You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Substitutions
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Substitutions


Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3
Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Apr 18 6.20pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Given our continuous ability to let in late goals, the "mental zone" you speak of is by that time in the game quite fatigued, hence the need for subs.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Apr 2018 6.29am)

Its a possibility if your getting the run around but Ive seen no evidence that that has been the case . Spurs winner was down to the late sub ,Damo , not as I have said getting with it and the Man U winner an effort from range , hardly signs of fatigue .
We havnt exactly been chasing games of late which if were the case would agree that subs are needed .

Being down the wrong end of the table maybe makes us fall too deep towards the end of games .That is in my view our problem ,not making substitutions

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Apr 18 9.17pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Its a possibility if your getting the run around but Ive seen no evidence that that has been the case . Spurs winner was down to the late sub ,Damo , not as I have said getting with it and the Man U winner an effort from range , hardly signs of fatigue .
We havnt exactly been chasing games of late which if were the case would agree that subs are needed .

Being down the wrong end of the table maybe makes us fall too deep towards the end of games .That is in my view our problem ,not making substitutions

We fall deep because we are done, physically and mentally. Still, top coaches across the world of football must be mistaken when protecting a lead to make timely late substitutions don't you think?

Edited by southnorwoodhill (10 Apr 2018 9.18pm)

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 10 Apr 18 9.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hodgson is a vastly experienced and capable manager and it is perhaps presumptious to assume that he can take lessons from those who are not steeped in his knowledge of the game.

I believe that when you are leading in the last 15 mins perhaps there is a tendency to 'Let sleeping dogs lie' unless of course certain players are visibly flagging.

Hodgson will have had good reasons not to have brought on the players listed - he did bring on a player against Tottenham and he was culpable in relation to the late goal they scored at a corner so substitutes don't always work !

Edited by Willo (09 Apr 2018 10.09am)

The late sub was Delaney: Tompkins was injured & Hennessey missed the catch, like the one before. We should have changed players in several games late on, sometimes just to disrupt the play, sometimes to change then pattern of plat from us. We have young players good enough to be given a go at least, which was our tradition & one Imam sorry to see going: my only issue with Roy is the subs/youngsters.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Apr 18 10.47am

I see that Barcelona's manager Valverde has been severely rebuked for not making any substitutions until the 80th minute against Roma last night, including comments that it looks as though he doesn't trust his bench.His inaction last night has not been well received.
Sounds familiar !

Edited by Willo (11 Apr 2018 10.49am)

 

Kieranemm Flag Towcester 11 Apr 18 11.08am

Originally posted by Willo

I see that Barcelona's manager Valverde has been severely rebuked for not making any substitutions until the 80th minute against Roma last night, including comments that it looks as though he doesn't trust his bench.His inaction last night has not been well received.
Sounds familiar !

Edited by Willo (11 Apr 2018 10.49am)

Maybe it is a red and blue thing not to use the subs bench then!

 

Aray Flag South London 11 Apr 18 3.40pm

Originally posted by Willo

Hodgson is a vastly experienced and capable manager and it is perhaps presumptious to assume that he can take lessons from those who are not steeped in his knowledge of the game.

I believe that when you are leading in the last 15 mins perhaps there is a tendency to 'Let sleeping dogs lie' unless of course certain players are visibly flagging.

Hodgson will have had good reasons not to have brought on the players listed - he did bring on a player against Tottenham and he was culpable in relation to the late goal they scored at a corner so substitutes don't always work !

Edited by Willo (09 Apr 2018 10.09am)

As you know. that was an unforced substitution. not what we are talking about.

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 11 Apr 18 3.47pm

YES, CANT UNDERSTAND IF THEY NOT GOOD ENOUGH TO BE ON THE BENCH DONT FILL IT WITH PLAYERS THAT WONT PLAY!!!


Originally posted by Kieranemm

I know we have a ton of injuries, but does anyone else think not using fresh legs from the bench in the past couple of weeks is part of the reason we are not seeing games out?

Late goals against Tottenham, Man Utd, Liverpool and Bournemouth I really hope doesn’t cost us come end of the season.

Need to just get through this nightmare season, and have a serious investment in squad depth over the summer!

 

Kentbaldeagle64 Flag Swanscombe 11 Apr 18 3.49pm

Roy needs To to use subs earlier to get them into the game,

Do they train for full matches that last 110 minutes
? then they won’t get to 85 mins and think sit tight for five and the game will finish.

Good to see Daly on the bench but why not use him. Annoying when we don’t have enough fit players then the bench is left sitting there twiddling their thumbs whilst players tire and struggle and concede silly goals.

AWB looked knackered at the end of the last game. Cabyaye can’t do 90 mins and Wilf and Jimmy Mac and PVA and Luka and Andros run around like mad making up for others.

Just frustrated when we see this happening week in week out when we can’t finish games off.

 

AshfordEagle94 Flag Canterbury 11 Apr 18 3.51pm

Originally posted by Kentbaldeagle64

Roy needs To to use subs earlier to get them into the game,

Do they train for full matches that last 110 minutes
? then they won’t get to 85 mins and think sit tight for five and the game will finish.

Good to see Daly on the bench but why not use him. Annoying when we don’t have enough fit players then the bench is left sitting there twiddling their thumbs whilst players tire and struggle and concede silly goals.

AWB looked knackered at the end of the last game. Cabyaye can’t do 90 mins and Wilf and Jimmy Mac and PVA and Luka and Andros run around like mad making up for others.

Just frustrated when we see this happening week in week out when we can’t finish games off.

Exactly right! as an opposition player would I rather be up against a Cabaye who's been on for 90 minutes or a Jairo who's been on for 5. These players are tired and it shows in the last 10 minutes of games

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 11 Apr 18 3.53pm

Yes it mutters, dont bring on Lee for last few minutes, what has he ever given us as late sub?

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

A late substitution would taken the sting out of the game and it would not have mattered who came on, but to concede in the last couple minutes again is infuriating.

One other thing, there was no one on the back post when the corner came in, are we learning from all these mistakes I am not so sure?

Edited by A1969Eagle (11 Apr 2018 3.53pm)

 

AshfordEagle94 Flag Canterbury 11 Apr 18 3.56pm

I will say I don't think it's just down to the substitutions, we're also too respectful. Get the ball in the corner, take as long as possible with everything. We never waste time

 

Kentbaldeagle64 Flag Swanscombe 11 Apr 18 3.57pm

Why not use Rakip as a sub Cabaye, fresh legs, seems keen and must be fit now surely.

If we don’t use him what was the point of getting him. Why not even put Jairo in the back and use tompkins for 15 mins as centre forward. Can’t be any worse than Benteke.

 

AshfordEagle94 Flag Canterbury 11 Apr 18 3.59pm

Originally posted by Kentbaldeagle64

Why not use Rakip as a sub Cabaye, fresh legs, seems keen and must be fit now surely.

If we don’t use him what was the point of getting him. Why not even put Jairo in the back and use tompkins for 15 mins as centre forward. Can’t be any worse than Benteke.

agree with this completely. Maybe if they can take 10 minutes to walk off, maybe fall down clutching their leg on the way for a bit, even better

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 11 Apr 18 4.00pm

[quote=Willo;332570
We all know the reason why Kane scored but delaney replaced an injured player and delaney was not up to speed with the game. we have brought on Tompkins in the past and we let in a goal almost straight away.
Its more about why we no longer have player on the line, should be asked....


Hodgson is a vastly experienced and capable manager and it is perhaps presumptious to assume that he can take lessons from those who are not steeped in his knowledge of the game.

I believe that when you are leading in the last 15 mins perhaps there is a tendency to 'Let sleeping dogs lie' unless of course certain players are visibly flagging.

Hodgson will have had good reasons not to have brought on the players listed - he did bring on a player against Tottenham and he was culpable in relation to the late goal they scored at a corner so substitutes don't always work !

Edited by Willo (09 Apr 2018 10.09am)

 

Kentbaldeagle64 Flag Swanscombe 11 Apr 18 4.11pm

If Roy with his vast wealth of experience along with the supporting coaching team et al can’t see we we see i.e. players are tired maybe specsavers need to sponser us.....

This tiredness in the squad is highlighted weekly, if you let sleeping dogs lie they do nod off......

Why is Jairo not on the bench, younger than Delaney, fit by now and will be keen to do a job as does Delaney. Yes experience is good but so is raw talent that is eager to do well.

 

Kieranemm Flag Towcester 15 Apr 18 3.28pm

Originally posted by Kentbaldeagle64

If Roy with his vast wealth of experience along with the supporting coaching team et al can’t see we we see i.e. players are tired maybe specsavers need to sponser us.....

This tiredness in the squad is highlighted weekly, if you let sleeping dogs lie they do nod off......

Why is Jairo not on the bench, younger than Delaney, fit by now and will be keen to do a job as does Delaney. Yes experience is good but so is raw talent that is eager to do well.


Seems Hodgson has learned from the Bournemouth game and utilised the bench yesterday to get us over the line.

Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek looked tired when the came off, and even though Benteke looked ineffective when he came on, bringing Riedewald on to shut out the game seemed the right option.

Probably wouldn’t have said so if Murray didn’t miss from 3 yards out right at the end mind!

 

chateauferret Flag 15 Apr 18 3.30pm

Originally posted by Kieranemm


Seems Hodgson has learned from the Bournemouth game and utilised the bench yesterday to get us over the line.

Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek looked tired when the came off, and even though Benteke looked ineffective when he came on, bringing Riedewald on to shut out the game seemed the right option.

Probably wouldn’t have said so if Murray didn’t miss from 3 yards out right at the end mind!

That would have been yet again nobody's fault in particular, but it would have been the price of once again failing to retain the ball on winning it in defence and booting it upfield to be brought back to us instead of doing something useful with it or at least stopping weed from getting it back for a while.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Petereagle Flag Brockley 15 Apr 18 4.25pm

Originally posted by bryne and holton

The bench looked weak.
Who could we bring on. Mutch ?
Of more crucial importance is the Club`s performance in the last transfer window.
Who was responsible for bringing in the Pole and
the Benfica.?
If the club`s performance in the window was stronger
then RH would have a better bench to use

Spot on. We had a really feeble January transfer windowt

 

Page 3 of 3 << First< 1 2 3

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Substitutions