You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 9.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Marco Silva (LOCKED)


Page 3 of 30 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Dan89 Flag Se25 24 May 17 7.27pm

The last manager we got from hull was peter Taylor. Look how that turned out. If silva wasn't mourinho mate he wouldn't even be in the prem.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Dan89 Flag Se25 24 May 17 7.28pm

Originally posted by Willo

I think Silva would be a real gamble.
Mancini and Howe less of a gamble.

Howe isn't coming to Palace

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 17 7.29pm

Originally posted by Dan89

The last manager we got from hull was peter Taylor. Look how that turned out. If silva wasn't mourinho mate he wouldn't even be in the prem.

Who has just been appointed 'Director of football' at Gillingham.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 17 7.30pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Howe isn't coming to Palace

I don't believe Howe would leave Bournemouth for our club.

 

Mstrobez Flag 24 May 17 7.30pm

Originally posted by Willo

The keeper did well for them.
Roberston and Maguire are useful in defence.
Clucas is decent in midfield.
Hernandez up front isn't bad either.

Martin Kelly was useful in defence, so to was Schlupp.. Connor Wickham looked decent earlier in the season to and Frazier Campbell wasn't bad when he played. I said name me one "excellent" player. Maguire looked there best player but would definitely not regard his excellent.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Painter Flag Croydon 24 May 17 7.30pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

dont quite understand the marco silva love in tbf...he took them down with acsquad that actually cost quite a lot to assemble.

would be a risky appointment if you ask me.

Who have they bought that cost a lot, their record signing cost about £9m.
How much did the Palace squad cost, over £100m.
Hulls wage bill is the lowest in the Premier and they have to pay more than a player is worth, as they don't want to live in Hull.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 24 May 17 7.31pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Your assured hatred of Marco Silva is bizarre. He inherited a team substantially worse than us with substantially less money and less of an attraction for players to join. That Hull team were pretty much dead and buried when he arrived, the fact they were even in with a shout against us is a testament to him as a coach. You do realise his record was pretty much identical to Sams right? You know the guy who's just left and had players such as Sakho, Zaha, Cabaye, Townsend, Benteke etc at his disposal? Imagine what this guy could do with backing and a full season under us. Marco Silva is 100% the guy for me.

Silva last 4 games at hull

Southampton-a 0-0
Sunderland- h L2-0
C Palace L - 4-0
Spurs h - L 7-1

Hull were by far the worst side to play at selhurst this season. What makes him so attractive to you.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Mstrobez Flag 24 May 17 7.32pm

Originally posted by Dan89

You seem to leave out his poor away record. Although Sam completed his mission his tenure was far from a success. If that Sean dyche for instance. Nobody would be talking about him. As for Cabaye and Sakho they will leave. You hadn't even heard of before hull plucked him out of nowhere. Who's he really gonna attract. Big backward step.

The logic of your post makes no sense and misses the point. What does Sakho and Cabaye leaving have to do with the fact that he had the same combined home and away record as Big Sam with a team in a substantially worse position in pretty much every department?

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 17 7.32pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Martin Kelly was useful in defence, so to was Schlupp.. Connor Wickham looked decent earlier in the season to and Frazier Campbell wasn't bad when he played. I said name me one "excellent" player. Maguire looked there best player but would definitely not regard his excellent.

Depends on what one deems "Excellent".

 

Mstrobez Flag 24 May 17 7.33pm

Originally posted by Dan89

Silva last 4 games at hull

Southampton-a 0-0
Sunderland- h L2-0
C Palace L - 4-0
Spurs h - L 7-1

Hull were by far the worst side to play at selhurst this season. What makes him so attractive to you.

What makes him so attractive is the fact that in 3 of those last 4 games Hull were still fighting for survival.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Mstrobez Flag 24 May 17 7.34pm

Originally posted by Willo

Depends on what one deems "Excellent".

Even very good? Townsend, Cabaye, Zaha, Benteke, Sakho are all undoubtedly very good players who would get into most PL teams. Any at Hull on the same level as the above?

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 24 May 17 7.36pm

Originally posted by Dan89

How many away - 2 pts that shocking. What so impressive about him.

I think he actual managed 23 points. From 19 games.

Now with that squad that is impressive.

Obviously if we only look at the game he lost then he's going to look s***!

38 games would have meant 46 points IF the form continued.

That's a Hull side that had sold its best players

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 24 May 17 7.37pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

What makes him so attractive is the fact that in 3 of those last 4 games Hull were still fighting for survival.

They went down. He was out coached by clement and many others. Surely you want more than survival. So do you think that silva could take us to the top 10 or even survive in the prem as a bare minimum. If your Zaha and silva joined would you stay.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 17 7.39pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez


Even very good? Townsend, Cabaye, Zaha, Benteke, Sakho are all undoubtedly very good players who would get into most PL teams. Any at Hull on the same level as the above?

No - but the Hull players I mentioned are good/decent/very good etc etc etc.

I'm not actually sure that Townsend would "Get in most PL teams" and perhaps not even Cabaye.

This is going somewhat "Off Piste" so let's concentrate on the subject matter.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 24 May 17 7.41pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

I think he actual managed 23 points. From 19 games.

Now with that squad that is impressive.

Obviously if we only look at the game he lost then he's going to look s***!

38 games would have meant 46 points IF the form continued.

That's a Hull side that had sold its best players

If it worked like that then great ,but he had the new manager bounce. look at their record in their last 4. It puts too much pressure on home form. If he's woeful away form continues.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

daven Flag Hailsham 24 May 17 7.41pm

The impression that I got from Silva was during the transfer window when Hull sold their jewels in the crown. Coupled with their dodgy start I had them down for 20th. I cant really say that I really followed them much but I was surprised that they managed to stay in the race for so long.
I wouldn't be devastated if we got him.
I like the sound of the German Huddersfield manager with nothing concrete to back it up.

 

manwitheagletattoo Flag Somewhere in England 24 May 17 7.41pm

I'm in two minds about Silva, doesn't have a lot of premiership experience and when he was at ours a few weeks back after the first goal went in he seemed a little dejected and the Hull players must of noticed that . On the other hand IF Sammy Lee stays then with his premiership experience and guidance then who knows. For me I would take either Mancini or Ranieri...

 


South London & Proud
Sometimes I really wonder if family are really worth it.
Because it doesn’t matter how time and affection you give
It’s never enough

Dan89 Flag Se25 24 May 17 7.44pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

I think he actual managed 23 points. From 19 games.

Now with that squad that is impressive.

Obviously if we only look at the game he lost then he's going to look s***!

38 games would have meant 46 points IF the form continued.

That's a Hull side that had sold its best players


Their but if it worked like double the pts. Then when we started in 2015 under pardew - ending 2015 - 4th in the table . Then our dreadful run in 2016. You can't judge that would guarantee survival.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 24 May 17 7.44pm

Originally posted by manwitheagletattoo

I'm in two minds about Silva, doesn't have a lot of premiership experience and when he was at ours a few weeks back after the first goal went in he seemed a little dejected and the Hull players must of noticed that . On the other hand IF Sammy Lee stays then with his premiership experience and guidance then who knows. For me I would take either Mancini or Ranieri...

You are talking about experience at the top level, "Been there done it" types against the relative inexperience of Silva who oveerall hasn't achieved that much of note when one considers the clubs with which he has won trophies and their standing in their respective leagues.

 

Mstrobez Flag 24 May 17 7.44pm

Originally posted by Dan89

They went down. He was out coached by clement and many others. Surely you want more than survival. So do you think that silva could take us to the top 10 or even survive in the prem as a bare minimum. If your Zaha and silva joined would you stay.

I'd be a lot less likely to stay then if we hired Coleman, Hodgson or Moyes.. Yes. Mancini would be great but I think very unlikely, suggestions such as Eddie Howe are just silly. Marco Silva makes the most sense of anyone we can realistically get, despite your mad expectations that he should've kept that Hull side up. He wasn't "out coached" by clement.

Your comparing a team that arguably had less quality than Sunderland with teams that have had a number of years PL experience and quality players. Hull had Snodgrass, and erm oh yeah, he left them.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

Page 3 of 30 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Topic