You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dementia Tax
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dementia Tax


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 11.54am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721


Plenty of people end up in old age care without dementia due to less fatal conditions, such a frailty etc. The point is, that we have accepted the idea of 'taxing people' who live unhealthy life styles without actually thinking of those costs that healthy lifestyles entail.

We encourage the idea of living as 'long as possible' and then financially try to fund that by targeting people who won't.

Yep...I appreciate that.as I said I work in the sector...you were the one that suggested people lived with Dementia for Decades...not me.

Also as I've explained in a further post...what people would've been admitted to residential/Nursing homes for 5years ago they wouldn't now. they'd still receive some sort of care but the emphasis is on rehabilitation, not just dealing with the symptoms..that's now considered old thinking.

Your final point ...which is the main one you've narrowed your thoughts down to...for me is a mute one...nowadays (certainly for the last 10 to 15years) there's been more than enough public information with regards to the harm that Smoking, drinking, drug taking and even consuming too much sugar has on a persons health.

If people choose to ignore that and then bleat about being taxed for it...tough.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 12.01pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Not really, I saw my grandparents live into their later years, suffering dementia and physical frailty, requiring constant care etc. It was a horrible existence, s**ting yourself, having no dignity, being herded around, in a banal and sterile environment where you're more an object than a person.

Its not really worth the effort if you ask me. I'd rather go out a) on my own terms b) whilst I'm still me c) and enjoy the pleasures and vices of life.

A walk around an old peoples home is like an advert for not making the average life expectancy.


Which of course is your right and choice..based on the knowledge that everything you take is taxed accordingly.

What you may have hit upon here as well is the 'choice' to not suffer when all these things take their toll. I can't see it being too long before a 'Dignitas' system is piloted over here for people to ensure they dont end up a burden on society when they get to the point that they dont want to carry on.

That's something I'd certainly be open to...but clearly it isnt for everyone.

Perhaps those that take that option should then get some Inheritance Tax Break?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Jun 17 12.02pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Not a question of correctness.

The system serves the people not the reverse. Encouraging people to a premature death is not what a society is about.
The real cause of our current problems is the short sighted, self serving nature of politicians and the greed of financial institutions. The public should not have to pay the cost with mass immigration, poor care in old age or being encouraged to slowly kill themselves.

People should be free to make there own decision theer is no forcing people to do things they don't want. Your view of government seems very National Socialistic.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jun 17 12.11pm

Originally posted by pefwin

People should be free to make there own decision theer is no forcing people to do things they don't want. Your view of government seems very National Socialistic.

No, I believe that people should be made aware of current thinking on what is good for them and what is not. To deliberately withhold that information and at the same time allow products to be sold that harm is unacceptable.

People still have a choice but it can be an informed choice. The government already allows smoking and drinking for the purpose of taxation, which in itself is already pushing the boundaries of common sense in my view.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Jun 17 12.13pm

Originally posted by becky


(1) Only some- especially those in the public sector, who are probably the biggest drain on public finances to this day. The rest of hard-working Joe-public just get by on what's available.

(2) Far, far fewer went to university in those days - it was a privilege reserved for the genuinely academic. Others went to a polytechnic and gained a 'useful' qualification that had a practical purpose in the workplace. Turning every poly into a university so any halfwit could get a degree in 'meeja
studies' increased the cost of those places immeasurably, so far less would have been spent on our generation, and probably to a greater level of usefulness and ultimate financial return from their future employment.

(3) For our generation the NHS was for sick people. Cosmetic surgery was not heard of, expensive stuff like premature baby units had not been developed, diagnostics were manually made assessments by the 'specialists' rather than millions of pounds worth of machinery, and hospitals were staffed by medical professionals rather than accountants and managers ( yeh, I'll allow that we did have the best there), so diagnostics and treatment was much pooer for us who had the 'best' of the service.....

(4) I have no idea what 'salary sacrifice' is - did not exist in my working time - you earned and you paid tax and National Insurance - the latter on your private pension annuity, whether you liked it or not!

1 Historically that is a myth until Bliar increased public sector earnings without dealing with public sector pension provision.

2 A good point. We could fund help for the elderly by reducing further education. We no longer need graduates but people to pick peas and other such jobs that Eastern Europeans and other immigrants did.

3 I agree the scope of the NHS should be reduced for example no artificial insemination. Neither is it the NHS's job to push expensive medical treatments for the minority at the expense of the majority. Neither should it push for increasing longevity.

4 It very much did exist mostly used by corporate executives but has become more popular for obvious reasons (NIC).

None of these pensions and dementia etc. have suddenly happened successive governments have known about these issues since at least the mid 80's.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 12.16pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Which of course is your right and choice..based on the knowledge that everything you take is taxed accordingly.

What you may have hit upon here as well is the 'choice' to not suffer when all these things take their toll. I can't see it being too long before a 'Dignitas' system is piloted over here for people to ensure they dont end up a burden on society when they get to the point that they dont want to carry on.

That's something I'd certainly be open to...but clearly it isnt for everyone.

Perhaps those that take that option should then get some Inheritance Tax Break?

I wholeheartedly support the right to die on your own terms and by choice.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Jun 17 12.19pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

No, I believe that people should be made aware of current thinking on what is good for them and what is not. To deliberately withhold that information and at the same time allow products to be sold that harm is unacceptable.

People still have a choice but it can be an informed choice. The government already allows smoking and drinking for the purpose of taxation, which in itself is already pushing the boundaries of common sense in my view.

You must deliberately not understand, nobody can be that thick. Where does it say anything you state above?

Unlike your nanny state, I asking for individual choice and suggest removing legislation and potentially lowering the price of an individual transaction to increase tax yield.

What would you do? Tax low IQ?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 13 Jun 17 12.20pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I wholeheartedly support the right to die on your own terms and by choice.

As would I IF it was your own choice.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jun 17 12.25pm

Originally posted by pefwin

You must deliberately not understand, nobody can be that thick. Where does it say anything you state above?

Unlike your nanny state, I asking for individual choice and suggest removing legislation and potentially lowering the price of an individual transaction to increase tax yield.

What would you do? Tax low IQ?

What I understand is that you are putting the funding of a system designed to serve the people before the people themselves. Now that is as dumb as it gets.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 12.28pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Which of course is your right and choice..based on the knowledge that everything you take is taxed accordingly.

But I'm not be taxed accordingly, I'm being taxed disproportionately, because healthy people are a major long term cost. I don't mind paying tax on cigs, booze etc, because there are costs. My lifestyle choice includes costing based on illness and disease related to my choices, but not the discounts (pension, late life illness, care etc).

Where as if I was maybe the kind of person who doesn't drink, smoke, eats a very balanced diet, exercises regularly etc I'm just as likely to incur additional health costs over the average person, but not get taxed accordingly.

The problem is people living too long, and we solve that by taxing people who don't? That's the problem with the health mentality in our moralised democracy - we're lepper taxers.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 12.31pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You cannot be serious.

Hold old are you Pefwin?

There is serious taxation revenue waiting to be raised there, plus massive savings in law enforcement and NHS costs. I'm wary about legalising heroin and cocaine...

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jun 17 12.33pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

But I'm not be taxed accordingly, I'm being taxed disproportionately, because healthy people are a major long term cost. I don't mind paying tax on cigs, booze etc, because there are costs. My lifestyle choice includes costing based on illness and disease related to my choices, but not the discounts (pension, late life illness, care etc).

Where as if I was maybe the kind of person who doesn't drink, smoke, eats a very balanced diet, exercises regularly etc I'm just as likely to incur additional health costs over the average person, but not get taxed accordingly.

The problem is people living too long, and we solve that by taxing people who don't? That's the problem with the health mentality in our moralised democracy - we're lepper taxers.

Ridiculous.
You have a choice to drink, smoke, over eat etc. You can stop whenever you please. The government will tax these vices all the time people still indulge in them and as such behaviour reduces, taxation will be shifted elsewhere.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jun 17 12.42pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

There is serious taxation revenue waiting to be raised there, plus massive savings in law enforcement and NHS costs. I'm wary about legalising heroin and cocaine...

Perfwin is advocating the reduction of attempts to educate people against a lifestyle that shortens life. That is bonkers.

Drug revenue would be welcomed by the chancellor but at what price?
The relaxation of rules on gambling was a nice little earner but do we have data on the effects of gambling on peoples lives? Has it been worth it? Vital services are still in crisis apparently.
There is clearly a need for more revenue but how can we ever cater comfortably for a rapidly growing population? Does the tax advantage really outweigh the burden of 300k more every year? Where is the evidence?

 

becky Flag over the moon 13 Jun 17 12.50pm

Originally posted by pefwin

What would you do? Tax low IQ?

Given the apparent current state of the gene pool, that could be a winner......

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 13 Jun 17 12.55pm

Originally posted by becky


Can we just dispel this myth please - if you worked in the Public sector or for a large company, you would have got a final-salary pension scheme (and let's remember that even these were contributory), if you worked for a medium sized company you MAY have got a non-final salary pension scheme........and then there is the rest of us (and all the self-employed)who had no pensions schemes at all, and who may (or may not have been able to afford it) have contributed fully to provide themselves with a small annuity (which would have been a comfortable annuity if Gordon Broon hadn't wrecked it!).

As for NIC on pensions, don't forget that having already paid tax on the money that was contributed to my personal private pension scheme, I am now taxed on it again as it is lumped in with my State Retirement pension for taxation purposes, so how many more times must I pay tax on the same bloody hard earned money?

You get tax relief on pension contributions even into private schemes as long as they are actual pension schemes, so no tax paid. So if you've paid tax on your contributions into your pension scheme you've made a (big) mistake. In terms of NIC you can avoid that if you pay into your pension via salary sacrifice, and your employer will save as well.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 12.56pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Ridiculous.
You have a choice to drink, smoke, over eat etc. You can stop whenever you please. The government will tax these vices all the time people still indulge in them and as such behaviour reduces, taxation will be shifted elsewhere.

Not what I'm saying, I'm happy to pay my fair share of the excess costs of my lifestyle on the NHS - and do. Now what about those people who are healthy long lifers who's choices not to smoke, drink, eat healthy etc is cause additional costs - are they taxed accordingly are they f**k.

Play football on the weekends - I don't, and you won't see me down the ER either having injuries treated, or days off work due to injuries sustained in my spare time.

I should pay more, because I use more. But we live with this idea that healthy people don't cost more. They do, a lot, and its growing.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 12.58pm

Originally posted by becky

Given the apparent current state of the gene pool, that could be a winner......

Secret, the only system that really will work is to raise revenue, proportional to the requirement, across the board, with a vanity tax on certain goods (like smokes, booze, sporting goods, running shoes etc so that the average person can feel like they're getting a fair deal).

Edited by jamiemartin721 (13 Jun 2017 12.58pm)

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jun 17 1.03pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

But I'm not be taxed accordingly, I'm being taxed disproportionately, because healthy people are a major long term cost. I don't mind paying tax on cigs, booze etc, because there are costs. My lifestyle choice includes costing based on illness and disease related to my choices, but not the discounts (pension, late life illness, care etc).

Where as if I was maybe the kind of person who doesn't drink, smoke, eats a very balanced diet, exercises regularly etc I'm just as likely to incur additional health costs over the average person, but not get taxed accordingly.

The problem is people living too long, and we solve that by taxing people who don't? That's the problem with the health mentality in our moralised democracy - we're lepper taxers.


Yeah, apart from the bit i've highlighted (which I haven't seen any evidence to suggest that's correct despite the fact that if they lived longer, they'd be likely to pay a similar amount of tax before they died) I think we're going round in circles on this one...you think it's unfair and i dont..so lets move on.


Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2017 1.04pm)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 1.05pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Perfwin is advocating the reduction of attempts to educate people against a lifestyle that shortens life. That is bonkers.

Drug revenue would be welcomed by the chancellor but at what price?
The relaxation of rules on gambling was a nice little earner but do we have data on the effects of gambling on peoples lives? Has it been worth it? Vital services are still in crisis apparently.
There is clearly a need for more revenue but how can we ever cater comfortably for a rapidly growing population? Does the tax advantage really outweigh the burden of 300k more every year? Where is the evidence?

Depends, on whether you think that prohibition is working, and the best way to deal with what is a social health problem.

Round our way, you can phone a number, and within 30-40 minutes, someone will drop round your weed order, no need to know the dealers. Within a few years or so, it'll all be done online, through the dark net - something that's already starting to happen.

That's the problem with Vice laws, you're trying to stop people doing something they enjoy.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jun 17 1.07pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


Yeah, apart from the bit i've highlighted (which I haven't seen any evidence to suggest that's correct despite the fact that if they lived longer, they'd be likely to pay a similar amount of tax before they died) I think we're going round in circles on this one...you think it's unfair and i dont..so lets move on.


Edited by Lyons550 (13 Jun 2017 1.04pm)

I doubt it. I don't think its unfair, I think its unfair that we only target the easy group that's deviating from the norm (and then demonise them in society).

I don't mind paying tax on booze and cigs. I object that other forms of life style don't get the same treatment.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dementia Tax