This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| simonmdt |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Maine Eagle
Of course it’s typical. Why would it not be. Parish still in charge making the same old mistakes in managing the squad. Maybe Susannah Reid can have a word. Ayew and Sorloth, add in benteke and wickham and that’s why we can’t score goals. Lose Cabaye and RLC and that’s why the midfield is not working.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
people are being far too negative - we'll be fine, disappointing start, but the replacements for RLC and Cabaye can't be faulted unless you're another Professor Hindsight, other clubs appear to have superior 'models' but these set ups are usually temporary and come under pressure when the quality of recruitment dips, as it inevitably does, Watford and Bournemouth look very solid now, but so did Swansea, Stoke and West Brom not very long ago, and Southampton's selling status is finally catching up with them, Parrish got benteke and Wickham in not on a whim, but bcos of Pardew, and we were all delighted when he turned up and most were surprised he stooped to our level - Parrish has no doubt got up most of our managers' noses, he is not quite perfect, the new stand delay is frustrating, but I'd have him over Jordan or Noades any day, and we've had Bloye and Goldberg so careful casually knocking SP - we haven't got the money to do a Wolves, we're in a run against the top sides, we will rally and finish lower mid table again - we may be the new Coventry City - but some of us remember watching with Mullery and 4000 fans at home v Shrewsbury or Barnsley. Poor results lately, form picking up, January to come, England managers with Palace links all over the place, cheer up chaps.
Pro USA & Israel |
|
|
Originally posted by Bangell
You can't blame Roy for Sorloth being crap and lazy in the first place. We had striker problems all last season, and the remedy for that was to bring in Jordan Ayew on loan? Not good enough. I can and do blame Roy for Sorloth. You can't judge a player who doesn't get to play. A sporadic 10 minutes when the game has already gone, is not going to do anything to help settle a player into a system. Roy keeps saying he's good enough, then play the lad. He's had one start and what happened... Oh, He scored. We have had a problem scoring for a couple of seasons, your right there but could anyone say after Benteke scores 17 goals, that the next season he would only score 2 in an injury ravaged side? I think not. Look at Everton, they signed Rooney and then he couldn't get in the team, a team that was struggling for goals. Then they got Tosun? Scored a couple, now can't get in the team. He slated us in the press, now there's rumours that Everton want rid and guess who to. We are competing with at least 8 other Premiership sides for goal scorers. They all have the same money we do and the same problem, but the club are expected to easily identify one, spent a sh!t load of money and quality for Europe. Our problem wasn't that we didn't sign a forward, it's that we let one go in Murray and Parish has stated that his biggest regret was being talked into letting him go but again, if you have two managers in a row that wouldn't play him, were we really going to offer him a new contract. It's down to the manager to motivate and get the best out of the players and build a team. Our manager is Roy Hodgson. Roy will do OK for us (Hopefully) but it's going to be ugly.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
Originally posted by simonmdt
Don't be like that, we are all here for the love of palace... let's keep it civil
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by ex hibitionist
people are being far too negative - we'll be fine, disappointing start, but the replacements for RLC and Cabaye can't be faulted unless you're another Professor Hindsight, other clubs appear to have superior 'models' but these set ups are usually temporary and come under pressure when the quality of recruitment dips, as it inevitably does, Watford and Bournemouth look very solid now, but so did Swansea, Stoke and West Brom not very long ago, and Southampton's selling status is finally catching up with them, Parrish got benteke and Wickham in not on a whim, but bcos of Pardew, and we were all delighted when he turned up and most were surprised he stooped to our level - Parrish has no doubt got up most of our managers' noses, he is not quite perfect, the new stand delay is frustrating, but I'd have him over Jordan or Noades any day, and we've had Bloye and Goldberg so careful casually knocking SP - we haven't got the money to do a Wolves, we're in a run against the top sides, we will rally and finish lower mid table again - we may be the new Coventry City - but some of us remember watching with Mullery and 4000 fans at home v Shrewsbury or Barnsley. Poor results lately, form picking up, January to come, England managers with Palace links all over the place, cheer up chaps. Telling me no one could foresee that we would miss RLC or Cabaye? That Roy stating 6 months earlier in jan that we were already 7 players light on what he felt was a reasonable squad?? so to lose those lads, we are now 9 players short. Plus to lose and replace squad players.. we are weaker this season than last and last season we were screaming out for reinforcements. A proven striker should have been the key target, not 'Oh CW is back soon, he'll be like a new signing' or 'It's ok we'll just stick a winger up front'
This was once a quality forum.... |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
So you think a team who looked like getting relegated for a large part of the season and whose main striker scored three goals didn't need to buy a quality striker? We did signed two players who never made the first eleven. Not good enough You don't need to spend in line with other clubs. You just need to buy what you need. Of course it is about bringing in new players. Why do you think Allardyce and Pullis left? Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Nov 2018 4.42pm) I didn't say we don't need a striker. We obviously need someone who can put the ball in the back of the net. I was saying that it's not sustainable to spend 30 million every transfer window. You say, a failed Norwegian, I say how can we tell until he's played. Steve Mandanda, couldn't get in our side, now he has a world cup medal. There's a pattern here. Your right about Ayew, swapping him for Riedewald was a stupid idea. So glad he had the nuts to say no. But there is another player not even given a decent chance. Shocking and down right embarrassing, poor lad. It's a joke that Kelly gets on the pitch before he does. Bringing in Ayew was a mistake imho, That's down to our senior management, as is bringing in any player that turns out to be naff but that's football. Not getting the best out of a good team. We know who that's down to. I don't want Roy to go by any stretch, he's OK for us now and we won't go down. I said the same last season despite our record losing streak. I just feel we can do much better on the pitch even though we are clearly competitive. P.S. Pulis left because he didn't want to be here in the first place and thought he could stiff us for a couple of mill. Sam used us to revive his career after an embarrassing scandal virtually destroyed his reputation. We did him a huge favour and he did us one. Fair do's Sam and thanks. Pulis is just a t055er, imho, who did do a good job for us, much like Bruce and Dowie.
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
|
To be fair that was then, now is the perennial dog fight. We have been relegated from Prem four times so our stay up number is better than that Originally posted by dp
How I long for the days when a typical Palace season is one where we flirt with relegation and stay up. Football didn’t start five years ago. As far as I am concerned, a typical Palace Premiership season still ends in relegation.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by Vaibow
Telling me no one could foresee that we would miss RLC or Cabaye? That Roy stating 6 months earlier in jan that we were already 7 players light on what he felt was a reasonable squad?? so to lose those lads, we are now 9 players short. Plus to lose and replace squad players.. we are weaker this season than last and last season we were screaming out for reinforcements. A proven striker should have been the key target, not 'Oh CW is back soon, he'll be like a new signing' or 'It's ok we'll just stick a winger up front' We tried to re sign Cabaye, offered him a new contract, gut he didn't want for various reasons, Roy and Parish also high hopes of getting RLC back, probably would have cone if Chelsea hadn't changed manager
|
|
|
Originally posted by Mr Palaceman
I can and do blame Roy for Sorloth. You can't judge a player who doesn't get to play. A sporadic 10 minutes when the game has already gone, is not going to do anything to help settle a player into a system. Roy keeps saying he's good enough, then play the lad. He's had one start and what happened... Oh, He scored. We have had a problem scoring for a couple of seasons, your right there but could anyone say after Benteke scores 17 goals, that the next season he would only score 2 in an injury ravaged side? I think not. Look at Everton, they signed Rooney and then he couldn't get in the team, a team that was struggling for goals. Then they got Tosun? Scored a couple, now can't get in the team. He slated us in the press, now there's rumours that Everton want rid and guess who to. We are competing with at least 8 other Premiership sides for goal scorers. They all have the same money we do and the same problem, but the club are expected to easily identify one, spent a sh!t load of money and quality for Europe. Our problem wasn't that we didn't sign a forward, it's that we let one go in Murray and Parish has stated that his biggest regret was being talked into letting him go but again, if you have two managers in a row that wouldn't play him, were we really going to offer him a new contract. It's down to the manager to motivate and get the best out of the players and build a team. Our manager is Roy Hodgson. Roy will do OK for us (Hopefully) but it's going to be ugly. How do you think you know more about Sorloth, than Roy and Ray who both have years of experience. They see him train everyday, but you who has never seen him train know better.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER
We tried to re sign Cabaye, offered him a new contract, but he didn't want for various reasons, We don't know what terms were offered though and it's my guess that they were greatly reduced from his existing terms
|
|
|
I expect he was offered more elsewhere so we offered below going rate and expected him to agree? Sadly, as daft as that sounds would not be surprised. Planning on vague assumption RLC might be available again also sounds possible but would not think Roy had any input into Cabaye wages or assumption RLC might be available Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
We don't know what terms were offered though and it's my guess that they were greatly reduced from his existing terms
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER
We tried to re sign Cabaye, offered him a new contract, gut he didn't want for various reasons, Roy and Parish also high hopes of getting RLC back, probably would have cone if Chelsea hadn't changed manager We knew Cabaye was leaving months ahead of time. If anyone on here still thinks Meyer can do what Cabaye did for us, I would be surprised. I am not saying Meyer is a poor player, but he is nowhere near strong enough in the tackle to be up there with Cabaye. Cabaye got a lot of stick for not scoring 30 yarders every week but he was an important cog for us, a player who could not only break up play but could pick a pass. Meyer is good at the latter but not strong enough at the former in this league as yet. As for RLC you cannot build your team or tactics around loan players. As soon as he got picked for the World Cup we must have known we would not get him, and it was OBVIOUS Chelsea would get a new manager in. We failed to replace RLC whatsoever, and so far don’t have a player doing what Cabaye did last year.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I expect he was offered more elsewhere so we offered below going rate and expected him to agree? Sadly, as daft as that sounds would not be surprised. Planning on vague assumption RLC might be available again also sounds possible but would not think Roy had any input into Cabaye wages or assumption RLC might be available I am sure he was offered a lot more in Dubai, they’re are not known for being short of money. He is 32 years old, can’t complete a Premier game. He would get a signing on fee and huge wages in Dubai with easier games each week. Why would he want to resign for us and why would we keep his wages the same on higher, when he can’t finish a game at this level. It’s not hard to work out, what occurred.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
I am sure he was offered a lot more in Dubai, they’re are not known for being short of money. He is 32 years old, can’t complete a Premier game. He would get a signing on fee and huge wages in Dubai with easier games each week. Why would he want to resign for us and why would we keep his wages the same on higher, when he can’t finish a game at this level. It’s not hard to work out, what occurred. And no income taxes.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Painter
How do you think you know about Sorloth, than Roy and Ray who both have years of experience. They see him train everyday, but you who has never seen him train know better. I have never said that know more about Sorloth than Roy, that would be ridiculous. He does see him in training everyday. There are players that do wonders in training but then come match day, they are poor and vice versa. But I don't care what anyone says, you can never really see how a player is going to do in a team unless they get a good run of games. Am I wrong? The world and his wife want a striker that can strike. Benteke was amazing in training last season, Roy said it lots of times in his press conferences. I personally thought that he would come good, as did many others and his contribution to the team when he did play was great but no goals. My main point is that, we have brought in players to improve the squad and we're not giving them a decent chance. They can't even get a shout ahead of the player they have been brought in to improve on. I say again, if Ward hadn't been injured, I can't see how Roy would have ever given AWB a chance in the first team. We now know how good he is purely by chance. Riedawald, not given a decent chance, Guiata, not give a decent chance, Sorloth, not being given a decent chance but Ayew, who everyone knows all about can get a start, Schllup, who is a good left back, gets played, out of position, Kelly, a good squad player, gets played ahead of Jairo. McArthur, played out of position, Townsend, played out of position, Zaha, played out of position, Meyer, played out of position. Those decisions are made by the manager and that's why we are where we are. It's not terrible, I say again, I don't think we will go down but wave goodbye to a comfortable, season where we push on, as we all hoped for. We're going to have another "Palace Season", and that's cool, I just wanted a little more this time. Roy does see his players day in day out but we look at the league table and imho, we should be doing better with what I think is one of the best Palace squads I have seen in a long while. P.S, I mentioned Rooney and Tosun to highlight that everyone is looking for a goal scorer but it doesn't always work out, even for bigger or the biggest clubs. If Everton didn't give Rooney games after signing him, fans would wonder why..
"You can lead a horse to water but a pencil must be lead" Stan Laurel |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.