Jeffrey Schlupp

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jeffrey Schlupp

Visit the current forum | Forum Rules

Page 3 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

Glazier#1 15 Feb 19 10.01pm
Originally posted by Petereagle For me it shows how much we have been missing with Cabaye leaving, who really fought hard defensively but was still great on the attack with Hugh pass completions. Neither Schlupp nor Meyer are as sound defensively whereas McArthur does offer a lot defensively but has lost a lot of edge going forward Agree

Glazier#1

15 Feb 19 10.01pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

For me it shows how much we have been missing with Cabaye leaving, who really fought hard defensively but was still great on the attack with Hugh pass completions. Neither Schlupp nor Meyer are as sound defensively whereas McArthur does offer a lot defensively but has lost a lot of edge going forward

Agree

dreamwaverider London 15 Feb 19 11.27pm
Scluppie is one of our best players

dreamwaverider

London 15 Feb 19 11.27pm

Scluppie is one of our best players

kennybrowns leftfoot Reigate 15 Feb 19 11.28pm
Originally posted by Petereagle For me it shows how much we have been missing with Cabaye leaving, who really fought hard defensively but was still great on the attack with Hugh pass completions. Neither Schlupp nor Meyer are as sound defensively whereas McArthur does offer a lot defensively but has lost a lot of edge going forward Agree with this.... I sometimes used to think towards the end that we wouldn't miss Cabaye... How wrong I was! I still don't know quite what Schlupp is?... Left back? Left winger? Centre midfielder?... What I do know is that Roy clearly rates him. Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

kennybrowns leftfoot

Reigate 15 Feb 19 11.28pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Agree with this.... I sometimes used to think towards the end that we wouldn't miss Cabaye... How wrong I was!

I still don't know quite what Schlupp is?... Left back? Left winger? Centre midfielder?... What I do know is that Roy clearly rates him.

Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

taylors lovechild 16 Feb 19 11.40am
My issue with Schlupp this season has been how slow he has been to track back, which has cost us a couple of goals at least, but in his last game he did actually put some leg work in and chased back to good effect. His plus points are that he is surprisingly good in the air for someone who is a modest 6' and over short distances he is incredibly quick, plus of course he has a good shot on him. On the downside, if you look at his stats (average per game) his pass success rate is worse than the rest of the midfield, he has no assists, offers very few key passes and is below every outfield player bar Meyer in terms of successful tackles. (stats taken from here [Link] ) I know you can't base a player on their stats, but from looking at them they basically confirm what I see when I watch him that being he is good offensively but questionable defensively. I do wonder his best position is as a striker/forward, rather than a midfielder.

taylors lovechild

16 Feb 19 11.40am

My issue with Schlupp this season has been how slow he has been to track back, which has cost us a couple of goals at least, but in his last game he did actually put some leg work in and chased back to good effect. His plus points are that he is surprisingly good in the air for someone who is a modest 6' and over short distances he is incredibly quick, plus of course he has a good shot on him.

On the downside, if you look at his stats (average per game) his pass success rate is worse than the rest of the midfield, he has no assists, offers very few key passes and is below every outfield player bar Meyer in terms of successful tackles.

(stats taken from here [Link] )

I know you can't base a player on their stats, but from looking at them they basically confirm what I see when I watch him that being he is good offensively but questionable defensively. I do wonder his best position is as a striker/forward, rather than a midfielder.

ripleyeagle Ripley Surrey 16 Feb 19 3.09pm
Originally posted by Maine Eagle Schlupp....is on the up.....yup..... I have royally slated Schluppers many times, but honestly he deserved it at times as his performances earlier in the season were dire. Lo and behold with a run of games in a similar position he is now starting to fire. He is still pretty clumsy and lacks accurate passing at times, however he does bring some solid attributes to the party. He is strong, quick, and does like to get a shot off and has a cheeky eye for goal. I think I would play him ahead of MaCarthur right now as Jimmy Mac is having a poor run. Previously when someone got Schlupped it was us, with a mistake or poor performance, however these days it is the opposition getting Schlupped by Jeffrey. You never fail to get in a dig at Jimmy Mac do you,even when the post is about Schlupp.

ripleyeagle

Ripley Surrey 16 Feb 19 3.09pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Schlupp....is on the up.....yup.....

I have royally slated Schluppers many times, but honestly he deserved it at times as his performances earlier in the season were dire.

Lo and behold with a run of games in a similar position he is now starting to fire.

He is still pretty clumsy and lacks accurate passing at times, however he does bring some solid attributes to the party.

He is strong, quick, and does like to get a shot off and has a cheeky eye for goal. I think I would play him ahead of MaCarthur right now as Jimmy Mac is having a poor run.

Previously when someone got Schlupped it was us, with a mistake or poor performance, however these days it is the opposition getting Schlupped by Jeffrey.

You never fail to get in a dig at Jimmy Mac do you,even when the post is about Schlupp.

Maine Eagle USA 16 Feb 19 4.43pm
Originally posted by ripleyeagle You never fail to get in a dig at Jimmy Mac do you,even when the post is about Schlupp. When discussing our midfield players it’s hard not to point out one who needs a rest. I used to dig out Schlupp on the regular too, but he turned me around with taking his chances for goals and his all around improvement. Sorry to point it out but based on that criteria Macca deserves some criticism. Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle

USA 16 Feb 19 4.43pm

Originally posted by ripleyeagle

You never fail to get in a dig at Jimmy Mac do you,even when the post is about Schlupp.

When discussing our midfield players it’s hard not to point out one who needs a rest.

I used to dig out Schlupp on the regular too, but he turned me around with taking his chances for goals and his all around improvement.

Sorry to point it out but based on that criteria Macca deserves some criticism.

Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Tickled pink Cornwall 16 Feb 19 6.45pm
Originally posted by Petereagle For me it shows how much we have been missing with Cabaye leaving, who really fought hard defensively but was still great on the attack with Hugh pass completions. Neither Schlupp nor Meyer are as sound defensively whereas McArthur does offer a lot defensively but has lost a lot of edge going forward Nonsense, he gets himself into great positions ..very very unfortunate not to score more.

Tickled pink

Cornwall 16 Feb 19 6.45pm

Originally posted by Petereagle

Nonsense, he gets himself into great positions ..very very unfortunate not to score more.

kennybrowns leftfoot Reigate 16 Feb 19 6.53pm
Originally posted by dreamwaverider Scluppie is one of our best players This comment is a joke right?? Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

kennybrowns leftfoot

Reigate 16 Feb 19 6.53pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Scluppie is one of our best players

This comment is a joke right??

Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

Tickled pink Cornwall 16 Feb 19 6.57pm
Originally posted by Maine Eagle When discussing our midfield players it’s hard not to point out one who needs a rest. I used to dig out Schlupp on the regular too, but he turned me around with taking his chances for goals and his all around improvement. Sorry to point it out but based on that criteria Macca deserves some criticism. Many think Schlupp is rather careless with distribution and I agree and almost every one of our players has been criticised for being silly with scoring opportunities ...not just McArthur who when you look at the teams performances on the pitch stands out as a positive for me every single time he plays.

Tickled pink

Cornwall 16 Feb 19 6.57pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

When discussing our midfield players it’s hard not to point out one who needs a rest.

I used to dig out Schlupp on the regular too, but he turned me around with taking his chances for goals and his all around improvement.

Sorry to point it out but based on that criteria Macca deserves some criticism.

Many think Schlupp is rather careless with distribution and I agree and almost every one of our players has been criticised for being silly with scoring opportunities ...not just McArthur who when you look at the teams performances on the pitch stands out as a positive for me every single time he plays.

Tickled pink Cornwall 16 Feb 19 7.02pm
Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot This comment is a joke right?? Yes, it is.

Tickled pink

Cornwall 16 Feb 19 7.02pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

This comment is a joke right??

Yes, it is.

Rachid Rachid Rachid 16 Feb 19 8.59pm
Schlupp and JM are both good players.Roy and Ray have managed to get a tune out of JS that most on these boards didn’t think existed and improved him as player rather than dismiss him as a championship left back who we paid too much for. Personally couldn’t give a monkeys who starts out of Meyer, JM and Schlupp as there’s little in it. It’s a squad game.

Rachid Rachid Rachid

16 Feb 19 8.59pm

Schlupp and JM are both good players.Roy and Ray have managed to get a tune out of JS that most on these boards didn’t think existed and improved him as player rather than dismiss him as a championship left back who we paid too much for.

Personally couldn’t give a monkeys who starts out of Meyer, JM and Schlupp as there’s little in it. It’s a squad game.

deetee 16 Feb 19 9.38pm
Meyer should start more he always makes a difference off the bench

deetee

16 Feb 19 9.38pm

Meyer should start more he always makes a difference off the bench

Rachid Rachid Rachid 16 Feb 19 9.44pm
Originally posted by deetee Meyer should start more he always makes a difference off the bench What is Meyer's best position apart from substitute ?

Rachid Rachid Rachid

16 Feb 19 9.44pm

Originally posted by deetee

Meyer should start more he always makes a difference off the bench

What is Meyer's best position apart from substitute ?

braunstoneagle the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 16 Feb 19 10.25pm
i have to say...i was sceptical of schlupps signing, it was expensive and big on wages. however, it has to be said, whenever called upon he has done a solid if not spectacular job, which is fine. it has been mooted he is the best finisher at the club, and has chipped in with a few goals. i have changed my opinion on him, he in my eyes is now a solid versatile player who when called upon does a solod job. however, i would rather max start in front of him, but thats not my call, its roys...and in my eyes roy can do nothing wrong whatsoever. ‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway

braunstoneagle

the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 16 Feb 19 10.25pm

i have to say...i was sceptical of schlupps signing, it was expensive and big on wages.

however, it has to be said, whenever called upon he has done a solid if not spectacular job, which is fine.

it has been mooted he is the best finisher at the club, and has chipped in with a few goals.

i have changed my opinion on him, he in my eyes is now a solid versatile player who when called upon does a solod job.

however, i would rather max start in front of him, but thats not my call, its roys...and in my eyes roy can do nothing wrong whatsoever.

‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway

Maine Eagle USA 16 Feb 19 11.17pm
Originally posted by braunstoneagle i have to say...i was sceptical of schlupps signing, it was expensive and big on wages. however, it has to be said, whenever called upon he has done a solid if not spectacular job, which is fine. it has been mooted he is the best finisher at the club, and has chipped in with a few goals. i have changed my opinion on him, he in my eyes is now a solid versatile player who when called upon does a solod job. however, i would rather max start in front of him, but thats not my call, its roys...and in my eyes roy can do nothing wrong whatsoever. Harry Kane on corners? Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Maine Eagle

USA 16 Feb 19 11.17pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i have to say...i was sceptical of schlupps signing, it was expensive and big on wages.

however, it has to be said, whenever called upon he has done a solid if not spectacular job, which is fine.

it has been mooted he is the best finisher at the club, and has chipped in with a few goals.

i have changed my opinion on him, he in my eyes is now a solid versatile player who when called upon does a solod job.

however, i would rather max start in front of him, but thats not my call, its roys...and in my eyes roy can do nothing wrong whatsoever.

Harry Kane on corners?

Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

ChrisGC Wantage 16 Feb 19 11.33pm
Originally posted by Maine Eagle Harry Kane on corners? Careful now, you've made fair criticisms of both SP and Hodgson in a short space of time. That's thoughtcrime around these parts...

ChrisGC

Wantage 16 Feb 19 11.33pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Harry Kane on corners?

Careful now, you've made fair criticisms of both SP and Hodgson in a short space of time. That's thoughtcrime around these parts...

syd snot munich 17 Feb 19 12.47am
End of the day the bloke plays football better than any f***er on here could dream of. Leave him be

syd snot

munich 17 Feb 19 12.47am

End of the day the bloke plays football better than any f***er on here could dream of. Leave him be

Midlands Eagle 17 Feb 19 8.35am
Originally posted by syd snot End of the day the bloke plays football better than any f***er on here could dream of. Leave him be That's not really a valid reason on a discussion forum. Eddie The Eagle can ski better than I can so does that make him immune from criticism?

Midlands Eagle

17 Feb 19 8.35am

Originally posted by syd snot

End of the day the bloke plays football better than any f***er on here could dream of. Leave him be

That's not really a valid reason on a discussion forum.

Eddie The Eagle can ski better than I can so does that make him immune from criticism?

ARGILE OLD GEEZER PORTIMAO 17 Feb 19 9.08am
Originally posted by ChrisGC Careful now, you've made fair criticisms of both SP and Hodgson in a short space of time. That's thoughtcrime around these parts... Quite right too, the crime bit i mean

ARGILE OLD GEEZER

PORTIMAO 17 Feb 19 9.08am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Careful now, you've made fair criticisms of both SP and Hodgson in a short space of time. That's thoughtcrime around these parts...

Quite right too, the crime bit i mean

ChrisGC Wantage 17 Feb 19 9.12am
Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER Quite right too, the crime bit i mean Haha, I knew that would get a bite :-)

ChrisGC

Wantage 17 Feb 19 9.12am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Quite right too, the crime bit i mean

Haha, I knew that would get a bite :-)

Page 3 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

Crystal Palace FC Supporters' Website - The Holmesdale Online

Jeffrey Schlupp

Site Map