You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy


Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >
Spiderman Flag Horsham 12 Aug 19 8.39pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

People that are claiming it's 3m are wrong its a deal up to 8m so again we have gone and over paid.

total for this window is around 11-12m if you include fees and add ons doesn't look like good business again.

I do not disbelieve you but have you got a link? The Everton fans I spoke to on Saturday were of the opinion it was 3 and said what a bargain we had.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 12 Aug 19 10.33pm

Originally posted by lush1076

He was ok. Tired in the second half.
Camarasa was good first half but again got tired in the second.
Cahill was good and looked match fit.
McGregor caught the eye as the stand out youngster.
Lokilo was sloppy in possession.
Daly may struggle with his size to make any impact.
Pierrick was quiet.

Thanks for this.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 13 Aug 19 3.24pm

Originally posted by lush1076

He was ok. Tired in the second half.
Camarasa was good first half but again got tired in the second.
Cahill was good and looked match fit.
McGregor caught the eye as the stand out youngster.
Lokilo was sloppy in possession.
Daly may struggle with his size to make any impact.
Pierrick was quiet.

Thanks

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 18 Aug 19 12.30pm

Originally posted by YT

Wouldn't it be good to at least let the man put on a Palace shirt a few times before we judge him?

That's asking a lot!

 

Nubes Flag London 19 Aug 19 6.49pm

I felt quite encouraged by his tenacity and willingness to get stuck in.

He showed a fire that doesn’t seem to be inside any of our other midfielders.

 

EddieMac Flag 19 Aug 19 6.54pm

Originally posted by Nubes

I felt quite encouraged by his tenacity and willingness to get stuck in.

He showed a fire that doesn’t seem to be inside any of our other midfielders.

He has been knocked by a lot on here since we signed him because of his injuries but if he stays fit he just what we need in the middle of the park. He may be small in stature but he is a tough player and can pass the ball about.

I am hoping he starts on Saturday but knowing Roy he will be on the bench for months while that stocking of piss Schlupp gets a run ahead of him.

 

Nubes Flag London 19 Aug 19 6.55pm

I felt quite encouraged by his tenacity and willingness to get stuck in.

He showed a fire that doesn’t seem to be inside any of our other midfielders.

 

Nubes Flag London 19 Aug 19 6.57pm

I hope Roy saw what he brought to the table.

His through balls - made the Sheffield defenders turn to face their own goal on a couple of occasions and he jus needs to be given game time - especially against Brighton!

 

EddieMac Flag 19 Aug 19 7.16pm

Originally posted by Nubes

I hope Roy saw what he brought to the table.

His through balls - made the Sheffield defenders turn to face their own goal on a couple of occasions and he jus needs to be given game time - especially against Brighton!

Roy has been chasing him for a couple years now so it shouldnt take long to get him into the team.

Id be happy with this team when all fit:

Guita
Ward Sakho Tomkins PVA

Milo

Townsend Mccarthty Zaha

Camarrasa

Benteke or Wickham

 

beak Flag croydon 19 Aug 19 7.25pm

So how often is it likely that the best eleven will all be available to play,fitness,bookings possible sulky wingers not performing etc ,the answer is rarely ,we will probably get an eleven like yesterday most weeks.Trust me Sheffield Utd are relegation fodder we are worse.

Originally posted by EddieMac

Roy has been chasing him for a couple years now so it shouldnt take long to get him into the team.

Id be happy with this team when all fit:

Guita
Ward Sakho Tomkins PVA

Milo

Townsend Mccarthty Zaha

Camarrasa

Benteke or Wickham

 

Nubes Flag London 19 Aug 19 7.26pm

The line up looks ready.

I’m jus not sure about Wickham!

Benteke has been done to death!

But Wickham - I feel Ayew will be the better option for creating chances .

 

PatrickA Flag London 19 Aug 19 8.25pm

This may prove to be a controversial view , but here goes... is Luka undroppable?
Yes he’s our captain, top scorer for the last two seasons and has just been awarded a 4 year deal.
However, in my view he has not played well for a while and I can’t see exactly what he does during the course of a game.
He’s one paced, gives away needless fouls in dangerous areas, is often sloppy in possession and seems to lack energy in the midfield area..
He has a strong character and does not lack effort (or penalty taking skills) but is that enough?

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 19 Aug 19 9.15pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

This may prove to be a controversial view , but here goes... is Luka undroppable?
Yes he’s our captain, top scorer for the last two seasons and has just been awarded a 4 year deal.
However, in my view he has not played well for a while and I can’t see exactly what he does during the course of a game.
He’s one paced, gives away needless fouls in dangerous areas, is often sloppy in possession and seems to lack energy in the midfield area..
He has a strong character and does not lack effort (or penalty taking skills) but is that enough?

You want my answer? Luka isnt a defensive midfielder, we havent had one since he joined but now McCarthy is here that hole is filled. You'll see luka playing further forward now that McCarthyr can do the doggy work in front of the defence and luka will be at his best.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 19 Aug 19 9.37pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

You want my answer? Luka isnt a defensive midfielder, we havent had one since he joined but now McCarthy is here that hole is filled. You'll see luka playing further forward now that McCarthyr can do the doggy work in front of the defence and luka will be at his best.

Pretty sure he is. In fact I remember one of his first interviews he was asked where he played and he said "defensive midfielder".

Am excited by the prospect of JM though.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 19 Aug 19 10.13pm

Might be a regular by November. Roy takes his time.

 

merganser Flag 19 Aug 19 10.27pm

I am sad to have to agree with PatricikA.

I’m not sure that, as skipper, Luca is much of a motivator either.

His performance on Sunday was lamentable. He should have been subbed.

His success as a penalty-taker has masked his many deficiencies .

Offering him a contract for as long as four years was folly.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Aug 19 12.18am

Originally posted by merganser

I am sad to have to agree with PatricikA.

I’m not sure that, as skipper, Luca is much of a motivator either.

His performance on Sunday was lamentable. He should have been subbed.

His success as a penalty-taker has masked his many deficiencies .

Offering him a contract for as long as four years was folly.

I disagree, he often takes one for the team. Possibly one of the best defensive midfielders in the League. Trouble is we lack any kind of out ball. Everyone so weak, perhaps Townsend the only player genuinely pushing forward. When Zaha is fit/ bothered at least we have a couple of options. Benteke is not holding play up or even reaching the pace of play

 


Red and Blue Army!

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 20 Aug 19 2.13am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Roy has been chasing him for a couple years now so it shouldnt take long to get him into the team.

Id be happy with this team when all fit:

Guita
Ward Sakho Tomkins PVA

Milo

Townsend Mccarthty Zaha

Camarrasa

Benteke or Wickham

I want Benteke to score, but until he starts doing so I’d rather Wickham or Ayew as they at least put in some effort. If a striker can’t score then he needs to do much more to contribute to overall play than Benteke does.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

sprites Flag Auckland 20 Aug 19 4.49am

Originally posted by merganser

I am sad to have to agree with PatricikA.

I’m not sure that, as skipper, Luca is much of a motivator either.

His performance on Sunday was lamentable. He should have been subbed.

His success as a penalty-taker has masked his many deficiencies .

Offering him a contract for as long as four years was folly.

Total tosh.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 20 Aug 19 7.29am

Originally posted by EddieMac

Roy has been chasing him for a couple years now so it shouldnt take long to get him into the team.

Id be happy with this team when all fit:

Guita
Ward Sakho Tomkins PVA

Milo

Townsend Mccarthty Zaha

Camarrasa

Benteke or Wickham


how can you be happy with PVA, yes i know we don't have anyone else to play LB, but we should have.

 

Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy