You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Miners vs farmers
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Miners vs farmers


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
dannyboy1978 Flag 11 Jul 18 3.46pm

Back in the 70's 80's we essentially got rid of miners and were told by them it would kill communities. 40 years on we survived.

With brexit we are told the same for farmers.
If they only exist because of subsidies what is the actual point?

Has brexit just highlighted there is no money in farming?


[Link]


 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 11 Jul 18 3.57pm

Reliance on coal had been declining since the 1960s so pit closures were inevitable one way or the other. As an aside, if you want to find out what happens to an area when an industry upon which it depends disappears try visiting, for example, the Rhondda.

But do you seriously think we should be entirely reliant on our food supply from imports, I mean, what could possibly go wrong? Is this perhaps something that you haven't quite thought through?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

dannyboy1978 Flag 11 Jul 18 4.41pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

Reliance on coal had been declining since the 1960s so pit closures were inevitable one way or the other. As an aside, if you want to find out what happens to an area when an industry upon which it depends disappears try visiting, for example, the Rhondda.

But do you seriously think we should be entirely reliant on our food supply from imports, I mean, what could possibly go wrong? Is this perhaps something that you haven't quite thought through?

couldn't you say the same about a reliance on Russian gas from most of the EU?

Isn't the problem that we can import food from low wage economies with free trade?

Take our selves away from the free trade means we need and must be more self sufficient which means our farmers are earning their money and have a purpose.

Has the EU dragged us down rather than up?
Fishing has been desimated?

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 11 Jul 18 5.52pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

couldn't you say the same about a reliance on Russian gas from most of the EU?

Isn't the problem that we can import food from low wage economies with free trade?

Take our selves away from the free trade means we need and must be more self sufficient which means our farmers are earning their money and have a purpose.

Has the EU dragged us down rather than up?
Fishing has been desimated?

I'm sorry, but I've lost the point of what you're trying to say. Relying on food imports, however cheap they may be, would be a foolish strategy. I voted to leave the EU for a number of reasons, one of which was because of the Fisheries Policy. You're using that as an argument, yet seem to want to "decimate" UK farming. If we want to be "self-sufficient" with respect to agriculture, as you put it, then everyone man jack of us is going to have to pay a whole lot more than we do now for produce. To suggest that UK farming doesn't have "a purpose" is, in my opinion, deeply ignorant.

Edited by bexleydave (11 Jul 2018 5.53pm)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

becky Flag over the moon 11 Jul 18 6.05pm

Most of the subsidies that farmers receive are for 'set-aside' measures. Basically they are paid by the EU to leave the fields bare of crops (except for silage for their own use)to keep down the stockpiled mountains of stuff that the EU purchases to maintain pre-set prices as per the Common Agricultural Policy.

There has been a lot of investment in alternatives to 'growing things' on farms; agro-tourism and agro-industry for starters, but the fields are still there and can be converted back for food at anytime.

As for selling their lamb and beef in the EU - Europe cannot produce enough of their own to meet demand and, as it will also prove with fish, they will either have to buy from us or import frozen from greater distance suppliers and at additional cost. We export most of our lamb there simply because under the current supply/demand they will take everything they can get from us - it will just cost them a bit more now.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Stirlingsays Flag 11 Jul 18 6.50pm

If we suffered loss of our imported foods during a conflict we could very quickly re-direct the very significant farm land we have towards purely internal use.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 11 Jul 18 7.03pm

I'm quite disappointed that this thread is not a debate about who would win a fight between miners and farmers.

 

.TUX. Flag 11 Jul 18 9.12pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Back in the 70's 80's we essentially got rid of miners and were told by them it would kill communities. 40 years on we survived.

With brexit we are told the same for farmers.
If they only exist because of subsidies what is the actual point?

Has brexit just highlighted there is no money in farming?


[Link]


It did kill communities.
You then mention ''we survived''.

Make your mind up.

 


Buy Litecoin.

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 11 Jul 18 9.59pm

The closure of the coal mines DID kill whole communities. The mining towns of the north, of Wales and even parts of Kent were decimated by those closures.

Even now they are mostly run down areas of high unemployment, social deprevation and poverty.

If by 'we,' you mean London, the South East or areas where there were not mines of course they survived. Take a wander round other parts of the country and many will disagree with you.

Edited by orpingtoneagle (11 Jul 2018 9.59pm)

Edited by orpingtoneagle (11 Jul 2018 10.00pm)

 

johnno42000 Flag 11 Jul 18 10.17pm

I live in The Rhondda and it most definitely destroyed the area. It still hasn't recovered.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Mapletree Flag Croydon 11 Jul 18 11.09pm

Farms aren’t just production lines. You could make the land more productive by moving to huge agribusinesses. The effect historically has been soil degrading, less attractive countryside, blocking of accesses to the countryside as an amenity and growth of cash crops to the detriment of more balanced farming.

Part of the reason for the CAP for all its flaws was to protect communities from faceless and detrimental capitalism

But hey, if you don’t like hedgerows and small farms you campaign for removal of subsidies.

You only have to look at the Scottish Highlands to observe the expulsion of communities in favour of huge offshore leisure businesses to see the effects. Desertion of areas previously thriving with mad bekilted Jocks. But lovely shooting for the Yanks and mega income for the 500 people that own half of Scotland. Yes, really.

 

the.universal 11 Jul 18 11.17pm

Originally posted by becky

Most of the subsidies that farmers receive are for 'set-aside' measures. Basically they are paid by the EU to leave the fields bare of crops (except for silage for their own use)to keep down the stockpiled mountains of stuff that the EU purchases to maintain pre-set prices as per the Common Agricultural Policy.

There has been a lot of investment in alternatives to 'growing things' on farms; agro-tourism and agro-industry for starters, but the fields are still there and can be converted back for food at anytime.

As for selling their lamb and beef in the EU - Europe cannot produce enough of their own to meet demand and, as it will also prove with fish, they will either have to buy from us or import frozen from greater distance suppliers and at additional cost. We export most of our lamb there simply because under the current supply/demand they will take everything they can get from us - it will just cost them a bit more now.

The EC agreed in November 2008 to abolish set-aside completely through the CAP Health Check.

Edited by the.universal (11 Jul 2018 11.17pm)

 


Vive le Roy!

the.universal 11 Jul 18 11.21pm

Originally posted by Direwolf

I'm quite disappointed that this thread is not a debate about who would win a fight between miners and farmers.

Miners. End of.

 


Vive le Roy!

DanH Flag SW2 12 Jul 18 7.38am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

If we suffered loss of our imported foods during a conflict we could very quickly re-direct the very significant farm land we have towards purely internal use.

And hope they grow overnight?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 12 Jul 18 10.10am

Originally posted by johnno42000

I live in The Rhondda and it most definitely destroyed the area. It still hasn't recovered.

The rivers have - particularly the Taff

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 12 Jul 18 11.52am

Originally posted by the.universal

Miners. End of.

Farmers are pretty nails as well though.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Mapletree Flag Croydon 12 Jul 18 2.13pm

Originally posted by Brentmiester_General

Farmers are pretty nails as well though.

Takes muscles to hold those sheep in place.

 

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 12 Jul 18 3.04pm

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Back in the 70's 80's we essentially got rid of miners and were told by them it would kill communities. 40 years on we survived.

With brexit we are told the same for farmers.
If they only exist because of subsidies what is the actual point?

Has brexit just highlighted there is no money in farming?


[Link]


I am most worried for keyboard warriors; which mining town were you in as you state "we"?

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

radsyrendot Flag From Coventry now in Leicester 12 Jul 18 3.15pm

Thought there A's gonna be a fight

 

johnno42000 Flag 12 Jul 18 4.26pm

Originally posted by chris123

The rivers have - particularly the Taff

True enough but the communities haven't.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Miners vs farmers