You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game - Player Ratings
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from the game - Player Ratings


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 28 Oct 18 5.40pm

Finally something to cheer about at the ground. Always find it harder to analyse players at the actual game.

Hennessey 6 - Seem to claim the ball when needed, wasn't tested much apart from their 2 goals. Feel more comfortable with him in goal these days.

Wan Bissaka 8 - Excellent game, takes on players well and dealt with their attacks. Needs to work on his final ball however.

Tomkins N/A - Didn't see much to be honest, can't rate.

Sakho N/A - Same as above.

Luka 8 - Scored 2 penalties.

Van Aanholt 7 - One of my favourite players, links up well with Wilf. Provides an attacking option. Not his best game, but better than recent weeks.

Zaha 8 - Our best player on the ball by far, always looks like he can do something. Sometimes he doesn't pass early enough but then again if he did we'd probably only give it away.

Kouyate 7 - Best game in a palace kit so far.

Townsend 6 - Works his arse off but he ends up running the ball into dead positions. Hopefully form will change for him.

McCarthur 6 - Same as above, works hard, lacking final quality.

Ayew 5 - Disappointing, doesn't hold the ball up well and goes down too easily.

SUBS

Meyer 8 - Such a positive player in and around the opposition box. He needs to play more.

Sorloth 8 - Very impressive game today, we have given him stick but he has to start the next game. He held up the ball well and looked far more threatening than Ayew.

 

mattteo Flag 28 Oct 18 5.48pm

Zaha gets an 8 for runing his ass off and getting the team a 1 on 1 with the opposing gk situation and Milivojevic gets the same for just taking the shot?? FFS

Also...Meyer should pass the damn ball faster!! Definitely not an 8 deserving performance

Edited by mattteo (28 Oct 2018 5.49pm)

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 28 Oct 18 6.01pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Zaha gets an 8 for runing his ass off and getting the team a 1 on 1 with the opposing gk situation and Milivojevic gets the same for just taking the shot?? FFS

Also...Meyer should pass the damn ball faster!! Definitely not an 8 deserving performance

Edited by mattteo (28 Oct 2018 5.49pm)

Just my opinion mate!

 

Fatherken Flag 28 Oct 18 6.04pm

sorry Sakho always made himself available free for players to find and did lots of great work , not sure what you were looking at

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 28 Oct 18 6.15pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

sorry Sakho always made himself available free for players to find and did lots of great work , not sure what you were looking at

Like I said, I didn't see enough. Hard to see the defence from where I sit. Not saying he had a bad game.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 28 Oct 18 6.24pm

8s for Sorloth and Meyer? Don't think Luka performed brilliantly overall other than the two penalties.

To fill in the blanks, Tomkins put in yet another good defensive display, and Sakho distributed the ball well and didn't make any glaring mistakes - 7 apiece.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 28 Oct 18 6.34pm

Originally posted by tinribzzz

Like I said, I didn't see enough. Hard to see the defence from where I sit. Not saying he had a bad game.

You can see both full backs and goalkeeper, but not central defenders in either half.
Crikey where do you sit.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 28 Oct 18 6.47pm

All players came out all guns blazing today and gave a fantastic performance. A very well deserved point and really we should have come away with more - we weren't far off from "dominating" the game, and for the most part dictated it which is something we've missed for a considerable amount of time, dictating.

Van Aanholt wasnt his best today but still a good performance. Sorloth struggled with the pace and technicality of the game but put in all his effort and managed to be very important to the team, wonderful to finally see him get more than 5 minutes. Kouyate was great in midfield and very important also. As always Townsend put in the effort but struggles a little bit in spots.

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 28 Oct 18 7.16pm

Originally posted by Painter

You can see both full backs and goalkeeper, but not central defenders in either half.
Crikey where do you sit.

Block B, but arsenal didn't attack us much in the first half.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 28 Oct 18 7.29pm

Roy gets a 9 from me for bringing on some fresh legs with time for them to make an impact.

the fellas he took off looked tired and ayew was on a yellow. Well done Roy.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

matthau Flag South Croydon 28 Oct 18 7.32pm

Luka was poor besides the pens. Got caught out twice badly, didn’t seem quite as alert or energetic as the rest. But this is how he’s been all season mind

The rest were superb and Luka gets a 6 for me

Edited by matthau (28 Oct 2018 7.45pm)

 

Eagleder1 Flag 28 Oct 18 7.49pm

I just struggle to understand some supporters. There are those that applaude the team off the field following a decidedly lacklustre performance against Wolves and then those that can’t see the contribution put in by particularly the ever dependable Tompkins and today Sako who i thought together with Tompkins was outstanding. We have just played and aguably could have beaten, a team coming of the back of 11 straight victories and instead of commend and give credit to those who put in a really good shift we criticise them. Great result totally unexpected!

 

tinribzzz Flag BROMLEY 28 Oct 18 8.21pm

Originally posted by Eagleder1

I just struggle to understand some supporters. There are those that applaude the team off the field following a decidedly lacklustre performance against Wolves and then those that can’t see the contribution put in by particularly the ever dependable Tompkins and today Sako who i thought together with Tompkins was outstanding. We have just played and aguably could have beaten, a team coming of the back of 11 straight victories and instead of commend and give credit to those who put in a really good shift we criticise them. Great result totally unexpected!

I think you've misunderstood, I am not criticizing at all. Just realised from the game I was not paying enough attention to those 2. No where have I stated they were poor. I get carried away at the game enjoying myself I didn't notice those two as much.

Were you there today?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Oct 18 8.38pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Zaha gets an 8 for runing his ass off and getting the team a 1 on 1 with the opposing gk situation and Milivojevic gets the same for just taking the shot?? FFS

Also...Meyer should pass the damn ball faster!! Definitely not an 8 deserving performance

Edited by mattteo (28 Oct 2018 5.49pm)

Just my opinion but you are way off the mark there.

 

EssexEagle16 Flag Essex 28 Oct 18 11.48pm

Originally posted by tinribzzz

Finally something to cheer about at the ground. Always find it harder to analyse players at the actual game.

Hennessey 6 - Seem to claim the ball when needed, wasn't tested much apart from their 2 goals. Feel more comfortable with him in goal these days.

Wan Bissaka 8 - Excellent game, takes on players well and dealt with their attacks. Needs to work on his final ball however.

Tomkins N/A - Didn't see much to be honest, can't rate.

Sakho N/A - Same as above.

Luka 8 - Scored 2 penalties.

Van Aanholt 7 - One of my favourite players, links up well with Wilf. Provides an attacking option. Not his best game, but better than recent weeks.

Zaha 8 - Our best player on the ball by far, always looks like he can do something. Sometimes he doesn't pass early enough but then again if he did we'd probably only give it away.

Kouyate 7 - Best game in a palace kit so far.

Townsend 6 - Works his arse off but he ends up running the ball into dead positions. Hopefully form will change for him.

McCarthur 6 - Same as above, works hard, lacking final quality.

Ayew 5 - Disappointing, doesn't hold the ball up well and goes down too easily.

SUBS

Meyer 8 - Such a positive player in and around the opposition box. He needs to play more.

Sorloth 8 - Very impressive game today, we have given him stick but he has to start the next game. He held up the ball well and looked far more threatening than Ayew.

Have to agree about Sorloth. Think he changed the game when he came on and ran his heart out. Got to be pushing for a starting spot now in Benteke's absense. Think we need a target man up top to link the play up and Sorloth was just that today

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 28 Oct 18 11.55pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Roy gets a 9 from me for bringing on some fresh legs with time for them to make an impact.

the fellas he took off looked tired and ayew was on a yellow. Well done Roy.

Agree with this, Roy was proactive today and it made a difference.

 

viveasheagle Flag perth 29 Oct 18 2.13am

Having watched the game on TV it was good to have a bit of excitement and entertainment compared to some of the performances earlier this season. Thought both Sakho and Tomkins played well - particularly Sakho who I don't think missed a pass the whole game.
My only dissappointment was at 2-2 with Arsenal on the ropes we went into panic mode and starting hoofing ball up the park. If we had kept on doing what we were doing to get back into the game we could have created some more chances.
I would temper the excitment by saying Arsenal were missing almost their entire back 4 and their second line defenders were pretty average. They really missed players like Koscielny and Monreal but we did compete well in midfield and Arsenal barely threatened and their second goal should have been disallowed and the first was a softly conceeded free kick.

 

PhuketEagle Flag Phuket 29 Oct 18 6.03am

Saw the TV player ratings afterwards & they actually gave Arsenal better numbers than ours! Can't believe that as we were much better than them over the course of the game.
What did you think of Arse's first goal? I thought there was a hint of offside to it, or am I just biased?
The second shd definitely have been disallowed, a Maradona-like moment of clear cheating.
As my Dad always says "We should have won."

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 29 Oct 18 6.33am

Originally posted by Bangell

8s for Sorloth and Meyer? Don't think Luka performed brilliantly overall other than the two penalties.

To fill in the blanks, Tomkins put in yet another good defensive display, and Sakho distributed the ball well and didn't make any glaring mistakes - 7 apiece.

More importantly, Sakho seems to have had a serious talking to by the management/colleagues, because I was pleased to see him regularly passing back the ball to Hennessey rather than put himself and team mates under pressure.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 29 Oct 18 7.50am

Originally posted by lefty27

Agree with this, Roy was proactive today and it made a difference.

Also he had players on the bench in Meyer and Sørloth he could be proactive with. They are both young players and still new to the PL. But they both no look to have learned a lot and are ready to start. Sørloth should start ahead of Ayew but not sure that Meyer should start ahead of McArthur

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game - Player Ratings