This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Commentators
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
dreamwaverider London 17 Feb 18 10.04pm |
|
|
Just been watching WBA v Ston on BT. The commentator is a female......Robyn something. I know we are living in a mad PC world and BT probably think it is wise to put on a female for a bit of balance, but come on BT her voice and commentary is like listening to some kind of funeral march. Dull, depressing, and generally very boring. Soory Robyn, nothing personal, but give me John Motson etc any day over that. Made me realise just how good most football commentators are......and yes they are ALL male. I honestly think the female voice is lacking on many fronts to deliver on football. Call me sexist go on miss my point. Throw the pathetic PC book at me why don't ya. Hey ho sorry ladies, just my personal opinion.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 18 Feb 18 12.35pm |
|
|
i cannot comment on that female commentator. no comment.
but jeff Stelling is cool .
Gary Lineker is an embarrassment
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Feb 18 1.04pm |
|
Originally posted by PalazioVecchio
i cannot comment on that female commentator. no comment.
but jeff Stelling is cool .
Gary Lineker is an embarrassment
Certainly a font of football knowledge and a very estimable chap.
|
PZ Eagle Penzance 18 Feb 18 2.11pm |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Just been watching WBA v Ston on BT. The commentator is a female......Robyn something. I know we are living in a mad PC world and BT probably think it is wise to put on a female for a bit of balance, but come on BT her voice and commentary is like listening to some kind of funeral march. Dull, depressing, and generally very boring. Soory Robyn, nothing personal, but give me John Motson etc any day over that. Made me realise just how good most football commentators are......and yes they are ALL male. I honestly think the female voice is lacking on many fronts to deliver on football. Call me sexist go on miss my point. Throw the pathetic PC book at me why don't ya. Hey ho sorry ladies, just my personal opinion.
I had to turn the sound off in order to enjoy watching.
Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 18 Feb 18 2.31pm |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Just been watching WBA v Ston on BT. The commentator is a female......Robyn something. I know we are living in a mad PC world and BT probably think it is wise to put on a female for a bit of balance, but come on BT her voice and commentary is like listening to some kind of funeral march. Dull, depressing, and generally very boring. Soory Robyn, nothing personal, but give me John Motson etc any day over that. Made me realise just how good most football commentators are......and yes they are ALL male. I honestly think the female voice is lacking on many fronts to deliver on football. Call me sexist go on miss my point. Throw the pathetic PC book at me why don't ya. Hey ho sorry ladies, just my personal opinion.
Possibly Robyn Cowen ?
Women have been more prevalent on the TV in relation to football of late.Kelly Cates was on' The Debate', Alex Scott has been on a few times of late and Steph Houghton was a studio pundit recently.
Edited by Willo (18 Feb 2018 2.36pm)
|
crvenaeagle 19 Feb 18 3.27am |
|
|
I recall the late Sir Patrick Moore used to say that female broadcasters lack the vocal power needed to deliver.
...Christ, I 'sound' like Willo now.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 18 8.56am |
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
I recall the late Sir Patrick Moore used to say that female broadcasters lack the vocal power needed to deliver.
...Christ, I 'sound' like Willo now.
My goodness, if he uttered these words in this modern era he would be "Hung drawn and quartered".
|
Stuk Top half 19 Feb 18 4.31pm |
|
|
It's odd that Sky have decided to crowbar a woman in to almost every live match coverage, yet it's the first season that Soccer AM hasn't had a female onscreen.
It's fine when they host it like Kelly Cates does, but Steph Houghton being a pundit in a men's game was irrelevant as she could offer no insight or experience of playing for or against either team, nor anyone who was playing in it.
Funnily enough the drill on Soccer AM this week was 3 Chelsea women pros versus 2 ex-footballers and a presenter, the women got beaten easily.
Optimistic as ever
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 19 Feb 18 10.30pm |
|
Originally posted by Stuk
3 Chelsea women pros versus 2 ex-footballers and a presenter, the women got beaten easily.
careful now
Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Feb 2018 10.34pm)
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
collier row eagle romford essex via another galaxy 19 Feb 18 10.46pm |
|
|
Women commentating on football, it's just so so wrong.
|
Jimenez SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 19 Feb 18 10.52pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
Certainly a font of football knowledge and a very estimable chap.
Are you related Willo?
Pro USA & Israel
|
Jimenez SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 19 Feb 18 10.54pm |
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
I recall the late Sir Patrick Moore used to say that female broadcasters lack the vocal power needed to deliver.
...Christ, I 'sound' like Willo now.
Pro USA & Israel
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 18 10.58pm |
|
|
My word, even if I was related to Jeff Stelling, in his interests I wouldn't advertise this on HOL !
|
dreamwaverider London 19 Feb 18 11.00pm |
|
|
I can just feel the sensitivity of this subject oooooozing from the page from those of you who have dared to comment.
Sad....very sad especially when I consider the football I grew up watching that has now long gone.
PC, modern world, mad world, WE ARE ALL SUPPRESSED.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Feb 18 11.04pm |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
I can just feel the sensitivity of this subject oooooozing from the page from those of you who have dared to comment.
Sad....very sad especially when I consider the football I grew up watching that has now long gone.
PC, modern world, mad world, WE ARE ALL SUPPRESSED.
To be perfectly honest I get my jolly cross knobs on when I think of all this PC hogwash.I have vented my spleen umpteen times outside of HOL.Makes my blood boil.
Only last weekend my dear wife urged me to "Zip it" as I launched into a tirade which she has been subjected to on a regular basis.
Anyway let's move away from my abhorrence of this PC hogwash - I believe it has been well documented on HOL.
Edited by Willo (19 Feb 2018 11.12pm)
|
gambler Kent 19 Feb 18 11.44pm |
|
Originally posted by dreamwaverider
Just been watching WBA v Ston on BT. The commentator is a female......Robyn something. I know we are living in a mad PC world and BT probably think it is wise to put on a female for a bit of balance, but come on BT her voice and commentary is like listening to some kind of funeral march. Dull, depressing, and generally very boring. Soory Robyn, nothing personal, but give me John Motson etc any day over that. Made me realise just how good most football commentators are......and yes they are ALL male. I honestly think the female voice is lacking on many fronts to deliver on football. Call me sexist go on miss my point. Throw the pathetic PC book at me why don't ya. Hey ho sorry ladies, just my personal opinion.
Sounded like she was reading off a script. Like she had learned all the old cliched comments are wanted to get them all in.
|
Temps Cronx 20 Feb 18 7.35am |
|
|
Football commentators in general wind me up, especially those fcukers on MOTD who have had several hours between the game ending and the program showing to edit the game and to dazzle us with their insider knowledge. Like picking out a player on the bench and wondering out loud if this player will make a difference, knowing full well he scores the winner, barsteds. Sorry, just finished a crappy night shift and me back hurts.
Dyslexics of the world, UNTIE!!
|
kenbarr Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 20 Feb 18 7.43am |
|
|
Most of the women commentators in the US are either studio hosts like Rebecca Lowe (NBCSN) or "color" match commentators like Julie Foudy on ESPN. I don't know of a play-by-play announcer for soccer on American TV.
Divorced...And LOVING it! VJRAM Rev. CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach Trevor Francis, International PRAT
|
Stuk Top half 20 Feb 18 2.21pm |
|
|
That's me out of the running to replace Phil Neville...
Optimistic as ever
|
Stuk Top half 20 Feb 18 2.24pm |
|
Originally posted by kenbarr
Most of the women commentators in the US are either studio hosts like Rebecca Lowe (NBCSN) or "color" match commentators like Julie Foudy on ESPN. I don't know of a play-by-play announcer for soccer on American TV.
Jeez, I knew you guys had Spanish commentary but having separate commentators for the white and coloured folk is a bit much!
(what the hell is a "colour" commentator?)
Edited by Stuk (20 Feb 2018 2.24pm)
Optimistic as ever
|