You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Young players
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Young players


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 28 Jun 17 1.26pm

[Link]

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 1.38pm

Ignore the terrible spelling folks!

 




CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 28 Jun 17 1.39pm

It's hardly educational. FDB first task is to remain in the division. Yes frank de Boer may give youngsters a chance. Let's no kid ourselves, that because de Boer turned up, these young players have turned into world beaters. They have the chance in pre season to stake a claim but remember Ajax main source is to produce their own. I'm all for youth but this we take time, if it's done right.

Edited by CPFC/SCCC (28 Jun 2017 1.39pm)

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 1.42pm

I'm not ruling out the youngest players on the list, but you'd have thought if any of the older ones on there were going to set the world alight we'd have seen more from them by now, either at Palace or out on loan.

 




CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 28 Jun 17 1.46pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

I'm not ruling out the youngest players on the list, but you'd have thought if any of the older ones on there were going to set the world alight we'd have seen more from them by now, either at Palace or out on loan.

Totally agree. I'm not gonna write them off but let's not fool ourselves that FDB arrival, has made our academy become the best. Pre season the time to impress.

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jun 17 2.00pm

I wonder which one of them it was that demanded £10,000 per week from us

 

LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 28 Jun 17 2.08pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Ignore the terrible spelling folks!

Yeah, i noticed that on that site. jeez, worse than a 6 year old.

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.11pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I wonder which one of them it was that demanded £10,000 per week from us

Nya Kirby seemed the most likely candidate from the description...

 




LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 28 Jun 17 2.12pm

i always thought boateng shouldve gradually been blooded in. he's not let anyone down when he's been given a run out. but at 22, time isnt really on his side now.

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 28 Jun 17 2.16pm

Dreher still looks like he needs to become a man, and at 18 it's no surprise. Could happen. Will take the usual loaning out to get there. Deli Alli had to do it.

 


COYP

Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.20pm

Originally posted by LeBoeuf

i always thought boateng shouldve gradually been blooded in. he's not let anyone down when he's been given a run out. but at 22, time isnt really on his side now.

Yeah that's my problem too. I think Kai Kai and Boateng needed more time when they were a bit younger. I appreciate that we weren't at liberty to muck about as a team trying to survive in the Prem so I'm not faulting the managers for it. Just that I don't really think a 21 and 22 year old that are yet to have had significant top level game time are likely to become world class. Squad players maybe. And of course I'd be happy to be proved wrong.

 




Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.23pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Dreher still looks like he needs to become a man, and at 18 it's no surprise. Could happen. Will take the usual loaning out to get there. Deli Alli had to do it.

I think if we were able to loan out 18 year olds to Championship teams and for them to make their mark then we can talk in terms such as "the next Zaha". Zaha broke through at about 18 and we were able to offer him the luxury of game time in the Championship.

I know it sounds harsh, but when we loan the players out to League 2 teams I don't really care if they are league top scorer by 20 clear goals, it's not a good enough test for a Premier League manager to determine a player's potential for the top tier, it's just keeping the player fit (and perhaps happy) whilst they gradually stagnate.

 




Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.26pm

Before I am accused of talking out of my arse, I know there are exceptions. There will be 23 year olds that have a few games in League 2 and suddenly become the next Premier League name. Possibly. Maybe.

 




becky Flag over the moon 28 Jun 17 2.32pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Before I am accused of talking out of my arse, I know there are exceptions. There will be 23 year olds that have a few games in League 2 and suddenly become the next Premier League name. Possibly. Maybe.

Two words: Ian Wright.........

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.35pm

Originally posted by becky

Two words: Ian Wright.........

Yes. Well exactly my point. That was how long ago? And before the days of multi million pound players. But you can have it anyway

 




Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.38pm

Although Ian Wright wasn't a top tier talent loaned out to a nothing team for experience....whereas the players in our academy were presumably scouted as big talents when we signed them then allowed to stagnate (or found not to be good enough). In my humble opinion, if you're loaned out to a League 2 side (or lower) after the age of 18, the best you can hope for is to one day be a peripheral player if you want to stay in the top tier.

 




chateauferret Flag 28 Jun 17 2.53pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Before I am accused of talking out of my arse, I know there are exceptions. There will be 23 year olds that have a few games in League 2 and suddenly become the next Premier League name. Possibly. Maybe.

If my sums are right Jamie Vardy was playing for Fleetwood Town at 25.

 


============
The Ferret
============

LeBoeuf Flag Bermondsey 28 Jun 17 2.58pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

Although Ian Wright wasn't a top tier talent loaned out to a nothing team for experience....whereas the players in our academy were presumably scouted as big talents when we signed them then allowed to stagnate (or found not to be good enough). In my humble opinion, if you're loaned out to a League 2 side (or lower) after the age of 18, the best you can hope for is to one day be a peripheral player if you want to stay in the top tier.

ive often wondered if, when a lot of youngsters go to div 1 or 2 sides, they do stagnate or even go backwards. we've heard about so many of our academy players being tipped to be future stars for us. only to be released a year or two later. this may be a bad comparison, but when i played football and cricket, i found that i played better, against higher standard opposition, and not so well against lesser.
i know you cant gamble on a premier league game by throwing someone in, just to see if theyre good enough. but then how do you bring players through? bit of a double edged sword. hopefully, de boer has the answer.

 


a rich man is only a poor man with an obscene amount of money

Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 2.59pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

If my sums are right Jamie Vardy was playing for Fleetwood Town at 25.

A name I thought might get mentioned, but he wasn't a Leicester City academy player that they'd loaned out. He also didn't break into the Leicester first team whilst they were in the Premier League.

Edited by Part Time James (28 Jun 2017 3.24pm)

 




Part Time James Flag 28 Jun 17 3.04pm

Originally posted by LeBoeuf

ive often wondered if, when a lot of youngsters go to div 1 or 2 sides, they do stagnate or even go backwards. we've heard about so many of our academy players being tipped to be future stars for us. only to be released a year or two later. this may be a bad comparison, but when i played football and cricket, i found that i played better, against higher standard opposition, and not so well against lesser.
i know you cant gamble on a premier league game by throwing someone in, just to see if theyre good enough. but then how do you bring players through? bit of a double edged sword. hopefully, de boer has the answer.

I don't know the figures, but the number of players that make it from all the talent in the world is absolutely minuscule. And I don't really blame the top clubs when survival in the Premier League is so important and valuable to a team. Some of our recent managers have taken players along to bench warm which is good but in reality you need to be about 4-0 up in the league before you're going to bring on an un-tested player. For me the Championship is the place to prepare players. Get 17 and 18 year olds out on loan in the Championship. If they can secure a good few games and perform well then they are much less of a risk than a 22 year old that has been player of the month twice at a League 2 club.

This is all hyperbole I'm sure, and makes me sound like I've been playing Football Manager so much that I can make sweeping and over-simplified commentary on the subject. I'd love for our academy to produce first teamers, but I don't buy it that anyone loaned out to League One or Two clubs is really going to be the next big thing. It's as rare as hen's teeth.

 




Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Young players