You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clattenburg in disguise?


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 26 Feb 17 1.21am

In real time Willo, at the game, the referee got numerous decisions wrong: My opinion and that of so many others, even when removing our red n blue rimmed specs. Refs are indeed 'only human' but less so when performing with the sheer incompetence shown today!

Sadly mate, your constant supercilous opinions are, far from creating the air of expert that you crave/demand, proving you to be an almighty laughing stock.

Just once, leave others to post and debate with your need to denounce everyone else's opinion.

 


Spirit of 1974

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 2.13am

Originally posted by Willo

You mention "Pundits" - they probably have had the advantage of viewing incidents from various angles several times using "Slow-Mos". The Referee does NOT have this advantage and forms a judgement from his sight angle in a fast moving scenario, not forgetting the fact that he has to be virtually instananeous in his decision making. All very easy reviewing incidents in the comfort of a TV studio and several times at that.

And I also mentioned that MoTD made it very clear where the officials were and what they could see and explained exactly why the referee should have had no problem calling the McArthur penalty decision correctly in real time from where he was standing. You chose to ignore this point and just pasted in your usual claptrap about replays, despite the fact that I had already dealt with it.

Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 2.16am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

ParchmoreEagle Flag Belair 26 Feb 17 7.07am

Watched the whole match streamed in Australia. The ref looked biased. Zaha was fouled and should have been a penalty. After that, any 50/50 went Middlesbrough's way.

 


[Link]

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Feb 17 7.44am

Originally posted by Willo

You mention "Pundits" - they probably have had the advantage of viewing incidents from various angles several times using "Slow-Mos". The Referee does NOT have this advantage and forms a judgement from his sight angle in a fast moving scenario, not forgetting the fact that he has to be virtually instananeous in his decision making. All very easy reviewing incidents in the comfort of a TV studio and several times at that.

As for so called s..e refereeing being acceptable, after every game his/her performance is 'Forensically' analysed in the 'Corridors of power' and they will form a judgement as to his/her performance on the day.


Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 12.06am)

And what exactly will happen to him for being totally incompetent and maybe even biased?? Answer..nothing! Its almost a joke watching Wilf getting kicked from pillar to post week after week, with no referee seeming to give him any protection at all from thug defenders whose only way to stop him seems to be fouling him, which they do with impunity as there is never any punishment! Guarantee if Wilf does move to Tottenham he WILL get penalties awarded week in week out by the very same referees who deny him now.....bias?? Maybe, possibly! And I see that youve already done the "I dont want to turn this into a Willo thread" post....yeah after youve already done your utmost to do just that with your ridiculous defence of the indefensible referee yesterday...Well done Willo!!!!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 26 Feb 17 7.49am

I won't accuse Madley of being biased.

But he was certainly incompetent.

One decision after another he called incorrectly.

A spell in the National League would be appropriate.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Feb 17 7.58am

Originally posted by NEILLO

I won't accuse Madley of being biased.

But he was certainly incompetent.

One decision after another he called incorrectly.

A spell in the National League would be appropriate.


Why should he be allowed to mess up their weekends too? A spell in the classroom learning how to referee a game fairly would be much more useful, as would a trip to Specsavers after the McArthur booking joke

Edited by the silurian (26 Feb 2017 7.59am)

 

bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 26 Feb 17 8.16am

To be fair(!), his incompetence included not booking Luka in the first half, for what looked like quite a scythe.

 


Spirit of 1974

DaWick Flag Kingston 26 Feb 17 8.36am

Willo
As much as I like you, I can't help but think that you were 'sitting down' during the game, hence missing the refs abysmal performance

To put it into further context for you, My 10 year old nephew was able to justifiably call out the ref's bad decisions time after time.

At best it was a Clattenburgesque shambles, without the s***e tattoos.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 8.56am

Originally posted by bifffabazz

In real time Willo, at the game, the referee got numerous decisions wrong: My opinion and that of so many others, even when removing our red n blue rimmed specs. Refs are indeed 'only human' but less so when performing with the sheer incompetence shown today!

Sadly mate, your constant supercilous opinions are, far from creating the air of expert that you crave/demand, proving you to be an almighty laughing stock.

Just once, leave others to post and debate with your need to denounce everyone else's opinion.

Those who really know me would indeed "Laugh" if they read these comments. They would readily testify that they would NEVER associate the word "Supercilious" with me nor ever conclude that I would crave/demand an air of expertise. I have constantly stated I am self-deprecation rather than self-promotion and this is how they see me.

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 9.02am

Originally posted by Willo

Those who really know me would indeed "Laugh" if they read these comments. They would readily testify that they would NEVER associate the word "Supercilious" with me nor ever conclude that I would crave/demand an air of expertise. I have constantly stated I am self-deprecation rather than self-promotion and this is how they see me.

"I've made my views perfectly clear.Don't want to turn this into a wearisome WILLO debate so this is my last post in this thread".

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.03am

Originally posted by the silurian

And what exactly will happen to him for being totally incompetent and maybe even biased?? Answer..nothing! Its almost a joke watching Wilf getting kicked from pillar to post week after week, with no referee seeming to give him any protection at all from thug defenders whose only way to stop him seems to be fouling him, which they do with impunity as there is never any punishment! Guarantee if Wilf does move to Tottenham he WILL get penalties awarded week in week out by the very same referees who deny him now.....bias?? Maybe, possibly! And I see that youve already done the "I dont want to turn this into a Willo thread" post....yeah after youve already done your utmost to do just that with your ridiculous defence of the indefensible referee yesterday...Well done Willo!!!!

All I have stated is that we won a very important game and people are concentrating on the performance of the referee ! And his decisions never cost us the game !!!!

I have no desire to stifle debate about referees and everyone can have their say but to have this in such focus after a much needed win is, in my humble estimation, somewhat incredulous.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 26 Feb 17 9.03am

Penalty for us at both ends.

On MoTD, even Alan Shearer agreed on the McArthur incident ... Tony Gale on Sky said "for me, it's a penalty" about Wilf being shoved over the line. Poor and inconsistent refereeing AGAIN.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.07am

Originally posted by chateauferret

"I've made my views perfectly clear.Don't want to turn this into a wearisome WILLO debate so this is my last post in this thread".

Indeed I posted this after midnight after celebrating our terrific and much needed win and I readily admit that I forgot about this post.Very worrying as far as I am concerned !

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.12am

Originally posted by Henry of Peckham

Penalty for us at both ends.

On MoTD, even Alan Shearer agreed on the McArthur incident ... Tony Gale on Sky said "for me, it's a penalty" about Wilf being shoved over the line. Poor and inconsistent refereeing AGAIN.

Pundits who have seen 'Slow-mo' replays probably loads of times.A referee only sees things once from his angle and often his view is obscured. Trust me, I know and have spoken to many referees about this.

Do pundits in general heap praise on some brilliant decisions ? Do they focus on the referee when he makes terrific judgement calls ?

 

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 9.14am

Originally posted by Willo

All I have stated is that we won a very important game and people are concentrating on the performance of the referee ! And his decisions never cost us the game !!!!

I have no desire to stifle debate about referees and everyone can have their say but to have this in such focus after a much needed win is, in my humble estimation, somewhat incredulous.

Oh, well, so that's OK then, right? If we win, it's OK for the ref to be as appallingly incompetent as he likes because his decisions "never cost us the game". What bizarre logic.

Even if they didn't, they cost us a couple of goals which affects our goal difference and in this case affects the standings - win 3-0 and we go above Boro. And if McArthur is suspended because he has five yellow cards on the last day of the season then the completely bollocks decision to book him yesterday could be very significant. And then there is the small matter that winning by a single goal his decisions *might* very well have cost us the points and certainly when McArthur was fouled converting the penalty would have killed the game there and then. Finally there is the difference in squad confidence and morale between winning 1-0 and feeling that you were ganged up on, on the one hand, and winning 3-0 on a fair and level playing field on the other. You would need to be blind not to have seen the effect on Wilf of the refs failing to protect him in the Stoke and Sunderland matches. He dealt with it yesterday but the ref still allowed defenders to commit repeated assaults on him, inside and outside the box, without raising an eyebrow.

You are talking out of your arse.


Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 9.19am)

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 9.16am

Originally posted by Willo

Pundits who have seen 'Slow-mo' replays probably loads of times.A referee only sees things once from his angle and often his view is obscured. Trust me, I know and have spoken to many referees about this.

Do pundits in general heap praise on some brilliant decisions ? Do they focus on the referee when he makes terrific judgement calls ?

Sometimes, but in general a ref who is doing his job properly is inconspicuous.

 


============
The Ferret
============

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Feb 17 9.25am

Originally posted by Willo

Pundits who have seen 'Slow-mo' replays probably loads of times.A referee only sees things once from his angle and often his view is obscured. Trust me, I know and have spoken to many referees about this.

Do pundits in general heap praise on some brilliant decisions ? Do they focus on the referee when he makes terrific judgement calls ?

Is this your last post, or will there be another last post?? Excitement is building.....

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.31am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Oh, well, so that's OK then, right? If we win, it's OK for the ref to be as appallingly incompetent as he likes because his decisions "never cost us the game". What bizarre logic.

Even if they didn't, they cost us a couple of goals which affects our goal difference and in this case affects the standings - win 3-0 and we go above Boro. And if McArthur is suspended because he has five yellow cards on the last day of the season then the completely bollocks decision to book him yesterday could be very significant. And then there is the small matter that winning by a single goal his decisions *might* very well have cost us the points and certainly when McArthur was fouled converting the penalty would have killed the game there and then. Finally there is the difference in squad confidence and morale between winning 1-0 and feeling that you were ganged up on, on the one hand, and winning 3-0 on a fair and level playing field on the other. You would need to be blind not to have seen the effect on Wilf of the refs failing to protect him in the Stoke and Sunderland matches. He dealt with it yesterday but the ref still allowed defenders to commit repeated assaults on him, inside and outside the box, without raising an eyebrow.

You are talking out of your arse.


Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 9.19am)

With respect not "Bizarre logic" at all in my book.

Of course one can debate about the performance of the referees and everyone is entitled to their opinion.What I find "Bizarre" is that we have achieved a much needed win yet debate is firmly centred on the referee ! That's all I am saying.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.32am

Originally posted by the silurian

Is this your last post, or will there be another last post?? Excitement is building.....

Silurian

I know how disappointed you would be if this indeed was my last post on this thread.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 26 Feb 17 9.35am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Sometimes, but in general a ref who is doing his job properly is inconspicuous.

Certainly "Inconspicious" after a game due to a terrific performance not being highlighted.I'm afraid no balance at all which is very disappointing.

 

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?