You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cup Tie on TV/ VAR Technology going to be tried
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Cup Tie on TV/ VAR Technology going to be tried


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
adrian b Flag Landrindod, Wales 07 Dec 17 9.13pm

Originally posted by Stuk

You can't conduct a test in a competition where you are effectively asking just 2 teams to operate to a different set of rules to everyone else. You either have VAR in every game of that round, or none of them.

And they've still chosen a high profile game, featuring two PL teams, particularly due to the piss poor way the last league tie was handled.

All gamers are played under different circumstances.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 07 Dec 17 11.15pm

Maybe they will use VAR outside the ground as well to assist Sussex Police before kick off to organise their pre-match tactics.
Also to make sure they can sift and corroborate properly all their officers reports before accusing Palace supporters of bringing knives knuckle dusters and other weapons without any shred of any evidence!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Dec 17 1.15pm

Its time to wheel all of the really good refs out of retirement as fourth officials. They won't need to run round a pitch any more however their experience would be invaluable in that seated role. (Note that I said really good refs like Collina, so I don't include Clattenburg in that list).

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 1.17pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Its time to wheel all of the really good refs out of retirement as fourth officials. They won't need to run round a pitch any more however their experience would be invaluable in that seated role. (Note that I said really good refs like Collina, so I don't include Clattenburg in that list).

Both Collina and Clattenburg are much better than "Really good" but let's not get into that debate now.

 

europalace Flag Europe 08 Dec 17 1.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

VAR was in place for the England v Germany friendly recently but wasn't used at all.

People have to get away from believing that VAR is a panacea - there will still be cases where 'Fact' doesn't come into it (Like ball over/not over the line) and subjective decisions are made.

Sure but it will resolve 99.9% of the decisions we see today that are incorrect. Therefore, we get a much, much fairer game. Nothing is 100% but since we've had goal line technology the fairness has improved massively. The more technology the better IMO.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Dec 17 1.19pm

Originally posted by Willo

Both Collina and Clattenburg are much better than "Really good" but let's not get into that debate now.


It would be nice if you commented on my suggestion rather than just your overprotective view of a self proclaimed cheat

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 1.23pm

Originally posted by europalace

Sure but it will resolve 99.9% of the decisions we see today that are incorrect. Therefore, we get a much, much fairer game. Nothing is 100% but since we've had goal line technology the fairness has improved massively. The more technology the better IMO.

The parameters for VAR have been laid down eg Whether a goal should stand,penalty decisions, red cards etc etc, so they don't cover each and every incident and scenario.

At the end of the day it will be down to interpretations of referees and subjective decisions but I look forward to seeing how it works.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 1.27pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops


It would be nice if you commented on my suggestion rather than just your overprotective view of a self proclaimed cheat

I'm not getting into any Clattenburg debate because as sure as night follows day it will end up in vitriol amidst yet another Willo thread.In the interests of HOL I will refrain from commenting on the barbs aimed in the direction of a certain referee much as I would like to offer a riposte.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Dec 17 1.35pm

Originally posted by Willo

I'm not getting into any Clattenburg debate because as sure as night follows day it will end up in vitriol amidst yet another Willo thread.In the interests of HOL I will refrain from commenting on the barbs aimed in the direction of a certain referee much as I would like to offer a riposte.

Are you sure you are not an MP, you never answer the question. I do not want you to talk about Clattenburg, but you have now posted yet again about the idiot.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 1.42pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Are you sure you are not an MP, you never answer the question. I do not want you to talk about Clattenburg, but you have now posted yet again about the idiot.

You brought Clattenburg into the debate hence my retort.
Let's NOT turn this into a Willo/Clattenburg thread please.
Let's get back to VAR.Thanks

Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 1.43pm)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Dec 17 1.45pm

Originally posted by Willo

You brought Clattenburg into the debate hence my retort.
Let's NOT turn this into a Willo/Clattenburg thread please.
Lets get back to VAR.Thanks

....and again, ad nauseum. My debate was about bringing good refs out of retirement as fourth officials but you seem to have been side-tracked from that.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 1.52pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

....and again, ad nauseum. My debate was about bringing good refs out of retirement as fourth officials but you seem to have been side-tracked from that.

Eaglecoops

I was aghast at your "Under-Egging" of the qualities of Collina and Clattenburg hence my retort.

With regard to your suggestion about "Retired referees", I do feel it has value. I'm not sure if this has been the case in respect of rugby and cricket.Certainly with cricket all referrals lead to decisions based on FACT within agreed parameters so no subjective decisions which is at variance with VAR in football.


Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 1.56pm)

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 08 Dec 17 1.54pm

Originally posted by Willo

The parameters for VAR have been laid down eg Whether a goal should stand,penalty decisions, red cards etc etc, so they don't cover each and every incident and scenario.

At the end of the day it will be down to interpretations of referees and subjective decisions but I look forward to seeing how it works.

Don't we have goal line technology for that? The ref's watch buzzes, it's a goal.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 1.59pm

Originally posted by kenbarr


Don't we have goal line technology for that? The ref's watch buzzes, it's a goal.

I wasn't thinking about that.

Evidently when a goal is scored there will be a review to ascertain whether there was any infringement leading up to it which could result in it being disallowed.More subjective decisions except I suspect in the case of some clear-cut offside scenarios.


Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 2.18pm)

 

Stuk Flag Top half 08 Dec 17 2.06pm

Originally posted by adrian b

All gamers are played under different circumstances.

But not different rules, which our's will be.

 


Optimistic as ever

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 08 Dec 17 2.47pm

Originally posted by Willo

I wasn't thinking about that.

Evidently when a goal is scored there will be a review to ascertain whether there was any infringement leading up to it which could result in it being disallowed.More subjective decisions except I suspect in the case of some clear-cut offside scenarios.


Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 2.18pm)

This could be interesting on how back they go. A handball that won the ball on the half way line before the pass (the only one) that then went to the goalscorer? or the goalscorer fouls to win the ball then involved in a one-two then scores?

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 08 Dec 17 2.55pm

Originally posted by Willo

I wasn't thinking about that.

Evidently when a goal is scored there will be a review to ascertain whether there was any infringement leading up to it which could result in it being disallowed.More subjective decisions except I suspect in the case of some clear-cut offside scenarios.


Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 2.18pm)

Well that will kill the euphoria of scoring if you have to wait another 45 seconds to confirm whether it counts

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 2.59pm

Originally posted by Andy_G


Well that will kill the euphoria of scoring if you have to wait another 45 seconds to confirm whether it counts

Consider the scenario :

Ball enters net
Silence from the crowd pending review.
Message on big screen after 60 secs "GOAL - You may now celebrate".

Just a thought !

Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 3.21pm)

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 08 Dec 17 3.00pm

Originally posted by PALACE FOR EVER

This could be interesting on how back they go. A handball that won the ball on the half way line before the pass (the only one) that then went to the goalscorer? or the goalscorer fouls to win the ball then involved in a one-two then scores?

Will only be used for goals,penalties and straight red cards.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 08 Dec 17 3.02pm

Originally posted by PALACE FOR EVER

This could be interesting on how back they go. A handball that won the ball on the half way line before the pass (the only one) that then went to the goalscorer? or the goalscorer fouls to win the ball then involved in a one-two then scores?

Indeed. I am not 100% certain of the parameters set for such a scenario.
Also the wording says that VAR is to ensure that "No CLEARLY wrong decisions are made....."Need to understand what precisely this means in practical terms.
Awaiting a call-back from someone who will know.The devil lies in the detail !

Edited by Willo (08 Dec 2017 3.11pm)

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Cup Tie on TV/ VAR Technology going to be tried