You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why has there been no progress in 5 years?
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why has there been no progress in 5 years?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 03 Oct 18 12.53pm

agreed

Originally posted by NEILLO

The thing is in the Premier League it's thin dividing lines.

Ward and Sakho miss gilt edge headers that cost us 3 points. Benteke squandered chances against Southampton which might have seen us get a ( undeserved ) draw. Then we have last night's penalty...

We could be 4 points better off and probably should be. Individual errors are difficult to legislate for particularly when we actually do have a fairly talented team - and the current group are arguably the best we have had in the last six years.

Unless we get a Chelsea / Man City type of financial investment, Palace will continue to occupy places in the middle to lower half of the table in the same way that a lot of other clubs do. Just so long as don't finish in that bottom three....

 

Master Coin Flag 03 Oct 18 12.54pm

The reality is that the fans (with maybe one or two exceptions) of EVERY club who finishes between 7th and 17th have an expectation of pushing for a top 10 finish the subsequent year.

Unfortunately, the boards of these teams typically have the same expectation which is why the managerial turnover is so ridiculous. The financial outlay of teams is also commensurate with everybody trying to kick on.

This is even tougher this year because normally the few teams you can expect to struggle and have an "avoid relegation" aspiration are the newly promoted sides and even they have loftier ambitions this year with Fulham and Wolves having spent huge and targeted instant success.

The idea of 'stability' for anybody but the top 6 (and maybe Everton) is madness. Case in point is Southampton who qualified for Europe for about 3 consecutive seasons and then last year were on a last minute relegation panic.

TL,DR: It's a tough league.

Edited by Master Coin (03 Oct 2018 12.55pm)

 

victor43 Flag St. Albans 03 Oct 18 12.55pm

We've made massive progress in 5 years, both on and off the pitch. The fact is below the top 6 it is a bit of a lottery and you need to keep improving year on year even to stay up.

Look at Swansea, Stoke, Southampton, West Brom - all seen as model mid-table clubs at one point or another - now 3 in the Championship and 1 almost joined them last year.

Our squad is lightyears ahead in terms of quality in comparison to the first season in the Prem, and has got better every year. This season we have struggled slightly from losing Cabaye and RLC, and our attacking options look quite poor.

As people have said, I don't know what is expected. When we were flying last season, we were the 7th best team in the league - however a lot of clubs have spent massively this summer - Everton, Brighton, Fulham, Wolves, West Ham even Bournemouth.

I reckon we are around the 10-12th best team in the league and that is roughly where we'll finish. Not every team can finish in a higher position each season, it's not possible!

 


Blog: Andy Johnson's Magic Hat [Link]

Twitter:

RyWa Flag Beckenham 03 Oct 18 12.56pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

And who's to say we won't is my point? I'm certainly not feeling even slightly panicky about where we're at and think we're capable of (and will deliver) significantly improved performances & results.

I generally echo your sentiment, what could turn the tide is having lost to Bournemouth, we've got top 4 coming up in a row in a game or two, if we were to pick up little to no points from the next 5 or 6, it will turn to panic and this place will meltdown.
Im confident we can snatch something v Arsenal and United.. Its all a case of wait and see, it is what it is.

 

Master Coin Flag 03 Oct 18 12.57pm

To illustrate my earlier point here is a short list of teams who (as little as two years ago) many would have thought were safe bets for a mid-table finish:-

Swansea City
Stoke City

 

Painter Flag Croydon 03 Oct 18 1.49pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

I meant in the market really. AWB is an absolute gem. How many players would you say "wow, what a player for 5 million quid"?

Hennessy not bad value for £3.3m.

 

The Dolphin Flag 03 Oct 18 2.45pm

I agree we have a come a long way in many respects but on the pitch we are stuttering again and given that we are 7 games in and have only played Liverpool (from the top 6) so far I worry with the fixtures that we have coming up.
I truly believe that we should be better placed right now given the quality of sides that we have played.
I am not asking for and nor do I expect top 8 but my concern is that other teams on the pitch - bar a very few - appear to be stronger and better but we don't.
It will be what it will be but I bet there is concern right through the Club at the moment.
Knowing us though - we will go and beat three of the top 6!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 Oct 18 9.20pm

Originally posted by palacebob

Watford and leicester come to mind they look solid dont rely on managers wasting money or chairmen buying players there is more than one way to survive its a back room problem for sure but not a manager issue any manager will only be short term that is the way of the game either let Dougie do his job which means trusting him or get someone in that you will trust.
The managers only known fact from the start is he will go one way or another he will be gone even the good ones go.
A quick rant .....
i really dont understand fans that say we need to spend big to succeed look at the the top six you could build several teams around the players they wasted money on Chelseas fixation with center forwards is horrific city no different with young players no team outside the top 6 could survive playing that game its a pundits answer to everything "you are with the big boys now" absolute Boxxoxs ....in my opinion...Rant over
Mind you what do i know i thought Frank was the answer as previously stated the Burnley game looked like a new beginning was starting.. in my defense no one mentioned his megalomaniac personality in any press conference

Edited by palacebob (03 Oct 2018 12.21pm)

And breathe

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 03 Oct 18 9.24pm

Playing at best average football so far and having 7 points is ok IMO
Laat season we played the same quality except huddersfield first game and got nish.
I cant square that!
Or are other teams worse.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 03 Oct 18 9.36pm

Corse there’s been progress ffs. Before we could only rely on counter attack and pace. Now we can compete by playing proper football

Unfortunately benteke has lost the plot, if he was still half decent we’d be half decent.

You would never have posted this last season when Roy won a few on the bounce

We’ll buy a striker in January or loan a decent one I’m certain

Joe Ledley v McArthur
Pva v d moxey

Truth is, anything better and we are talking Everton territory. And we just aren’t..

 

Den1923 Flag 04 Oct 18 11.37am

The truth is that we are in for another battle to stay out the bottom three, we have had an easy start (Liverpool excepted) and the fact is that we have struggled against teams around us and have had some luck in getting the points we have so far. Lack of investment in the team during the summer is partly to blame and the reluctance of quality player wanting to come to CP for whatever reason. The progress of Bournemouth is an example of a team that has invested wisely in quality players that have come to the club and have delivered on the field. Why quality players find the thought of coming to palace so toxic I just do not understand.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Oct 18 3.27pm

Originally posted by Den1923

The truth is that we are in for another battle to stay out the bottom three, we have had an easy start (Liverpool excepted) and the fact is that we have struggled against teams around us and have had some luck in getting the points we have so far. Lack of investment in the team during the summer is partly to blame and the reluctance of quality player wanting to come to CP for whatever reason. The progress of Bournemouth is an example of a team that has invested wisely in quality players that have come to the club and have delivered on the field. Why quality players find the thought of coming to palace so toxic I just do not understand.

I don't think it's that quality players don't want to come to palace . We have/had a few. It's our recruitment. Teams like bournemouth, wolves, even brighton seem to find players relatively cheaply who do well in the premiership. We pay a lot for 'premiership' players who on the whole have been dissapointing.

Edited by spartakev2 (04 Oct 2018 3.29pm)

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 04 Oct 18 3.31pm

Originally posted by Master Coin

To illustrate my earlier point here is a short list of teams who (as little as two years ago) many would have thought were safe bets for a mid-table finish:-

Swansea City
Stoke City

To be fair, that's s very small list to illustrate you're point &#129300;

 

Painter Flag Croydon 04 Oct 18 3.41pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

I don't think it's that quality players don't want to come to palace . We have/had a few. It's our recruitment. Teams like bournemouth, wolves, even brighton seem to find players relatively cheaply who do well in the premiership. We pay a lot for 'premiership' players who on the whole have been dissapointing.

Edited by spartakev2 (04 Oct 2018 3.29pm)

I doubt you know all the players the teams you quote have purchased, the total cost and how many were flops and never saw the first team. Our record on transfers is no different from other clubs our size.
Every Premiership clubs buy flops and expensive ones, that’s the reality.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 04 Oct 18 8.30pm

I find it funny that people still think if a billionaire bought us that we'd suddenly become free spending to move up the table.

Three words: Financial Fair Play.

We are where we are and are confined by our stature until we get a bigger capacity, win something or increase our income somehow other than a rich owner putting money into the club.

Clubs like Chelsea and Man City were lucky to get money pumped into them before the drawbridge was pulled up for the rest of us.

 

Den1923 Flag 04 Oct 18 9.21pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

I find it funny that people still think if a billionaire bought us that we'd suddenly become free spending to move up the table.

Three words: Financial Fair Play.

We are where we are and are confined by our stature until we get a bigger capacity, win something or increase our income somehow other than a rich owner putting money into the club.

Clubs like Chelsea and Man City were lucky to get money pumped into them before the drawbridge was pulled up for the rest of us.

what about Bournemouth and how have they done it?

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 04 Oct 18 9.57pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

I find it funny that people still think if a billionaire bought us that we'd suddenly become free spending to move up the table.

Three words: Financial Fair Play.

We are where we are and are confined by our stature until we get a bigger capacity, win something or increase our income somehow other than a rich owner putting money into the club.

Clubs like Chelsea and Man City were lucky to get money pumped into them before the drawbridge was pulled up for the rest of us.

This does seem to get bandied about a lot and I'm still unsure of how it works when the club we are playing on Saturday, Wolves can supposedly spend £70 million or so in the summer on their squad ?

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

davehuggins Flag 04 Oct 18 9.59pm

I really think something is not quite right at the moment. We are not playing with the spirit we were at the end of last year, we seem to be blowing hot and cold IMO. Wilf has gone off the boil since the Watford game. Just hope Roy can put the fire back asap

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 04 Oct 18 10.21pm

It’s all about our strikers for me. Benteke and Wickham are both quality strikers, or were, We’ve been incredibly unlucky to have one permanently injured for two years and the other one incapable of getting over a lack of form for one reason or another. If either were playing every week we would have been comfortably in the top ten last season. Also there’s obviously something wrong with our youth setup. Why are no young players coming through? Wan Bissaka only got his chance because we were so injury struck that Hodgson had no choice otherwise he would still be languishing in the youth team like all the others.

 

woody6013 Flag Bundaberg Queensland 04 Oct 18 10.56pm

Start of season looked good with only Liverpool to worry about for 9 games. However typical Palace to just make hard work of it all. Then with few minutes to go at Bournemouth and being warned bl.... stupid Sako elbows and its a penalty. We only deserved a point yet f...d that up, why oh why cant these talented overpaid individuals do the right thing and stop mauling. The rules regarding grabbing/shirt pulling and hands around waists should be banned for all. In my opinion it would make for a better game and we would see the real quality of football. 7 games in and I am already sick of this season and cpfc havent fronted the other 5 biggies. After 61 years of support and spending thousands to fly over for matches from Oz you would think I should know better. As an Ex Selsdon boy cant get further away than Queensland but often wish I could. Its painful and Ive gone grey after years of frustration but it would be impossible to change my allegience at 76. Beam me up Scotty

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why has there been no progress in 5 years?