You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Gard
November 21 2026 11.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Charlie Gard


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
becky Flag over the moon 12 Jul 17 11.53am

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

My children are older than charlie gard but if I asked them what they want replies would range from sweets to a certain toy to a trip out somewhere or maybe a friend round for a sleepover. This child cannot communicate in any way shape or form. Is only 10 months old so wouldn't form much of a rational response anyway and even if he was older no one would be having these types of conversations about life or death with a child. More crucially and very sadly he is completely unable now or in the future of doing any of the things a completely healthy or even another child with some disabilities can do. I am only starting to skirt round these kind of topics with my own mother and she's 66 and I am 32!! She has health problems and I am the next of kin and should the worst happen it will be on my shoulders to make the call. You have to think to yourself would the other person want to live like this. I am pretty sure no one would to be honest

Edited by Michaelawt85 (11 Jul 2017 4.58pm)

No experience with children, but I had to make that call with my mother. The fact that she had made her wishes clear to me still didn't stop it being a difficult thing to do, but sometimes you just have to love them enough to let them go.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jul 17 12.22pm

Sometimes in life, maybe often, I think you have to decide not on what you want to do / or happen, but what is the most difficult thing for you to do or outcome you least desire - And I think its definitely true in very hard decisions - that usually the best solution is the most difficult decision to make.

When my mother was diagnosed with cancer, I think the choice of my family was always to go with the easy decision, and then rationalise that decision as the best outcome (notably that she wasn't suffering because of the morphine, or that she wasn't concious).

I wanted to help her in the end, there was a point at which it was clear that there was no coming back, getting better, but the rest of the family were against it. Even in the end they were rationalising their decision, as she effectively drowned in her own fluid, until her heart gave out after five slow days.

Easy decision, is to watch suffering, hope and keep telling yourself its the best.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 12 Jul 17 2.49pm

Both Becky and Jamies posts are very sad and difficult to read. Probably because most of us know this is a scenario many of have either faced or will do in the future.

I think sometimes people feel so guilty at having to make the hard choice they choose to wait , possibly hoping the decision will be out of their hands at some stage and they won't have to live with the guilt . It's a difficult thing to bring up isn't it. My mum has got quite defensive about it at times. Thinks I am wishing her dead or something but I think having 'that' conversation and having some thought as to the wishes of the other person , although doesn't make it hurt any less , it can help you later to be confident you are doing something they would ultimately be at peace with you about. Xx

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 12 Jul 17 5.25pm

An illustration of how difficult it can be the other way too

[Link]

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Jul 17 5.38pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

An illustration of how difficult it can be the other way too

[Link]

How cruel we as a society are, that we would allow people to be starved or suffocated to death, by turning off machines, but not provide a means of death that is painless such as an overdose of diamorphine or barbiturate: that we as a society would see our own moral senses as being more valid than the suffering an individual is going through as their body decays or collapses around them, whilst their mind goes on.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

wordup Flag 12 Jul 17 10.03pm

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

An illustration of how difficult it can be the other way too

[Link]

This can be such a complex issue with people fighting for what they think is the best for their child. That clip is heart breaking. I can't imagine how hard it must be to care for your child day in, day out but at the same time feel that they would be better off dead. How frustrating it must be too, to have that decision taken out of your hands.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 13 Jul 17 11.26am

Parents back in court today waiting for a decision from the judge as they seek to overrule the last court judgement saying life support should be withdrawn.

Personally I envisage the court upholding the last judgement and this continuing. How can the doctors physically withdraw life support with two parents in attendance who would understandably be hysterical and are completely anti the decision. I can only see more of a stand off. More legal challenges to buy the parents time and this child remaining in this state until he passes away of his own accord. What happens if he doesn't? Mind boggling scenario

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 13 Jul 17 11.51am

Turning off his life support even with a 0.01 % chance of a cure is tantamount to murder. quality of any future life shouldn't even be on the table for discussion. What should we have done with Stephen Hawking, when he became paraplegic? roll him off Beachy Head ? of course not.

While there is a chance, no matter how slim his parents have every right to fight for the childs right to live.

I almost hate myself for thinking this, but I bet my best boll0ck this wouldn't even be in the papers if the Gards were one of the vogue minority couples, gay, lesbian, etc etc.

It stinks.

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 13 Jul 17 1.14pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Turning off his life support even with a 0.01 % chance of a cure is tantamount to murder. quality of any future life shouldn't even be on the table for discussion. What should we have done with Stephen Hawking, when he became paraplegic? roll him off Beachy Head ? of course not.

There is zero chance for a cure. None of the treatments will be able to reverse the existing damage. I suspect any parent would be prepared to go to Hell and back for their child - But they're also giving this kid morphine because they believe he is in serious pain. The reality for this child, in the best case prognosis is severe brain damage, physical disability and a short life expectancy, that might be extended somewhat from infancy to childhood - likely full of pain and suffering. The likely outcome is that the treatment will have little to no effect other than to extend a life on tubes.

Its not a choice I'd want to make, and its not that often that you hear of paediatric doctors wanting to end the treatment of a child allowing them to die. These experimental treatments, one of them hasn't even started animal trials yet (so its a theoretical treatment).

Difference with Hawking is he is in a position to be able to decide for himself etc.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 13 Jul 17 2.04pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Turning off his life support even with a 0.01 % chance of a cure is tantamount to murder. quality of any future life shouldn't even be on the table for discussion. What should we have done with Stephen Hawking, when he became paraplegic? roll him off Beachy Head ? of course not.

While there is a chance, no matter how slim his parents have every right to fight for the childs right to live.

I almost hate myself for thinking this, but I bet my best boll0ck this wouldn't even be in the papers if the Gards were one of the vogue minority couples, gay, lesbian, etc etc.

It stinks.

There isn't a cure for irreversible brain damage . He can't see, hear, breathe for himself, cry or show any response to pain whatsoever. The size of him in recent weeks points towards possible organ failure on top of that.

We are talking about parents using a drug which hasn't even been tested on mice on him. If it can actually cross the blood barrier and get into the brain (50% chance it can even do that) it's got a hundredth of 1 per cent of a chance of stopping his symptoms progressing. So we are talking about a child being consigned to a life deaf in the dark with a machine breathing for him and if he's in pain (no one knows what this experimental drug could do to him side effect wise) he won't have any chance of communicating it to a soul.

The more I read about this and the more I think about it I think to do that to anyone animal or human is cruel in the extreme.

The reason it's in the papers to the level it is as the parents and aunt have had blogs, fundraising, pages all over social media etc etc with a massive publicity machine. Posed photographs of the child holding his passport saying he wants to go to America and all sorts. I get why they are doing it I really do but I seriously question their reasoning and thought process behind it. And having social media campaigns slagging off and running down the name of GOSH who cannot publicly respond to their comments is bloody scandalous.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 13 Jul 17 2.16pm

Originally posted by dannyh

Turning off his life support even with a 0.01 % chance of a cure is tantamount to murder. quality of any future life shouldn't even be on the table for discussion. What should we have done with Stephen Hawking, when he became paraplegic? roll him off Beachy Head ? of course not.

While there is a chance, no matter how slim his parents have every right to fight for the childs right to live.

I almost hate myself for thinking this, but I bet my best boll0ck this wouldn't even be in the papers if the Gards were one of the vogue minority couples, gay, lesbian, etc etc.

It stinks.


Unfortunately you're not comparing like for like there Danny so the point you make..although perfectly sound for Mr Hawking doesn't hold water with regards to the case in point.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 13 Jul 17 10.52pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

The parents should be allowed to do everything they can for their child.

Ashya King would not be alive today if the doctors had had their way.

Yep I don't know the story but I'd have to agree with this.

Their the parents and they have to live with the aftermarth of the decisions. If they feel it's best for them then who are we to judge? Will the little lad be any worse off if it doesn't work?

But yeah I don't know the story so guess that's just my general view on situations like this.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 14 Jul 17 11.27am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Yep I don't know the story but I'd have to agree with this.

Their the parents and they have to live with the aftermarth of the decisions. If they feel it's best for them then who are we to judge? Will the little lad be any worse off if it doesn't work?

But yeah I don't know the story so guess that's just my general view on situations like this.

I think the problem is more that he won't be any better off if it does work.

I would say that in most cases, doctors and parents are in agreement, and they will do everything they can towards saving a patient (in fact doctors will act against parents wishes to force treatment, where parents might, say for religious reasons, not want vital treatment).

Cases like this are the abnormality, where in you're balancing hope vs expert opinion. Neither party is objective (its emotion vs rationality) and someone has to make an objective decision on the best interests of the child.

When no one can achieve that, we refer it to the court. Same with any other case where the best interest of the child cannot be assured to be with the parents, due to evidence from expert opinion.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 14 Jul 17 1.10pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think the problem is more that he won't be any better off if it does work.

I would say that in most cases, doctors and parents are in agreement, and they will do everything they can towards saving a patient (in fact doctors will act against parents wishes to force treatment, where parents might, say for religious reasons, not want vital treatment).

Cases like this are the abnormality, where in you're balancing hope vs expert opinion. Neither party is objective (its emotion vs rationality) and someone has to make an objective decision on the best interests of the child.

When no one can achieve that, we refer it to the court. Same with any other case where the best interest of the child cannot be assured to be with the parents, due to evidence from expert opinion.

It also raises the medical ethics question. This child cannot give any form of consent to an experimental unlicensed untested drug being used on him. That's where the parents usually come in and give the consent in their interests of their child . However the American doctor being questioned yesterday via video link has agreed to use this drug on charlie has never actually met or examined him, has admitted it would be an experiment . It starts to enter a very murky area of essentially testing on humans which is to a degree fine if they can agree to it and if something goes wrong or there are side effects they can be communicated to doctors . The courts will be aware that agreement to allow it in this case Will without a doubt open the floodgates in all kinds of conditions to all manner of experiments being carried out on people , adults, children and babies. For this very reason I don't personally think they will allow it.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 Jul 17 5.14pm

[Link]

 

becky Flag over the moon 16 Jul 17 6.07pm

I cannot understand why people keep going on about how the Doctors in this case (and other similar ones) shouldn't be allowed to "play God"........ surely they played God when they put the poor mite on life support and incubation machines, else he would be dead by now and we wouldn't be having this discussion.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

wordup Flag 16 Jul 17 6.51pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

There is zero chance for a cure. None of the treatments will be able to reverse the existing damage. I suspect any parent would be prepared to go to Hell and back for their child - But they're also giving this kid morphine because they believe he is in serious pain. The reality for this child, in the best case prognosis is severe brain damage, physical disability and a short life expectancy, that might be extended somewhat from infancy to childhood - likely full of pain and suffering. The likely outcome is that the treatment will have little to no effect other than to extend a life on tubes.

Its not a choice I'd want to make, and its not that often that you hear of paediatric doctors wanting to end the treatment of a child allowing them to die. These experimental treatments, one of them hasn't even started animal trials yet (so its a theoretical treatment).

Difference with Hawking is he is in a position to be able to decide for himself etc.

I wasn't aware of that. It's a heart breaking situation for all concerned. Some people get dealt such a crap hand in life. Poor kid.

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Charlie Gard