You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Grujic foul on Tomkins
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Grujic foul on Tomkins


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 24 Apr 17 11.21am

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

'which they should have' - really? The referee allowed play to go on, in a goalscoring opportunity which they didnt take. You can't have the best of both worlds. If a referee plays advantage and the allotted time is up, he shouldn't bring the play back.

That's what I think, yes, and it's what I would have wanted had it been the other way around. It's not completely black and white though as it didn't look like a foul (to me) in real time. It's only when it is replayed that you see that he was a should have resulted in a penalty.

I'm certainly not complaining, there have been loads of penalty decisions not given to us. Some highlighted on MOTD but most not.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 24 Apr 17 11.22am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Six minutes added time was criminal too

Klopp was being given some 'fergie time'.
Quite where the hell they got 6 mins from is a mystery!

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 11.24am

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

And?


I'm not sure they would have! It was a shocking challenge. I think we'd at least on here say it was a poor challenge made due to desperation at losing the ball and them being 2-1 down at home. I think the other way round we'd be saying he was lucky not to get sent off if it was a yellow!

Your obsession with defending every bungling referee and every bad/wrong/incompetent decision they make continues to mystify me.

I'm getting pretty fed up with the straight red assaults on our players that go unpunished or result in only a booking. Olsson for Sunderland already had a yellow when he did his and still didn't walk. Rojo, God knows how many times and he's currently enjoying a dose of his own medicine. And that one yesterday was as blatant and obvious a straight red card as you could ever expect to see. Stupid, reckless, dangerous challenge with his foot up and studs out and about 200 years late and done on purpose because he knew Tomkinds had won the ball fairly. Doing that on purpose to a player and putting him out for a whole lot of matches is just disgusting and even a sending-off and a three-match ban is lenient: Tomkins could easily miss more than three matches.

The ref made his decision instantly without thinking about it, consulting the other officials, or knowing what damage had been done. That's plain incompetence, if it isn't bias, and if people acted like this anywhere else they'd be up in front of the beak on charges under the Health and Safety at Work Act.

But because it's Liverpool we carry on as if nothing had happened. Unless you're James Tomkins, that is.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 11.25am

Originally posted by sa_eagle

Klopp was being given some 'fergie time'.
Quite where the hell they got 6 mins from is a mystery!

At least two of them were to reward Liverpool for trying to take Tomkins' foot off.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 11.28am

Originally posted by topcat

That's what I think, yes, and it's what I would have wanted had it been the other way around. It's not completely black and white though as it didn't look like a foul (to me) in real time. It's only when it is replayed that you see that he was a should have resulted in a penalty.

I'm certainly not complaining, there have been loads of penalty decisions not given to us. Some highlighted on MOTD but most not.

Well, now if the ref is being consistent then if that was a pen so was the Benteke one. More contact on Benteke than on Coutinho. Giving both would have been consistent. Not giving either is consistent too. But if he gives the Coutinho pen he has to give ours.

Booking Benteke for a "dive" was f***ing preposterous. If you're going to allow a certain level of contact before you blow the whistle it follows that not all tumbles in the box are either a) penalties or b) simulation.

 


============
The Ferret
============

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 24 Apr 17 11.31am

Originally posted by chateauferret

I'm getting pretty fed up with the straight red assaults on our players that go unpunished or result in only a booking. Olsson for Sunderland already had a yellow when he did his and still didn't walk. Rojo, God knows how many times and he's currently enjoying a dose of his own medicine. And that one yesterday was as blatant and obvious a straight red card as you could ever expect to see. Stupid, reckless, dangerous challenge with his foot up and studs out and about 200 years late and done on purpose because he knew Tomkinds had won the ball fairly. Doing that on purpose to a player and putting him out for a whole lot of matches is just disgusting and even a sending-off and a three-match ban is lenient: Tomkins could easily miss more than three matches.

The ref made his decision instantly without thinking about it, consulting the other officials, or knowing what damage had been done. That's plain incompetence, if it isn't bias, and if people acted like this anywhere else they'd be up in front of the beak on charges under the Health and Safety at Work Act.

But because it's Liverpool we carry on as if nothing had happened. Unless you're James Tomkins, that is.

Quite agree with you cf but what we are forgetting is that Rojo and Grujic play for BIG clubs and, as such, have to break an opposing players leg before warranting a red card!!

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Adamoc123 Flag Ennis 24 Apr 17 11.34am

Had he gone down he'd have got the penalty and rightly so, luckily for us his will to continue gave them the advantage which they wasted. As for the tckle on Tomkins, absolutely horrendous! thought when i saw it that was his season over.

 


The First 90 Minutes Are The Most Important!

Red Eagle Flag Crawley 24 Apr 17 11.38am

Wow! It's the first incident on Ref Watch!! They waffled around it because no one on commentary saw how nasty it was until after the replay. Well there were a few of us who saw it straightaway. At least they featured it.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Apr 17 12.29pm

Yeah I think it should have been a red on the replay, but then on the replays Coutinho probably should have had a penalty as well.

So I can live with that

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 24 Apr 17 12.43pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Yeah I think it should have been a red on the replay, but then on the replays Coutinho probably should have had a penalty as well.

So I can live with that

Coutinho's wasn't given as he still managed to get a shot away when in a goal scoring position. It was actually a good bit of reffing and is different from a similar thing happening in the middle of the pitch as Klopp referred to as it's highly unlikely that it would deny a goal scoring opportunity.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 24 Apr 17 1.10pm

Originally posted by essetwentyone

No chance of restropective action because the ref gave a yellow.

It should have been a straight red and when you compare it to the red card for that Hull player on Saturday it's a joke. Big team bias once again !!

are there not any chance of appeal? i'd think there needs to be contingencies for cases of gross incompetence from the referee.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Apr 17 1.43pm

Originally posted by Lyons550

Coutinho's wasn't given as he still managed to get a shot away when in a goal scoring position. It was actually a good bit of reffing and is different from a similar thing happening in the middle of the pitch as Klopp referred to as it's highly unlikely that it would deny a goal scoring opportunity.

The referee should have pulled it back for the penalty when it was blocked a second later. Full kudos to Coutinho staying on his feet, but had he not tripped there is no way that was getting blocked. Had Coutinho gone down like most players do in that situation, he would certainly have got the penalty (and likely a card for Kelly).

As I said, I'm happy to accept the non-red and that not being a penalty.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Apr 17 1.49pm

Originally posted by essetwentyone

No chance of restropective action because the ref gave a yellow.

It should have been a straight red and when you compare it to the red card for that Hull player on Saturday it's a joke. Big team bias once again !!

No way was that Hull red justified - The ref got that wrong. Luckily for both sides, it had no result on the impact of the game. I think until they have video replays for decisions, its unavoidable that referees will make these kinds of mistakes. One looked a lot worse than it was, and ours looked a lot less nasty than it was.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 1.58pm

Originally posted by nairb75

are there not any chance of appeal? i'd think there needs to be contingencies for cases of gross incompetence from the referee.

Have you not been listening to Willo? There's no such thing as gross incompetence from the referee.

 


============
The Ferret
============

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 24 Apr 17 5.08pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Have you not been listening to Willo? There's no such thing as gross incompetence from the referee.

apologies. i'm a little slow and forget the rules.

 

tshepp897 Flag Dublin - Cabra 25 Apr 17 12.03pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

The referee should have pulled it back for the penalty when it was blocked a second later. Full kudos to Coutinho staying on his feet, but had he not tripped there is no way that was getting blocked. Had Coutinho gone down like most players do in that situation, he would certainly have got the penalty (and likely a card for Kelly).

As I said, I'm happy to accept the non-red and that not being a penalty.

I agree it was a penalty and should have been pulled back, but Cabaye should have had a penalty in the second half too. It was not as obvious from the camera angle but did anyone else spot that he was fouled by Milner, who raked his ankle, before he blazed over the bar, from Benteke's over head kick.

 


The cellophane illusion of a starry sky / Stretched over an open sore.
Big Nothing

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Apr 17 1.01pm

Originally posted by tshepp897

I agree it was a penalty and should have been pulled back, but Cabaye should have had a penalty in the second half too. It was not as obvious from the camera angle but did anyone else spot that he was fouled by Milner, who raked his ankle, before he blazed over the bar, from Benteke's over head kick.

Still I find I care less when we win, about decisions that didn't go our way

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 25 Apr 17 1.17pm

The look on Grujic's face after was enough to merit the Red Card. Career-wise that kind of foul is worse than any elbow to the chops.

Nothing really is made of it from our end, all we hear though are the sounds of Scouse discontent, and the media lap it up and echo it round to pander to the victim culture that has been nurtured for decades.

 

chateauferret Flag 25 Apr 17 1.57pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Still I find I care less when we win, about decisions that didn't go our way

I didn't spot that at all and I'd be surprised if a referee did - especially one of the quality of Marriner. Clattenburg, Pawson or their ilk.

 


============
The Ferret
============

The_postman Flag Forest Row 25 Apr 17 2.34pm

Tomkins left the ground on crutches wearing a protective boot. The ankle is swollen and he is a doubt for the next two games.

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Grujic foul on Tomkins