loose....

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jan 17 6.58pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Whilst a draw wouldn't have been an unfair result, we only had 1 shot on target that I remember and only maybe 1 more chance than that. In contrast, Everton had numerous chances and had Barkley not been so wasteful they could've had 3 or 4.

We were clearly setup to not concede and get that confidence back and to be fair we nearly did it. However, you're not gonna get the points required unless you score goals so we need to find the balance and quick!

According to the BBC it was two shots on target, as well as hitting the bar. We also had another blatant penalty turned down.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

cardiff eagle Flag 21 Jan 17 7.09pm

Yeah not criticising- just saying that on balance we deserved to lose (note: not loose). Not sure how that equates to not supporting the team.

Understand why Sam setup the way he did and partially agree. However, we also need to remember that not conceding is actually quite a rare thing so to only muster 1 or 2 attempts of note at goal won't keep us up.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 21 Jan 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

According to the BBC it was two shots on target, as well as hitting the bar. We also had another blatant penalty turned down.

Really? What for? I was there and don't remember any players appealing for anything?

 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 21 Jan 17 7.17pm

Looked promising in the 1 half, but second half looked pooooor!!
And all this back passes from when even are on the opponents field,,,,why,,,just pass it forward instead of Hennesey!
Well now we are in the RELAGATION ZONE and from what I have seen, we will stay there and then we go down.
And we woun`t come up again, cause we are Paalace arent we??

 

bicycle repair man 21 Jan 17 8.33pm

But we didn't deserve another awful decision from a referee.
After the ball went out for a throw he should have held up play. How can you let the game go on while the physio is on the pitch giving treatment ?
Or at least give us a chance to get a sub on.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 21 Jan 17 8.42pm

The objective right now is to end the losing habit and in doing so repair confidence. Without confidence you cannot achieve anything and losing all the time just destroys you more and more. Unusually for us we've also been victim to very poor decisions and Worldies taking points away from us, this can be even more demoralising as you ask, as we as fans are, "What is it we need to do to get some luck here?"
So if we have to suffer some negative turgid football for a few weeks to try and rebuild confidence then so be it. Too many are quick to make claims like the OP, yet when the boots on the other foot they claim the same thing because we didn't put away our chances and if you can't score you deserve nothing. Everton deserved f*** all for such a highly touted team, but once again they got the luck from rank poor officiating. Just like at Goodison where they scored direct from what should of been an indirect free kick and we had a perfectly good winning goal disallowed because a player not interfering with play was flagged offside. Honestly the list of bent reffing decisions is just getting ridiculously long and yes I do mean bent.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 21 Jan 17 8.49pm

You must of been watching a different game from me Everton are on a crest of a wave at the moment, they had a little more quality but i think we were unlucky not to come away with something from this game,The team played with purpose and just needed a little luck If Benteke's header went in the first half it could of been so different. And with there goal, the guy who scored would of been picked up by Schlupp if he had not been out of the game with an injury. Also the goal was possibly offside, So all in all IMO one of our best performances this season

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Whilst a draw wouldn't have been an unfair result, we only had 1 shot on target that I remember and only maybe 1 more chance than that. In contrast, Everton had numerous chances and had Barkley not been so wasteful they could've had 3 or 4.

We were clearly setup to not concede and get that confidence back and to be fair we nearly did it. However, you're not gonna get the points required unless you score goals so we need to find the balance and quick!

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jan 17 9.09pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Really? What for? I was there and don't remember any players appealing for anything?

Remy did. He was wrestled to a halt by Fuentes Mori. It looked blatant at full speed, and more obvious on the replay.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Jan 17 9.10pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

The objective right now is to end the losing habit and in doing so repair confidence. Without confidence you cannot achieve anything and losing all the time just destroys you more and more. Unusually for us we've also been victim to very poor decisions and Worldies taking points away from us, this can be even more demoralising as you ask, as we as fans are, "What is it we need to do to get some luck here?"
So if we have to suffer some negative turgid football for a few weeks to try and rebuild confidence then so be it. Too many are quick to make claims like the OP, yet when the boots on the other foot they claim the same thing because we didn't put away our chances and if you can't score you deserve nothing. Everton deserved f*** all for such a highly touted team, but once again they got the luck from rank poor officiating. Just like at Goodison where they scored direct from what should of been an indirect free kick and we had a perfectly good winning goal disallowed because a player not interfering with play was flagged offside. Honestly the list of bent reffing decisions is just getting ridiculously long and yes I do mean bent.

This 100%

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Jan 17 9.11pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Remy did. He was wrestled to a halt by Fuentes Mori. It looked blatant at full speed, and more obvious on the replay.

He was blatantly held, ref had excellent view

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 21 Jan 17 9.15pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Whilst a draw wouldn't have been an unfair result, we only had 1 shot on target that I remember and only maybe 1 more chance than that. In contrast, Everton had numerous chances and had Barkley not been so wasteful they could've had 3 or 4.

We were clearly setup to not concede and get that confidence back and to be fair we nearly did it. However, you're not gonna get the points required unless you score goals so we need to find the balance and quick!

I was actually there and it was a vastly improved performance. Hit the bar and goalie making an excellent save equates to more than 1 chance. We played some good stuff against a good Everton team, of course we dont want to concede...who does?

 

cardiff eagle Flag 21 Jan 17 9.52pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

He was blatantly held, ref had excellent view

Was in Holmesdale and wasn't as big a deal our end. Looked at players and none seemed to kick off (obv remy did and i didn't see) so assumed it was nothing.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 21 Jan 17 9.53pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

I was actually there and it was a vastly improved performance. Hit the bar and goalie making an excellent save equates to more than 1 chance. We played some good stuff against a good Everton team, of course we dont want to concede...who does?

Yeah I was there too. Was defo better but that's not overly difficult compared to recent weeks. However, whilst better, we didn't show enough going forward to win the game.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 21 Jan 17 9.55pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Remy did. He was wrestled to a halt by Fuentes Mori. It looked blatant at full speed, and more obvious on the replay.

Resembled a rugby tackle, it appears refs were told not to give any penalties this week, after watching Walker blatantly pushing Sterling in the back as he was about to score for Man City.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 21 Jan 17 10.10pm

Originally posted by Painter

Resembled a rugby tackle, it appears refs were told not to give any penalties this week, after watching Walker blatantly pushing Sterling in the back as he was about to score for Man City.

Both of those should be retroactive red cards, if the league is actually doing its job properly (which of course won't happen). The rules are clear that grabbing and pushing to deny a goal scoring opportunity are red cards. A regular foul is meant to be a yellow in the area. They went over the rule during the game.

Both could not have been any more blatant.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 21 Jan 17 10.22pm

Originally posted by bicycle repair man

But we didn't deserve another awful decision from a referee.
After the ball went out for a throw he should have held up play. How can you let the game go on while the physio is on the pitch giving treatment ?
Or at least give us a chance to get a sub on.

If you are referring to when Schlupp was down the ref. was quite entitled to allow play to go on, even when the throw in was given. When Schlupp first went down he was over the line and off the field of play and could have been attended to by the physio. However, he intentionally rolled back over the line to try to get play stopped.

Edited by Pete53 (21 Jan 2017 10.22pm)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Deserved defeat