This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Tactics v Arsenal
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Hutchyeagle Hove 29 Dec 17 10.17am |
|
|
Driving up to the game we all like to discuss team selection etc... The overwhelming thoughts, were that height was not too important at the back tonight (no Giroud) ...But with players such as Arsenal’s front three (raw pace) we need quick agile defenders. The decision to play Kelly (primarily for his height..back post defending etc..) was wrong. Sanchez made him look pedestrian, which meant Tomkins had to again and again cover Kelly... Just seems a decision made out of loyalty rather than picking a team for each respective team we play ....appreciate we haven’t the numbers to be too clever, but TFM was the obvious choice to inject some pace into the back four
|
bexleydave Barnehurst 29 Dec 17 10.34am |
|
Originally posted by Hutchyeagle
Driving up to the game we all like to discuss team selection etc... The overwhelming thoughts, were that height was not too important at the back tonight (no Giroud) ...But with players such as Arsenal’s front three (raw pace) we need quick agile defenders. The decision to play Kelly (primarily for his height..back post defending etc..) was wrong. Sanchez made him look pedestrian, which meant Tomkins had to again and again cover Kelly... Just seems a decision made out of loyalty rather than picking a team for each respective team we play ....appreciate we haven’t the numbers to be too clever, but TFM was the obvious choice to inject some pace into the back four
Clearly Roy doesn't agree.
Bexley Dave
Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!
"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)
|
BarEagle Monmouth 29 Dec 17 10.36am |
|
|
I think TFM will be in for Kelly now.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 29 Dec 17 10.49am |
|
|
The main error was not pressing enough, and in the case of Benteke, at all, apart from a late show of it when it was obviously started too late to actually get there and actually close down, block or tackle.
COYP
|
Elpis In a pub 29 Dec 17 10.59am |
|
|
Why point the finger at Kelly , the first goal came from a weak defensive header from Schulpp ,the second a poor clearance from Benteckers and the third because Tompkins the only player not marking anyone should have dropped ten yards as soon as Whiltshire found space in the middle of the park . The great ball he delivered could have been dealt with had we not been so flat . Sanchez would make most defenders look pedestrian Kelly included but the goals last night were not Kellys fault but others individual errors .
|
chateauferret 29 Dec 17 11.04am |
|
|
Fosu-Mensah was only just back from injury so presumably there was a judgement about his fitness - last thing we would have wanted was a relapse and another long outage.
Ward is listed on physioroom as back on 8 January.
============ The Ferret ============
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 17 11.16am |
|
Originally posted by Elpis
Why point the finger at Kelly , the first goal came from a weak defensive header from Schulpp ,the second a poor clearance from Benteckers and the third because Tompkins the only player not marking anyone should have dropped ten yards as soon as Whiltshire found space in the middle of the park . The great ball he delivered could have been dealt with had we not been so flat . Sanchez would make most defenders look pedestrian Kelly included but the goals last night were not Kellys fault but others individual errors .
I suppose some might argue that he should have been aware of Mustafi at the far post who of course scored the opening goal.Maybe this is a tad harsh, I will need to look at the TV coverage.
|
Elpis In a pub 29 Dec 17 11.26am |
|
Originally posted by Willo
I suppose some might argue that he should have been aware of Mustafi at the far post who of course scored the opening goal.Maybe this is a tad harsh, I will need to look at the TV coverage.
I'm sure he was aware of Mustafi but was also covering the space in front of him which was the danger zone , the ball in fairness could not have fallen better to the Arsenal player . It was a poor goal to concede all round from poor clearance ,the failure to stop the shot , a weak save from Jules and then Kelly being caught between covering the middle and the back stick .
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 29 Dec 17 11.30am |
|
Originally posted by Elpis
I'm sure he was aware of Mustafi but was also covering the space in front of him which was the danger zone , the ball in fairness could not have fallen better to the Arsenal player . It was a poor goal to concede all round from poor clearance ,the failure to stop the shot , a weak save from Jules and then Kelly being caught between covering the middle and the back stick .
I need to look at the TV coverage to see if Speroni could have done better.
I suppose one could argue that he did push it away from the goal but unfortunately the ball fell to Mustafi who was unmarked.
Edited by Willo (29 Dec 2017 11.31am)
|
ex hibitionist Hastings 29 Dec 17 11.37am |
|
|
the tactics v Arsenal weren't about selection - we had two different formations each half, once Zaha went back to the right wing and Cheek came off the left back to an advanced central position we were more effective. Schlupp was a different player second half - he is a real athlete and if his ability to burst through the lines and turn defence into attack could be used more regularly he could be handy for us, cos lately he's looked so poor. Wouldn't put the loss down to individual errors either - we were basically outclassed but gave it a good go. Be interesting if Roy v City tries to do what Benitez tried the other night (a formation of 10-0-0) or is more adventurous like we were second half.
|
Dangermouse Hastings 29 Dec 17 2.19pm |
|
|
Thought we stood off too much 1st half. Clearly forward pair were asked to not close down in their half and just drop into shape. We were far more effective when we got in their faces and switched Wilf wider, especially when Sako came on. Obviously people want Benteke to disobey his manager and chase down defenders in their own half. When chasing the game we had to be more proactive and that's when we closed higher up, but the team were following their managers instructions, clearly.
That's Life And as funny as it may seem Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream. KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!
|
Uphill Bedford 29 Dec 17 3.21pm |
|
|
Our tactics were not why we lost.
We had just one problem - Jack Wilshere was playing for them. Now he has calmed down and has stopped his self-injury causing tackles he will become the best English born midfield general since Glen Hoddle.
Swap Benteke for him?
|
Hrolf The Ganger 29 Dec 17 3.35pm |
|
|
I can handle Kelly playing at centre half but he cannot start at right back if there is a fit alternative.
|
EverybodyDannsNow SE19 29 Dec 17 3.55pm |
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Our tactics were not why we lost.
We had just one problem - Jack Wilshere was playing for them. Now he has calmed down and has stopped his self-injury causing tackles he will become the best English born midfield general since Glen Hoddle.
Swap Benteke for him?
Based on what? Lampard, Gerrard and Scholes we're amongst the best players in Europe by the time they were Wilshere's age - he's barely completed a full season in a near 10 year career - Wilshere would do well to achieve half of what Michael Carrick has done, never mind getting close to the three mentioned above.
He was good yesterday, but nothing special - the pass for the 3rd goal aside, I don't think he stood out at all in that Arsenal side. Sanchez and Lacazette were far far more impressive.
|
gerry theagle newbury 29 Dec 17 4.27pm |
|
|
What game were you watching, all of Arsenals midfield play was through him,found space and was always in the right place at the right time to cause us problems.
|
Ray in Houston Houston 29 Dec 17 4.37pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
I suppose some might argue that he should have been aware of Mustafi at the far post who of course scored the opening goal.Maybe this is a tad harsh, I will need to look at the TV coverage.
Kelly looked back at Mustafi before the shot/cross came in, so knew exactly where he was. Mustafi would have been offside if the ball had been crossed to him, and Kelly was holding the line with the rest of the defense. I was mad at the time, but it's clear now that Kelly was doing the right thing.
As was mentioned above, the ball could not have fallen more kindly for Mustafi, who dispatched it with calm aplomb. Just one of those things.
We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.
|
cpj Kent 29 Dec 17 5.08pm |
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
The main error was not pressing enough, and in the case of Benteke, at all, apart from a late show of it when it was obviously started too late to actually get there and actually close down, block or tackle.
^^ This. First half Zaha and Benteke didn't cross the h-w line when they had the ball. Can't give these teams the ball all the time.
|
chateauferret 29 Dec 17 7.29pm |
|
Originally posted by Ray in Houston
Kelly looked back at Mustafi before the shot/cross came in, so knew exactly where he was. Mustafi would have been offside if the ball had been crossed to him, and Kelly was holding the line with the rest of the defense. I was mad at the time, but it's clear now that Kelly was doing the right thing.
As was mentioned above, the ball could not have fallen more kindly for Mustafi, who dispatched it with calm aplomb. Just one of those things.
Indeed. We can all be correct with the benefit of slo-mo replays from different angles. Zat right, Willo?
============ The Ferret ============
|
slubglurge welling 29 Dec 17 7.59pm |
|
|
Roy is not getting the best out of RLC by playing him wide. If he continues to play 4 4 2 put him just off of Benteke and put Wilf back to the wing. RLCs defensive play is uselese so put him further forward
|
boo909 Figeac 29 Dec 17 8.56pm |
|
Originally posted by Uphill
Our tactics were not why we lost.
We had just one problem - Jack Wilshere was playing for them. Now he has calmed down and has stopped his self-injury causing tackles he will become the best English born midfield general since Glen Hoddle.
Swap Benteke for him?
We've already got one world class player that rolls around on the floor and cries whenever he's tackled, not sure I could handle another.
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|