You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Likelihood of keeping Big SAM!!!
November 16 2026 9.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Likelihood of keeping Big SAM!!!


Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >
KAOS Flag In a tree 20 Apr 17 10.06am

Originally posted by est1905

You are deluded. Currently, in terms of players, infrastructure and finances compared to us? Leeds are a tiny, weeny little club. Of course that can change but it would take 4 or 5 years for that to happen. Wake up mate, you are living in the past. No one cares how many Yorkshire farmers go along to watch them fail every Saturday. Big club? They're not even guaranteed a play off spot. And if they don't go up Monk will probably get the boot. Such is the nutter that owns them.

Wow! You seem to think we are this massive club now on the strength of hitting a bit of form over the last 6 or so weeks. Guaranteed, you wouldn’t be giving it all this if we were in the bottom 3 currently … and not that long ago, we were. And we could still end up there. We are still a work in progress in terms of a Prem club …

Leeds aren’t a big club! Yeah right-e-o! You sound like a plastic fella … it’s not all about how much dough you have in the bank to warrant being a big club …


 

est1905 Flag 20 Apr 17 5.56pm

Not really bothered what I sound like to you 'fella', plastic or otherwise. I've probably been supporting Palace since you were in nappies (or longer) but unlike yourself that wants to use words like 'plastic' I'm not in the 'I'm a better fan that you club'. its drivel.
Coming back to your actual post you are finding it very difficult to differentiate between now and the past. In the 1970s Leeds Untited weren't a big club, they were huge. A monster. The Don Revie/Billy Bremner days will always be remembered and rightly so. Just as the Clough days at Forest are and even the Stanley Mathews days going back even further.
But history does not make you a big club. If it did Notts County, Burnley, Preston and Wolves would be the biggest clubs in the world. They have been around longer than anyone else therefore have more history than any of us.
Right here and right now Leeds are not even close to being a big club. They are not even in a play off position in the 2nd tier of English football. You talk about 'IF' we were in the bottom 3 I would not have this opinion. But we are not so what are you going on about? We'll survive this season and embark on a 5th season in the top division. Leeds might come up this year (doubtful). If they did they might stay up (extremely doubtful) and then we may see them strengthen to the point where they establish themselves which would take a couple more years. Only then would they be close to where we are at right now. It really isn't rocket science.
If you base how big a club is on their potential and how many seats they would potentially fill in the top division then with your logic Leeds, Forest, Sheffield Wednesday are all bigger clubs than Chelsea that get gates of 'only' 40,000 a week
So Leeds have won a few trophies in their history. So what. Hasn't kept them in the top division has it.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 20 Apr 17 6.09pm

Originally posted by est1905

Not really bothered what I sound like to you 'fella', plastic or otherwise. I've probably been supporting Palace since you were in nappies (or longer) but unlike yourself that wants to use words like 'plastic' I'm not in the 'I'm a better fan that you club'. its drivel.
Coming back to your actual post you are finding it very difficult to differentiate between now and the past. In the 1970s Leeds Untited weren't a big club, they were huge. A monster. The Don Revie/Billy Bremner days will always be remembered and rightly so. Just as the Clough days at Forest are and even the Stanley Mathews days going back even further.
But history does not make you a big club. If it did Notts County, Burnley, Preston and Wolves would be the biggest clubs in the world. They have been around longer than anyone else therefore have more history than any of us.
Right here and right now Leeds are not even close to being a big club. They are not even in a play off position in the 2nd tier of English football. You talk about 'IF' we were in the bottom 3 I would not have this opinion. But we are not so what are you going on about? We'll survive this season and embark on a 5th season in the top division. Leeds might come up this year (doubtful). If they did they might stay up (extremely doubtful) and then we may see them strengthen to the point where they establish themselves which would take a couple more years. Only then would they be close to where we are at right now. It really isn't rocket science.
If you base how big a club is on their potential and how many seats they would potentially fill in the top division then with your logic Leeds, Forest, Sheffield Wednesday are all bigger clubs than Chelsea that get gates of 'only' 40,000 a week
So Leeds have won a few trophies in their history. So what. Hasn't kept them in the top division has it.

Great post, totally agree. Are Old Corinthians still a big club?

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 20 Apr 17 6.18pm

Originally posted by est1905

Not really bothered what I sound like to you 'fella', plastic or otherwise. I've probably been supporting Palace since you were in nappies (or longer) but unlike yourself that wants to use words like 'plastic' I'm not in the 'I'm a better fan that you club'. its drivel.
Coming back to your actual post you are finding it very difficult to differentiate between now and the past. In the 1970s Leeds Untited weren't a big club, they were huge. A monster. The Don Revie/Billy Bremner days will always be remembered and rightly so. Just as the Clough days at Forest are and even the Stanley Mathews days going back even further.
But history does not make you a big club. If it did Notts County, Burnley, Preston and Wolves would be the biggest clubs in the world. They have been around longer than anyone else therefore have more history than any of us.
Right here and right now Leeds are not even close to being a big club. They are not even in a play off position in the 2nd tier of English football. You talk about 'IF' we were in the bottom 3 I would not have this opinion. But we are not so what are you going on about? We'll survive this season and embark on a 5th season in the top division. Leeds might come up this year (doubtful). If they did they might stay up (extremely doubtful) and then we may see them strengthen to the point where they establish themselves which would take a couple more years. Only then would they be close to where we are at right now. It really isn't rocket science.
If you base how big a club is on their potential and how many seats they would potentially fill in the top division then with your logic Leeds, Forest, Sheffield Wednesday are all bigger clubs than Chelsea that get gates of 'only' 40,000 a week
So Leeds have won a few trophies in their history. So what. Hasn't kept them in the top division has it.

Nappies!!! You're a funny one eh! I doubt it as you'd have to be typing this with the aid of a home help!

Let's hope you're right about us staying up as this season isn't over yet ... and we're a couple of bad results away from being right down in the mire again! But, I admire your confidence ..

Yeah - I see ya point to some degree but my point is, about losing Sam to someone else and I used Leeds loosely. Saying they're not a big club is madness tho!

Let's agree to disagree as I'm finding you a bit boring/tedious now 'fella'

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 20 Apr 17 6.20pm

And Chelsea get 40k due to SB capacity limitations - hence them rebuilding SB in the near future ...

Anyway, I'm gone ...

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 20 Apr 17 6.24pm

Originally posted by est1905

Not really bothered what I sound like to you 'fella', plastic or otherwise. I've probably been supporting Palace since you were in nappies (or longer) but unlike yourself that wants to use words like 'plastic' I'm not in the 'I'm a better fan that you club'. its drivel.
Coming back to your actual post you are finding it very difficult to differentiate between now and the past. In the 1970s Leeds Untited weren't a big club, they were huge. A monster. The Don Revie/Billy Bremner days will always be remembered and rightly so. Just as the Clough days at Forest are and even the Stanley Mathews days going back even further.
But history does not make you a big club. If it did Notts County, Burnley, Preston and Wolves would be the biggest clubs in the world. They have been around longer than anyone else therefore have more history than any of us.
Right here and right now Leeds are not even close to being a big club. They are not even in a play off position in the 2nd tier of English football. You talk about 'IF' we were in the bottom 3 I would not have this opinion. But we are not so what are you going on about? We'll survive this season and embark on a 5th season in the top division. Leeds might come up this year (doubtful). If they did they might stay up (extremely doubtful) and then we may see them strengthen to the point where they establish themselves which would take a couple more years. Only then would they be close to where we are at right now. It really isn't rocket science.
If you base how big a club is on their potential and how many seats they would potentially fill in the top division then with your logic Leeds, Forest, Sheffield Wednesday are all bigger clubs than Chelsea that get gates of 'only' 40,000 a week
So Leeds have won a few trophies in their history. So what. Hasn't kept them in the top division has it.

What Leeds are, and are probably the most apt club outside The Prem to be called this, is a sleeping giant.

Maybe if they are still languishing 30 years from now and most of us who remember them from the 70's and 90's have departed this mortal coil then they can be classed the same as the Prestons, Huddersfields, etc.

They got 32,000 to go 7th in The Champ on Saturday. Truth is if they had a very rich investor tomorrow they would be in The Prem averaging 40,000 within two years and if bigger stands were built 50,000 within three to four.

A sleeping giant indeed. We have never been called that outside the Prem.

They are a bigger club than us history and fan base and world recognition wise but, as it stands, we are richer and higher up.

You'll be saying Bournemouth are bigger than them next

Edited by Kermit8 (20 Apr 2017 6.26pm)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 20 Apr 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Wow! You seem to think we are this massive club now on the strength of hitting a bit of form over the last 6 or so weeks. Guaranteed, you wouldn’t be giving it all this if we were in the bottom 3 currently … and not that long ago, we were. And we could still end up there. We are still a work in progress in terms of a Prem club …

Leeds aren’t a big club! Yeah right-e-o! You sound like a plastic fella … it’s not all about how much dough you have in the bank to warrant being a big club …


Maybe 'big club' isn't the correct description or phrase but people keep using it.

He means 'pull factor' or 'attraction factor', and I agree with him, because anyone is going to choose us over Leeds as things stand, and it'll take our standings to diverge for that to change.

Money and level of football supercedes thousands more fans.

 


COYP

KAOS Flag In a tree 20 Apr 17 10.02pm

Yep, valid points and I hear what you're saying. The whole thread is hyerthetical but if Leeds do come up via the play offs - which they could do as that's exactly how we got promoted a few years back - then their profile will be raised again very quickly. Primarily because of their history and then fan base which is potentially massive. They get the wind behind their sales - which can be done without spending silly money - due to momentum, teamwork & belief then their appeal will improve.

As someone else just said, it's like saying Bournemouth are a bigger club than Leeds! They're not ... for numerous reasons. It just happens that their league position and 'relative' finances are. But as we know, being in the Prem changes that dramatically. In the same way our reality will be dramatically changed if we were relegated ... which is a possibility, especially with our run in.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 20 Apr 17 10.54pm

Yes indeed Leeds are the proverbial sleeping giants. I remember a few years back they played Doncaster Rovers at Wembley in a play off game. I was working in a Midtown bar & was maybe expecting 20 or so in for the game, which incidentally kicked off at 8.30 AM (Local time) & over a 150 turned up to watch the game (they lost 1-0). At The Football Factory even to watch Liverpool this Sunday who would be a big draw you'll probably only get 20/30 Palace fans Tops!!

 


Pro USA & Israel

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 21 Apr 17 6.41am

If Leeds came up, it would take several years of both clubs having similar fortunes before he'd FO to them. They'd need several years of PL revenue I think.

So in short I don't see an army of candidate clubs for him now or in the near future. Looking at the PL itself, i see nobody. And, like Leeds, promoted sides will mostly need time to bed in.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Lombardos barber Flag 21 Apr 17 7.04am

Originally posted by KAOS

LOL ... really hope you're all right BUT this is Palace we're talking about at the end of the day! There'll always be a swerve ball / meteorite, out of nowhere, just when things start to look up!

Not sure you are right there anymore.

We are on the cusp of 5 straight seasons in the Premier League and have had an FA Cup Final.

We have a £30m striker and cladding on the Main Stand.

Very, very different club these days.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 21 Apr 17 7.23am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

If Leeds came up, it would take several years of both clubs having similar fortunes before he'd FO to them. They'd need several years of PL revenue I think.

So in short I don't see an army of candidate clubs for him now or in the near future. Looking at the PL itself, i see nobody. And, like Leeds, promoted sides will mostly need time to bed in.

Even then it would only happen if he wanted to move back up north. Living in London on mega bucks is the massive pull we have over most teams in the prem. There is simply no better city in the country and a lot of people think in the world, to be living as a wealthy person.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 21 Apr 17 8.42am

I think he might see this as a chance to build something, maybe for his last job. See how far we can go with good financial backing and a solid team to work with from the start. Happy to have him for a few years whatever happens, it's time we kept a manager for a while.

I don't see big teams going for him and I think we'd keep him if a relegation battler or mid table team had a go. He only sounds committed to CPFC tbh

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 21 Apr 17 8.49am

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Even then it would only happen if he wanted to move back up north. Living in London on mega bucks is the massive pull we have over most teams in the prem. There is simply no better city in the country and a lot of people think in the world, to be living as a wealthy person.

He has said he likes liking in London as well, either in a press conference or in his book (worth a read by the way)

 

chateauferret Flag 21 Apr 17 10.22am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Great post, totally agree. Are Old Corinthians still a big club?

Exactly. The only place I've heard (current) Leeds United referred to as a "big club" and destined for big things is on TalkSh!te. And they barely believe that we even exist.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 21 Apr 17 10.56am

The 'sleeping giant' thing is complete nonsense these days. Ultimately you're as big as your owner is wealthy and that's basically all that matters. Chelsea were never in contention for the league until Abramovich took over and City have spent time in league 1 within the last 20 years but now, thanks to mega rich chairman, are two of the three biggest clubs in the country.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

est1905 Flag 21 Apr 17 3.52pm

Originally posted by KAOS

Yep, valid points and I hear what you're saying. The whole thread is hyerthetical but if Leeds do come up via the play offs - which they could do as that's exactly how we got promoted a few years back - then their profile will be raised again very quickly. Primarily because of their history and then fan base which is potentially massive. They get the wind behind their sales - which can be done without spending silly money - due to momentum, teamwork & belief then their appeal will improve.

As someone else just said, it's like saying Bournemouth are a bigger club than Leeds! They're not ... for numerous reasons. It just happens that their league position and 'relative' finances are. But as we know, being in the Prem changes that dramatically. In the same way our reality will be dramatically changed if we were relegated ... which is a possibility, especially with our run in.

If If If. And you say YOU are getting bored.
If your auntie had bollox she'd be your uncle. Pointless scenario

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 22 Apr 17 12.20am

Originally posted by Lombardos barber

Not sure you are right there anymore.

We are on the cusp of 5 straight seasons in the Premier League and have had an FA Cup Final.

We have a £30m striker and cladding on the Main Stand.

Very, very different club these days.

and boy, that cladding on the stand. It really cements things for us.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Apr 17 6.55am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

The 'sleeping giant' thing is complete nonsense these days. Ultimately you're as big as your owner is wealthy

Whilst that is to a large extent true crowd attendances and marketing do still play a part thanks to FFP rules

 

KAOS Flag In a tree 22 Apr 17 4.44pm

Originally posted by est1905

If If If. And you say YOU are getting bored.
If your auntie had bollox she'd be your uncle. Pointless scenario

You do talk a lot of old pony eh! First you state categorically that we will embark on a 5th season in the top flight! Seen the results today per chance?!

And by your reckoning Bournemouth are a bigger club than Leeds too!!!

Youse a strange one eh!

 

Page 3 of 5 < 1 2 3 4 5 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Likelihood of keeping Big SAM!!!