This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Schlupp at centre back
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
glaziermart 06 May 17 2.31pm |
|
|
What the hell was Sam thinking off??!! Surely one of the worst decisions of his managerial career
|
whitehorselane 06 May 17 2.34pm |
|
|
Should have put PVA at centre back
|
FairweatherEagle London 06 May 17 2.36pm |
|
|
That in addition to playing one recognised CB. Surely we couldn't have done any worse playing a youth teamer at CB? Easy to say in hindsight perhaps....
Edited by FairweatherEagle (06 May 2017 2.37pm)
|
P4E_ 06 May 17 2.36pm |
|
|
Well we three centre backs out injured there was not a lot of options! Im guessing Delaney did not start as the felt he would not cope with the pace and movement of the city front line. Not that it worked out that well anyway.
|
chateauferret 06 May 17 2.36pm |
|
|
If he'd started Delaney and had him injured we would've had potentially no centre-backs available next week.
============ The Ferret ============
|
peterg Anerley 06 May 17 2.44pm |
|
|
So who do we play in central defence for the crunch match v Hull? Any chance of Dann being back?
The right place at the right time
|
BelfastEagle 06 May 17 2.45pm |
|
|
Sam has realised that Delaney is done....he shouldn't be playing at all.
|
Dangermouse Hastings 06 May 17 2.48pm |
|
|
Stupid decision IMO, but we unfortunately met a City team on absolute fire. Need Cabaye next week and one cb's back.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 06 May 17 2.53pm |
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Stupid decision IMO, but we unfortunately met a City team on absolute fire. Need Cabaye next week and one cb's back.
Cabaye and one of the 3 centre backs returning will hopefully make us look more solid. .
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 06 May 17 2.56pm |
|
Originally posted by FairweatherEagle
That in addition to playing one recognised CB. Surely we couldn't have done any worse playing a youth teamer at CB? Easy to say in hindsight perhaps....
Edited by FairweatherEagle (06 May 2017 2.37pm)
I mentioned this in the match thread. Might of been a baptism of fire but also if he hadn't played may of not had the supposed nervousness. Just got in there and got on with his job. Certainly would of been trained to head out a cross for a corner early on.
Edited by Booted Eagle (06 May 2017 2.57pm)
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
SW19 CPFC Addiscombe West 06 May 17 2.58pm |
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
If he'd started Delaney and had him injured we would've had potentially no centre-backs available next week.
Has to be why. Fair enough. All our remaining energy needs to go into Hull. If we don't turn up again (Burnley) then we are in serious trouble. 1pt should do it
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.
|
Pierre Purley 06 May 17 3.18pm |
|
|
I don't think it mattered who played at CB today. Basically Palace were dismantled by a far superior opposition who had to win to to finish in the top 4 or better.
No Palace player can be singled out as playing well just basically outclassed.
Better to have everyone who's left fit for next week that's where the battle will take place if it goes that far!
Then with Cabaye available as well we will look much more organised and effective. Who knows Dann may even make the bench!
|
Azerbaijan Eagle 06 May 17 3.36pm |
|
|
Jim Beglin said that there was talk that Tomkins might have been fit for this game,
That was on BEIN sports - the Qatar channel
How close is Tomkins?
|
Dangermouse Hastings 06 May 17 4.31pm |
|
|
I know we are still in trouble, but there is a massive overreaction going on IMO. The top 6 always have the ability to dismantle any of the bottom 10/12 in this division. The fact it doesn't is testament to the competitive nature of this division. Today it happened to be our turn to be in the wrong place at the wrong time. Obviously our chances would of been better with an entire first team available, but they weren't and we had to throw a defence together at short notice. How anyone could expect a cohesive performance from the defence available is beyond me. Add the fact that Macca can't play the role Cabaye plays then our only hope was for City not to click. Unfortunately they did and their first time passing was incredible. Against that sort of performance grit, passion and hard running just ain't gonna be enough, no matter what anyone thinks. We hope again next week and hopefully we win . It's doable, but we gotta have faith.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 06 May 17 9.05pm |
|
|
Absolute madness. Hard to criticise Sam at the moment but this was a howler. Schlupp has never played CB in his career and we had a CB on the bench.
Not only a terrible tactical error but what a huge insult to Damo. Damo is past his best for sure but has been a great servant to the club and still has a good performance in him as we saw earlier in the season. If selected for Hull his confidence will be shattered.
If not Damo surely Milo would have been the obvious choice. 5 goals conceded says it all really.
|
Painter Croydon 06 May 17 9.19pm |
|
|
I doubt we could of held City with a full first team out, they were very good. There is a massive gulf between the top 6 and the rest. Yes, we have some great results lately, but everyone was on their game for those. This was not a game. I doubt anyone thought we could anything from, especially with our injuries. Why are people being critical of the players, Schlupp has never played at CB, there was no midfield to protect the defence, City just glided past our midfield. To suggest we should of put an U23 player in at CB, who nobody can name is just bizarre and naïve. This game will not define our season.
|
chateauferret 06 May 17 9.29pm |
|
|
I think we would have lost that game no matter whom we played. Had we had Sakho and Cabaye available we could have limited the damage and maybe got forward more but they played some stuff there's basically no defence against today.
Not worth risking injuries and knackered players for a slightly better performance but which would still have got us nulle points and might have cost us the point we need next week. Better to make sure of the performance next week when we really need it than to waste it on a lost cause.
============ The Ferret ============
|
Mad4palace 06 May 17 9.34pm |
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
If he'd started Delaney and had him injured we would've had potentially no centre-backs available next week.
That was what I thought.
|
whitehorselane 06 May 17 10.03pm |
|
|
I thought dropping Schlupp for PVA v Burnley was the first time I've witnessed favouritism from Sam. Schlupp didn't deserve to be dropped after Spurs
PVA as the more experienced defender of the two, I thought should have played centre back to day. I don't think Sam was saving Damo for Hull, more that he was disappointed with our defence v Burnley
|
Aolcpfc Finchley, London 06 May 17 10.13pm |
|
|
Sam's master stroke. Lose the game. Mix the defence around so we look like a push over when Hull try to work out what we're up to, whilst knowing all along that we'd never use that defence in real life and when it really matters. Most importantly don't allow Damo to get injured,as we will need him next week against Hull.
|