You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dominic Fifield article in the guardian
November 16 2026 8.34am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dominic Fifield article in the guardian


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
budgie2 Flag 12 Sep 17 11.17am

Well written piece on latest mess we find ourselves in .

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 17 11.24am

Fans' protest? Fvck off. We need results and a dof, not a fans' protest. Protest to what exactly?

 


COYP

NeaKnuck Flag London 12 Sep 17 11.27am

I think we are the best at protesting. Get the Holmesdale Fanatics on a flag NOW. I'll gladly chip in

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 12 Sep 17 11.31am

Indeed a very well written piece that sums it up nicely.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 17 11.32am

Originally posted by NeaKnuck

I think we are the best at protesting. Get the Holmesdale Fanatics on a flag NOW. I'll gladly chip in

Just sing and support the club for points. It's that simple. None of that cr&p when Sam started until we realise we're contributing to our own relegation. It's up to blocks c, d etc, the upper and the Arfur to wake up from their coma before it's too late.

 


COYP

Part Time James Flag 12 Sep 17 11.38am

Absolutely agree. Keep the moans and groans to this forum or to yourself or to your mates in the pub. In the stands it's time to save ourselves from embarrassment and remind the league what Palace fans can do in the face of adversity.

 




Bangell Flag Oxford 12 Sep 17 11.55am

A protest? The whole point of a protest is to get something changed immediately - what exactly is anyone demanding now?

Although I would like to see a big banner saying 'WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE SENSIBLE AND EFFECTIVE LONG-TERM PLANNING', it's not really protest material.

 

Part Time James Flag 12 Sep 17 12.13pm

Originally posted by Bangell

A protest? The whole point of a protest is to get something changed immediately - what exactly is anyone demanding now?

Although I would like to see a big banner saying 'WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE SENSIBLE AND EFFECTIVE LONG-TERM PLANNING', it's not really protest material.

That made me chuckle.

How about "A manager's for life, not just til Christmas"

 




antipodeagle Flag Wellington 12 Sep 17 12.17pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

That made me chuckle.

How about "A manager's for life, not just til Christmas"

If only they lasted that long...

 

mike_sc Flag South London 12 Sep 17 12.23pm

Originally posted by Bangell

A protest? The whole point of a protest is to get something changed immediately - what exactly is anyone demanding now?

Although I would like to see a big banner saying 'WE WOULD LIKE TO SEE SENSIBLE AND EFFECTIVE LONG-TERM PLANNING', it's not really protest material.

I think that would be the perfect banner. Pretty expensive if you're paying by the letter mind...

Having said that, Hodgson will be 72 when his contract is up. Hard to plan too far ahead when he's liable to dose off midway through the second half.

 

FairweatherEagle Flag London 12 Sep 17 12.36pm

Originally posted by antipodeagle

If only they lasted that long...

I'll be measuring the time left till Christmas in palace managers from now on 😂

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 12 Sep 17 12.42pm

There is nothing to protest about .
We were nailed on for relegation with Frank.
You only have to have watched the pre season and the matches to know it.
Also he was upsetting the regime / players as being suggested in background thus damaging the club, he had to go.
In four matches times we would have said have a protest to get him out.

 

wisdom man Flag SURREY 12 Sep 17 12.47pm

Originally posted by budgie2

Well written piece on latest mess we find ourselves in .

Just another lot of waffle, telling us nothing we all didn't already know.
Lazy Journalism.
It was more exciting when he told us about the 4 new signings we were getting, even though it wasn't true!

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 12 Sep 17 12.56pm

Originally posted by antipodeagle

If only they lasted that long...

Let's just say that pantomine season has arrived early at Selhurst Park.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 17 1.00pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

There is nothing to protest about .
We were nailed on for relegation with Frank.
You only have to have watched the pre season and the matches to know it.
Also he was upsetting the regime / players as being suggested in background thus damaging the club, he had to go.
In four matches times we would have said have a protest to get him out.

More than likely inevitable. I would've had him on game by game monitoring but it does seem as though he was itching to play 3-4-3, show the top 5 what he could do and go there if it works or just walk away without a care if it didn't. That was my reading of him once he mentioned it and still is. And I didn't want him before that. Was willing to give him a bit of time though. The chairmanship has been far from classy. Who conducts transfers. Manager old style or continental board style, with Parish in Spain for most of the summer. Oh it's okay, modern communications and all that.

Frank, parish and board all share some blame. Time to support and them to sort it out and move out those who should be when possible. That's how you do that. Not renewing contracts on a cb to never play and then end up with 7 of them or isolate them and then select them a day later. They're all acting very amateurishly but have time to correct it. That or they're going to get abuse for sh1t performances once relegated.

 


COYP

est1905 Flag 12 Sep 17 1.13pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

There is nothing to protest about .
We were nailed on for relegation with Frank.
You only have to have watched the pre season and the matches to know it.
Also he was upsetting the regime / players as being suggested in background thus damaging the club, he had to go.
In four matches times we would have said have a protest to get him out.

All of your points are based on your own opinion (which is fine) and gossip (which is not) but none of which is fact.
We were not nailed on to be relegated under FdB. The game against Burnley actually suggests the tide is (or was) about to turn in our favour.
Talk of him upsetting the regime/players is just that, talk. The performance Sunday 100% proves that at least the players on the pitch were playing for him. On your final point, in 4 matches time I think most of us would have been breathing a sigh of relief that we didn't sack him as I truly believe it would have started to come good.
The bloke has been treated unforgivably badly. This will do us harm in the future when recruiting a manager that isn't in his 70s and has a choice of other clubs and is talented. Would you want to take a job with someone that may sack you 4 games in? I know I wouldn't

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Sep 17 1.57pm

Originally posted by est1905

All of your points are based on your own opinion (which is fine) and gossip (which is not) but none of which is fact.
We were not nailed on to be relegated under FdB. The game against Burnley actually suggests the tide is (or was) about to turn in our favour.
Talk of him upsetting the regime/players is just that, talk. The performance Sunday 100% proves that at least the players on the pitch were playing for him. On your final point, in 4 matches time I think most of us would have been breathing a sigh of relief that we didn't sack him as I truly believe it would have started to come good.
The bloke has been treated unforgivably badly. This will do us harm in the future when recruiting a manager that isn't in his 70s and has a choice of other clubs and is talented. Would you want to take a job with someone that may sack you 4 games in? I know I wouldn't

You could argue Frank treated the future and league status with little respect. Saying one thing in interviews, well certainly in public so we assume in interviews, then either without assessing the squad or assessing it very badly, decides it's full steam ahead with 3 at the back. It didn't sound like he shelved it either.

Whatever anyone hears, thinks, believes, we weren't a good match. I said that when he joined and I still think it. He has serious shortcomings, more than we can absorb, and it's very obvious to me he was putting himself on a fast track to a top 5 job. Think about it. He was considered for jobs like Liverpool before inter where he's probably convinced himself with the help of the media that none of that was any of his responsibility.

When there were points to be had he didn't respect them, then when it was tough with injuries and fixtures etc we wished he had. Whether he does or not or would just only reluctantly change short term to save his job, well.... That side of him is very Pardew.

 


COYP

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 12 Sep 17 3.28pm

Originally posted by est1905

All of your points are based on your own opinion (which is fine) and gossip (which is not) but none of which is fact.
We were not nailed on to be relegated under FdB. The game against Burnley actually suggests the tide is (or was) about to turn in our favour.
Talk of him upsetting the regime/players is just that, talk. The performance Sunday 100% proves that at least the players on the pitch were playing for him. On your final point, in 4 matches time I think most of us would have been breathing a sigh of relief that we didn't sack him as I truly believe it would have started to come good.
The bloke has been treated unforgivably badly. This will do us harm in the future when recruiting a manager that isn't in his 70s and has a choice of other clubs and is talented. Would you want to take a job with someone that may sack you 4 games in? I know I wouldn't

If I took job and was really cr@p at from day one and made things worse than they were by just because I thought I knew better than everyone else I would expect the sack.
Indeed I would have sacked someone who did that , and Frank would have qualified for the sack for gross incompetence just for for his approach and team selection for the Huddersfield game.
My opinion at least is based on the hard facts and results of what we saw while he was in charge at Crystal Palace. It is not based on fantasy or hope that we would get better based on a game we lost to bang average relegation rival Burnley. We dominated because they had gone ahead early , they were content with that , sat back and we had to go at them , a better side would have come at us more or hit us harder on the break. If Burnley had not gone ahead so early you might well have seen a different type of game.
The gossip is just that gossip as you say but I was adding that as lots of people suggesting it might a clash etc, and some of them claim to be ITK, but whatever even just based on the football he had to go.
In the real world by the way there are probation periods so that the people who manage to get through the selection process by an invented CV and or a B&B interview who get get found out on the job can be removed quickly and easily. This seems to have happened to Frank , unfortunately I do not suppose we had Frank on probation and he will get compo for his b@lls*** so do not feel sorry for him he has made a tidy sum out of us.


 

TheExpatEagle Flag 12 Sep 17 4.01pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Just sing and support the club for points. It's that simple. None of that cr&p when Sam started until we realise we're contributing to our own relegation. It's up to blocks c, d etc, the upper and the Arfur to wake up from their coma before it's too late.

I can agree with your sentiments however isn't there a danger that the powers that be will just think they can do whatever they like and the great unwashed will still come, cheer and sing like trained monkeys?

That said, what are people protesting about? Appointing FdB? Sacking FdB? Players? Parish? The bogs in the Arthur?

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 12 Sep 17 4.29pm

Originally posted by Sportyteacher

Let's just say that pantomine season has arrived early at Selhurst Park.

Oh no it hasn't

Its all typical Palace, we have to do it the hard way!

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dominic Fifield article in the guardian