You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What is it letting us down?
November 16 2026 8.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

What is it letting us down?


Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 4.06pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

We didn't have enough backup last season, we then let the only other fit striker go. Whilst we spent big on Benteke, relying on that is absolutely crazy. Our recruitment has been pretty farcical since we came up, massive expenditure on mediocre players bar one or two. Holloway called it early doors that the infrastructure wasn't there and lessons should have been learned but haven't been.
A premier league team cannot start a season with 1 fit striker, 1 injured and 1 who has never played above league 1 standard on their books and not expect to be in serious trouble. As always we left it to deadline day to try and fix the issue but as usual failed.

We are in this position because we have not moved on as a club, we have not recruited in the right areas at the right time and have relied heavily, season upon season, for a messiah to drag us out the brown stuff at the last minute. Sadly I think it has all caught up with us and when we go down, our top players will leave and the squad that is left will be championship standard, just like the one that got lucky promotion.

think your being a bit sensationalist with the relegation comments, were only 25% thru the season.

im fully aware we are in a bit of a pickle with regards to strikers but we have to see out the next few games til bentekkers is back and go from there til january, then wickhams back, and another will be brought.

its very easy to point fingers here there & everywhere but without stability on the manager front we cant move forward, we had that with pards, but now weve gotta wait until the next manager at least for that to happen again, or at least untill he gets hounded out.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 17 4.14pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

think your being a bit sensationalist with the relegation comments, were only 25% thru the season.

im fully aware we are in a bit of a pickle with regards to strikers but we have to see out the next few games til bentekkers is back and go from there til january, then wickhams back, and another will be brought.

its very easy to point fingers here there & everywhere but without stability on the manager front we cant move forward, we had that with pards, but now weve gotta wait until the next manager at least for that to happen again, or at least untill he gets hounded out.

It's more the change in style of new manager and actually Pardew changing style as well without being prepared. If we kept with a similar style with Dyche or even just a manager with prem experience we wouldn't have fvcked up the summer, because the manager with promises coming wouldn't have let it happen.

You can also smooth over the changing of managers with a decent recruitment set up but we don't have that so making as much in your favour manager wise is what we should've done but did the opposite. Jordan called this and was ridiculed by most fans on here and now look.

 


COYP

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 22 Oct 17 4.43pm

Reaching the FA cup final has been our downfall and not getting rid of Pardew sooner. We're all guilty of thinking we were better than we really are. The American investment hasn't helped as to accommodate them the other three have had to reduce their investment, given Parish complete control. Just seems that when there was 4 there was a plan and focus. Now there is crisis and short sightedness. I hope we have another few years in the top flight and become established as Stoke have done. We all know what we need player wise and we need it at the beginning of the window sadly our chairman will probably dither til the end.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 22 Oct 17 4.56pm

The chairman's involvement

Originally posted by Reknaw

Just what is it that keeps letting us down, every season?

We’ve got a fantastic squad, great set of players, fantastic fans, well respected manager with a great history and career.

Year after year pundits say ‘they won’t go down their squad is too good’. Yet year after year, we end up in a mess one way or another.

Yes for the past 3 years we’ve somehow managed to survive, but pundits are correct, we should not be anywhere near relegation with a squad like ours.

I just can not put my finger on what it is that is causing us to become in a mess each season one way or another. Please, please discuss and shed some light on this for me.

 


This was once a quality forum....

cpj Flag Kent 22 Oct 17 4.58pm

We are now on the same points total after 9 games as we were on in our first season up. But at this stage we sacked Holloway. So we can still get out of this.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 22 Oct 17 5.02pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

think your being a bit sensationalist with the relegation comments, were only 25% thru the season.

im fully aware we are in a bit of a pickle with regards to strikers but we have to see out the next few games til bentekkers is back and go from there til january, then wickhams back, and another will be brought.

its very easy to point fingers here there & everywhere but without stability on the manager front we cant move forward, we had that with pards, but now weve gotta wait until the next manager at least for that to happen again, or at least untill he gets hounded out.

Since 01 Jan 16 we have played 66 premier league games. Won 15, drawn 10 and lost 41. We now have 29 games to go and realistically need another 31 points and based on our form over those 66 games we're likely to pick up 7 wins and 4 draws losing the rest. That gives us a points total of 28.

Our last 2 seasons we had (15/16) 15 points, (16/17) 11 points at the same stage, we now have 3. We have been going backwards for 18 months through poor decisions and not learning from them. Call me sensationalist but this has been coming and this summer could have stopped the rot had it been planned correctly but it wasn't.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Oct 17 5.06pm

It will take a monumental effort and a lot of breaks from Lady Luck to stay up now.

The Chelsea result shows what is possible when you have both in tandem, but you can't always rely on being lucky.

A point yesterday would have been another building block on the long road to recovery but once again a result was beyond us.

What has let us down is the infrastructure of the club. We still look like a newly promoted team even in our 5th consecutive season.

It's a shame, because after 51 seasons, I would like to have seen Palace look comfortable at the top level. But it's hardly a shock that once again we have as a club shot ourselves in the foot.

If relegation becomes a reality, then I'm not sure where that leaves the current ownership. So I wouldn't be surprised if the club is in new hands next summer. And I think Parish will be a casualty in any new arrangement - and frankly I don't think that would necessarily be a bad thing.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 5.11pm

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Reaching the FA cup final has been our downfall and not getting rid of Pardew sooner. We're all guilty of thinking we were better than we really are. The American investment hasn't helped as to accommodate them the other three have had to reduce their investment, given Parish complete control. Just seems that when there was 4 there was a plan and focus. Now there is crisis and short sightedness. I hope we have another few years in the top flight and become established as Stoke have done. We all know what we need player wise and we need it at the beginning of the window sadly our chairman will probably dither til the end.

its not all down to pardew, how about the fact he was backed with just £10m net spend after keeping us up 2 years on the trot & making the cup final.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


est1905 Flag 22 Oct 17 5.29pm

Originally posted by cpj

We are now on the same points total after 9 games as we were on in our first season up. But at this stage we sacked Holloway. So we can still get out of this.

If you look at the Premiership table year on year after 9 games the team that occupies bottom position is only still in that position a handful of times. a few are still in the bottom 3 come the end but believe it or not most of the time that club finishes well outside the bottom 3.
Derby County are one of the very very few that started at the bottom and never left.
If we win Saturday and other results go our way we'll be 2 points from safety (ok 3 because of GD) with 28 games to go!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Oct 17 5.34pm

There is a simple answer to this question.
We have not strengthened the squad to the level required.

The board are completely to blame, particularly this season. Given our Summer dealings, this season's collapse was entirely predictable.
The only surprise is that we have stayed up this long.

 

The Dolphin Flag 22 Oct 17 5.43pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

think your being a bit sensationalist with the relegation comments, were only 25% thru the season.

im fully aware we are in a bit of a pickle with regards to strikers but we have to see out the next few games til bentekkers is back and go from there til january, then wickhams back, and another will be brought.

its very easy to point fingers here there & everywhere but without stability on the manager front we cant move forward, we had that with pards, but now weve gotta wait until the next manager at least for that to happen again, or at least untill he gets hounded out.

Well 3 points in 25% of the season equates to 12 for the whole season!!
Whilst we by no means relegated yet it is going to take a minor miracle to keep us up.
We have no fit forwards but 7 fit centre halves - says it all really!!!

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 22 Oct 17 5.45pm

Cabaye,Wickham, Tompkins, Mutch , Benteke, Townsend, 80 million give or take. SOLD Jedi , Bolassie , Gayle, and Murray. 40 odd million. Net spend is a lot more than 10 million.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 17 6.18pm

Originally posted by CPFC1965

Cabaye,Wickham, Tompkins, Mutch , Benteke, Townsend, 80 million give or take. SOLD Jedi , Bolassie , Gayle, and Murray. 40 odd million. Net spend is a lot more than 10 million.

The summer he was talking about after the cup final we did only spend £10 mil. Pardew and Parish are responsible for that as no respectable manager success wise would accept that.

That was with the intention of changing style. Hang on we've done pretty much the same because Parish thinks there's always an escape option but without a striker it's close to hopeless. Benteke will have to regain some form when he does return.

 


COYP

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 6.32pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The summer he was talking about after the cup final we did only spend £10 mil. Pardew and Parish are responsible for that as no respectable manager success wise would accept that.

That was with the intention of changing style. Hang on we've done pretty much the same because Parish thinks there's always an escape option but without a striker it's close to hopeless. Benteke will have to regain some form when he does return.

rudi...tell ne if you see this differently to me but can you imagine pardew was happy with a £10m net spend, im sure if he was offered £50m he wouldav spent it, obviously £40 was spent the jan after pardew left but that was probably more sam wouldnt have come if he was promised the cash to spend. whereas (i assume) pardew & sp has a muchbetter working relationship so he accepted those figures.

the change in style was a bold move that worked for 6 weeks then papa smurf getting joe mangled in a car accident screwed the balance of the team, we can point fingers in every direction saying the problem lies here, here & here i strongly beleive that f***ed us, balance wise, much like wilf being out f***s us balance wise.

so yes, we shouldav signed a left back last summer, we should have signed a striker this summer but we didnt & we are where we are.

last summer if you had asked 100 fans what would they like, bentekkers or a lesser striker and a reserve left back i recon 85/100 wouldav said bentekkers, papes solid. its f***s luck i suppose

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 17 6.41pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

rudi...tell ne if you see this differently to me but can you imagine pardew was happy with a £10m net spend, im sure if he was offered £50m he wouldav spent it, obviously £40 was spent the jan after pardew left but that was probably more sam wouldnt have come if he was promised the cash to spend. whereas (i assume) pardew & sp has a muchbetter working relationship so he accepted those figures.

the change in style was a bold move that worked for 6 weeks then papa smurf getting joe mangled in a car accident screwed the balance of the team, we can point fingers in every direction saying the problem lies here, here & here i strongly beleive that f***ed us, balance wise, much like wilf being out f***s us balance wise.

so yes, we shouldav signed a left back last summer, we should have signed a striker this summer but we didnt & we are where we are.

last summer if you had asked 100 fans what would they like, bentekkers or a lesser striker and a reserve left back i recon 85/100 wouldav said bentekkers, papes solid. its f***s luck i suppose

What? A healthy business relationship is not one based on acquiescence. If you know you need a mini you 2 left backs and more than 6 defenders then you say so and actually if Parish knew anything about football he would as well.

Parish liked the £10'mil net spend so I don't know where you see this left back or cheaper striker choice. We spent more than the inevitable in January. If we'd just done it in the 1st place we would've spent the average net spend the same as everywhere else.

Same sh1t this summer, but worse with more fvcking about with the players out of position in a formation that wouldn't work.

It's far from luck. It's poor planning and decision making, not once, but twice. If I was looking in from the outside I'd say we deserve to go down.

 


COYP

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 7.12pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

What? A healthy business relationship is not one based on acquiescence. If you know you need a mini you 2 left backs and more than 6 defenders then you say so and actually if Parish knew anything about football he would as well.

Parish liked the £10'mil net spend so I don't know where you see this left back or cheaper striker choice. We spent more than the inevitable in January. If we'd just done it in the 1st place we would've spent the average net spend the same as everywhere else.

Same sh1t this summer, but worse with more fvcking about with the players out of position in a formation that wouldn't work.

It's far from luck. It's poor planning and decision making, not once, but twice. If I was looking in from the outside I'd say we deserve to go down.

ok rudi...last summer if i has offered you schlupp as reserve LB & shane long( for example) or bentekkers who would you have chosen?

on paper last summer looked decent (from the outside) sell yannick & gayle buy tomkins/townsend/bentekkers looks acceptable but in reality even if it cost £50m we could get a proper yannick replacement to join little old palace.

also i dont agree SP has little football knowledge, its just he has the unfortunate job of ruling head over heart to stop a multi-million pound buisness from going into administration again, only for us fans to bitch & moan he hasnt spent enough, and even then people moan he takes a relativly modest £650k p/a salary for the pleasure, which to put into context is only roughly 20% of what bakary sakho earns for being overweight & producing f*** all for the cause!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Oct 17 7.29pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

ok rudi...last summer if i has offered you schlupp as reserve LB & shane long( for example) or bentekkers who would you have chosen?

on paper last summer looked decent (from the outside) sell yannick & gayle buy tomkins/townsend/bentekkers looks acceptable but in reality even if it cost £50m we could get a proper yannick replacement to join little old palace.

also i dont agree SP has little football knowledge, its just he has the unfortunate job of ruling head over heart to stop a multi-million pound buisness from going into administration again, only for us fans to bitch & moan he hasnt spent enough, and even then people moan he takes a relativly modest £650k p/a salary for the pleasure, which to put into context is only roughly 20% of what bakary sakho earns for being overweight & producing f*** all for the cause!

Do you not understand we had the money for Benteke and all those players we bought plus a left back after selling Bolasie, or are you on the default setting of defend Parish, the same as hol radio? Evidence is we had to buy 2 in January whereas if we did it to begin with we could've signed 1, and for less. That would've given us more to spend this summer.

I don't know why I'm bothering. You'd defend us needing to get a point at Burton next season with Parish as manager and best mate of half the players.

 


COYP

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 22 Oct 17 7.47pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Do you not understand we had the money for Benteke and all those players we bought plus a left back after selling Bolasie, or are you on the default setting of defend Parish, the same as hol radio? Evidence is we had to buy 2 in January whereas if we did it to begin with we could've signed 1, and for less. That would've given us more to spend this summer.

I don't know why I'm bothering. You'd defend us needing to get a point at Burton next season with Parish as manager and best mate of half the players.

you are correct, i will defend players & the club, maybe thats because i am realistic in my expectations, as the great homer simpson once said “aim low, acheive your goals, avoid dissapointment”

but did we have money for all the players you say after selling yannick? as havnt the club actually made a loss over the past few years, and actually borrowed from the next years PL cash cow money (risky buisness) just to keep up with the jones’ in transfer window with (i assume) the losses being made up by the owners.

also rudi we defo did not have to sign both schlupp & PVA in january we could have easily signed 1 of them and stayed up!

im not on any HOL radio agenda i just say things as i see them, but ive said every season all i want is for us to stay up on goal difference and would be over the moon with that, i think your older than me, im 35 so all ive ever known is midtable 2nd tier football with the odd flirtation with the big boys, thats why i dont expect the world, and would accept the bare minimum...im suprised you expect more than that given youve experienced curtis flemming/james scowcroft/andy morrison/tony craig/andy linaghan/frazier digby to name a few...f*** i forgot jamie pollock!

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Oct 17 8.20pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

you are correct, i will defend players & the club, maybe thats because i am realistic in my expectations, as the great homer simpson once said “aim low, acheive your goals, avoid dissapointment”

but did we have money for all the players you say after selling yannick? as havnt the club actually made a loss over the past few years, and actually borrowed from the next years PL cash cow money (risky buisness) just to keep up with the jones’ in transfer window with (i assume) the losses being made up by the owners.

also rudi we defo did not have to sign both schlupp & PVA in january we could have easily signed 1 of them and stayed up!

im not on any HOL radio agenda i just say things as i see them, but ive said every season all i want is for us to stay up on goal difference and would be over the moon with that, i think your older than me, im 35 so all ive ever known is midtable 2nd tier football with the odd flirtation with the big boys, thats why i dont expect the world, and would accept the bare minimum...im suprised you expect more than that given youve experienced curtis flemming/james scowcroft/andy morrison/tony craig/andy linaghan/frazier digby to name a few...f*** i forgot jamie pollock!

Hey - Curtis is a good lad.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 22 Oct 17 8.29pm

I really believe it is a lack of stability that is at the root of the problem. Pardew’s tenure was the only remotely stable time we’ve had and his entire managerial career has been characterized by huge fluctuations in form. The tipping point, which I fear we may not recover from, was appointing FDB. The man came across as an idiot, and the Huddersfield game was, I think, our poorest performance since promotion. Regardless of the man’s managerial skills, it is obvious to anyone with half a clue that our team is not capable of playing ‘total football’.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Page 3 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > What is it letting us down?