You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year and young player of the year
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player of the year and young player of the year


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
eddiqc Flag Tunbridge wells 01 May 18 1.20pm

Mattteo.. I don't understand how you mind works, I think you're just trying to wind people up.

POTY: Milivojevic
YPOTY: RLC

Edited by eddiqc (01 May 2018 1.20pm)

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 1.28pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Are you suggesting Townsend hasn't also been taking set pieces all season? Did you see his attempt direct from a free kick on the weekend?

To approach this as you normally would; Townsend has contributed 2 goals in 2956 mins this season,

Guess assists don't matter at all.....doesn't matter if you have the most assists in the squad or from the entire teams outside of top 6. If you don't score goals you're not a good player. For me, it's actually the players providing assists who do more work than the actual goalscorers. Or at least they are on the same level.

Look at this: Townsend dribbles the defenders, gets a penalty kick for Palace and Luka takes the penalty. Whose contribution is greater? I think Townsend could have also scored a penalty. But could have Luka made that dribbling?

[Link]

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 01 May 18 1.37pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Guess assists don't matter at all.....doesn't matter if you have the most assists in the squad or from the entire teams outside of top 6. If you don't score goals you're not a good player. For me, it's actually the players providing assists who do more work than the actual goalscorers. Or at least they are on the same level.

Look at this: Townsend dribbles the defenders, gets a penalty kick for Palace and Luka takes the penalty. Whose contribution is greater? I think Townsend could have also scored a penalty. But could have Luka made that dribbling?

[Link]

Nice deflection - I'll bear it in mind next time the goals/'minutes stats suit your argument and you use them again.

The Premier League website has Towsend at 6 assists, which is joint 24th in the league, along with the likes of Calvert-Lewin and Jordon Ibe and incidentally only one more than Benteke (who now has more goals).

6 assists and 2 goals in 3000 minutes as a forward - by any definition that's not a good return is it?

Benteke has 3 goals and 5 assists in 2187 minutes and you have absolutely rinsed him all season...

Your logic is not consistent.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 May 18 1.57pm

AWB is easy. It’s not just about what the young player does for the first team but also a mark of progress, he was playing under 23s and stepped up to play against some of the biggest teams in the world and was MOM several times including against Huddersfield.

Zaha for POTY because if his excellent contributions.

Luka second and Tomkins third.

How anyone can doubt the importance of Luka is beyond me, his leadership on the pitch from having the bottle to smash vital penalties, to calming Zaha down and preventing him from being sent off several times, he doesn’t overplay the ball and makes the right decision most of the time.

 

Dman Palace Flag Brixton 01 May 18 2.08pm


Wilfried Zaha is, without any doubt or consideration, our stand out POTY. (by a country mile)

Milivojevic has been brilliant and had a great season for sure... but no-one comes close to Wilf in terms of contribution and making such a difference. His positive influence is what has made us this season.

( and without him LM wouldn't have had so many set pieces to benefit from )

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 2.11pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow


Benteke has 3 goals and 5 assists in 2187 minutes and you have absolutely rinsed him all season...


Taking penalties doesn;t mean the same!! That's why I'm ranting about Luka. He's a good enough player, but he's overrated because he is the designated penalty taker. Without all those penalty goals, people here would've said just "Oh, Luka, oh ok, he's a decent player, pretty good at holding the midfield". But now, people think he's seriously the team's second goalscorer!! Because of penalty goals.

Same for your example of Benteke. Every site I've seen mention 7 assists and 2 goals for Townsend. Maybe the PL one doesn't count obtainning a penalty as an assist (but it should, cause the Huddersfield 2nd goal was mostly his work getting that penalty). Plus, there's 1 more assist in the Cup against Huddersfield (a PL team). So that's 8 assists and 2 goals in 3000 minutes in a season. Maybe not amazing for a winger, but show me 3 more wingers outside the top 6 teams who have done this in 3000 minutes.

 

MikeCrete Flag Crete 01 May 18 2.23pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Taking penalties doesn;t mean the same!! That's why I'm ranting about Luka. He's a good enough player, but he's overrated because he is the designated penalty taker. Without all those penalty goals, people here would've said just "Oh, Luka, oh ok, he's a decent player, pretty good at holding the midfield". But now, people think he's seriously the team's second goalscorer!! Because of penalty goals.

Same for your example of Benteke. Every site I've seen mention 7 assists and 2 goals for Townsend. Maybe the PL one doesn't count obtainning a penalty as an assist (but it should, cause the Huddersfield 2nd goal was mostly his work getting that penalty). Plus, there's 1 more assist in the Cup against Huddersfield (a PL team). So that's 8 assists and 2 goals in 3000 minutes in a season. Maybe not amazing for a winger, but show me 3 more wingers outside the top 6 teams who have done this in 3000 minutes.

Give Lokilo a go, pretty sure he would be no worse than Townsend.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 01 May 18 2.36pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Taking penalties doesn;t mean the same!! That's why I'm ranting about Luka. He's a good enough player, but he's overrated because he is the designated penalty taker. Without all those penalty goals, people here would've said just "Oh, Luka, oh ok, he's a decent player, pretty good at holding the midfield". But now, people think he's seriously the team's second goalscorer!! Because of penalty goals.

Same for your example of Benteke. Every site I've seen mention 7 assists and 2 goals for Townsend. Maybe the PL one doesn't count obtainning a penalty as an assist (but it should, cause the Huddersfield 2nd goal was mostly his work getting that penalty). Plus, there's 1 more assist in the Cup against Huddersfield (a PL team). So that's 8 assists and 2 goals in 3000 minutes in a season. Maybe not amazing for a winger, but show me 3 more wingers outside the top 6 teams who have done this in 3000 minutes.

Ok, so even if you discredit Benteke's penalty (which is a nonsense argument, but we'll entertain it), that's 2 goals and 5 assists in 2187 mins compared to Townsend's 2 goals and 6 assists in 3000 minutes - the point still stands. Make it 7 assists for Townsend if you want.. It still stands.

I specifically remember you saying that Benteke's cup goals last year shouldn't be 'counted' when people highlighted that he had 17 goals, so to suggest Townsend's cup assist can now count is just more hypocrisy.

Off the top of my head, 3 wingers outside the top six with better numbers;

- Mahrez
- Shaqiri
- Zaha
- Gross (not quite a winger, but comparable role to Townsend)

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 2.43pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Ok, so even if you discredit Benteke's penalty (which is a nonsense argument, but we'll entertain it), that's 2 goals and 5 assists in 2187 mins compared to Townsend's 2 goals and 6 assists in 3000 minutes - the point still stands. Make it 7 assists for Townsend if you want.. It still stands.

I specifically remember you saying that Benteke's cup goals last year shouldn't be 'counted' when people highlighted that he had 17 goals, so to suggest Townsend's cup assist can now count is just more hypocrisy.

Off the top of my head, 3 wingers outside the top six with better numbers;

- Mahrez
- Shaqiri
- Zaha
- Gross (not quite a winger, but comparable role to Townsend)


See what names you came up with. All amazing players. The fact that Townsend is up there competing with these players means that he's great. Gross has the advantage that he takes all set pieces and his number of assists is big (but a great player in my opinion nonetheless, though relatively unknown).

Swap Townsend for any of Mahrez, Shaqiri, even Tadic or and I'll agree. But see if you can do that.

Heck, even swap him for Izquierdo, Jordon Ibe or Richarlison (though they are right footed and you'll be stuck without a proper left footed winger).

But truth is- Townsend is in top 5 left footed wingers in the PL outside of top 6 teams (and even with them included).

 

OldFella Flag London 01 May 18 3.02pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Milivojevic??????????

Took set pieces all year, didn't hit a single assist (edit: had one assist in the 34th matchday against Brighton, with only 4 matches to go until the end of the season, but it wasn't one of his set pieces). Makes you wonder why does he take set pieces actually? Ok, he scored 1 very nice goal from a free kick and is good from the penalty spot (7 of his 10 goals were from the penalty spot) but he couldn't cross for a goal an entire season despite taking set pieces!!

Guilty at plenty of goals (the one in the 90th minute against Man United easily comes to mind, but there were others too).

It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more.

Edited by mattteo (01 May 2018 10.00am)

Serious Wally Alert!!

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

victor43 Flag St. Albans 01 May 18 3.10pm

Originally posted by mattteo

I never said that. Others have brought up Milivojevic's goals and assist contribution. I didn't say it's what makes a good defensive midfielder.

Let's talk his defensive midfielder contribution if you'd like. His recoveries, his speed. And his set pieces

I think the main problem here is that you clearly have no idea what makes a good defensive midfielder.

Luka is not a classic defensive midfielder anyway, he likes to break forward a fair amount, not your typical sit back and hold like Jedi used to be, and from what I can see what Amadou looks like too.

Luka's passing is very good and he helps us move up the field a lot - this stuff isn't going to result in assists or chances created very often, but is still very valuable - particularly when Benteke is not playing and we can't go long.

You can't find stats on who has taken how many set pieces, but I am fairly confident that until recently Cabaye was taking most of the corners, and Andros takes a fair amount too so seems bizarre to judge him on those.

He also contributes a high amount of tackles and interceptions for a central midfielder. In my opinion he is pretty perfect to have in a 2 man midfield.

Yes he's made a couple of mistakes this season - but who hasn't?

And looking at offensive output - even allowing for his penalties, he has contributed more than Cabaye who is naturally more attacking.

After all that I wouldn't have him POTY, Wilf has been our best player by a considerable margin.

My top 5 this season:
1. Zaha
2. Luka
3. Tomkins
4. Townsend (I agree his creativity is underrated)

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 3.31pm

Originally posted by victor43

Agreed. That's all I've been trying to say.

Edit: You said top 5 and wrote only 4. You forgot someone. Maybe PVA?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 3.42pm

Originally posted by mattteo

What Huddersfield free kick????? The one in the video I posted above? A decent effort, I admit, but nothing came of it. Maybe you're refferring to another Huddersfield match, but there haven't been any other goals against Huddersfield, so please tell me what free kick are you talking about please stop telling me about facts until you clarify this)

1st corner against Brighton was a trick. Kuddos to Luka for thinking it, but it doesn't show great corner delivery abilities.

All in all, 2 or 3 corners that resulted in goals in 30+ matches of taking corners in a Premier League season is not much

My apologies I meant the free kick against Bournemouth, surely with your extensive knowledge you remember that one.
Luka was not assigned as corner taker at the beginning of the season, it was Cabaye

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 3.49pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Agreed. That's all I've been trying to say.

Edit: You said top 5 and wrote only 4. You forgot someone. Maybe PVA?

Really? You had me fooled!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 18 3.53pm

Originally posted by mattteo

You're turning this into a personal agenda you have against me instead of answering the points made by the discussion. I'd really, really like to punch your stupid ass face in real life, to see if you'd still have the balls to talk like that

Hit a nerve did he? Not a very pleasant response and must be bordering on a Yellow Card offence

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 01 May 18 3.58pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Agreed. That's all I've been trying to say.

Edit: You said top 5 and wrote only 4. You forgot someone. Maybe PVA?

You were trying to say that Luka should be runner up for POTY by posting:

"It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more."

You move the goalposts so often it's untrue.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 01 May 18 3.58pm

POTY - Zaha
YPOTY - RLC

 

mattteo Flag 01 May 18 5.10pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You were trying to say that Luka should be runner up for POTY by posting:

"It's like fans here have a fascination with Milivojevic. Decent player but in no way player of the season. Not even a great season if you ask me, just a mediocre one.

Undoubtedly Zaha, Townsend, Tomkins, PVA, McArthur have kept this team up and deserve it a lot more."

You move the goalposts so often it's untrue.


I agree with what he said without the Luka in second place part.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 01 May 18 5.43pm

Tomkins POTY.

Young player is tough, as AWB hasn't played many games and RLC has looked average as often as he's looked good, whilst missing a load of games.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 01 May 18 5.59pm

POTY - Milo

YPOTY - if Aaron gets a shout then shouldn't TFM as well for his contribution when we needed him? Overall though RLC should get it.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year and young player of the year