This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
That's why there's no English refs at the wc. Shocking all game
|
|
|
If he abused or accused the ref then had to go
|
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Buffon would probably have saved the penalty. I don't know what he said but you don't generally get a straight red for dissent. It was an accidental collision after the ball had gone. Penalty my arse. Oh and dished out quite a few ludicrous yellow cards. An embarrassment to English football and a disgrace. Edited by chateauferret (11 Apr 2018 9.57pm) Try watching the replays, you can find them on youtube by now i am sure. Ronaldo had headed it back across goal to Vazquez who goes to control the ball on his chest as he gets shoved in the back. Clear penalty, glad Oliver had the balls to give it. As to the sending off, we dont know what was said, but Buffon did get a little physical with Oliver, maybe a combination of words and actions, i am sure its all in his report. What is interesting is that you all second guess the whole thing and put Oliver down despite not having any of the facts.
|
|
|
Originally posted by twist
Try watching the replays, you can find them on youtube by now i am sure. Ronaldo had headed it back across goal to Vazquez who goes to control the ball on his chest as he gets shoved in the back. Clear penalty, glad Oliver had the balls to give it. As to the sending off, we dont know what was said, but Buffon did get a little physical with Oliver, maybe a combination of words and actions, i am sure its all in his report. What is interesting is that you all second guess the whole thing and put Oliver down despite not having any of the facts. I am no Madrid fan, but i do like truth to shine through.
|
|
|
Originally posted by twist
Try watching the replays, you can find them on youtube by now i am sure. Ronaldo had headed it back across goal to Vazquez who goes to control the ball on his chest as he gets shoved in the back. Clear penalty, glad Oliver had the balls to give it. As to the sending off, we dont know what was said, but Buffon did get a little physical with Oliver, maybe a combination of words and actions, i am sure its all in his report. What is interesting is that you all second guess the whole thing and put Oliver down despite not having any of the facts. I wholeheartedly concur with these sentiments.
|
|
|
Originally posted by twist
Try watching the replays, you can find them on youtube by now i am sure. Ronaldo had headed it back across goal to Vazquez who goes to control the ball on his chest as he gets shoved in the back. Clear penalty, glad Oliver had the balls to give it. As to the sending off, we dont know what was said, but Buffon did get a little physical with Oliver, maybe a combination of words and actions, i am sure its all in his report. What is interesting is that you all second guess the whole thing and put Oliver down despite not having any of the facts.
this does again bring up the whole questions about how soft football has become and unless the rules are laid out very clearly on global scale we will continue to see human error/opinion on how they see the rule being applied
|
|
|
Originally posted by grumpymort
this does again bring up the whole questions about how soft football has become and unless the rules are laid out very clearly on global scale we will continue to see human error/opinion on how they see the rule being applied At the end of the day most decisions are not black and white and fact IE Ball in or out of goal,but subjective. I noted recently comments by Dermot Gallagher and Graham Poll and there were differing opinions about a penalty award.Gallagher said on TV he can discuss incidents with colleagues and they can have different viewpoints about incidents.And this probably watching incidents a few times on "Slow-Mo" etc etc. Edited by Willo (12 Apr 2018 8.16am)
|
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by A89M
Buffon put/nudged his head against the back of Oliver's whilst seemingly screaming expletives at him - Oliver's reaction was to lean forward so he clearly felt it. Regardless of the player playing his last game, he had to go. Correct decision. No keeper was saving that penalty anyway. As for the penalty, I've seen them given and I've seen them just waived on. Edited by A89M (12 Apr 2018 9.34am) I don't see a shove there before the attacker goes down, though it might look like one from where the ref is standing. The defender is trying to get his foot round him to the ball and he's goal-side of him, not in his back. I had to slow it down and freeze the picture to actually see what it might have been for, so how Oliver can call it without doubt in real time is beyond me. If there's doubt you don't give it. Still Oliver's name is all over the papers this morning and there's no such thing as bad publicity so all's well that ends well.
============ |
|
| chateauferret |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
Went through the back of him to get to the ball, no complaint about the penalty. Buffon just made a fool of himself. Even more so when he did his interview today saying that the "ref should know what happened in the first leg" like he's there to rectify supposedly aggrieved decisions in a game he wasn't involved in. He then goes on to say that "he should have a certain sensitivity as there are some of the best players in the world on the pitch" And proceeds to list "Ronaldo, then himself, Navas and Chiellini" - as if they deserve special treatment. Buffon seems to have added an extra "o" to his name. Whether the decision was wrong or right he's bound to accept it and if you lose the plot the ref won't wonder why before sending you for a shower. Which said I do think the defender comes round the forward, he doesn't go through his back.
============ |
|
|
Originally posted by chateauferret
Buffon seems to have added an extra "o" to his name. Whether the decision was wrong or right he's bound to accept it and if you lose the plot the ref won't wonder why before sending you for a shower. Which said I do think the defender comes round the forward, he doesn't go through his back. As I've heard a rugby player or two say in the past, "when have you ever seen a ref change his decision after screaming in his face?" From the goal side camera you could argue that, but the ref is on the other side. I'd still say he makes contact with the player before the ball though.
Optimistic as ever |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.