This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by se25 rudy
This post has been merged from a topic called 'rlc' by Midlands Eagle I think I have to agree - if anyone can pinpoint a game in which he's been the most influential player on the pitch then they have a better memory than me, I realise he's had injury problems and i really do like him as a player but he's not persuaded me that he's the 'Rolls Royce' the media keeps describing him as. Whether or not we try to sign him is another matter - surely the crucial point would be the price. I can't see Chelsea selling him for under £30M and (as much as he's shown glimpses of excellence) I'd be far happier to take him on loan for another season rather splurge a huge chunk of the Summer of budget on a player who has - on reflection - failed to convince.
I have to agree. In his defense Roy has played him in positions where I believe he is less effective. Anyway I think the money Chelsea would demand would probably kill any deal.
"Billy Gilbert really is God" |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
He played for 90 minutes, against the World cup winners and a perennially outstanding team. Why would anyone not give that the credence it deserves? International games, friendly or otherwise, can only discredited by playing against lesser opponents, not the benchmark sides like Germany, Brazil etc. As far as I'm aware we have no idea what Chelsea expect to demand, but that wasn't the question you asked. He is an excellent player and he'll only improve IMO. And toto scillachi who played in Italia 90 was the best striker in that World Cup and couldn’t stop scoring and yet was s*** before and after. Loftus could prove in time to be the dogs bollox but as of now he hasn’t impressed me much at all. HOWEVER the potential is admittedly there and if we can afford we should consider But I’d prefer shakiri tbf Edited by matthau (27 Apr 2018 11.58pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
And toto scillachi who played in Italia 90 was the best striker in that World Cup and couldn’t stop scoring and yet was s*** before and after. Loftus could prove in time to be the dogs bollox but as of now he hasn’t impressed me much at all. HOWEVER the potential is admittedly there and if we can afford we should consider But I’d prefer shakiri tbf Edited by matthau (27 Apr 2018 11.58pm) "f*** Schillaci!" Niche film reference if you aren't familiar. Edited by Stuk (28 Apr 2018 12.05am)
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Well I'm not really getting the big fuss over RLC Agreed that where he is being played at the moment maybe doesn't play to his strengths. And perhaps that's why I think he flatters to deceive - I don't think his end product is all that. Obviously that will improve with experience, but at the moment I think we are in greater need of a more rounded player at Prem level. I also don't think he has a great 'engine ' - without the ball he doesn't contribute as much as he could. He seems to be too top heavy physically. He may be taking one for the team at the moment and playing out of position and clearly Roy thinks he's the best man for that job. Anyway, I fully expect to be slated for my opinion, bring it on...
Some people will say he is still young which is true but at his age he should be better English talent is so far behind at this age look at the foreign players they have so much more about them I think the next 3 years will show if he will succeed or just another one of those over hyped English talents if he does get picked for England squad that is a complete joke he doesn't deserve the call up spending most time out injured.
|
|
|
Originally posted by FairweatherEagle
(I suggested Joe Allen but got shot down) It's not a bad shout actually. He is industrious, chips in with as many goals/assists as either Cabaye or Macca,(both of whom could be leaving as free agents) very durable (which would be a nice change) only just turned 28. Currently signed till 2021 on around 30 per so I expect Stoke will be looking for decent fee. He cost them 13 million so anything North of that probably a stumbling block
|
|
|
Originally posted by se25 rudy
This post has been merged from a topic called 'rlc' by Midlands Eagle I think I have to agree - if anyone can pinpoint a game in which he's been the most influential player on the pitch then they have a better memory than me, I realise he's had injury problems and i really do like him as a player but he's not persuaded me that he's the 'Rolls Royce' the media keeps describing him as. Whether or not we try to sign him is another matter - surely the crucial point would be the price. I can't see Chelsea selling him for under £30M and (as much as he's shown glimpses of excellence) I'd be far happier to take him on loan for another season rather splurge a huge chunk of the Summer of budget on a player who has - on reflection - failed to convince.
Failed to convince, those 3 words sum up his season in a nutshell,
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
And toto scillachi who played in Italia 90 was the best striker in that World Cup and couldn’t stop scoring and yet was s*** before and after. Loftus could prove in time to be the dogs bollox but as of now he hasn’t impressed me much at all. HOWEVER the potential is admittedly there and if we can afford we should consider But I’d prefer shakiri tbf Edited by matthau (27 Apr 2018 11.58pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by se25 rudy
This post has been merged from a topic called 'rlc' by Midlands Eagle I think I have to agree - if anyone can pinpoint a game in which he's been the most influential player on the pitch then they have a better memory than me, I realise he's had injury problems and i really do like him as a player but he's not persuaded me that he's the 'Rolls Royce' the media keeps describing him as. Whether or not we try to sign him is another matter - surely the crucial point would be the price. I can't see Chelsea selling him for under £30M and (as much as he's shown glimpses of excellence) I'd be far happier to take him on loan for another season rather splurge a huge chunk of the Summer of budget on a player who has - on reflection - failed to convince.
There is no chance, absolutely no chance, that we sign this player. When we have made big name signings it has been down to special circumstances. Benteke’s stock was low. Sakho is suicidal with his passing at times AND people seem to forget he had a massive fall out with Klopp. Cabaye wanted to hook up with Pardew and be a big fish in a small pond again. RLC will be in high demand as he is going to the World Cup. We don’t have a chance. What we need to do is sign a player who brings what he brings, as he was absolutely first class today.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
The semi final v Germany may well never be surpassed for my generation (I was early 20's) as the most important game England ever played. I've watched the game so many times and the reason they did so well was that they were a team. The manager had a lot to do with that.
Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978 |
|
|
Originally posted by Casual
Yeah fair enough Was the best World Cup wasn’t it? Nothing in the National game has matched that since, sadly. I feel sorry for today’s youth. That was a time when watching England meant as much as watching palace. Well, nearly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
There is no chance, absolutely no chance, that we sign this player. When we have made big name signings it has been down to special circumstances. Benteke’s stock was low. Sakho is suicidal with his passing at times AND people seem to forget he had a massive fall out with Klopp. Cabaye wanted to hook up with Pardew and be a big fish in a small pond again. RLC will be in high demand as he is going to the World Cup. We don’t have a chance. What we need to do is sign a player who brings what he brings, as he was absolutely first class today.
Highly doubtful I agree, but there’s always a chance
|
|
|
He's an excellent player, as I said before today's great performance.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by General
After today's performance how anyone can doubt RLC wouldn't be an enormous talent and massively important if we could manage to sign him I do not know. He's a dream to watch. Must be a dream to play with too. Intelligent. Creative. Powerful. Stamina. Positional play is superb. I'd rather we spent £25 mill on him than a striker. He'd be in or around 10/15 goals and assists a season easy playing as much as zaha or Townsend. He frees up zaha to be the difference in a match so often it's great to see someone know he can assist the.l currently better and form player. Please sing his name more and you never know he may make up his mind on it and tell Chelsea he wants to go. I think that this is of high importance If we are to press on in establishing ourselves as a force in the top division. Wether or not we take RLC or another player who can free up space / time for Wilf and others. I see the passing range of RLC akin to Hoddle in his heyday or Sigurdson today. He turns like a Matador and controls the ball like Zidane, and yet with this high regard it is true that his school report should read “could do better.” Would love to sign him, but it would be more likely should Chelsea sign a Galatico in his position. If someone could just confirm what that position is...
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.