This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by teedee
That's the reality with top players - they suffer lots bad tackles. Zaha has a reputation as a diver he needs to keep his feet and curb his temper then he will be truly a top player. If he does have such a reputation then it is 100% unfounded! [Link] The fact that he's the most fouled player in the Prem and yet given virtually no protection by the officials is disgraceful and is a direct cause of his occassional loss of temper. In the light of the treatment he gets I think he's incredible! Edited by sa_eagle (24 Jul 2017 12.49pm)
Cynic or realist? It's a fine line! |
|
|
Are you telling me Neymar is not a diver? We must not have the same player in mind ....... Originally posted by Nobbybm
Coincidence, but FdB has been quoted today as saying Wilf is our version of Neymar. Neymar is the most fouled player in La Liga & has been for a while. I'm trying to find an article I read on this a while back which showed how his speed and quick feet meant that referees just didn't see many of the fouls on him. This led to a 'diving' reputation which exacerbated the problem & it was only after a formal case with lots of video evidence was put forward by FCB that he started getting any kind of protection. In the modern game this really shouldn't be needed but officials & pundits alike seem to be more swayed by reputation than fact much of the time.
|
|
|
Maybe this should've been the kit for this season?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Which is why teams get around it by "fouling by committee". No concept of "team fouls" in football.....now wouldn't that be a thing? I forget who, but a ref gave Man Utd a team warning for the endless booting of Hazard: the next player to do it would get a yellow. The next player - almost immediately after the warning - was Lindgard who was already on a yellow, so off he duly went. Man Utd are masters at rotating fouls through the team; it won them the FA Cup, FFS! They get away with it because referees rarely issue them the team warning...and because they're Man Utd. I hope the management at Palace keep up the pressure on league officials. I'd make a "highlight" reel each week of the assaults on Wilf and send it in for review. Edited by Ray in Houston (24 Jul 2017 2.40pm)
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football. |
|
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Looking at it cynically, we need Zaha to be fouled as much as possible - why? This may be our only source of goals (from the resultant free kicks) - and those from Wilf himself. I cannot see goals from anywhere else. Benteke was hardly seen, Townsend ran a lot but ultimately lost the ball and wasted the one cross he did manage to get over. With the present set up we need to add a Gayle-type player who can run on to the through balls that will now be forthcoming from our new set up. Erm, can we leave the pant-wetting until at LEAST a few games into the season please?
|
|
|
Our Wilf is a man, he can take of himself.
|
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
Tsk tsk. I would be horrified if he got injured. I am simply nervous that if he doesn't get proper protection it is inevitable; as most seem to be saying along with me (without your unsustainable aggression and anger). UKIP
|
|
|
Originally posted by BarEagle
Remember this comment. If the boys in black don't start giving him proper protection and realising he is not a diver but extremely skilful he is going to get a very, very bad injury. Team after team, player after player, week after week he is targeted with fouls to try and take him out of games with NO consequence. There is going to be a brawl soon because players will take it into their own hands because he gets no protection. Horrid but true. Something needs to be done or football will suffer.
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
To be fair, if he was an opposition player, wouldn't you want our defenders to 'stop him playing'..... Every team identifies the opposing sides most dangerous player and targets him. Wilf gets fouled more because he takes on more players than anyone else. If he gets past 2, the third one is going to clobber him. Not going to stop that, and the more we, and the manager whinge about it, the worst it will get.... Okk, we can just expect him to be badly injured and say nothing?
|
|
|
Originally posted by DutchEagleJohan
Are you telling me Neymar is not a diver? We must not have the same player in mind ....... Nope. What was said is that his reputation as one was not founded on fact but more 'perception'. Going down easy is not the same as diving & they had enough video to show that a majority of the time fouls were being committed. It was shown, evidentially, that you didn't need that strong a contact to fell someone in full flight so he could be accused of being a bit of lightweight at times but not as much simulation as the media made out. Whatever occurred, the Spanish officials took a much stronger view on fouls committed against him - he still tops the 'most fouled' chart but not by the same huge margin. Edited by Nobbybm (24 Jul 2017 9.03pm)
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by adrian b
Okk, we can just expect him to be badly injured and say nothing? Grow uo. He had the most dribbles in the league last year. What do you expect teams to do, He has been targeted the last few seasons, he's coped. Nothings going to change.
|
|
|
Was that a video Barca made? Because I have no single bit of doubt that diving in Spanish football is at it worst level it has ever been and I despise the current Barca team for it . It has gotten to the stage I have stopped watching El Classico. Maybe my perception is wrong, but doubt it. Diving, simulation, play acting is a huge part of the Spanish and South American game and I can't stand it. Mind you, we had Robben here who has improved a lot since his Chelsea time but still has his moments so I'm not saying it's mainly a Southern European or Latin thing. Saw Victor Moses doing it against Spurs, or Vardy against Arsenal last season when he got a penalty for tripping himself. How I would like to hand out 10 plus games bans for anything like it. And take all the pundits who tell everyone "there is contact he is entitled to go down" off the telly. Originally posted by Nobbybm
Nope. What was said is that his reputation as one was not founded on fact but more 'perception'. Going down easy is not the same as diving & they had enough video to show that a majority of the time fouls were being committed. It was shown, evidentially, that you didn't need that strong a contact to fell someone in full flight so he could be accused of being a bit of lightweight at times but not as much simulation as the media made out. Whatever occurred, the Spanish officials took a much stronger view on fouls committed against him - he still tops the 'most fouled' chart but not by the same huge margin. Edited by Nobbybm (24 Jul 2017 9.03pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by europalace
and so if he doesn't? Will you come back and admit you were wrong? We'll also remember this comment and when he doesn't get a serious injury blatently caused by another player, you'll be reminded of it. Europalace. You going to take it back now?
|
|
|
Originally posted by adrian b
Well the season is only two games long and Wilf has already lost 50% of the currentvseason. Was this through over-robust tackling by Huddersfield? Was it team rotattion tackles by the Terriers? I don't know, but its bloody coincidence it has happened to our best player who may well be the best player in the PPL.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.