This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| Flash |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by peterg
Is this true about the loan market? Only free agents now until January. Not sure about the rules regarding signing a GK in emergency due to injuries.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Plumpton eagle
Yes, SP has been a great chairman and saved the club (for a modest investment with 3 other very rich people). But surely that must now be considered done and dusted. In my view the credit from that has expired. In looking at more recent events, two managers a season is becoming the norm. Why do SP's appointments just not seem to work out? He is the common denominator. When Pardew was sacked we were told it was time to "wind back the clock" and say goodbye to expansive football. After a shaky start under Sam, we became harder to beat and spanked Chelsea, Arsenal and Liverpool. Safety was achieved and we could look forward to a new season of consolidation and growth without relegation worries. Sam leaves (it's seems not SP's fault but on his watch). After weeks of humming and haahing, SP appoints FDB who is new to the premiership and clearly wants to completely change the way we play. I can only assume with the blessing of SP. This style of play failed under Pardew and he had the the benefit of years of premiership experience. We don't know what assurances FDB was given about new signings. Now here we are, just into September, with no points, no goals scored, a very unpopular manager, a modest transfer window and many disgruntled fans. SP was the front man of the group that saved Palace and we will always be grateful. But a lot of bad things have happened on his watch. If he didn't have previous credit in the bank, he would be getting a lot more stick than he is now. I don't doubt that he is Palace through and through. But I do now doubt his ability to run the business side of the club and appoint and deal effectively with managers and oversee player recruitment. As a small club, in premiership terms, we need to be at our very best and sharpest in managerial and player recruitment. Perhaps SP would be better suited to be Chief Financial Officer and concentrate on income generation, budgets and marketing? Maybe the recruitment of Doogie is a subtle move in that direction. I don't believe in witch hunts and personal abuse. But it is not unreasonable, or disloyal, to hold any chairman to account irrespective of their previous achievements. Credit for saving the club expired? You what? Edited by Dangermouse (01 Sep 2017 10.21am)
That's Life |
|
| Flash |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Flash
Only free agents now until January. Not sure about the rules regarding signing a GK in emergency due to injuries. Apparently emergency loan system was outlawed this year, but with transition-easing measures:
|
|
|
I think the first words Sakho says to FdB will be. "And you are"?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Credit for saving the club expired? You what? Edited by Dangermouse (01 Sep 2017 10.21am) My nephew who is 3 years old does what he thinks is right, when he plays connect 4. Trouble is that is tip the board over and start crying. Doing what you think is right is not good enough at this level, we need someone who is GOOD at what they do. The appointment of FDB is an absolute clanger, except if he was backed with transfers, he has not been backed with transfers. We have 1 fit striker who can play at this level. We haven't signed a goalie, how on earth have we not signed a goalie, its incredible. We have no transfer strategy, we treat transfers like its the first time we are doing it, every time, time and again. Its not good enough at this level.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
A forum doesn't work unless different opinions are offered and for that reason I try and respect everyone's and whilst I'll disagree with some I'll never revert to some of the personal abuse people throw around on here. Is Parish perfect? No. Does he have the best interests of the club whilst rightly not blindly throwing money around that will bankrupt himself and the club? Yes. We need to take a look at ourselves and wonder if e would prefer a Mike Ashley for example - we are lucky to have the people in place that we have and we would do well not to forget that. If you could turn back time and be offered the 6/7 seasons we've had to any supporter, I bet not a single one would have turned it down. Expectations have changed granted but we'd all do well to remember that so have that of every other club every season, it cant work 100% of the time for everyone. And in regards to transfers, none of us know what goes on in the background of one of the most complex things in football, for all we know we targeted every single one of the players mentioned and were blocked by impossible things. People on here expect savvy businessmen to throw money around like its paper, giving in to every demand of every agent and hanger on involved in the process. We are all supporters including the board but I'm betting you wouldn't throw an entire paycheck at something without carefully thinking it through. And for Christ sakes please stop booing at games, it offers nothing positive to a team that is already of fragile confidence. Remember the cauldron we created to greet Arsenal, broke their spirit before the game even started. Exactly! If you were to go onto pretty much every premier league club's forums right now, those fans who are inclined to moan will be having a field day, while those who are more realistic will probably not. All clubs have tried to improve their squads, very few (not even City or Chelsea) will have got all the players they wanted. SP has done pretty much as well as he could, and the squad is clearly much improved. Yes, we are short in one or two areas, but every squad could be improved if the clubs are prepared to throw money at the problem with no regard for anything else. If you can't see that 3 out of the 4 players that have come in are improvements on what we had (I'll reserve my opinion of Riederwald until he's played around 10 games) then you really are a "glass half empty" person. Not a perfect window by any means, but not a reason to string Parish up by his balls either!
I used to be immortal |
|
|
We seem to treat buying needed players like running out of milk: 'Oh, I'll just pop to Sainsbury's'.
|
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
All clubs have tried to improve their squads, very few (not even City or Chelsea) will have got all the players they wanted. Perhaps not but they don't have the glaring holes in their squad that we do
|
|
|
Originally posted by crystal balls
Exactly! If you were to go onto pretty much every premier league club's forums right now, those fans who are inclined to moan will be having a field day, while those who are more realistic will probably not. All clubs have tried to improve their squads, very few (not even City or Chelsea) will have got all the players they wanted. SP has done pretty much as well as he could, and the squad is clearly much improved. Yes, we are short in one or two areas, but every squad could be improved if the clubs are prepared to throw money at the problem with no regard for anything else. If you can't see that 3 out of the 4 players that have come in are improvements on what we had (I'll reserve my opinion of Riederwald until he's played around 10 games) then you really are a "glass half empty" person. Not a perfect window by any means, but not a reason to string Parish up by his balls either! Yes - It all comes down to what kind of person you are. I'm sure you'd have found Leicester supporters that were still moaning and thought they knew better when they won the league. But surely even the most negative person must concede the squad is stronger this year? I know we haven't improved areas that we clearly need to but I'm sure the intent was there
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Perhaps not but they don't have the glaring holes in their squad that we do Disagree - personally can't be arsed to go on every forum but I'm sure every teams fans is disappointed with at least one starting player and wanted them replaced.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
Credit for saving the club expired? You what? "Credit for saving the club expired?" was probably the wrong term as the poster should have said that SP can't live on that credit for ever more. Interesting comment you made that you "don't know if SP is good or bad at this job, but I'm sure he does what he thinks is right" as I'm sure that the same could have been said about Mark Goldberg and Simon Jordan and look where that left us.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
Disagree - personally can't be arsed to go on every forum but I'm sure every teams fans is disappointed with at least one starting player and wanted them replaced. I'm not referring to a substandard player but I'm concerned about what happens if Benteke is injured or suspended as we have no cover hence the glaring holes in our squad
|
|
|
Originally posted by Dangermouse
OK Maine, who? Edited by Dangermouse (01 Sep 2017 10.37am) Not sure what you mean with who? Who could do a better job? How long is a piece of string. Steve Parish could make any number of moves to bring new blood into running the football side of the house. He seems to have done that with Freedman but its the same old story of inept transfer strategies and huge gaps in the squad, which smells like Parish again. This transfer window has been a huge failure especially in the context of having just hired a manager who likes to play possession football and pass it around the park. You seem to be missing the point I made about my nephew. Person A doing what they think is right playing connect 4 - putting the coloured chips into the holes to try to put 4 into a row, and maybe they are good at it and always win. Person B - throwing the pieces around and crying - not a good player of connect 4. At this stage of the game, we need someone who is good at being chairman of our football club. We needed to address pressing needs in the squad by executing a professional and coordinated strategy regarding transfers. Instead of trying to sign Oumar Niasse at midnight and then cocking it up over agent fees. We saved 3 or 4 million quid on waiting this long on Sakho, and all the uncertainty and noise that brought to the other deals, was it really worth it? Parish is getting obsessed about waiting late on deadline day, other clubs around us didnt do that, so why do we do it every time? The managerial appointment and then transfer window was shambolic. Parish himself said "barring disasters" we would sign 3 players yesterday, I guess then you can call it a disaster - and who is responsible for this disaster?
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
I'm not referring to a substandard player but I'm concerned about what happens if Benteke is injured or suspended as we have no cover hence the glaring holes in our squad My statement still stands. You genuinely think all other teams aren't worried about the replacement of one particular player? Of course I'm worried about Benteke being injured but we are Crystal Palace A) no player even near his level will be happy sitting on our bench B) decent strikers don't come cheap, salary included C) they tried to address this but transfers are complex
|
|
|
Originally posted by CPFC1965
He saved us, he gave us Burley, he's paid 650k per annum, he's sold a large part of us to the yanks, he's promised us a new stadium, brought back Freedman, appointed FdB, he let Pardew nearly take us to the gallows.....If you dressed him in a toga and stuck a laurel crown on his bonce he looks like Julius Caesar. He is not accountable to anyone. We are his toy. Better his toy than Mike Ashley's. Be careful what you wish for
|
|
|
Originally posted by Littlebogreek
Disagree - personally can't be arsed to go on every forum but I'm sure every teams fans is disappointed with at least one starting player and wanted them replaced. Count how many clubs have 1 available striker for 4- 5 months. Just as perhaps?
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.