You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Where has it gone wrong for Crystal Palace ?
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Where has it gone wrong for Crystal Palace ?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 24 Feb 17 11.27am

Originally posted by Kermit8

My initial five would have cost around £10mill all told. Not cheap at all. Add Mutch and Fryers that's another £10mill. £20mill that could have been spent on The Academy/Training facilities.

Campbell and Sako? Another £5mill-ish and counting.

Bamford, Sanogo and Ameobi wages? Another few million. I could name other worthless acquisitions since promotion too.

Then there is the 'value for money?' £80mill on Cabaye, Benteke and Townsend and Tomkins (incl salary)


Your examples were cheap risks and my examples are expensive risks. I would argue your lot have given more to Palace than my lot.

Someone is mis-managing the finances/the golden goose.

Kermit, your free from blame super al signed that £80mil lot whilst supposedly having palace's best interests at heart whereas I think he's always aimed to be as close to the manager as possible and safe from the sack and the offer of a new contract just around the corner. Same at Newcastle. All of which was the case just before signing that quartet and nobody else in defence or down the left hand side.

Ultimately Parish and Pardew being too close is where it's gone wrong and it all stems from there. I'm sure Parish knows that now. Filling the coaching staff with pals from the early '90s and booting out Garner was highly unprofessional and arrogant and that's why we're uncohesive, unfit, unable to hang onto points and unable to salvage anything from being 1 nil down.

But he thinks he did nothing wrong. Yeah nothing if you look at the table from when he was sacked and end your analysis there beside him on the sofa or in Staines Palace's mind.

 


COYP

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 24 Feb 17 11.37am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

Kermit your just finding fault with everything.
All clubs waste money on players.
Cheer up mate it's only a game.

I'm cool, alan. This will be my eighth relegation and your's i believe. We are used to it

We've never had anything like this kind of money go through the tills before though

Edited by Kermit8 (24 Feb 2017 11.38am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Username Flag Horsham 24 Feb 17 11.39am

Originally posted by Kermit8

My initial five would have cost around £10mill all told. Not cheap at all. Add Mutch and Fryers that's another £10mill. £20mill that could have been spent on The Academy/Training facilities.

Campbell and Sako? Another £5mill-ish and counting.

Bamford, Sanogo and Ameobi wages? Another few million. I could name other worthless acquisitions since promotion too.

Then there is the 'value for money?' £80mill on Cabaye, Benteke and Townsend and Tomkins (incl salary)


Your examples were cheap risks and my examples are expensive risks. I would argue your lot have given more to Palace than my lot.

Someone is mis-managing the finances/the golden goose.

Not when we were at the bottom of the champ they weren't. The figures might be higher these days, but then as a club we have a budget that is 100x what we had previously to work with.

And you're right, my lot did give more. That's the point I'm making. Sometimes these work out, and sometimes they don't. You can't sign Jedinak or Jerome every time. Sometimes you end up with Adebayor. Mutch didn't work out, McArthur did.

There isn't a single club in football who has a 100% success rate.

The fees you mention? Have a look at other clubs. That's how much player's cost these days if you are a Premier League club. We sold Yannick for £30m, Bournemouth paid £15m for Ibe etc.

If you're a Premier League club signing a player who you expect to start for you, £10m is a pretty common starting price. That's why Cabaye's fee doesn't seem so ridiculous to me? He's a regular starter who was exactly in that price range.

Benteke? There are only 10 players who have scored more than him in the league this season:

Sanchez (£36m)
Lukaku (£28m)
Costa (£32m)
Zlatan (£0m)
Defoe (£8m?)
Kane (£0m)
Aguero (£30m)
Alli (£5m)
Mane (£35m)
Hazard (£30m)

Six of those have reportedly cost more than, or a similar amount to Benteke (and I imagine Lukaku, Hazard and Aguero would all cost a lot more now). Other than that, you've got a 34 year old Jermain Defoe (CB is 26), a 35 year old Ibrahimovic (who let's face it is not exactly in our category) and Harry Kane and Delle Alli, who would probably cost £50m each as well.

Point is, in terms of goals Benteke is pretty much performing where he should be based on the transfer fees, and likely salaries, of those ahead of him on the list. If we wanted to replace him, we either have to gamble on someone who could flop completely, or spend at least the same amount again. Islam Slimani has 5 league goals for Leicester this season and cost about the same as Benteke.

Those price tags are why it's still worth gambling on Flamini or Remy. If these sorts of players were guaranteed top performers then they wouldn't be available on a free or on loan would they?


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Palace in the Blood Flag 24 Feb 17 11.40am

I am afraid that the appointment of SA was the end of the road. The players have just not responded to him. He has had money and he has had time

I am not saying AP was great in last year and I am not his greatest supporter but the side had much more fight under him

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 24 Feb 17 11.41am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Kermit, your free from blame super al signed that £80mil lot whilst supposedly having palace's best interests at heart whereas I think he's always aimed to be as close to the manager as possible and safe from the sack and the offer of a new contract just around the corner. Same at Newcastle. All of which was the case just before signing that quartet and nobody else in defence or down the left hand side.

Ultimately Parish and Pardew being too close is where it's gone wrong and it all stems from there. I'm sure Parish knows that now. Filling the coaching staff with pals from the early '90s and booting out Garner was highly unprofessional and arrogant and that's why we're uncohesive, unfit, unable to hang onto points and unable to salvage anything from being 1 nil down.

But he thinks he did nothing wrong. Yeah nothing if you look at the table from when he was sacked and end your analysis there beside him on the sofa or in Staines Palace's mind.

Rudi - i started a thread on here a year or so ago lamenting just how awful Palace have been through the decades with getting the right 'big money' signings and not wasting money and hoping Parish hadn't forgotten the past and learn from it. He has and he hasn't, obviously.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 17 11.51am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Willo, please read my post in detail, I never mentioned sliding down to Div 1 just relegation. I was as stated putting things into perspective and the fact is however you may wish to ignore it that SP and the three others saved this club at the eleventh hour plus enabling us to have conversations on this forum. I agree that you cannot keep looking back but when he (SP ) is coming in for criticism there has to be the good and not so good brought out and the events of 2010 were the launch pad for where we are today ......in the Premier league and in good financial shape. That is the balance.

Dynamic Dick

I am certainly not in "Ignore mode" in the manner you have suggested and having read the post above I understand where you are coming from in terms of "Balance".

I fully appreciate the part CPFC2010 played in saving our club from extinction and appreciate the "Launch pad" effect which you stated.

All I was saying is that through all our trials and tribulations now and possibly in future years we simply cannot keep up the mantra of "Oh well, we nearly went bust blah, blah ,blah etc etc". I am eternally grateful for CPFC2010 but sometimes in life one has to move on and face the 'Music' in the current without making comparisons with the past.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 24 Feb 17 11.59am

Originally posted by Username

Not when we were at the bottom of the champ they weren't. The figures might be higher these days, but then as a club we have a budget that is 100x what we had previously to work with.

And you're right, my lot did give more. That's the point I'm making. Sometimes these work out, and sometimes they don't. You can't sign Jedinak or Jerome every time. Sometimes you end up with Adebayor. Mutch didn't work out, McArthur did.

There isn't a single club in football who has a 100% success rate.

The fees you mention? Have a look at other clubs. That's how much player's cost these days if you are a Premier League club. We sold Yannick for £30m, Bournemouth paid £15m for Ibe etc.

If you're a Premier League club signing a player who you expect to start for you, £10m is a pretty common starting price. That's why Cabaye's fee doesn't seem so ridiculous to me? He's a regular starter who was exactly in that price range.

Benteke? There are only 10 players who have scored more than him in the league this season:

Sanchez (£36m)
Lukaku (£28m)
Costa (£32m)
Zlatan (£0m)
Defoe (£8m?)
Kane (£0m)
Aguero (£30m)
Alli (£5m)
Mane (£35m)
Hazard (£30m)

Six of those have reportedly cost more than, or a similar amount to Benteke (and I imagine Lukaku, Hazard and Aguero would all cost a lot more now). Other than that, you've got a 34 year old Jermain Defoe (CB is 26), a 35 year old Ibrahimovic (who let's face it is not exactly in our category) and Harry Kane and Delle Alli, who would probably cost £50m each as well.

Point is, in terms of goals Benteke is pretty much performing where he should be based on the transfer fees, and likely salaries, of those ahead of him on the list. If we wanted to replace him, we either have to gamble on someone who could flop completely, or spend at least the same amount again. Islam Slimani has 5 league goals for Leicester this season and cost about the same as Benteke.

Those price tags are why it's still worth gambling on Flamini or Remy. If these sorts of players were guaranteed top performers then they wouldn't be available on a free or on loan would they?


I was no major Dwight Gayle fan but even I recognise he would have scored as many goals as Benteke given the same amount of playing time. Just using goals as a pointer to overall worth is mis-leading.

You may think Parish/the managers have been successful and used most of the Prem dosh wisely and with prudence and in-keeping with what was expected given the status but I politely strongly disagree.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Feb 17 12.00pm

Originally posted by Willo

I fully appreciate the part CPFC2010 played in saving our club from extinction and appreciate the "Launch pad" effect which you stated.

All I was saying is that through all our trials and tribulations now and possibly in future years we simply cannot keep up the mantra of "Oh well, we nearly went bust blah, blah ,blah etc etc". I am eternally grateful for CPFC2010 but sometimes in life one has to move on and face the 'Music' in the current without making comparisons with the past.


Quite right, but you're pushing your luck expecting that to happen on here

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 24 Feb 17 12.01pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

You don't need to sign off your posts. I know you are

Very funny. Don't bother arguing the points though, none of that rubbish.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

The Dolphin Flag 24 Feb 17 12.07pm

1. Sticking with Pardew for way too long - should have gone last May.
2. Changing things too quickly - or trying to anyway - Pardew.
3. Getting rid of strong characters way too soon even if they were not going to play every week - Pardew.
4. A generally poor transer policy in as much as the players we bought - in many cases players purchased were hardly if at all better than those we had already - Pardew said in an interview that it was he who decided who he wanted even if someone else did the actual deal.
2-4 above have caused huge disruption and have surely led to our perilous position.
The transition between Team come up and team to move on is always difficult but I can't think of many who have handled it as badly as Alan Pardew.
BFS was not my choice to take over but I totally understand the logic in employing him and I will continue to support him and his decisions - within reason of course.
Whether it works or not remains to be seen but we are in a pickle and that is putting it mildly!

Edited by The Dolphin (24 Feb 2017 12.08pm)

Edited by The Dolphin (24 Feb 2017 12.08pm)

 

Username Flag Horsham 24 Feb 17 12.08pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

I was no major Dwight Gayle fan but even I recognise he would have scored as many goals as Benteke given the same amount of playing time. Just using goals as a pointer to overall worth is mis-leading.

You may think Parish/the managers have been successful and used most of the Prem dosh wisely and with prudence and in-keeping with what was expected given the status but I politely strongly disagree.

Four managers thought Gayle wasn't the answer, and his performances when starting were very average.

It's basically impossible to compete in the Premier League on the cheap. Players simply aren't available to snap up for £800,000 anymore.

I'm not saying Parish and his merry men have been excellent in the transfer market. I don't think they've been disastrous either.


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 24 Feb 17 12.23pm

Parish Pardew love in. Stopped Parish thinking straight and realising that things had gone t1ts up way before December

Also the current players for being weak minded and gutless.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 24 Feb 17 12.48pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

I'm cool, alan. This will be my eighth relegation and your's i believe. We are used to it

We've never had anything like this kind of money go through the tills before though

Edited by Kermit8 (24 Feb 2017 11.38am)

Kermit,Take a look at Season 73/74.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Feb 17 12.52pm

I've said it before. Football is about players. Managers are secondary. We didn't sign enough good players in the summer and we sold,arguably, our best one. Townsend was not good enough for Spurs and went down with Newcastle. He was never going to be good enough to play every week for Palace. We needed to sign a better winger to replace Bolasie.
The rest of the squad was flimsy and struggling half of last season and it needed bigger investment. Signing Remi as a cheap option was doomed to failure. We sold two strikers and need two better ones to replace them. What we got was a one dimensional header specialist and a Chelsea failure on loan who had hardly played for two seasons.
We sold Jedinak who was a midfield general and did not replace him with a similar player until January. Jedinak was not good enough but we were left with a weak midfield. Cabaye spends half the game on his arse and McArthur is always recovering from injury.
Parish is happy to take the blame he says. Well he's got that right at least.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Feb 2017 12.55pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 17 1.12pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I've said it before. Football is about players. Managers are secondary. We didn't sign enough good players in the summer and we sold,arguably, our best one. Townsend was not good enough for Spurs and went down with Newcastle. He was never going to be good enough to play every week for Palace. We needed to sign a better winger to replace Bolasie.
The rest of the squad was flimsy and struggling half of last season and it needed bigger investment. Signing Remi as a cheap option was doomed to failure. We sold two strikers and need two better ones to replace them. What we got was a one dimensional header specialist and a Chelsea failure on loan who had hardly played for two seasons.
We sold Jedinak who was a midfield general and did not replace him with a similar player until January. Jedinak was not good enough but we were left with a weak midfield. Cabaye spends half the game on his arse and McArthur is always recovering from injury.
Parish is happy to take the blame he says. Well he's got that right at least.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Feb 2017 12.55pm)

With respect, Steve does the deals and the financials but he doesn't identify the players or influence the manager and tell him who to buy etc.He is not a scout !

At the end of the day, it is the manager who selects potential signings and then allows SP to do the rest.Of course money comes into it and SP won't put the club at risk.Perhaps one could go further and look at the scouting/recruitment who of course feed into the manager.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 24 Feb 17 1.23pm

Originally posted by Willo

Dynamic Dick

I am certainly not in "Ignore mode" in the manner you have suggested and having read the post above I understand where you are coming from in terms of "Balance".

I fully appreciate the part CPFC2010 played in saving our club from extinction and appreciate the "Launch pad" effect which you stated.

All I was saying is that through all our trials and tribulations now and possibly in future years we simply cannot keep up the mantra of "Oh well, we nearly went bust blah, blah ,blah etc etc". I am eternally grateful for CPFC2010 but sometimes in life one has to move on and face the 'Music' in the current without making comparisons with the past.

Last paragraph accepted Willo but also be careful what you wish for as the supporters of Coventry, Leyton Orient and Charlton will testify to. I would much prefer to have at the helm someone who does genuinely care about the club and with us through good and bad times. Even if the worst happens and we go down this year I would want SP in charge with sleeves rolled up ready to come back. He has made mistakes like all of us and being the chairman of a PL club cannot be easy.

As you say let's look forward and hope that we can escape the dreaded drop.

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 Feb 17 1.59pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Last paragraph accepted Willo but also be careful what you wish for as the supporters of Coventry, Leyton Orient and Charlton will testify to. I would much prefer to have at the helm someone who does genuinely care about the club and with us through good and bad times. Even if the worst happens and we go down this year I would want SP in charge with sleeves rolled up ready to come back. He has made mistakes like all of us and being the chairman of a PL club cannot be easy.

As you say let's look forward and hope that we can escape the dreaded drop.

With respect your comments infer that I am Anti-Parish and CPFC2010 when nothing could be further from the truth.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 24 Feb 17 5.48pm

Football is a funny old game, as JG famously said. If you look at Leicester's situation its similar to ours, they have good players, but they are just not performing this year, anywhere near what they did last year.
Our players have been under performing for 18 months, what the reason is has been the subject of much debate, but nobody has come up with the answer.
Blaming Pardew, Parish, Hennessy or anybody they can think of at any moment in time. We have good players, but they just don't seem to bond as a team, with team spirit and a will to win. How you put that back into a team is the question, until we do, its a downward spiral.

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 24 Feb 17 6.50pm

I believe it started when talk of European qualification started, been downhill ever since.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 24 Feb 17 7.45pm

Originally posted by Painter

Football is a funny old game, as JG famously said. If you look at Leicester's situation its similar to ours, they have good players, but they are just not performing this year, anywhere near what they did last year.
Our players have been under performing for 18 months, what the reason is has been the subject of much debate, but nobody has come up with the answer.
Blaming Pardew, Parish, Hennessy or anybody they can think of at any moment in time. We have good players, but they just don't seem to bond as a team, with team spirit and a will to win. How you put that back into a team is the question, until we do, its a downward spiral.

Excellent post Painter

 


Bring back Brolin

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Where has it gone wrong for Crystal Palace ?