You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Line Up Without Zaha for Everton
November 16 2026 7.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace Line Up Without Zaha for Everton


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
crvenaeagle Flag 07 Feb 18 2.45pm

A few days ago I would have said "no way" and "God forbid" in regards to trying to sign that odious human being Samir Nasri, but that was before we lost both Sako and Zaha for the remainder of the season.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 07 Feb 18 4.27pm

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

A few days ago I would have said "no way" and "God forbid" in regards to trying to sign that odious human being Samir Nasri, but that was before we lost both Sako and Zaha for the remainder of the season.

Keep your eyes on Roys presser for proper news rather than the crap circulating the press the last few days before getting totally stressed out about Wilf's injury. Samir Nasri as you say is not a pleasant person but not a bad footballer. Not sure if I would like him at the club though and would prefer to see Lumeka or Lokilo given a go on the wing. They don't have to set the world alight, just concentrate when defending and get some decent crosses in when attacking.

 

Copthorne_Eagle Flag Copthorne, West Sussex 07 Feb 18 5.13pm

Hennessey

TFM----Tomkins-----Sakho----PVA

Townsend---Luka--Cabaye---CYL

----------Jimmy--------

-------------Benteke---------

Henry
Souare
Ward
Delaney
Riedwald
Rakip
Soroloth

Makes me sick/angry to still be typing Chungs name into a team sheet in our 5th season in the premier league, but we have no other options.
Could of course play Jimmy wide and pack midfield with Riedwald.
Or as has been discussed, push PVA on and use Ward/Souare at left back, think that will be too many changes for Roy though.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 07 Feb 18 5.23pm

Originally posted by Copthorne_Eagle

Hennessey

TFM----Tomkins-----Sakho----PVA

Townsend---Luka--Cabaye---CYL

----------Jimmy--------

-------------Benteke---------

Henry
Souare
Ward
Delaney
Riedwald
Rakip
Soroloth

Makes me sick/angry to still be typing Chungs name into a team sheet in our 5th season in the premier league, but we have no other options.
Could of course play Jimmy wide and pack midfield with Riedwald.
Or as has been discussed, push PVA on and use Ward/Souare at left back, think that will be too many changes for Roy though.

Why not give Sørloth a go and play McArthur left midfield? Asking a lot of him I know but needs must etc....?

 

Copthorne_Eagle Flag Copthorne, West Sussex 07 Feb 18 5.32pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Why not give Sørloth a go and play McArthur left midfield? Asking a lot of him I know but needs must etc....?

I would say purely as we need an option on the bench if we need to try and change the game. Sako is such a loss

 

Woody28 Flag Alton 07 Feb 18 6.32pm

Hi, I rarely post but always read the comments. I do think we should change formation to 4411 - very similar to the 442 formation that has been drilled into the players by Roy.

Hennessey
Ward Tomkins Sakho PVA
TFM McArthur Milivojevic Townsend
Cabaye
Benteke

Or

Hennessey
TFM Tomkins Sakho Ward
Townsend McArthur Milivojevic PVA
Cabaye
Benteke

Subs - Speroni / Henry, Kelly, Soure, Jach / Rakip, Riedewald, Lee, Sorloth

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 07 Feb 18 6.54pm

A lot of attempting to square pegs into round holes on here - not to mention going back to solutions that haven't worked previously and general panic..!!

Can't see Roy changing his starting formation - so forget the 3 at the back with wing backs scenario.

No-one seems to be mentioning/considering Rakip - he's obviously got something about him for Benfica to sign him on a 5 year deal - reports suggest that they see him as a big part of their future.

So why not;

Hennessy
TFM, Tomkins, Sakho, PVA
Milo McArthur
Townsend Cabye Rakip
Benteke

Just a thought and seems good to me.

COYP

 

Mstrobez Flag 07 Feb 18 10.23pm

Seeing as we know Roy likes 442 with more defensive wide players I'd like to see.

Hennessey

TFM - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA

Rakip - Cabaye - Milivojevic - Mccarthur

Townsend - Benteke

I know Wilf has a little dip in form (although I'd argue he just hasn't scored and has actually played well in a lot of games), and people just make it out as easy as being "oh he's playing up front" but the fact of the matter is this is system Roy plays with and we need pace in our attacking areas. One target man is enough in a team. Some of the best football we played this season was when it was Townsend and Wilf up top running at defences. We need a runner at the front of the pitch and it's just not the style of either Benteke or Sorloth. It would be like playing Wickham and Benteke off of eachother. It's a tactic that can surely only work in very particular games (Burnley at home for example).

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

merganser Flag 07 Feb 18 10.29pm

I want a starting role for Chung-Yong - most underrated player at the club.

He’s desperate to impress to boost his World Cup prospects.

Really versatile and creative player. His time has surely come.

Go, Chungy, go!

 

JtCpfc Flag 07 Feb 18 11.09pm

It's very simple in my mind

Hennessey
Fosu mensah. Tomkins. Sakho. Pva
Milivojevic. Reidewald.
Townsend. Cabaye. Mcarthur
Benteke

Subs: Henry, souare, ward, rakip, lee, lumeka/kirby, sorloth

Could even bring in Michael Phillips. Solid central player.

Yes we're low on numbers.
No I can't bring myself to put Delaney on the bench.
We're Palace... we've got this!

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 08 Feb 18 8.16am

Originally posted by merganser

I want a starting role for Chung-Yong - most underrated player at the club.

He’s desperate to impress to boost his World Cup prospects.

Really versatile and creative player. His time has surely come.

Go, Chungy, go!

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 08 Feb 18 8.19am

Originally posted by mattteo

Jach, you mean the new center back??

Oops.. I meant Rakip.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 08 Feb 18 8.19am

I've been thinking some more about it and I'm strongly of the view we should put Souare on the left wing while Wilf is out.

As well as getting deliveries from him that I think would better suit Benteke, and his defensive support, putting him on the wing seems a good way to get him fully fit.

We can probably carry him more as a winger than a left back and get him fit enough to cover at LB. At the moment, we would be in a big bind if we lost PVA. Give Souare 3/4 matches in the wing and he'll probably be ready.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 08 Feb 18 11.41am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I've been thinking some more about it and I'm strongly of the view we should put Souare on the left wing while Wilf is out.

As well as getting deliveries from him that I think would better suit Benteke, and his defensive support, putting him on the wing seems a good way to get him fully fit.

We can probably carry him more as a winger than a left back and get him fit enough to cover at LB. At the moment, we would be in a big bind if we lost PVA. Give Souare 3/4 matches in the wing and he'll probably be ready.


I wonder if he still has his pace. If not then no way can he play there. Not sure of his history either, has anyone got any details of where he has played in his career other than LB?

 

Thereandbackagain Flag Crawley 08 Feb 18 12.15pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I've been thinking some more about it and I'm strongly of the view we should put Souare on the left wing while Wilf is out.

As well as getting deliveries from him that I think would better suit Benteke, and his defensive support, putting him on the wing seems a good way to get him fully fit.

We can probably carry him more as a winger than a left back and get him fit enough to cover at LB. At the moment, we would be in a big bind if we lost PVA. Give Souare 3/4 matches in the wing and he'll probably be ready.


I would go with Souare at Left Back with PVA on the left wing giving not only cover in defense but a good outlet for attack , we are not replacing Wilf as a striker as it is a awful position for him and I don't know why Roy thinks it is good , he has his back to the goal which he doesn't like and he gets hoofed from behind like he did against West Ham ....He is a winger and that is the position that needs filling , stick PVA on the left and get him to pop crosses in to the front two .

 

fledgling Flag Beckenham 08 Feb 18 12.16pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

I wonder if he still has his pace. If not then no way can he play there. Not sure of his history either, has anyone got any details of where he has played in his career other than LB?

I don't think Roy rates Souare. I can see him putting Ward at LB and PVA on the wing.

WH
TFM JT MS JW
LM YC
AT JM PVA
CB

Playing a 451 in defence and pushing either JM or YC forward when attacking.

 

mattteo Flag 08 Feb 18 12.20pm

Originally posted by fledgling

I don't think Roy rates Souare.


I think he does. He wouldn't have named a player who's been missing for 2 years on the bench every matchday otherwise.

If Roy goes down the Pardew route with Ward/ Kelly on the left, I'm loosing all faith.

 

Sheks Crows Eye Flag Virginia 08 Feb 18 12.39pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Lineup Vs Everton' by Guntrisoft

Thought 1 driving home from work

Hennessy

Ward------Tomkins------Sakho------TFM

Cabaye------Luka

McCarthur-----Rakip-----Van Ahnholt

Benteke

Thought 2 on the throne after Chili

Hennessy

TFM-----Tomkins-----Sakho-----Van Ahnholt

McCarthur-----Cabaye-----Luka------Chungy

Benteke------Sorloth

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 08 Feb 18 12.48pm

Originally posted by mattteo


I think he does. He wouldn't have named a player who's been missing for 2 years on the bench every matchday otherwise.

If Roy goes down the Pardew route with Ward/ Kelly on the left, I'm loosing all faith.

He would if he had no other options. (cue a mega list of "other" options, with accompanying stats!)

 

mattteo Flag 08 Feb 18 1.02pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

He would if he had no other options. (cue a mega list of "other" options, with accompanying stats!)

Ok, let me be more precise. If he had in mind Ward for the left back position, he wouldn't have named both Ward (or TFM, depending on who was starting and who was back-up) and Souare on the bench on the same time. Seems like a waste of space to have someone there who you wouldn't send in no matter what. He'd have named....Mutch or someone

 

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace Line Up Without Zaha for Everton