This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Lyons550
I think that the ONLY tinkering of taxes that needs to be done in order to make a far great magnitude of difference to the economy is to ensure that business can't evade/avoid it....but this needs to be on an international level, as otherwise only Turkey's voting for Xmas would take it on! OECD already doing this. Companies being fined for not paying taxes and not paying fines. Problem is no one will then stand up to them and say, OK you're no longer allowed to trade here.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
OECD already doing this. Companies being fined for not paying taxes and not paying fines. Problem is no one will then stand up to them and say, OK you're no longer allowed to trade here. I read that the EU are fed up with tax evasion by companies and are considering taxing on turnover not profit. That would put the cat among the pigeons.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I think you are a Labour Party drone who spends most of his life trying to bad mouth the Tories. A very poor response, the O.P.tried to Initiate a debate and you chose to be rude,if you have nothing to contribute -don't bother replying.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
That's where we differ, I think. I like the lower end being tax free, that's fair enough to keep people from poverty and afford a decent standard of living, but to levy higher taxes on greater earnings makes little to no sense to me. It seems like a "you don't need it" approach, which may well be true but is fundamentally not fair. If I choose to work loads of overtime, and the bloke next to me doesn't, why should I take home 60% of my wage while he takes home 80% (for exactly the same work done to the same standard) because I've passed some arbitrary threshold? I may be thrashing myself to save for a deposit on a house, to put a kid through university, or to buy a new kidney for great auntie Doris.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I read that the EU are fed up with tax evasion by companies and are considering taxing on turnover not profit. That would put the cat among the pigeons.
Wow! If true that would be both radical and daft! No startups would ever get going - lots of them make big losses in the early years, on what may be decent turnovers, also depending on the business area, they may be working on low profit margins. I think the mega-businesses need to be targetted where they are quite clearly taking the p**s, but I don't have the first idea how to do that. Making your tax bill expensive in country A may well make the company not wish to do business there at all (may not, in itself, be a bad thing - maybe more competition on the high street).
|
|
|
Originally posted by beak
A very poor response, the O.P.tried to Initiate a debate and you chose to be rude,if you have nothing to contribute -don't bother replying.
|
|
|
Originally posted by tome
Couldn't the government compel landlords to retain or accept equal offers regardless of benefit status? I am divided on the idea of giving the cash straight to landlords, doesn't seem likely to engender positive behaviour by either landlords or tenants. Speaking as a landlord myself not ALL landlords are shysters...just as not all benefit claimants are. For me having the money go straight into my account is beneficial for both my tennants and myself, it saves chasing for/and the chance for there to be any missed payments and it aids a good relationship between the two.
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
OECD already doing this. Companies being fined for not paying taxes and not paying fines. Problem is no one will then stand up to them and say, OK you're no longer allowed to trade here. Clearly that's the 'Turkeys voting for xmas' bit of my stance....completely agree
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World |
|
|
Originally posted by npn
Wow! If true that would be both radical and daft! No startups would ever get going - lots of them make big losses in the early years, on what may be decent turnovers, also depending on the business area, they may be working on low profit margins. I think the mega-businesses need to be targetted where they are quite clearly taking the p**s, but I don't have the first idea how to do that. Making your tax bill expensive in country A may well make the company not wish to do business there at all (may not, in itself, be a bad thing - maybe more competition on the high street). Isn't it that you can hide profits but not turnover? Obviously its more complex, but that's the basis.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
I read that the EU are fed up with tax evasion by companies and are considering taxing on turnover not profit. That would put the cat among the pigeons.
That would be mental. Companies legitimately makes losses, so taxing loss making companies could put them out of business, when they might otherwise be able to turn it around.
|
|
|
Originally posted by npn
That's where we differ, I think. I like the lower end being tax free, that's fair enough to keep people from poverty and afford a decent standard of living, but to levy higher taxes on greater earnings makes little to no sense to me. It seems like a "you don't need it" approach, which may well be true but is fundamentally not fair. If I choose to work loads of overtime, and the bloke next to me doesn't, why should I take home 60% of my wage while he takes home 80% (for exactly the same work done to the same standard) because I've passed some arbitrary threshold? I may be thrashing myself to save for a deposit on a house, to put a kid through university, or to buy a new kidney for great auntie Doris.
The system is that only amounts above a threshold are taxed at the higher rate, so everything you make up to that amount is taxed at exactly the same rate as those earning below that amount. Tax isn't a punishment, it's a system whereby we pay in according to our means into a social system that provides us with public services, social security, social care and education. Paying appropriate amounts mean that society as a whole can function and that has a wide reaching benefit to everyone, including the highest earners. Don't forget that 20% tax on £20k means disposable income of £16k, which after housing costs will be almost nothing. 20% tax on £200k would mean disposable income of £160k which, after housing costs is really quite a lot. Taxing that person an additional 10% on the top £100k of their earners say, would still leave them with £150k. Still close enough to 10x what the other bloke has. As a proportion of disposable income tax is a much bigger burden on the lowest earners. Even if housing cost the rich bloke £60k he'd then have £100k and tax would be 40% of that. The poor guy who would be left with, say £4k, his tax is 100% of his disposable income. For some people it will in reality be way over 100%.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
Isn't it that you can hide profits but not turnover? Obviously its more complex, but that's the basis.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
That would be mental. Companies legitimately makes losses, so taxing loss making companies could put them out of business, when they might otherwise be able to turn it around.
You cannot do this with turnover as you know where the turnover is made for example Germany etc. I think after all legal processes are exhausted said companies just still don't pay up. The idea is an 'equalisation tax' sitting on top of corporation tax so a corporation tax liability would already be established.
|
|
|
Originally posted by steeleye20
You cannot do this with turnover as you know where the turnover is made for example Germany etc. I think after all legal processes are exhausted said companies just still don't pay up. The idea is an 'equalisation tax' sitting on top of corporation tax so a corporation tax liability would already be established.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
not earning more base, just doing more overtime (so voluntary). So where is my incentive to come in on Saturday for £120 when Johnny next to me is coming in for £160?
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
The system is that only amounts above a threshold are taxed at the higher rate, so everything you make up to that amount is taxed at exactly the same rate as those earning below that amount. I know, but once you breach that threshold, everything you earn is taxed heavier than someone else doing precisely the same job
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Tax isn't a punishment, it's a system whereby we pay in according to our means into a social system that provides us with public services, social security, social care and education. Paying appropriate amounts mean that society as a whole can function and that has a wide reaching benefit to everyone, including the highest earners. I agree, we just differ on our definition of an appropriate amount. I think a flat rate is appropriate, and completely fair (whether a chairman of the board or the toilet cleaner, x% of your salary goes to run the country). I'm never going to earn as much as Richard Branson, I accept that, but I see no reason why he should be giving up 60% of everything he makes where I am giving up 40%.
|
|
|
Originally posted by npn
not earning more base, just doing more overtime (so voluntary). So where is my incentive to come in on Saturday for £120 when Johnny next to me is coming in for £160? Because Johnny might be a better worker or indeed negotiator of his salary
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Don't forget that 20% tax on £20k means disposable income of £16k, which after housing costs will be almost nothing. 20% tax on £200k would mean disposable income of £160k which, after housing costs is really quite a lot. You seem to be aiming at some sort of zero sum game where both people end up with similar levels of take home pay regardless. If I get promoted it will involve stress and more hours - in return I want more money. I don't want to then be told "now we're taking a larger chunk of that cash because you have more disposable income than the other guy" - now THAT would be unfair
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.