You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf compared to Palace legends...
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Wilf compared to Palace legends...


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 03 Jan 18 1.39pm

My personal opinion is that he is up there with a few of the Palace legends right now.....Possibly top.
The fact he says he isn't going anywhere makes him more of a star...
Others in my book ... Kenny Sansom, So goood for us..The class of Lombardo ... Ian Wright (His mums place is all palace memorabilia and she wont have anything in her place)..
Ian Wrights mum.....
Brighty Solid... Billy Gilbert (I just like nutters)....
AJ... A good striker plus three against the weed..
John Jackson.. Probably the best keeper to never play England.....
Probably loads more but Wilf is definitely up there to date,,,
Who else..?

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 03 Jan 18 1.41pm

Originally posted by westquay

My personal opinion is that he is up there with a few of the Palace legends right now.....Possibly top.
The fact he says he isn't going anywhere makes him more of a star...
Others in my book ... Kenny Sansom, So goood for us..The class of Lombardo ... Ian Wright (His mums place is all palace memorabilia and she wont have anything arsenal in her place)..
Ian Wrights mum.....
Brighty Solid... Billy Gilbert (I just like nutters)....
AJ... A good striker plus three against the weed..
John Jackson.. Probably the best keeper to never play for England.....
Probably loads more but Wilf is definitely up there to date,,,
Who else..?

Edited by westquay (03 Jan 2018 1.42pm)

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 03 Jan 18 1.47pm

Originally posted by westquay

Edited by westquay (03 Jan 2018 1.42pm)

Er, Kenny Samson?

 

npn Flag Crowborough 03 Jan 18 1.47pm

Jim Cannon - solid as you like (and loyal as they come)

 

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 03 Jan 18 1.52pm

Originally posted by npn

Jim Cannon - solid as you like (and loyal as they come)

Loved big Jim Cannon.
He would have scared the s%^t out of players today...
Good call.....

Edited by westquay (03 Jan 2018 1.53pm)

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

Kant Flag exeter 03 Jan 18 2.09pm

On the basis of the following variables:
1. Skill and entertainment;
2. Impact on outcomes;
3. Loyalty to the club/affinity with the fans;
I now rate Wilf as the best we’ve produced.

In fact I’d stick my neck out and say he’s the best player to ever wear the claret/red and blue.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 03 Jan 18 2.11pm

Obviously it partly depends on the length of time you have followed Palace as to who you include in your list of legends.

Some older folk might include the likes of Johnny Byrne (just a bit before my time - just).

I often think the best time to decide where a player sits in the list of legends (and it is always going to be subjective) is after the player has departed the club when you have the whole picture.

But that's a bit boring - and yes, Wilf I am sure will sit in everyone's top 5 and for many right at the top. We have been very lucky and privileged to have been able to watch him develop into the player he now is.

 

rikz Flag Croydon 03 Jan 18 2.16pm

For me he's number 1, been with us since he was 9 I think, loves our club, would never see him kiss another clubs badge like wrighty. You can genuinely see his palace through and through.

Sansom, Wright and lombardo are at this stage better players and I know the older fans will say Jonny Byrne is our greatest player but I'm too young to judge.

With a bit of luck and the right club and manager he could go on to be more successful than any player to have played for palace.

 

becky Flag over the moon 03 Jan 18 2.25pm

Let's also not forget the likes of

Steve Kember

Nigel Martin, and

(for all the wrong reasons)

Trevor Aylott


but, yes, Wilf has to be up there with the best of them!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 03 Jan 18 2.41pm

Originally posted by rikz

For me he's number 1, been with us since he was 9 I think, loves our club, would never see him kiss another clubs badge like wrighty. You can genuinely see his palace through and through.

Sansom, Wright and lombardo are at this stage better players and I know the older fans will say Jonny Byrne is our greatest player but I'm too young to judge.

With a bit of luck and the right club and manager he could go on to be more successful than any player to have played for palace.

I agree, he could well be for us what Le Tiss was for Southampton. The centre of everything the club does for years.

He fits the mould of what everyone would say they want and like most about a Palace player - local kid, through the academy, a bit of a maverick, extremely skilful, no ego, works hard, plays with a smile on his face and genuinely feels every result like a fan does

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 03 Jan 18 2.43pm

Ambrose just for his amazing goal..?
He was ok ... Kinda liked his long range goals...
Aki ... He just loved our club....
Keepers ... 1) Martyn 2)John Jackson 3) Burridge 4) Hammond (Pulled off the best save ever at Aldershot) ....
5) Joint... Kolinko and Kiraly (Played in his PJ,s.....)
Worst keeper .... Paul baron ....
Player I hated the most... Clive (Fekkin) Allen....
Smuggy permed hair prick....

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 03 Jan 18 2.52pm

Originally posted by Kant

On the basis of the following variables:
1. Skill and entertainment;
2. Impact on outcomes;
3. Loyalty to the club/affinity with the fans;
I now rate Wilf as the best we’ve produced.

In fact I’d stick my neck out and say he’s the best player to ever wear the claret/red and blue.

I kinda wanted somebody else to say it first... So thanks mate... The man is a legend...
Manure really messed up with him...
Had Fergie been in charge the season after Wilf signed
who knows what may have happened...?
And England have probably missed the man that could (possibly) helped them win the world cup...I honestly believe that....

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

westquay Flag 58 miles from se25 03 Jan 18 3.09pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

I agree, he could well be for us what Le Tiss was for Southampton. The centre of everything the club does for years.

He fits the mould of what everyone would say they want and like most about a Palace player - local kid, through the academy, a bit of a maverick, extremely skilful, no ego, works hard, plays with a smile on his face and genuinely feels every result like a fan does

Plus.. He donates %10 of his wages,,,,, Thoroughly decent bloke.....

 


"Numb,gutted and shocked . Three words that sum up how I feel."
"Passionate,principled, genius. Three words that sum up Joe Strummer"
Martin Scorcese, Film director.

essetwentyone Flag london 03 Jan 18 4.18pm

I've seen them all from the great Johnny Byrne onwards and to my mind Wilf is up there with any of them in every aspect.

 

beak Flag croydon 03 Jan 18 4.23pm

Originally posted by westquay

My personal opinion is that he is up there with a few of the Palace legends right now.....Possibly top.
The fact he says he isn't going anywhere makes him more of a star...
Others in my book ... Kenny Sansom, So goood for us..The class of Lombardo ... Ian Wright (His mums place is all palace memorabilia and she wont have anything in her place)..
Ian Wrights mum.....
Brighty Solid... Billy Gilbert (I just like nutters)....
AJ... A good striker plus three against the weed..
John Jackson.. Probably the best keeper to never play England.....
Probably loads more but Wilf is definitely up there to date,,,
Who else..?

Jim Cannon.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 03 Jan 18 4.43pm

Terry Long, Cliff Holton and as already mentioned Johnny Byrne.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

maltaeagle 03 Jan 18 4.52pm

you got to say Vince Hilaire, surely a legend, as was Dave swindlehurst, in my eyes anyway, in fact all the team of that era were pretty much legends

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 03 Jan 18 4.57pm

Wilf is around fifth for me until he shows a bit more guile when he has goal-scoring opportunities. And I reckon Wright would have given Kyle Walker a much harder game on Sunday if he had had to mark our best ever player and legend so far. Never saw Byrne. Sansom up there obviously too in legend status and the fact he ahs that but was only with us for three full seasons shows just how superb he was. At least Ian Wright was with us for six.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 03 Jan 18 5.20pm

Originally posted by westquay

Plus.. He donates %10 of his wages,,,,, Thoroughly decent bloke.....


Sansom donated 80% of his wages- to Weatherspoons

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Aetos Flag 03 Jan 18 10.12pm

The two obvious comparisons are Don Rogers and Peter Taylor. Both goal scoring wingers, both hugely talented. Wilf's up there with them. Different eras, but Wilf may well become our greatest attacking player ever.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Wilf compared to Palace legends...