You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best three replacements if Roy steps down
November 16 2026 6.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best three replacements if Roy steps down


Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
spartakev2 Flag Anerley 08 Apr 19 5.13pm

Originally posted by est1905

Oh well, if he interviews well........

That and the fact that he did an unbelievable job with Huddersfield. ...getting them up was huge, keeping them up for even one season was huge. I don't think any manager could have kept them up for a second season.

 

est1905 Flag 08 Apr 19 5.21pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

That and the fact that he did an unbelievable job with Huddersfield. ...getting them up was huge, keeping them up for even one season was huge. I don't think any manager could have kept them up for a second season.

....But you think he is the only man that could have kept them up in the first season?
Rubbish.
Even Holloway (who turned out to be out of his depth) nearly kept little Blackpool up.
Wagner is overrated by some on here. I'll bet he wont be back in the Premiership any time soon

 

manoftaste Flag Hastings 08 Apr 19 5.21pm

I like the Gerrard suggestion (if we could get him). Would be a bit like when we recruited Steve Coppell - great player, very young and inexperienced as a manager, respected by players, everything to prove. But why would Gerrard leave Rangers?
Further thought: We all know Roy will retire sooner rather than later, so why isn't a replacement already lined up and working as his assistant? Maybe Popovich would be interested in deputising for a year or two (if he could be tempted back from Oz to the grey skies of SE25).

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 08 Apr 19 5.52pm

Originally posted by est1905

....But you think he is the only man that could have kept them up in the first season?

Rubbish.
Even Holloway (who turned out to be out of his depth) nearly kept little Blackpool up.
Wagner is overrated by some on here. I'll bet he wont be back in the Premiership any time soon

did I say that??

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 08 Apr 19 10.01pm

Originally posted by manoftaste

I like the Gerrard suggestion (if we could get him). Would be a bit like when we recruited Steve Coppell - great player, very young and inexperienced as a manager, respected by players, everything to prove. But why would Gerrard leave Rangers?
Further thought: We all know Roy will retire sooner rather than later, so why isn't a replacement already lined up and working as his assistant? Maybe Popovich would be interested in deputising for a year or two (if he could be tempted back from Oz to the grey skies of SE25).

Possibly because they’re sh**e and won’t win anything unless Celtic decide to keep Neal Lennon as manager.

 

fishbone Flag London 08 Apr 19 10.21pm

Do we really think that a change of management would be of help especially with our lack of funding within the transfer windows!
Hmm!

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 08 Apr 19 10.49pm

For those arguing for a change of manager:

[Link]

[Link]

No to big name former players and yes to someone like Hodgson who has a ton of experience in the lower leagues, and has a record of doing what we need.

Mid table security and a cup run will do it for me.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Kant Flag exeter 08 Apr 19 11.39pm

When a club first gets promoted to the PL its fans are delirious with joy. For the next few seasons they are satisfied if their team avoids relegation. Staying up is an achievement in itself and one to be proud of. But as time goes by, complacency sets it. Mere survival is, as Danny Kelly puts it, the thinnest of gruel. It’s no longer sufficient to satisfy the appetite of the fans. Aspirations outstrip stretched finances as expectations soar. The fans turn on the manager and the Charlton Syndrome sets in. ‘He’s taken us as far as he can’, they cry. ‘Let’s ditch him for someone who can take us to the next level.’ They call for the man who showed promise when failing in his previous job or the recently retired player with little experience who is looking for his next stepping stone. In reality there is no sustainable ‘next level’. The best that can be achieved is the mere survival that the fans reject. The inexorable clamour to ‘push on’ ends in failure and the club returns to the ranks from which it came. Hope springs eternal of a swift return to the Premiership, so that the cycle can begin again.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 08 Apr 19 11.42pm

Originally posted by Kant

When a club first gets promoted to the PL its fans are delirious with joy. For the next few seasons they are satisfied if their team avoids relegation. Staying up is an achievement in itself and one to be proud of. But as time goes by, complacency sets it. Mere survival is, as Danny Kelly puts it, the thinnest of gruel. It’s no longer sufficient to satisfy the appetite of the fans. Aspirations outstrip stretched finances as expectations soar. The fans turn on the manager and the Charlton Syndrome sets in. ‘He’s taken us as far as he can’, they cry. ‘Let’s ditch him for someone who can take us to the next level.’ They call for the man who showed promise when failing in his previous job or the recently retired player with little experience who is looking for his next stepping stone. In reality there is no sustainable ‘next level’. The best that can be achieved is the mere survival that the fans reject. The inexorable clamour to ‘push on’ ends in failure and the club returns to the ranks from which it came. Hope springs eternal of a swift return to the Premiership, so that the cycle can begin again.

There was an excellent article, a few years ago, on the success of Sevilla in Spain. Their model was to accept they are mid-table, and to make sure they stayed there but went for the cups. We have fans who seems to think we should be challenging for Europe each year. It’s silly. We don’t have the money to do that year in year out. I’d settle for safety and a decent cup run every couple of years.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 09 Apr 19 12.12am

Originally posted by Kant

When a club first gets promoted to the PL its fans are delirious with joy. For the next few seasons they are satisfied if their team avoids relegation. Staying up is an achievement in itself and one to be proud of. But as time goes by, complacency sets it. Mere survival is, as Danny Kelly puts it, the thinnest of gruel. It’s no longer sufficient to satisfy the appetite of the fans. Aspirations outstrip stretched finances as expectations soar. The fans turn on the manager and the Charlton Syndrome sets in. ‘He’s taken us as far as he can’, they cry. ‘Let’s ditch him for someone who can take us to the next level.’ They call for the man who showed promise when failing in his previous job or the recently retired player with little experience who is looking for his next stepping stone. In reality there is no sustainable ‘next level’. The best that can be achieved is the mere survival that the fans reject. The inexorable clamour to ‘push on’ ends in failure and the club returns to the ranks from which it came. Hope springs eternal of a swift return to the Premiership, so that the cycle can begin again.

And your 3 replacements should roy step down are?

 

dorking Flag 09 Apr 19 5.49am

Claude Puel - top half finishes for Southampton and Leicester. Leicester sacked him when they were 12th FFS!

Rafa Benitez - Champions League winner, need I say more! Suspect he's running down the clock on his contract so he can manage in a different country for £££ though

Sean Dyche - not pretty, but he'd know what we need and keep us up each season

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 09 Apr 19 7.14am

Originally posted by Kant

When a club first gets promoted to the PL its fans are delirious with joy. For the next few seasons they are satisfied if their team avoids relegation. Staying up is an achievement in itself and one to be proud of. But as time goes by, complacency sets it. Mere survival is, as Danny Kelly puts it, the thinnest of gruel. It’s no longer sufficient to satisfy the appetite of the fans. Aspirations outstrip stretched finances as expectations soar. The fans turn on the manager and the Charlton Syndrome sets in. ‘He’s taken us as far as he can’, they cry. ‘Let’s ditch him for someone who can take us to the next level.’ They call for the man who showed promise when failing in his previous job or the recently retired player with little experience who is looking for his next stepping stone. In reality there is no sustainable ‘next level’. The best that can be achieved is the mere survival that the fans reject. The inexorable clamour to ‘push on’ ends in failure and the club returns to the ranks from which it came. Hope springs eternal of a swift return to the Premiership, so that the cycle can begin again.

Fully agree and a good post. When we came up we laughed at other clubs fans as being too over demanding, thinking they were better than they were and that we wouldn't be like that. We prided ourselves on our togetherness and fully fledged support even though we were playing worse than we are now. Now we are no different. As soon as there is a poor result forums are littered with criticism.

For years we bemoaned the lack of managerial stability, and now we have it every time something goes wrong Roy is past it or a doddling old man. I hope he stays with us for 2 to 3 years more. Who his replacement will be after that we just don't know now as we all know things, and who is the manager is in ascendancy in a few years time we simply do not know.

 

Kant Flag exeter 09 Apr 19 7.16am

Originally posted by spartakev2

And your 3 replacements should roy step down are?

As Roy has given no indication of stepping down the question is at best premature.

I have no desire to add to the “clamour “ for him to be replaced, which is what this exercise essentially is. When the day of his departure arrives I think we will struggle to find a man with a better track record at a bottom 14 club. The astonishing level of support on here for the likes of Wagner simply evidences the dearth of talent available.

But I know my view will be increasingly a minority one as the cycle I’ve mentioned reaches its zenith and the mounting disenchantment with mere survival leads us back to the Championship.

 

aashman12 Flag 09 Apr 19 7.58am

Originally posted by dorking

Claude Puel - top half finishes for Southampton and Leicester. Leicester sacked him when they were 12th FFS!

Rafa Benitez - Champions League winner, need I say more! Suspect he's running down the clock on his contract so he can manage in a different country for £££ though

Sean Dyche - not pretty, but he'd know what we need and keep us up each season

And our fans are bored with Roy's football,

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 09 Apr 19 8.01am

Originally posted by Kant

Edited by hastingseagle67 (09 Apr 2019 8.03am)

Edited by hastingseagle67 (09 Apr 2019 8.05am)

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

hastingseagle67 Flag 09 Apr 19 8.13am

Originally posted by Kant

As Roy has given no indication of stepping down the question is at best premature.

I have no desire to add to the “clamour “ for him to be replaced, which is what this exercise essentially is. When the day of his departure arrives I think we will struggle to find a man with a better track record at a bottom 14 club. The astonishing level of support on here for the likes of Wagner simply evidences the dearth of talent available.

But I know my view will be increasingly a minority one as the cycle I’ve mentioned reaches its zenith and the mounting disenchantment with mere survival leads us back to the Championship.

I started this thread not to clamour for Roy's exit but because I was frustrated with people calling for Roy's head but not having what I considered a valid replacement. I was curious to gauge who people thought would actually be a viable option and their reasoning behind it. I personally would not be unhappy to see Roy as our manager next season but I also realize his limitations and that it is important to always stay one step ahead of the game. The industry is ever evolving and it is important to remain proactive rather than reactive which has sadly not been the case in the past. Your first post on this thread about fan expectations was excellent by the way.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Apr 19 8.22am

Originally posted by dorking

Claude Puel - top half finishes for Southampton and Leicester. Leicester sacked him when they were 12th FFS!

Rafa Benitez - Champions League winner, need I say more! Suspect he's running down the clock on his contract so he can manage in a different country for £££ though

Sean Dyche - not pretty, but he'd know what we need and keep us up each season

When Leicester sacked him they had lost 6 of their previous 8 games which included home defeats to struggling Southampton and Cardiff and his last game was that 4-1 defeat against us.Leicester also lost to Newport Co in the FA cup so the direction of travel wasn't encouraging.Leicester have won 5 out of 6 since Puel departed.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 09 Apr 19 8.35am

Originally posted by Kant

As Roy has given no indication of stepping down the question is at best premature.

I have no desire to add to the “clamour “ for him to be replaced, which is what this exercise essentially is. When the day of his departure arrives I think we will struggle to find a man with a better track record at a bottom 14 club. The astonishing level of support on here for the likes of Wagner simply evidences the dearth of talent available.

But I know my view will be increasingly a minority one as the cycle I’ve mentioned reaches its zenith and the mounting disenchantment with mere survival leads us back to the Championship.

Most of the disenchanted Palace fans I come across are not unhappy with our position but the way we have attained it. Understandably people would like some entertainment for their money, because surely that is important? It is the same reason Puel was unpopular at two different clubs despite decent results. It is the same reason Allardyce was unpopular at West Ham and Everton. Roy has done a good job of organising the team and ensuring we get enough points and I'm thankful for that and I am not clamouring for him to be replaced. However, at 71 time is not exactly on his side and so it is only prudent to be looking at the future, be it next season or the one after. As to Wagner, see what Huddersfield fans have to say and I think you'll find it hard to find many clubs with so few points that still support their manager.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Apr 19 8.43am

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Most of the disenchanted Palace fans I come across are not unhappy with our position but the way we have attained it. Understandably people would like some entertainment for their money, because surely that is important? It is the same reason Puel was unpopular at two different clubs despite decent results. It is the same reason Allardyce was unpopular at West Ham and Everton. Roy has done a good job of organising the team and ensuring we get enough points and I'm thankful for that and I am not clamouring for him to be replaced. However, at 71 time is not exactly on his side and so it is only prudent to be looking at the future, be it next season or the one after. As to Wagner, see what Huddersfield fans have to say and I think you'll find it hard to find many clubs with so few points that still support their manager.

When Wagner first arrived at Huddersfield they were struggling and they finished a lowly 19th in the Championship.
The following season he led them to promotion via the play-offs after finishing 5th so that was some turnaround.
In the PL in their first season,they were favourites for the drop but survived finishing 16th.
He built up a lot of credit at the club and their supporters look over his overall time at the club rather than just focusing on this season.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 09 Apr 19 8.46am

Originally posted by dorking

Claude Puel - top half finishes for Southampton and Leicester. Leicester sacked him when they were 12th FFS!

Rafa Benitez - Champions League winner, need I say more! Suspect he's running down the clock on his contract so he can manage in a different country for £££ though

Sean Dyche - not pretty, but he'd know what we need and keep us up each season

According to Hodgson's critics, this is what Roy is doing. Actually I would contend that the football would be worse under Dyche.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 3 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best three replacements if Roy steps down