You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Puncheon


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Bobbycrayfish Flag Warlingham 15 Aug 17 5.48pm

Anyone think he deserves a place in the first team let along captaincy?

 

supernaut Flag Armagh 15 Aug 17 5.59pm

Yes, he deserves to be in the first team and yes, he should be captain

 


Supernaut - Ireland's premier Black Sabbath tribute band
Facebook: [Link]

Palace Forever!

Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 15 Aug 17 6.00pm

Originally posted by Bobbycrayfish

Anyone think he deserves a place in the first team let along captaincy?

Doesn't deserve a place on the bench let alone team.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 15 Aug 17 7.48pm

As much as I like Punch, not for me. Behind RLC, Cabaye, Milo and McArthur in centre midfield. Used to be effective in AMC/No 10 role but has lost pace. Try's to do too much on the ball and needs to release it earlier.

I don't see where he fits in the 343 and I've no idea where he was meant to be playing on Saturday - was he in CM or as a wide attacker? He doesn't suit either. FDB has shot himself in the foot by making him captain

 

EddieMac Flag 15 Aug 17 8.21pm

Puncheon has to be dropped from first team for us to have any hope this season.He has been in awful form for about a year. I cant remember the last time he has struck a shot on target, I have seen milk turn quicker. Breaks my heart when I see his name on the team sheet.

I honestly think FDB is just biding his time till he drops him. New Managers dont like to come in and drop the club captain straight away.

 

Part Time James Flag 15 Aug 17 8.36pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

Puncheon has to be dropped from first team for us to have any hope this season.He has been in awful form for about a year. I cant remember the last time he has struck a shot on target, I have seen milk turn quicker. Breaks my heart when I see his name on the team sheet.

I honestly think FDB is just biding his time till he drops him. New Managers dont like to come in and drop the club captain straight away.

Was he named captain before or after FdB took over? My memory is fuzzy, but I thought he was the boss when he was named captain.

 




Bangell Flag Oxford 15 Aug 17 8.44pm

Loftus-Cheek seems to better him in every department. When Cabaye is fit, I don't think you can justify squeezing Punch into the line-up ahead of Cabaye, RLC and Luka.

 

supernaut Flag Armagh 15 Aug 17 8.50pm

I can't understand all the negativity surrounding Jason Puncheon. As far as I'm concerned he's Palace through and through, and can always be relied on. He deserves to play.

 


Supernaut - Ireland's premier Black Sabbath tribute band
Facebook: [Link]

Palace Forever!

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 15 Aug 17 9.12pm

Originally posted by supernaut

I can't understand all the negativity surrounding Jason Puncheon. As far as I'm concerned he's Palace through and through, and can always be relied on. He deserves to play.

Mate, I'm Palace through and through. Doesn't make me a starter. The opinion of most is that he's not the player he used to be and there are others who should be ahead of him in the pecking order.

I too love him as a local lad and a trier but that unfortunately is not enough.

 

Coach 3 Flag Sandown Isle of Wight 15 Aug 17 9.23pm

Old Father Time has caught up with him, has lost pace and zip. Maybe a seat on the bench but should no longer be considered a starter.

 

benchharp Flag 15 Aug 17 9.35pm

I love Puncheon but he never wants to go forward, we're really missing that, someone who can drive down the middle or at least try and create something.

Was refreshing to see Loftus Cheek doing that in the second half last week, Punch and Cabeye to be fair don't seem bothered about venturing forward or just seem to lack ideas once they get past half way. (and disappointingly Van Aanholt 90% of the time)

Great guy but needs competition at least.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Aug 17 9.36pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Loftus-Cheek seems to better him in every department. When Cabaye is fit, I don't think you can justify squeezing Punch into the line-up ahead of Cabaye, RLC and Luka.

These 3 every time.

 


COYP

Casual Flag Orpington 15 Aug 17 10.30pm

His few decent games for Palace were in a 5/6 purple patch when Pullis was manager. Not even a championship winger, can't tackle , never scores, slows the game down and can't cross a free kick/corner.

Notice I didn't start my post with 'I like puncheon, but', or 'I know he's one of our own but', he's not , he's a journeyman that was never any good and ended up playing for his local team, that I doubt he supported as a kid. Stealing a living now.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 15 Aug 17 10.41pm

Originally posted by Casual

His few decent games for Palace were in a 5/6 purple patch when Pullis was manager. Not even a championship winger, can't tackle , never scores, slows the game down and can't cross a free kick/corner.

Notice I didn't start my post with 'I like puncheon, but', or 'I know he's one of our own but', he's not , he's a journeyman that was never any good and ended up playing for his local team, that I doubt he supported as a kid. Stealing a living now.

His best period was straight after Pardew came in and moved him to the centre. Was really influential, and scored a few good goals too.

Don't think he'll ever be able to recreate that.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 15 Aug 17 10.47pm

Originally posted by Bangell

His best period was straight after Pardew came in and moved him to the centre. Was really influential, and scored a few good goals too.

Don't think he'll ever be able to recreate that.

I can't remember that. At the end of the season (under Pullis), he scored a few goals in 5/6 games that pretty much kept us up. I might be wrong, may have been under Pardew. Either way, not good enough now.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 15 Aug 17 11.07pm

I share the sentiment of most - it's not that he's a terrible player. But we've just got better options at the moment. Luca, Yohan and RLC is a very good centre midfield. Let alone McArthur.

Time to move on I'm afraid.

 

chateauferret Flag 15 Aug 17 11.15pm

Originally posted by Casual

His few decent games for Palace were in a 5/6 purple patch when Pullis was manager. Not even a championship winger, can't tackle , never scores, slows the game down and can't cross a free kick/corner.

Notice I didn't start my post with 'I like puncheon, but', or 'I know he's one of our own but', he's not , he's a journeyman that was never any good and ended up playing for his local team, that I doubt he supported as a kid. Stealing a living now.

His dead ball skills are something else. Has the record for the widest penalty miss in Palace history, can't get a free kick anywhere near where intended, and the other team is more likely to score from his corners than we are.

 


============
The Ferret
============

sprites Flag Auckland 15 Aug 17 11.21pm

I think if we're honest with ourselves, out strongest team is:

Hennessy

Tomkins - Dann - Riedewald

Fosu-Mensah - Luca - Cabaye - RLC - Van Aanholt

Zaha - Benteke - Townsend.


Unfortunately, there's no room for Punch.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Aug 17 11.23pm

Originally posted by sprites

I think if we're honest with ourselves, out strongest team is:

Hennessy

Tomkins - Dann - Riedewald

Fosu-Mensah - Luca - Cabaye - RLC - Van Aanholt

Zaha - Benteke - Townsend.


Unfortunately, there's no room for Punch.

There's no room for them. It's a 3-5-3, unless one of them is rush keeper. Probably better than Hennessey.

 


COYP

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 16 Aug 17 3.54am

Beyond belief how he still starts tbh

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Puncheon