You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > I f@cking hate Man United
November 22 2026 8.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

I f@cking hate Man United


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 12.20pm

Originally posted by PALACE FOR EVER

A penalty for me but is another example of the problem using replays would cause for deciding decisions. Not everyone would agree.

Yes I agree with you.

In certain circumstances even with replays there wouldn't be a consensus and there would still be debates on HOL and the like.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Mar 17 2.30pm

Originally posted by Willo

Why was it ridiculous ?

Smith had his arm out - when the ball made contact with it his arm moved forward and the ball went in that direction so it looked for all the world it was a penalty. I can understand why it was given.

Edited by Willo (05 Mar 2017 12.10pm)

Fair enough Willo, but can you understand why the burnley pen was given? Burnley player puts arm towards ball, ball hits Burnley players arm held out in front of him and ......Burnley are awarded a penalty!!! Unbelievable, ridiculous....any other word you like, it was a joke decision!!!

 

chateauferret Flag 05 Mar 17 4.59pm

Originally posted by Willo

Why was it ridiculous ?

Smith had his arm out - when the ball made contact with it his arm moved forward and the ball went in that direction so it looked for all the world it was a penalty. I can understand why it was given.

Edited by Willo (05 Mar 2017 12.10pm)

If you can't see why that decision was ridiculous you need to go and see someone.

Of course, you can, and you're merely trolling as usual.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 5.02pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

If you can't see why that decision was ridiculous you need to go and see someone.

Of course, you can, and you're merely trolling as usual.

No it wasn't ridiculous at all.
What IS ridiculous is your risible allegation that I am "Merely trolling as usual". Absolute hogwash.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 5.06pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Fair enough Willo, but can you understand why the burnley pen was given? Burnley player puts arm towards ball, ball hits Burnley players arm held out in front of him and ......Burnley are awarded a penalty!!! Unbelievable, ridiculous....any other word you like, it was a joke decision!!!

I have seen the incident.There was a 'Freeze frame' and all I could see was the ball next to the arm of a Swansea player. Also there were so many bodies in a short space and from the referees view it was a white shirt which handled hence the penalty.

If the referee had the benefit of TV replays in 'Slow-Mo' then he would have reacted differently.Yes we all know about the decision but it certainly wasn't a "Joke".

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 05 Mar 17 5.13pm

If in doubt referees - just don't give it.

And please do not guess.

 

chateauferret Flag 05 Mar 17 6.10pm

Originally posted by Willo

No it wasn't ridiculous at all.
What IS ridiculous is your risible allegation that I am "Merely trolling as usual". Absolute hogwash.

You have been outed as a persistent long-term troll many times and I make no apology for calling you out on it. There is no balance in your position, no acceptance of anyone else's view, and no such thing as a s**** or dodgy ref no matter how outrageous the decisiins they take.

I've been using social media fora since Usenet was invented and I know a f***ing troll when I see one.

Edited by chateauferret (05 Mar 2017 6.11pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 6.14pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

You have been outed as a persistent long-term troll many times and I make no apology for calling you out on it. There is no balance in your position, no acceptance of anyone else's view, and no such thing as a s**** or dodgy ref no matter how outrageous the decisiins they take.

I've been using social media fora since Usenet was invented and I know a f***ing troll when I see one.

Edited by chateauferret (05 Mar 2017 6.11pm)

I would seriously suggest you consider your judgement given that you make such ridiculous allegations about me.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Mar 17 6.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have seen the incident.There was a 'Freeze frame' and all I could see was the ball next to the arm of a Swansea player. Also there were so many bodies in a short space and from the referees view it was a white shirt which handled hence the penalty.

If the referee had the benefit of TV replays in 'Slow-Mo' then he would have reacted differently.Yes we all know about the decision but it certainly wasn't a "Joke".

Im sorry Willo but that is total hogwash, piffle and bull****!!! From MOTD coverage it was VERY obvious it was a Burnley player handling it, for a start Swansea players had long sleeve WHITE shirts, the handball was a BARE arm (with a Burnley shirt attached to the top of it)but I suppose with the generally awful standard of refereeing today we have to accept it, just as Ibrahimovics elbow was purely an accidental attempt to maim Mings in the other game!!! Both decisions were most certainly 'a joke'!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 6.26pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Im sorry Willo but that is total hogwash, piffle and bull****!!! From MOTD coverage it was VERY obvious it was a Burnley player handling it, for a start Swansea players had long sleeve WHITE shirts, the handball was a BARE arm (with a Burnley shirt attached to the top of it)but I suppose with the generally awful standard of refereeing today we have to accept it, just as Ibrahimovics elbow was purely an accidental attempt to maim Mings in the other game!!! Both decisions were most certainly 'a joke'!

I never saw MOTD nor did the referee have such assistance if it was so conclusive !

I saw a clip on 'Goals on Sunday' and I saw the ball very close to a white shirt which of course is a Swansea shirt.All about the angle of the referee and what he sees when players are in very close proximity.A referee only gives what he sees and he has NO help from any TV 'Slow-Mos' and makes split-second decisions.

All very well to say it was a bad decision when one has seen it on TV.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Mar 17 6.35pm

Originally posted by Willo

I never saw MOTD nor did the referee have such assistance if it was so conclusive !

I saw a clip on 'Goals on Sunday' and I saw the ball very close to a white shirt which of course is a Swansea shirt.All about the angle of the referee and what he sees when players are in very close proximity.A referee only gives what he sees and he has NO help from any TV 'Slow-Mos' and makes split-second decisions.

All very well to say it was a bad decision when one has seen it on TV.

Ok OK i give up, talking to you about referees is like arguing with porridge! You will NEVER admit for one minute that a referee got it wrong, you ALWAYS give various reasons why he may have seen it differently to 99.9% of the rest of the viewing public..OK if they are not up to it, and I can understand why they may not be, due to age lack of fitness etc etc, then they need technology to help them. I can also understand why they dont want it, because it would show up their incompetence (and I do hope it is incompetence, rather than something more sinister).
Either way, I now give up on this thread as I dont want to turn it into a Silurian thread, so I will not comment again!!!! Unless of course, like you I forget I said it and then I will post again

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 6.44pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Ok OK i give up, talking to you about referees is like arguing with porridge! You will NEVER admit for one minute that a referee got it wrong, you ALWAYS give various reasons why he may have seen it differently to 99.9% of the rest of the viewing public..OK if they are not up to it, and I can understand why they may not be, due to age lack of fitness etc etc, then they need technology to help them. I can also understand why they dont want it, because it would show up their incompetence (and I do hope it is incompetence, rather than something more sinister).
Either way, I now give up on this thread as I dont want to turn it into a Silurian thread, so I will not comment again!!!! Unless of course, like you I forget I said it and then I will post again

With respect I HAVE said on numerous occasions that referees are only human and err from time to time as do managers and players.

I have also said quite a few times that I try to see things from a referee's perspective to try and understand why he/she made a decision and this is what I bring to the debate on HOL.

There are lot of terrific referees after they have viewed TV 'Slow-Mos' from a plethora of angles !!!!

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Mar 17 6.50pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect I HAVE said on numerous occasions that referees are only human and err from time to time as do managers and players.

I have also said quite a few times that I try to see things from a referee's perspective to try and understand why he/she made a decision and this is what I bring to the debate on HOL.

There are lot of terrific referees after they have viewed TV 'Slow-Mos' from a plethora of angles !!!!

Oh look I forgot I wasnt going to post!!
The referee in both those matches GOT IT WRONG!! DO YOU AGREE WITH THAT OR NOT?? Thats all I want to know!!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 7.22pm

Originally posted by the silurian

Oh look I forgot I wasnt going to post!!
The referee in both those matches GOT IT WRONG!! DO YOU AGREE WITH THAT OR NOT?? Thats all I want to know!!

What I am saying is that referees cannot get EVERY decision correct, nor can we expect this of managers and players.

When I have felt that a referee has got a contentious decision 100% right, I have given my honest assessment even though others vehemiently disagree - I don't take an alternative viewpoint just to be provocative or to stimulate a fiesty debate on here.Seemingly there are those on here who believe I adopt a position of 'Agent provocateur' just to raise hackles when nothing could be further from the truth.

At the end of the day I assess decisions from the point of view of the referee/assistant to try and understand why decisions were made or not made.Some seem baffling to the general public but then again the vast majority don't have any experience of refereeing/lining to understand the complexities involved.

 

batcountry Flag Melbourne 05 Mar 17 7.40pm

When discussing referee error you cant just trot out the same plethora of reasons why they dekcuf up. They don't all apply to every situation. Narrow it down to individual cases and tell it like it is.
And I have to say the Swansea/Burnley situation reminded me of a penalty that palace were awarded against Leeds. As the cross came over Dyer was head and shoulders above the defenders and everyone in Selhurst Park barring the referee and assistants saw that it was his raised gloved hand that touched the ball and we got the penalty. So the point I guess is that referees do inexplicable things that are idefensible and unaccountable so until robots control our beautiful game we're stuck with it.
Imagine the holmesdale questioning the parentage of R2D2.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 7.52pm

Originally posted by batcountry

When discussing referee error you cant just trot out the same plethora of reasons why they dekcuf up. They don't all apply to every situation. Narrow it down to individual cases and tell it like it is.
And I have to say the Swansea/Burnley situation reminded me of a penalty that palace were awarded against Leeds. As the cross came over Dyer was head and shoulders above the defenders and everyone in Selhurst Park barring the referee and assistants saw that it was his raised gloved hand that touched the ball and we got the penalty. So the point I guess is that referees do inexplicable things that are idefensible and unaccountable so until robots control our beautiful game we're stuck with it.
Imagine the holmesdale questioning the parentage of R2D2.

With respect, I DO "Narrow it down.." as I have discussed specific incidents and tried to see these individual incidents from the referee's perspective.

Indeed some decisions appear "Inexplicable" but there is always a reason and often a very plausible explanation.

Very fast-moving scenarios, split-second decisions, sight-lines, varying types of incidents in terms of angles and force, player simulation etc etc etc - Is it any wonder that referees err from time to time ?

Edited by Willo (05 Mar 2017 7.55pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 05 Mar 17 8.09pm

Originally posted by Willo

What I am saying is that referees cannot get EVERY decision correct, nor can we expect this of managers and players.

When I have felt that a referee has got a contentious decision 100% right, I have given my honest assessment even though others vehemiently disagree - I don't take an alternative viewpoint just to be provocative or to stimulate a fiesty debate on here.Seemingly there are those on here who believe I adopt a position of 'Agent provocateur' just to raise hackles when nothing could be further from the truth.

At the end of the day I assess decisions from the point of view of the referee/assistant to try and understand why decisions were made or not made.Some seem baffling to the general public but then again the vast majority don't have any experience of refereeing/lining to understand the complexities involved.


ok you've proved my point!You still haven't answered my simple question. I know refs cant get 100% correct, what we are asking for is that those decisions that are easy (Ibrahimovic elbow...red card.Mings stamp...red card Burnley penalty....wrongly awarded) are judged correctly..Honestly Willo even with your one eyed view of refs, you have to see that those three decisions were WRONG yet you still wont say the word will you??? They were wrong decisions, the world knows they were wrong yet you wont admit it.....just those 3 not the myriad other errors every week...just those 3 !! Why is it so difficult?

Edited by the silurian (05 Mar 2017 8.11pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 8.29pm

Originally posted by the silurian


ok you've proved my point!You still haven't answered my simple question. I know refs cant get 100% correct, what we are asking for is that those decisions that are easy (Ibrahimovic elbow...red card.Mings stamp...red card Burnley penalty....wrongly awarded) are judged correctly..Honestly Willo even with your one eyed view of refs, you have to see that those three decisions were WRONG yet you still wont say the word will you??? They were wrong decisions, the world knows they were wrong yet you wont admit it.....just those 3 not the myriad other errors every week...just those 3 !! Why is it so difficult?

Edited by the silurian (05 Mar 2017 8.11pm)

I have consistently stated that referees err from time to time, how many more times do I have to type this ? It is NOT difficult for me to say this as this is fact and it would be ridiculous of me to say otherwise.

One can disect individual decisions but let's have some balance.I have witnessed some brilliant 'Tight' calls by assistants, some terrific refereeing decisions but are these highlighted ? Are they hell.

I have clapped some excellent decisions either at a ground or in front of the television but these never get a mention at all.

 

chateauferret Flag 05 Mar 17 8.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have consistently stated that referees err from time to time, how many more times do I have to type this ? It is NOT difficult for me to say this as this is fact and it would be ridiculous of me to say otherwise.

One can disect individual decisions but let's have some balance.I have witnessed some brilliant 'Tight' calls by assistants, some terrific refereeing decisions but are these highlighted ? Are they hell.

I have clapped some excellent decisions either at a ground or in front of the television but these never get a mention at all.

The point is not that referees err frim time to time (although the wording I would use is "they f*** up constantly" ).

The point is that it's not acceptable.

Edited by chateauferret (05 Mar 2017 8.33pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 05 Mar 17 8.40pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

The point is not that referees err frim time to time (although the wording I would use is "they f*** up constantly" ).

The point is that it's not acceptable.

Edited by chateauferret (05 Mar 2017 8.33pm)

So you expect them to be right 100% of the time ?

And whilst they do make mistakes, I do NOT accept that they are "Serial offenders", constantly making bad decisions throughout a game on a regular basis.

Of course there will be contentious issues but a referee never purposely makes a decision he knows to be wrong and he doesn't have the benefit of technology to assist him/her.Overall our referees do a darned good job in difficult circumstances.Rest assured this is my HONEST view and NOT designed as any sort of provocation on HOL.

Edited by Willo (05 Mar 2017 8.40pm)

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > I f@cking hate Man United