You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forward line
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Forward line


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
george1212 Flag london 22 Aug 18 10.07pm

Ayew should start. He scored 10 goals for Swansea last season.

I can't even see what the argument is, he is a much better player then all our other strikers. He needs to start. Or at least between him and Bentecke.

Sorloth won't make it in the premier league.

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 22 Aug 18 11.14pm

Originally posted by General

Again I'm lost and confused.
As someone said Zaha gets so much freedom because of Benteke.
If you watch them two for a while you will see.
Cannot possibly expect Sorloth to have the same impact or usefulness over 90 mins coming from the Norwegian league are you serious. He's clearly not a superstar.
Watch Benteke best games and you will see how he was quite lucky at Villa with who supplied him balls. We are just not that team.
I'm not sure if you expect Kane for £30 million but Sorloth is a third of the price and clearly a third of the player.
Wickham about half the cost and half the player.
Benteke has more class than plenty of the strikers we have had. Murray included. Murray was super at his work rate and making the absolute maximum of his opportunities and obviously did have class moments I'm not denying that but come on he was a notch below Benteke overall.
I can agree a little more confidence and you'll see him chest a ball down perfect, lay it off perfect, and move into a super position where defenders are retreating thus creating more space for midfielder driving forward or Zaha run etc etc but I'm still hopeful Roy can work it out of him..

Wow... Weird how differently we see football as supporters... If I had a choice of Benteke or Murray based on the performances of both over the last 12 months it would be Murray with bells on.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 23 Aug 18 12.13am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Last night tells us that Ayew has not been brought in to replace the likes of Benteke in our system. He would be replacing Zaha or a winger.

Sorloth is our Benteke replacement until Wickham is back, and based on what I have seen of Sorloth, if sick note Wickham can remain remotely fit, he will supplant Sorloth pretty sharpish.

Sorloth looked quite poor last night, to play that role you need a bit better close control and a bit more guile and he showed none of that last night, but it was under tough circumstances that he came in.

Which is why I said to give defences something different to think about. Our striking options (when all fit) are similar types of striker whereas Ayew can play anywhere across the front and in midfield if needed.

If plan A isn’t working you might not want a straight swap sub.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

taylors lovechild Flag 23 Aug 18 9.30am

Bentenke played well against Fulham with some good link up play as well as chasing things down. He did not play well against Liverpool and seemed off the pace. I think Watford is a game where he should get more chances, so I would stick with him. It still feels like it's a confidence thing, but given he had a whole season of playing below par even his biggest supporters eventually have to concede and say maybe we need to try something else.

I'm hoping Wickham can get fit as I still think he can be a really good player for us. With Ayew and Sorloth as well we do have options, so unlike last season I think Roy will change things if Tekkers doesn't rediscover some form.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 23 Aug 18 9.49am

The ideal choice would be an in-form Benteke, but I've lost hope. (Of course, Hodgson can't lose hope, because we've got to get something for those 120k p/w wages - hopefully enough to justify renewing Benteke's contract rather than letting a £27 million investment go for free when his contract expires in the summer.)

Ayew doesn't seem like such a good partner for Zaha at first glance, but when you think that we looked pretty decent with Andros and Wilf up front last season, I'm wondering if that's a combination which could really work...

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 23 Aug 18 12.36pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Ultimately I would like to see Townsend Zaha up top, Meyer, Kouyate, Milivojevic and Ayew in midfield and the normal back 4, with Ayew and Meyer chopping and changing/overlapping with Zaha and Townsend during the game. Keep the ball on the deck and fizz it about. That would make for an exciting line up - all in my humble opinion.

What about Ayew up top with Zaha, and as you suggest, changing and overlapping with Townsend

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 23 Aug 18 12.42pm

Originally posted by babylonjohn

There is a reason Liverpool paid 75M for Van Dyke .... he showed it last night and made sure Benteke hardly got a sniff of a chance. We will not face many other teams as good as Liverpool. We cannot afford for Benteke not to come good again we have invested massively in him. Yes we have options now up front but we have to keep supporting Benteke. He will get his mojo back.

and also the premiership's most expensive goalkeeper who made a tremendous save to keep out Benteke's header after he had out jumped Van Dyke.

 

theshezla Flag wibble 23 Aug 18 2.20pm

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle


I think I agree with this. If we want to play a number 9 Benteke has to be the one. Ayew is a different type of player which is probably why we bought him as an alternative style should we need it.

This exactly, unfortunately too many people confuse real life with champ manager / FIFA.

 


Yep

PatrickA Flag London 23 Aug 18 2.21pm

Roy plays 4-4-2 which requires two mobile runners up front.
It’s why we had some joy playing with Zaha and Townsend up top last season.
Benteke just does not suit this way of playing.
He was at his most effective at Villa in a 4-3-3 with fast runners either side and lots of crosses coming in..
Ayew is the best option in the current system.

 

IMpalace Flag London 23 Aug 18 2.41pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

Roy plays 4-4-2 which requires two mobile runners up front.
It’s why we had some joy playing with Zaha and Townsend up top last season.
Benteke just does not suit this way of playing.
He was at his most effective at Villa in a 4-3-3 with fast runners either side and lots of crosses coming in..
Ayew is the best option in the current system.

Why does it require two "mobile runners"? Roy has made clear he wants a big man up top in his 4-4-2.
Townsend only played up front when Benteke was injured. I actually think Benteke has been playing reasonably well with hold up play, has just lost all confidence in front of goal.

 

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 23 Aug 18 2.55pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Why does it require two "mobile runners"? Roy has made clear he wants a big man up top in his 4-4-2.
Townsend only played up front when Benteke was injured. I actually think Benteke has been playing reasonably well with hold up play, has just lost all confidence in front of goal.

I don't want to knock him any more, but why does he never seem to be in the right position in front of goal?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Aug 18 2.57pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Why does it require two "mobile runners"? Roy has made clear he wants a big man up top in his 4-4-2.
Townsend only played up front when Benteke was injured. I actually think Benteke has been playing reasonably well with hold up play, has just lost all confidence in front of goal.

So how many more games does he get to regain his confidence? Or will you be happy at the end of thd season if he's played reasonably well, but only scored 3 goals again.

 

PatrickA Flag London 23 Aug 18 3.34pm

My point is not an anti-Benteke one.
I just don’t think he suits the system played by the team.
Furthermore, Roy still used Zaha and Townsend up front together at the end of the season even when Benteke was fit.

 

IMpalace Flag London 23 Aug 18 4.54pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

So how many more games does he get to regain his confidence? Or will you be happy at the end of thd season if he's played reasonably well, but only scored 3 goals again.

Not saying we should wait, just saying the suggestion that Roy has a system in place designed for two quick, mobile players is obviously not the case given he plays a striker who doesn't score every week because he can hold the ball up. Roy obviously believes that the system needs a "big man"

Believe me, I'm as frustrated about his inability to score a goal as everyone else, however, until we have a player who can hold the ball up and win headers like he does (Sortloth or Wickham?), then I imagine Roy will keep him in the team.


Edited by IMpalace (23 Aug 2018 4.55pm)

 

Mstrobez Flag 23 Aug 18 6.04pm

Originally posted by IMpalace

Why does it require two "mobile runners"? Roy has made clear he wants a big man up top in his 4-4-2.
Townsend only played up front when Benteke was injured. I actually think Benteke has been playing reasonably well with hold up play, has just lost all confidence in front of goal.

Not true. To begin with maybe, but towards the end of last season, Wilf & Townsend featured together a few times even when Benteke was fit. And at times they were devastating as a pair.

I agree, and always have, pretty much completely with what others have said regarding Benteke. He is by no means a bad player, and if you take away your anger for his poor scoring record in recent times and actually watch him play, he does contribute a hell of a lot more to a game than some would have you believe. He’s a target man, but an intelligent one, he’s not so much about brute power & strength, more movement & height, and his link up play is fantastic at times.

However, as others have also pointed out, the problem for me personally is he just does not fit the system that Roy plays. His system is one of high intensity, and we always look more dangerous playing under Roy when we bring the ball down and look to play. It’s just not his game and never has been, he is what he is. That doesn’t mean Benteke is s***, he could join an Allardyce style team tomorrow and I guarantee he’d be banging goals in for fun. I just don’t see how he ever fits in with our current style of play, sadly.

Edited by Mstrobez (23 Aug 2018 6.09pm)

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

pssguy Flag 25 Aug 18 4.05pm

Originally posted by Mstrobez

Wilf & Townsend featured together a few times even when Benteke was fit. And at times they were devastating as a pair.


Edited by Mstrobez (23 Aug 2018 6.09pm)

Really? Townsend scored twice in the league last season; both in games we lost

If they want to try a more mobile forward alongside Zaha then Ayew is the obvious choice

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 25 Aug 18 7.49pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

and also the premiership's most expensive goalkeeper who made a tremendous save to keep out Benteke's header after he had out jumped Van Dyke.

Have we already played Chelsea?

Kepa Arrizabalaga, Athletic Bilbao to Chelsea in 2018, £71m
Alisson Becker, AS Roma to Liverpool in 2018, £65m

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 26 Aug 18 7.02am

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Have we already played Chelsea?

Kepa Arrizabalaga, Athletic Bilbao to Chelsea in 2018, £71m
Alisson Becker, AS Roma to Liverpool in 2018, £65m

S**t, shot down in flames just for a measly 6M

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 26 Aug 18 3.03pm

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

S**t, shot down in flames just for a measly 6M

TBF it gets confusing when one media source quotes Euros and another pounds.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 26 Aug 18 3.26pm

Not including Wilf as a striker, we surely have the worst set of forwards in the league?

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forward line