You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player Shake Up
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player Shake Up


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Bert's Boys Flag 05 Feb 17 4.52pm

Enough is enough!
Sam has to drop the pre-madonnas we are playing.
Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins, Puncheon.
Tomkins performance yesterday would not be allowed in academy football. Elementary mistakes for a £10 million acquisition. Ledley also not at the races.
Dann and Cabaye are injured - we'll miss Dann more than Cabaye.
I would play Kelly at RB (can't do any worse) and Sakho if fit.
Flamini needs to come in.
Hopefully Schlupp & Mile (when he gets his visa)will come In asap.
Lee has more fight in him, and deserves a start.

Thoughts?

 

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 05 Feb 17 4.57pm

[quote=Bert's Boys;3123807]

Enough is enough!
Sam has to drop the pre-madonnas we are playing.
Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins, Puncheon.
Tomkins performance yesterday would not be allowed in academy football. Elementary mistakes for a £10 million acquisition. Ledley also not at the races.
Dann and Cabaye are injured - we'll miss Dann more than Cabaye.
I would play Kelly at RB (can't do any worse) and Sakho if fit.
Flamini needs to come in.
Hopefully Schlupp & Mile (when he gets his visa)will come In asap.
Lee has more fight in him, and deserves a start.

Thoughts?

Pretty sure he went to Villa quite a while ago

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 05 Feb 17 4.58pm

[quote=Bert's Boys;3123807]

Enough is enough!
Sam has to drop the pre-madonnas we are playing.
Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins, Puncheon.
Tomkins performance yesterday would not be allowed in academy football. Elementary mistakes for a £10 million acquisition. Ledley also not at the races.
Dann and Cabaye are injured - we'll miss Dann more than Cabaye.
I would play Kelly at RB (can't do any worse) and Sakho if fit.
Flamini needs to come in.
Hopefully Schlupp & Mile (when he gets his visa)will come In asap.
Lee has more fight in him, and deserves a start.

Thoughts?

We are certainly in trouble if we are playing this 80's pop star's support act.

 

cpj Flag Kent 05 Feb 17 5.00pm

[quote=Bert's Boys;3123807]

Enough is enough!
Sam has to drop the pre-madonnas we are playing.
Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins, Puncheon.
Tomkins performance yesterday would not be allowed in academy football. Elementary mistakes for a £10 million acquisition. Ledley also not at the races.
Dann and Cabaye are injured - we'll miss Dann more than Cabaye.
I would play Kelly at RB (can't do any worse) and Sakho if fit.
Flamini needs to come in.
Hopefully Schlupp & Mile (when he gets his visa)will come In asap.
Lee has more fight in him, and deserves a start.

Thoughts?

My main thought is why use a word if you have no idea of its spelling.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 05 Feb 17 5.20pm

I would drop

Hennesey
Delaney
Punch
Ledley
Benteke
Tomkins

Replace with

Remi
Townsend
Flamini
Mili ...
Speroni
Sakho


Keep

Ward
Dann
Van ...
Zaha
McArthur

Edited by premier fan (05 Feb 2017 5.22pm)

 

Holmesdale Hibs Flag Sydenham Hill 05 Feb 17 5.21pm

[quote=Bert's Boys;3123807]

Enough is enough!
Sam has to drop the pre-madonnas we are playing.
Hennessey, Ward, Tomkins, Puncheon.
Tomkins performance yesterday would not be allowed in academy football. Elementary mistakes for a £10 million acquisition. Ledley also not at the races.
Dann and Cabaye are injured - we'll miss Dann more than Cabaye.
I would play Kelly at RB (can't do any worse) and Sakho if fit.
Flamini needs to come in.
Hopefully Schlupp & Mile (when he gets his visa)will come In asap.
Lee has more fight in him, and deserves a start.

Thoughts?

Hennessy will be replaced when Steve is fit. Don't think Hennessey is as bad as some make out though.

Tompkins was poor yesterday but has been ok in other games. I'd personally go with a back 4 with Ward, Dann, Sakho and Van Aarnholt (sp?). Ward is a better right back than Kelly.

Ledley is a squad player and only plays when we have injuries and Puncheon is a decent player who is low on confidence. Schlopp and the new Serbian who's name I can't be bothered googling will put them further down the pecking order, although Puncheon would be good enough to start if he rediscover his form. Surprised Flamini doesn't play more because he's looked ok.

I'd also like to see Townsend given a chance. He can be frustrating but at least he makes forward runs and attempts the difficult pass rather than going back all the time. Same goes for Remy.

At least we have options after a decent transfer window.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 05 Feb 17 5.21pm

Interestingly both Jedi and Milli are of Serbian origin, perhaps that's why you mixed them up?

All the players you name deserve a chance to prove themselves and get their confidence back up. But not for much longer, especially Wayne. I think PVA and Schlupp should be our RB/LB from now on. Schlupp did great against Everton. Kelly's future is at CB Imo

 

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 05 Feb 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by FairweatherEagle

Interestingly both Jedi and Milli are of Serbian origin, perhaps that's why you mixed them up?

All the players you name deserve a chance to prove themselves and get their confidence back up. But not for much longer, especially Wayne. I think PVA and Schlupp should be our RB/LB from now on. Schlupp did great against Everton. Kelly's future is at CB Imo

Urm, Jedinak is definitely not of Serbian decent. His family are Croatian.

I think it will be easier just to call Milivojevic, Luka.

 

cpj Flag Kent 05 Feb 17 5.37pm

Originally posted by FairweatherEagle

Interestingly both Jedi and Milli are of Serbian origin, perhaps that's why you mixed them up?

All the players you name deserve a chance to prove themselves and get their confidence back up. But not for much longer, especially Wayne. I think PVA and Schlupp should be our RB/LB from now on. Schlupp did great against Everton. Kelly's future is at CB Imo

Can't play PVA at RB - crazy as playing Ward/Kelly at LB.

 

Bert's Boys Flag 05 Feb 17 6.35pm

Originally posted by cpj

My main thought is why use a word if you have no idea of its spelling.

What are you? - the spelling Police?
My main thought is try picking up the jist of the post, as opposed to being a school teacher.

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 05 Feb 17 6.43pm

I don't think there's any doubts - with anyone associated with Palace - that changes need to be made. It's just what ones!

Let's see what happens in the next 2 games and trust in Allardyce & Lee ... they've got buckets of experience and if they can't work it, then no one can with what is available.

Personally, I'm resigned to going down and think we deserve it too as been appalling for over a year.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 05 Feb 17 6.49pm

Originally posted by GlaziertoEagle

Urm, Jedinak is definitely not of Serbian decent. His family are Croatian.

I think it will be easier just to call Milivojevic, Luka.

or 'that Greek lad'

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 05 Feb 17 6.54pm

Originally posted by GlaziertoEagle

Urm, Jedinak is definitely not of Serbian decent. His family are Croatian.

I think it will be easier just to call Milivojevic, Luka.

My mistake - I keep forgetting his 1st name but yes that does make more sense.

 

OldFella Flag London 05 Feb 17 7.01pm

[quote=Bert's Boys;3123861]

What are you? - the spelling Police?
My main thought is try picking up the jist of the post, as opposed to being a school teacher.

I think you mean "gist". Looks like he has a point...

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Feb 17 7.10pm

Originally posted by Holmesdale Hibs

Hennessy will be replaced when Steve is fit. Don't think Hennessey is as bad as some make out though.

Tompkins was poor yesterday but has been ok in other games. I'd personally go with a back 4 with Ward, Dann, Sakho and Van Aarnholt (sp?). Ward is a better right back than Kelly.

Ledley is a squad player and only plays when we have injuries and Puncheon is a decent player who is low on confidence. Schlopp and the new Serbian who's name I can't be bothered googling will put them further down the pecking order, although Puncheon would be good enough to start if he rediscover his form. Surprised Flamini doesn't play more because he's looked ok.

I'd also like to see Townsend given a chance. He can be frustrating but at least he makes forward runs and attempts the difficult pass rather than going back all the time. Same goes for Remy.

At least we have options after a decent transfer window.

Enough is enough with Punch. Rediscovering his form of 2 seasons ago ? 89 PL games over 3 seasons scoring 6 goals. Dann has 10. Whilst some might say that his role is to supply the lone striker he still should be pushing a lot more forward when in possession, getting at the defence. If he can't move the play forward then he needs to be given the chop. Personally I'd be happy to get rid of him in the summer, same with Ledley, and get a real attacking midfield player who is going to put us on the offensive much more, hold onto the ball without weakly giving it away, linking up with the striker/s. If nobody can get anywhere near the striker/s we are going to struggle.

Edited by Booted Eagle (05 Feb 2017 7.11pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Bert's Boys Flag 05 Feb 17 7.48pm

Originally posted by Holmesdale Hibs

Hennessy will be replaced when Steve is fit. Don't think Hennessey is as bad as some make out though.

Tompkins was poor yesterday but has been ok in other games. I'd personally go with a back 4 with Ward, Dann, Sakho and Van Aarnholt (sp?). Ward is a better right back than Kelly.

Ledley is a squad player and only plays when we have injuries and Puncheon is a decent player who is low on confidence. Schlopp and the new Serbian who's name I can't be bothered googling will put them further down the pecking order, although Puncheon would be good enough to start if he rediscover his form. Surprised Flamini doesn't play more because he's looked ok.

I'd also like to see Townsend given a chance. He can be frustrating but at least he makes forward runs and attempts the difficult pass rather than going back all the time. Same goes for Remy.

At least we have options after a decent transfer window.


Think Hennessey and Puncheon have had enough chances now.
Agree on the rest, but as I mentioned Kelly couldn't do any worse than Ward.
Ward consistently loses his marker.

 

Bert's Boys Flag 05 Feb 17 7.49pm

Originally posted by OldFella

I think you mean "gist". Looks like he has a point...

zzzzzzzzzz

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 05 Feb 17 7.57pm

Originally posted by Holmesdale Hibs

Hennessy will be replaced when Steve is fit. Don't think Hennessey is as bad as some make out though.

Tompkins was poor yesterday but has been ok in other games. I'd personally go with a back 4 with Ward, Dann, Sakho and Van Aarnholt (sp?). Ward is a better right back than Kelly.

Ledley is a player running down his contract who looks like he no longer gives a s*** and only plays when we have injuries and Puncheon is a decent player who is low on confidence. Schlopp and the new Serbian who's name I can't be bothered googling will put them further down the pecking order, although Puncheon would be good enough to start if he rediscover his form. Surprised Flamini doesn't play more because he's looked ok.

I'd also like to see Townsend given a chance. He can be frustrating but at least he makes forward runs and attempts the difficult pass rather than going back all the time. Same goes for Remy.

At least we have options after a decent transfer window.

EFA

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

FairweatherEagle Flag London 06 Feb 17 12.01am

Originally posted by cpj

Can't play PVA at RB - crazy as playing Ward/Kelly at LB.

Again my bad, exposing myself as the clueless plastic I am eh!! Does that mean we really don't have a decent backup RB?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 06 Feb 17 9.57am

Originally posted by premier fan

I would drop

Hennesey
Delaney
Punch
Ledley
Benteke
Tomkins

Replace with

Remi
Townsend
Flamini
Mili ...
Speroni
Sakho

Keep

Ward
Dann
Van ...
Zaha
McArthur


It would appear that we're unlikely to see either of those starting anytime soon:

[Link]

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player Shake Up