You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > When is enough…enough?
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

When is enough…enough?


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 29 Mar 19 12.34am

Yes I am with you Jamesey it’s just a part of life, I’ve made my bed and this is it for the time being but in years to come it hopefully will be better and we will look back remembering those lean years but it could also get worse.
P.S could be a few extra seats available for the displaced E blockers, perhaps it’s a secret plan !

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 29 Mar 19 9.15am

Promotion to the premier league has been a double-edged sword. The money has been both a blessing and a curse. We have bigger attendances and I think received around £700m, which has helped buy the training ground, clad the main stand, create a fan zone and do the club shop up. Its also allowed us to be competitive in transfers, with both fees and wages for players.

However it’s a results based business and when transfer fees and wages are boarding on obscene the average joe supporter that has to graft is entitled to be the raving hump when supposedly star players can't do the basics right, such as passing, taking free kicks and corners and in tekkers case putting the ball in the back of the net (3 leagues goals in two seasons and 120k per week – blimey!)

Hopefully the January clear out was a sign that Steve P has had enough like us and is going to do something about it. I think he needs to start trying to get the fans back on side and one way would be to take a leaf out of Vichai Srivaddhanaprabha's book. I think a simple message in his match day program notes saying "thanks for our support even though the home form as been crap for a while but its being worked on…and by the way have a free half time beer on us" would be a good start.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 29 Mar 19 9.54am

Originally posted by martin2412

Originally posted by glaziermart

This is total BS peddled by the OP and others on here. We are playing in the best league in the world as proven by our clubs in Europe. The simple fact is that most of the time we have just not converted our many chances in the home games, but we have scored more per ratio of chances in away games. We have murdered West Ham 1-1, Cardiff 0-0, should have scored 10 Against Burnley, but only beat them 2-0. The only really bad performances were Brighton and Watford at home, i accept that, although in the case of the Watford game we still had about 20 odd good chances. If we were regularly losing and not creating, i could understand the anger on here, but to trot out the usual comments 'they don't try anymore' and 'they get paid too much' etc. That just does not wash

This is the typical Palace attitude, and acceptance of mediocrity. Could've, should've, might've - well we didn't.

With the squad we have, there are 4 or 5 teams who are above us who shouldn't be, and none of them have been in the league longer than us this time around.

I bet Cardiff were delighted being battered 0 - 0 away from home, and West Ham will look at it as 2 points dropped, as Selhurst Park has become the away team's banker. Huddersfield will certainly be looking at it that way on Saturday.

I think that rather than it being a typical Palace attitude - which may well exist - I think it shows how fine a line there is between success and failure. Had we taken some of those chances - (only a handful required) and beaten those teams whilst playing the Same Style of football then the glazierMarts of this world will still be optimists, but the difference is that most of the Martins of This world will have joined him.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

RedandBlueArmy! Flag Croydon 30 Mar 19 7.20pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

ok let’s cut the crap that Palace did really well today to beat Huddersfield. We played really badly and were luck not to end up loosing.
Every season we play this game of will we stay up or not.
We have really good players on our books now, we are not the Palace of 4 or 5 or 6 years ago.
Someone needs to read these players And management the riot act, someone is not pushing these players hard enough to achieve what we want to achieve, someone is complacent and is happy for us to just barely stay in the PL.
Mr Parish you are a very successful businessman so you must see that we are allowing ourselves to stagnate and not conquer this league.
If management needs changing then so be it have a spring clean but do something.

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 30 Mar 19 7.35pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

Maybe the January clear out was the start of something...the club looks like it aware things ain't right and although I don't condone booing our own team as happened today, its maybe a way to get a point across in no uncertain terms...

However in SP's program note at least he highlighted there's a problem.

"I have acknowledged previously in these notes that results at Selhurst Park this season have not yielded enough points, and I can understand how frustrating that must have been at times for you as loyal supporters. Roy and the players are acutely aware of it, but now is the time to rally round as a club and throw your support behind the team, even if at times things aren’t going to plan on the pitch.

Thank you for your continued support.

Up the Palace."

[Link]

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 30 Mar 19 7.45pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

Who has said that we did really well today to beat Huddersfield?

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 30 Mar 19 7.58pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

Well we did win. Many a time over the last few seasons we would have lost a game like that. 3 points and move on.

 

Alex1991 Flag Ashford 30 Mar 19 9.36pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

We played poorly first half and defensively we were iffy all game. However, our quality eventually came through. Let's not forget we lost this game 3-0 last season, albeit under different circumstances.

 


"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 30 Mar 19 9.40pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by RedandBlueArmy!

ok let’s cut the crap that Palace did really well today to beat Huddersfield. We played really badly and were luck not to end up loosing.
Every season we play this game of will we stay up or not.
We have really good players on our books now, we are not the Palace of 4 or 5 or 6 years ago.
Someone needs to read these players And management the riot act, someone is not pushing these players hard enough to achieve what we want to achieve, someone is complacent and is happy for us to just barely stay in the PL.
Mr Parish you are a very successful businessman so you must see that we are allowing ourselves to stagnate and not conquer this league.
If management needs changing then so be it have a spring clean but do something.

Not sure if it is about pushing the players to perform than a lack of ability to adapt to different opposition tactics. When teams come at us we look threatening but breaking down teams we struggle. Wolves, who have been better than us employing this system have looked a little similar at times. Again today it looked like the players weren't gelling and seemed to get in each others way or lose possession with poor passing. Solution might have to come from the transfer market but don't think we have been very clever at times previously there. Maybe our best bit of business will be to get somebody in who knows what they are doing in the market ?

Edited by Booted Eagle (30 Mar 2019 9.40pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

roystoneagle Flag modsville;hove actually 31 Mar 19 12.18am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

i think that the team we have today is ultimately the best team we have ever had...some strength in depth too (albeit assisted by the batsman loan)

i can't help but feel that these players , coached in a progressive modern way would be pushing for this europe thing that so often the club has muted.

i think Roys is doing all 'he' can with all he has...however all 'he' can ...and all 'someone else' can may , and i suspect, are, two very different things.

Roy has all the attributes a 'director of football' needs that dougie doesn't have. Keep him on board for the rest of his life as an advisor to the 'chairman/owner fans'

a new, progressive manager for next season would breath new life into this team that is being stifled by its own leadership....

can you imagine this group of players mixed with a wagner/hassenhutle type

i sense we need a dowie moment (the good one, not the run out of ideas one) where upon a fresh approach to training and tactics bring about remarkable on field performances.

today i actually was dying for huddersfield to score, as for a moment, it seemed the only way we were actually going to step up a gear....c'mon terriers ...woof it in

 


“He’s six foot something, fit as a flea, good looking – he’s got to have something wrong with him. Hopefully he’s hung like a hamster – That would make us all feel better. Having said that, me missus has got a pet hamster at home, and his cock’s massive.”

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 31 Mar 19 10.15am

Maybe if we play as bad again against Everton as we did first half yesterday we should all down programs and do a frank...wonder how mush our players would enjoy playing in front of an empty holmesdale...might make Mr Parish do something...like move Uncle Roy into another role.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 31 Mar 19 11.18am

Originally posted by HesHereHesThere

Maybe if we play as bad again against Everton as we did first half yesterday we should all down programs and do a frank...wonder how mush our players would enjoy playing in front of an empty holmesdale...might make Mr Parish do something...like move Uncle Roy into another role.

It looks like we'll survive for another season so one would expect news of ownership, managerial appointment, transfers etc to happen close season. Saying that in typical Palace fashion it'll all happen at the proverbial 11.55 moment...

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 31 Mar 19 11.25am

We are all but safe. It’s time for Roy to experiment a bit and try and get a 90 minute performance out of our team. I thought we looked better yesterday when Wilf got further forward and supporting Bats, so maybe a couple of changes to assist this.

1) we are clearly not getting the best out of PVA, he is a capable quick counter attacking player but has defensive frailties, so maybe it’s time to move Schlupp to left back and PVA to left midfield. This will allow Wilf to drift more inside. If this fails then you have Meyer who can slot in there (if looking for an aggressive substitution) and our third defensive minded midfielder (if we are looking to tighten it up or close a game out).

2) we look solid with Milivojevic and Kouyate or McArthur but is it realistic to have all 3 of them on the pitch at one time? For me it has to be Luka plus one other. Andros should keep his place right side.

3) Bats struggles to hold up play or win 50:50s he is a different sort of player and needs someone close by so that they can link up play. Moving Wilf closer to him is I think beneficial .

This is just my view on what I have seen this season, happy to be shot down and expecting to be with the PVA suggestion but I genuinely think it is worth a go.

 

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 31 Mar 19 12.01pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

We are all but safe. It’s time for Roy to experiment a bit and try and get a 90 minute performance out of our team. I thought we looked better yesterday when Wilf got further forward and supporting Bats, so maybe a couple of changes to assist this.

1) we are clearly not getting the best out of PVA, he is a capable quick counter attacking player but has defensive frailties, so maybe it’s time to move Schlupp to left back and PVA to left midfield. This will allow Wilf to drift more inside. If this fails then you have Meyer who can slot in there (if looking for an aggressive substitution) and our third defensive minded midfielder (if we are looking to tighten it up or close a game out).

2) we look solid with Milivojevic and Kouyate or McArthur but is it realistic to have all 3 of them on the pitch at one time? For me it has to be Luka plus one other. Andros should keep his place right side.

3) Bats struggles to hold up play or win 50:50s he is a different sort of player and needs someone close by so that they can link up play. Moving Wilf closer to him is I think beneficial .

This is just my view on what I have seen this season, happy to be shot down and expecting to be with the PVA suggestion but I genuinely think it is worth a go.

I understand your point about PVA & Schlupp but here is why I disagree. While PVA doesn't cut out as many passes as I would like he still closes down his mark well and prevents crosses. He and Schlupp have developed a good understanding that allows both to attack when required. I not one of those who thinks Meyer is so much superior to Schlupp that he should be in the side instead. Schlupp is more consistently active and is a more consistent player than Meyer. Remember, Meyer is only 19 playing his first season in England. He is coming along nicely.

Getting back to PVA and Schluppp, a 4-3-3 doesn't play as well to their respective strengths as a 4-4-2. Roy has had the luxury (especially since it's Palace) of having depth in the midfield with Kouyate and McArthur giving him options every match. Football is slowly evolving into a full roster game from a set starting XI. I believe we have to get used to squad rotation and a bit of horses for courses. For example, I see changes coming for Wednesday with rither McArthur or Kouyate starting with Milivojevic and Townsend in midfield and Meyer returning to the subs bench. PVA will have his hands full on the left of defense and Schlupp (or perhaps he sits for the addition of both Kouyate and McArthur) will need to support him more than usual. I am absolutely certain that PVA is our best choice at LB, My other question for Wednesday is whether Kelly or Dann starts with Tomkins.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 31 Mar 19 12.58pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

I understand your point about PVA & Schlupp but here is why I disagree. While PVA doesn't cut out as many passes as I would like he still closes down his mark well and prevents crosses. He and Schlupp have developed a good understanding that allows both to attack when required. I not one of those who thinks Meyer is so much superior to Schlupp that he should be in the side instead. Schlupp is more consistently active and is a more consistent player than Meyer. Remember, Meyer is only 19 playing his first season in England. He is coming along nicely.

Getting back to PVA and Schluppp, a 4-3-3 doesn't play as well to their respective strengths as a 4-4-2. Roy has had the luxury (especially since it's Palace) of having depth in the midfield with Kouyate and McArthur giving him options every match. Football is slowly evolving into a full roster game from a set starting XI. I believe we have to get used to squad rotation and a bit of horses for courses. For example, I see changes coming for Wednesday with rither McArthur or Kouyate starting with Milivojevic and Townsend in midfield and Meyer returning to the subs bench. PVA will have his hands full on the left of defense and Schlupp (or perhaps he sits for the addition of both Kouyate and McArthur) will need to support him more than usual. I am absolutely certain that PVA is our best choice at LB, My other question for Wednesday is whether Kelly or Dann starts with Tomkins.

He really doesn't. .....

But I do agree that he is our best option af LB. I also agree that schlupp shoukd start ahead of meyer. At the moment meyer is better used as an impact sub. Although schlupp is a bit if a headless chicken, I love his enthusiasm and when he drives forward i always feel something might happen...
We're probably in the minority though

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 31 Mar 19 1.26pm

I thought Huddersfield targeted our L/H/S yesterday. In the first 5 mins PVA had given the ball away 4 times and after 12 mins Schlupp and PVA had given it away a combined 11. I got a bit bored counting after that TBH.

Schlupp is really frustrating, one minute he might do something really good like his touch for the shot when he slipped yesterday but then cocks up the simple stuff like passing.

PVA looks shaky to me at LB. For example Brighton's winner the other week needed him to get a foot on the ball but he let Knockheart (however his name is spelled) continue his run and score. I think competition for PVA next season is a must so he's no longer a shoe in at LB.

I was convinced Schlupp was going to be replaced by Kouyaté as he was having a bad game but Roy must see something different. Maybe Mr H should have a watch from the upper sometime?

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 31 Mar 19 1.28pm

Originally posted by HesHereHesThere

I thought Huddersfield targeted our L/H/S yesterday. In the first 5 mins PVA had given the ball away 4 times and after 12 mins Schlupp and PVA had given it away a combined 11. I got a bit bored counting after that TBH.

Schlupp is really frustrating, one minute he might do something really good like his touch for the shot when he slipped yesterday but then cocks up the simple stuff like passing.

PVA looks shaky to me at LB. For example Brighton's winner the other week needed him to get a foot on the ball but he let Knockheart (however his name is spelled) continue his run and score. I think competition for PVA next season is a must so he's no longer a shoe in at LB.

I was convinced Schlupp was going to be replaced by Kouyaté as he was having a bad game but Roy must see something different. Maybe Mr H should have a watch from the upper sometime?


Too many abbreviations to make that remotely understandable

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 31 Mar 19 2.01pm

Originally posted by matthau


Too many abbreviations to make that remotely understandable

Sorry - L/H/S "Left hand side", TBH "To be honest" and LB "Left back" and upper is Upper Holmesdale

 

HesHereHesThere Flag Beckenham 01 Apr 19 12.30pm

After the first 70 mins on Saturday all three season tickets were nearly in the bin let alone renewing for next season.

It’s got to change at some point though.

 

est1905 Flag 02 Apr 19 5.43pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'wake up' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by RedandBlueArmy!

ok let’s cut the crap that Palace did really well today to beat Huddersfield. We played really badly and were luck not to end up loosing.
Every season we play this game of will we stay up or not.
We have really good players on our books now, we are not the Palace of 4 or 5 or 6 years ago.
Someone needs to read these players And management the riot act, someone is not pushing these players hard enough to achieve what we want to achieve, someone is complacent and is happy for us to just barely stay in the PL.
Mr Parish you are a very successful businessman so you must see that we are allowing ourselves to stagnate and not conquer this league.
If management needs changing then so be it have a spring clean but do something.

I thought that was the best I have seen Huddersfield play all season (out of the times I have seen them of course which must be five or six inc TV games they've been on and against us).
If they had played like that every game they might well have stayed up.
And to think idiots on here think Wagner is a better option for us than Hodgson!

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > When is enough…enough?