You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Feb 17 11.32pm

Originally posted by elgrande

Besides not really liking the man,I still think BFS is the right man for the job.
But again I thought there were some strange decisions,if Cabaye goes of injured why the f*** bring ledley on,Flamini all day long.
Hoping the new man Luka is available next game.
Cabaye, macarthur and Luka in the middle,puncheon on the bench.....and anyone but hennesey in goal.

Actually you have a point. Flamini looked bright in the warm up. Ledley is a waste of space and incidentally Pardew's masterstroke vs Stoke, Mboro etc at the start of the season and the only sides we could beat in 12 months under Pardew. He was so wonderful with Jimmac we didn't need Cabaye again.

Then........ Cabaye goes off injured and Ledley makes a complete cvnt of himself. Still the solution from Pardew? Some of our fans are fvckling idiots. That t1t was a charlatan.

 


COYP

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 04 Feb 17 11.34pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Pirlo played in front of the defence in his last years. He wasn't very different from Puncheon. Thiago Motta does it for PSG, Kroos for Madrid sometimes.

Not a defensive midfielder, but a deep lying playmaker. If there are 2 central box-to-box midfielders in front of him, it's doable. All he'd have to do is maintain position and close spaces, as the other 2 midfielders would be the ones doing the tackles. McArthur and Cabaye could be those.

But I reckon Allardyce will always play them differently: McArthur and Cabaye lower, Puncheon behind the striker. And not having the necessary pace in that position where you're basically the second striker really damages the pressing and recovery of the team.

LOL.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 04 Feb 17 11.35pm

Puncheon is well past his sell by date. He's too slow and hardly ever passes forward. At fault for one of today's goals ... second or third I think but there were so many!

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Mstrobez Flag 05 Feb 17 12.46am

Originally posted by mattteo

Pirlo played in front of the defence in his last years. He wasn't very different from Puncheon. Thiago Motta does it for PSG, Kroos for Madrid sometimes.

Not a defensive midfielder, but a deep lying playmaker. If there are 2 central box-to-box midfielders in front of him, it's doable. All he'd have to do is maintain position and close spaces, as the other 2 midfielders would be the ones doing the tackles. McArthur and Cabaye could be those.

But I reckon Allardyce will always play them differently: McArthur and Cabaye lower, Puncheon behind the striker. And not having the necessary pace in that position where you're basically the second striker really damages the pressing and recovery of the team.

Lord above you're full of s*** aren't you. Comparing Kroos, Motta and Pirlo to Jason Puncheon. Even in a hypothetical sense they are completely different types of players, Puncheon a winger turned number 10. You cannot play defensive mid (dlp whatever you wanna say) in a relegation threatened team with no strength or defensive abilities and to even play it at the top teams like Pirlo did, your vision and understanding of the game has to be near perfect. You become more deluded and your knowledge gets exposed more by the day.

Edited by Mstrobez (05 Feb 2017 12.47am)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 17 12.51am

Has been disappointing for a while.
Not worthy of a place in the side at the present time.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Feb 17 12.55am

He is getting axed after that shower of sh&&e today. If nothing else this will put the fear of god into Allardyce that his reputation is on the line and he is going to have to ring the changes. Puncheon was playing so well about 2 years ago, he was class, banging in those free kicks. He is awful now. So many players were puncheon above their weight (boom boom) previously and now are looking worse than they actually are.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 17 1.03am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

He is getting axed after that shower of sh&&e today. If nothing else this will put the fear of god into Allardyce that his reputation is on the line and he is going to have to ring the changes. Puncheon was playing so well about 2 years ago, he was class, banging in those free kicks. He is awful now. So many players were puncheon above their weight (boom boom) previously and now are looking worse than they actually are.

To my mind we needed more in that 'Engine room' other than just a single player.No wonder we are struggling when our squad contains the likes of Ledley,Flamini,Cabaye,Puncheon,Mutch etc etc in that vital area.

Edited by Willo (05 Feb 2017 1.03am)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Feb 17 1.07am

Originally posted by Willo

To my mind we needed more in that 'Engine room' other than just a single player.No wonder we are struggling when our squad contains the likes of Ledley,Flamini,Cabaye,Puncheon,Mutch etc etc in that vital area.

Edited by Willo (05 Feb 2017 1.03am)

Honestly in my eyes things started to go downhill when we signed Cabaye. We have too many lightweights in the centre of the park for sure. Liked my Puncheon pun so much I started a new thread with it!! Boom boom. I hope this new Serb has some nous about him and can start to drill those around him to just do the basics properly. I would love Tony Pulis back right now.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 17 1.10am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Honestly in my eyes things started to go downhill when we signed Cabaye. We have too many lightweights in the centre of the park for sure. Liked my Puncheon pun so much I started a new thread with it!! Boom boom. I hope this new Serb has some nous about him and can start to drill those around him to just do the basics properly. I would love Tony Pulis back right now.

I totally agree.Lack of physicality,lack of pace etc etc.
And all we have managed to acquire in this vital area is ONE player !

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 05 Feb 17 1.11am

Others on here have said it and they are right. I cannot believe we play Punch ahead of a naturally gifted and (once upon a time) world class defensive midfielder in Flamini.

He might not be world class anymore but he can play that position with more skill in his little toe than Puncheon can.

And McArthur on the left wing?? What the f*** is that all about??

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Maine Eagle Flag USA 05 Feb 17 1.15am

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

Others on here have said it and they are right. I cannot believe we play Punch ahead of a naturally gifted and (once upon a time) world class defensive midfielder in Flamini.

He might not be world class anymore but he can play that position with more skill in his little toe than Puncheon can.

And McArthur on the left wing?? What the f*** is that all about??

He used to get played in the hole. He is like that kid at school who can play anywhere. He can probably play in goal. I think he can play ice hockey too. Its a joke, joking aside. He needs to play in the middle of the park with that Serbian lad that wont be here next year.....

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Feb 17 1.19am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

He used to get played in the hole. He is like that kid at school who can play anywhere. He can probably play in goal. I think he can play ice hockey too. Its a joke, joking aside. He needs to play in the middle of the park with that Serbian lad that wont be here next year.....

And do you think Allardyce will be here next year if we are relegated ?

Edited by Willo (05 Feb 2017 1.20am)

 

chateauferret Flag 05 Feb 17 1.21am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

He is getting axed after that shower of sh&&e today. If nothing else this will put the fear of god into Allardyce that his reputation is on the line and he is going to have to ring the changes. Puncheon was playing so well about 2 years ago, he was class, banging in those free kicks. He is awful now. So many players were puncheon above their weight (boom boom) previously and now are looking worse than they actually are.

Here's a list of players who I think actually improved whilst Pardew was here.

Zaha.
Wickham (now long-term injury).
Maybe McArthur.

McArthur has always been good. Zaha became more direct and tracked back more. Wickham improved I think by training and playing with the likes of Adebayor and Benteke.

Ward, Dann, Delaney, Kelly, Hennessey, Puncheon, Ledley, Cabaye, Townsend - all got worse.


Edited by chateauferret (05 Feb 2017 1.21am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

mattteo Flag 05 Feb 17 8.14am

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Lord above you're full of s*** aren't you. Comparing Kroos, Motta and Pirlo to Jason Puncheon. Even in a hypothetical sense they are completely different types of players, Puncheon a winger turned number 10. You cannot play defensive mid (dlp whatever you wanna say) in a relegation threatened team with no strength or defensive abilities and to even play it at the top teams like Pirlo did, your vision and understanding of the game has to be near perfect. You become more deluded and your knowledge gets exposed more by the day.

Edited by Mstrobez (05 Feb 2017 12.47am)


Well thank you for the kind words and the vast improvement you bring on this site.

For your knowledge, all those players were wingers in their youth

 

dannyboy1978 Flag 05 Feb 17 8.21am

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Undoubtedly technically gifted, but like possession statistics it's the end product which really counts.

Technically gifted at passing it sideways and not scoring. He is an attacking midfield right?

 

Mo Sizlak Flag 05 Feb 17 8.35am

He's been piss poor for a long time now but he's not the only one.
We need a big clear out. Unfortunately, I think that'll be enforced upon us in a few months.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 05 Feb 17 9.10am

Needs to be out of the team, lost it!!

 

bromleysteve01 Flag Bromley 05 Feb 17 9.19am

Puncheon should have been dropped last season. He has no discipline to play in any position, wastes possession and creates little rather gives it away after going around in circles. With Ledley yesterday they are both so slow and negative. Add in Ledley its like playing with 9 men and our only good midfield player is on the left wing. We need to pray Luka is top quality as our midfield we are fielding is not even championship standard and making the attack and defence look silly.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 05 Feb 17 9.56am

Originally posted by mattteo

Pirlo played in front of the defence in his last years. He wasn't very different from Puncheon. Thiago Motta does it for PSG, Kroos for Madrid sometimes.

Not a defensive midfielder, but a deep lying playmaker. If there are 2 central box-to-box midfielders in front of him, it's doable. All he'd have to do is maintain position and close spaces, as the other 2 midfielders would be the ones doing the tackles. McArthur and Cabaye could be those.

But I reckon Allardyce will always play them differently: McArthur and Cabaye lower, Puncheon behind the striker. And not having the necessary pace in that position where you're basically the second striker really damages the pressing and recovery of the team.

Yes, let's compare Punch to one of the best playmakers ever? His basic story with us over the last 2/3 seasons has been, he wasn't good enough to be a winger once Wilf and Bolasie were on song so he was tried out as a No.10 as Chamakh was injured all the time. He got the odd goal in the beginning but the way the team set up allowed him to basically float and not really have many duties.
He then he got pushed further back into the midfield as apparently he is very technical and good on the ball.

He is out of his depth now and can't play the position, regardless of who is next to him he doesn't have the vision or ability needed to play the role. Our team isnt good enough to carry him so it highlights how ineffective he is. He isn't a Kroos, Pirlo or a Motta, he's a lad from south London who done alright but has never been top quality. Not an international midfielder that you're comparing him to.

Yesterday really did show how much of a difference Cabaye makes in our midfield 3 as once he went off we were lost in the middle.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

chateauferret Flag 05 Feb 17 9.59am

Originally posted by Icepick Tony


Yesterday really did show how much of a difference Cabaye makes in our midfield 3 as once he went off we were lost in the middle.

Pity we brought on Ledley instead of Flamini. Pity the Home Office couldn't issue Milevojevic' visa in time, as well.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon