You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Graham Poll (TalkSport)
November 16 2026 10.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Graham Poll (TalkSport)


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Phil H Flag 03 Mar 17 9.56am

Originally posted by Willo

Absolutely correct.

Regards the Man C v Huddersfield game,despite umpteen replays using 'Slow-Mo' a consensus could not be reached.Such things are often not a matter of 'Fact' like goalline technology when the ball is either in or out.I understand the calls for video technology but it is not a panacea and there will still be disputes.

Edited by Willo (03 Mar 2017 9.36am)

I think these points are fair but at least having a fourth official take a good look would take the heat out of the situation. And avoid the insanely wrong calls which occur when the ref's vision is impeded when everyone at home and in the studio can see it but not the ref.

 

chateauferret Flag 03 Mar 17 9.59am

Originally posted by Willo

Absolutely correct.

Regards the Man C v Huddersfield game,despite umpteen replays using 'Slow-Mo' a consensus could not be reached.Such things are often not a matter of 'Fact' like goalline technology when the ball is either in or out.I understand the calls for video technology but it is not a panacea and there will still be disputes.

Edited by Willo (03 Mar 2017 9.36am)

It is a matter of fact that Madley's decision to book McArthur instead of giving a penalty was clearly wrong. That is just an example.

Referees don't want this help because it would expose their dishonesty and incompetence. If they were honest they would welcome it with open arms.

 


============
The Ferret
============

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Mar 17 10.00am

Originally posted by Willo

Absolutely correct.

Regards the Man C v Huddersfield game,despite umpteen replays using 'Slow-Mo' a consensus could not be reached.Such things are often not a matter of 'Fact' like goalline technology when the ball is either in or out.I understand the calls for video technology but it is not a panacea and there will still be disputes.

Edited by Willo (03 Mar 2017 9.36am)

Goddess of universal remedy.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Mar 17 10.04am

Originally posted by Phil H

I think these points are fair but at least having a fourth official take a good look would take the heat out of the situation. And avoid the insanely wrong calls which occur when the ref's vision is impeded when everyone at home and in the studio can see it but not the ref.

It is a very interesting debate as to how and when technology should be used.For instance, is EVERY goal reviewed in case there was an infringement ? Is EVERY tackle in the area that could possibly be a penalty reviewed ? What are the guidelines for reviews - what are the parameters ? As ever when one 'drills down' the devil lies in the detail.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Mar 17 10.09am

Originally posted by chateauferret

It is a matter of fact that Madley's decision to book McArthur instead of giving a penalty was clearly wrong. That is just an example.

Referees don't want this help because it would expose their dishonesty and incompetence. If they were honest they would welcome it with open arms.

This is not a matter of FACT which I am referring to. I am talking about clear-cut issues like the ball being in or out of the goal IE Goalline technology.

Other matters come down to interpretation ie What IS a hand's unnatural or natural position ? A few inches here or there and it can be construed as one or the other.
Even a tackle can be open to dispute with some thinking it should be a 'Red', others a 'Yellow'. I have even heard of the term 'Orange' being used !

Clear 'Matters of fact' are not disputable (Goalline technology), others can create a debate where there is no consensus at all.

Edited by Willo (03 Mar 2017 10.21am)

 

chateauferret Flag 03 Mar 17 11.30am

Originally posted by Willo

This is not a matter of FACT which I am referring to. I am talking about clear-cut issues like the ball being in or out of the goal IE Goalline technology.

Other matters come down to interpretation ie What IS a hand's unnatural or natural position ? A few inches here or there and it can be construed as one or the other.
Even a tackle can be open to dispute with some thinking it should be a 'Red', others a 'Yellow'. I have even heard of the term 'Orange' being used !

Clear 'Matters of fact' are not disputable (Goalline technology), others can create a debate where there is no consensus at all.

Edited by Willo (03 Mar 2017 10.21am)

It's a matter of fact becaus the only two people who dispute it are a) Madley himself and b) you.

My point is that this like a great many cases are open and shut and are harldy matters for the kind of interpretation you suggest.

There is no point in trying to run when you can't yet walk.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Mar 17 11.54am

Originally posted by chateauferret

It's a matter of fact becaus the only two people who dispute it are a) Madley himself and b) you.

My point is that this like a great many cases are open and shut and are harldy matters for the kind of interpretation you suggest.

There is no point in trying to run when you can't yet walk.

With respect, 'Open and shut' cases are whether the ball crossed the line or not.

I don't agree that others incidents are as 'Open and shut' as you suggest and are open to a great deal of interpretation but I can envisage cases where it enters such a category.
Video techology won't be a panacea as has been demonstrated by a lack of consensus amongst those who have seen umpteen 'Slow-Mo' replays.There could still be healthy and fiesty debate even after a decision has been reached using technology ! We have to have something to argue about down the pub !

 

Username Flag Horsham 03 Mar 17 12.14pm

Originally posted by Willo

With respect, 'Open and shut' cases are whether the ball crossed the line or not.

I don't agree that others incidents are as 'Open and shut' as you suggest and are open to a great deal of interpretation but I can envisage cases where it enters such a category.
Video techology won't be a panacea as has been demonstrated by a lack of consensus amongst those who have seen umpteen 'Slow-Mo' replays.There could still be healthy and fiesty debate even after a decision has been reached using technology ! We have to have something to argue about down the pub !


Whilst it is far from perfect, and plenty of people moan about it, in both NFL and Cricket there is the concept of the 'on field call' or 'umpires call' when it comes to teams challenging decisions.

In the event of a close decision which isn't absolutely nailed on, the decision stays as it was called orginally if the TV evidence isn't conclusive.

There has to be conclusive proof that a decision was incorrect.

So for example, if teams had one challenge per game then we could potentially have challenge Snodgrass' penalty and Southampton could have challenged the Gabbiadini offside. In more debateable situations, Wilf on Saturday for example, the call would remain the same.

The added impact of these to me, is not only to fix obviously bad decisions, but also empower and encourage referees to make calls in the first place.

It lessens the need for a referee to feel like he's playing it safe?


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Phil H Flag 03 Mar 17 12.26pm

I totally agree with this and can't understand why football is so far behind other sports. Almost every wicket in cricket they check for no-ball; the basic legality of the wicket. Every goal should be routinely checked for offside. The Gabbiadini incident was a shocker. Penalties are less clear-cut but the idea is not to create a perfect world, just eliminate the howlers.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Mar 17 12.29pm

Originally posted by Username


Whilst it is far from perfect, and plenty of people moan about it, in both NFL and Cricket there is the concept of the 'on field call' or 'umpires call' when it comes to teams challenging decisions.

In the event of a close decision which isn't absolutely nailed on, the decision stays as it was called orginally if the TV evidence isn't conclusive.

There has to be conclusive proof that a decision was incorrect.

So for example, if teams had one challenge per game then we could potentially have challenge Snodgrass' penalty and Southampton could have challenged the Gabbiadini offside. In more debateable situations, Wilf on Saturday for example, the call would remain the same.

The added impact of these to me, is not only to fix obviously bad decisions, but also empower and encourage referees to make calls in the first place.

It lessens the need for a referee to feel like he's playing it safe?

In cricket, in terms of an LBW an umpire makes a decision and then it is reviewed if challenged.He doesn't fall back on technology each and every time he believes that it COULD be LBW.

Different for 'Run-Outs' for example, when umpires will call for technology if it is a close-call.

When one considers the use of technology in football, a number of thoughts enter one's mind ie Manager challenges, when should a referee call for the video,should a 5th official advise the referee during the game, what should he call it for etc etc etc. Can get quite detailed and complicated but interesting all the same.
As they say "The devil lies in the detail".

Edited by Willo (03 Mar 2017 12.51pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Mar 17 12.36pm

Originally posted by Phil H

I totally agree with this and can't understand why football is so far behind other sports. Almost every wicket in cricket they check for no-ball; the basic legality of the wicket. Every goal should be routinely checked for offside. The Gabbiadini incident was a shocker. Penalties are less clear-cut but the idea is not to create a perfect world, just eliminate the howlers.

You cannot be offside from a corner or if the ball is cut-back to a player who scores so why check for offside in these circumstances ? Maybe a case of availing of technology/5th referee for "Interfering with opponent" etc etc when a goal is scored eg Player in offside position affecting sightline of goalkeeper.
So much to consider regarding technology !

 

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 03 Mar 17 12.43pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Wasn't it Wilf going over in the box (not saying a dive by the way) that relegated Peterborough from the Championship? Or have I dreamt up some fantastical scenario that didn't happen?

Foul in Gabbidon. But that was absolutely hilarious, that knobhead Durham on TalkSport had started a campaign: #NoMorePensForPalace

Then we relegated his team, with a penalty. Glorious.

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Phil H Flag 03 Mar 17 1.30pm

Originally posted by Willo

You cannot be offside from a corner or if the ball is cut-back to a player who scores so why check for offside in these circumstances ? Maybe a case of availing of technology/5th referee for "Interfering with opponent" etc etc when a goal is scored eg Player in offside position affecting sightline of goalkeeper.
So much to consider regarding technology !

I'm not suggesting changing the rules of the game. It's just that, in the modern era of Hawkeye it shouldn't be possible for a goal to be allowed from an offside position - or given offside when not.
Regarding penalties - fifth official to review a decision made. And give a manager two calls per game for fifth official to query decisions not given when the ball next goes out of play.
There! couldn't be simpler.

 

Part Time James Flag 03 Mar 17 1.34pm

I'd like to see yellow and red cards awarded in hindsight as well, even if the ref did see it. Especially for diving. If a player got a penalty for diving and a review panel decided it's a dive then they ought to pick up a ban.

And don't say they couldn't reach a decision. Reds and yellows get overturned based on a review so why not awarded on appeal too?

 




stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 03 Mar 17 2.42pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I assume that would be as an opposing manager given that Pulis had left before Jimmy Mc had signed?


Ok, maybe got the wrong manager, my memory is s**t at the best of times, but I'm still sure that Jimmy and another player both got a telling off for diving in the same game...or maybe my memory is completely s**t!!

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 03 Mar 17 3.09pm

Originally posted by Phil H

I'm not suggesting changing the rules of the game. It's just that, in the modern era of Hawkeye it shouldn't be possible for a goal to be allowed from an offside position - or given offside when not.
Regarding penalties - fifth official to review a decision made. And give a manager two calls per game for fifth official to query decisions not given when the ball next goes out of play.
There! couldn't be simpler.

The offside rule nowadays makes it very difficult for the ref and the linesman.
If you have ever tried running the line you will see.
Bertrand was offside but Gabbiadini was not.
But was Bertrand interfering with play.?
De Gea would have known he was there.
The old rule was better IMO.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Selhurstboys Flag Basel 04 Mar 17 7.40am

I would go as far as saying nothaving video technology is slowly bring the game into disrepute. There are too many bad decisions being let.standing and the build up will eventually turn people off the sport.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 04 Mar 17 8.31am

Originally posted by Selhurstboys

I would go as far as saying nothaving video technology is slowly bring the game into disrepute. There are too many bad decisions being let.standing and the build up will eventually turn people off the sport.

Are you saying that if too many wrong decisions affect Palace that you would stop supporting them?

It's not surprising that football is slow to adopt modern technology as the game is run by dinosaurs anyway so what do you expect

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 04 Mar 17 11.09am

Originally posted by stuckinbristol


Ok, maybe got the wrong manager, my memory is s**t at the best of times, but I'm still sure that Jimmy and another player both got a telling off for diving in the same game...or maybe my memory is completely s**t!!

Your memory is OK, I remember it vividly. One of the worst, most inept attempts at a dive I've ever seen. Clearly the work of a player who's never done something like that before.

 

Phil H Flag 04 Mar 17 11.00pm

Originally posted by Selhurstboys

I would go as far as saying nothaving video technology is slowly bring the game into disrepute. There are too many bad decisions being let.standing and the build up will eventually turn people off the sport.

Yes.Did you see Anthony Taylor's ridiculous award of a penalty today to Burnley v Swansea when a Burnley player (Vokes) handled? Video technology would never allow that penalty to be awarded. The whole thing's a joke. Even Wimbledon tennis is ahead of the Premier League.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Graham Poll (TalkSport)