You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Bernado Silva
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bernado Silva


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 27 Sep 19 7.07pm

Here is an article on the chocolate brand character Silva likened Mendy to.


[Link]

Edited by ASCPFC (27 Sep 2019 7.08pm)

Edited by ASCPFC (27 Sep 2019 7.08pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 27 Sep 19 10.13pm

Load of fuss about nothing.
Ssn had John Barnes on the other day and he told them ( much to their very obvious disappointment ) that the tweet wasn't offensive or racist.
He also asked why people were offended on Mendys behalf when he himself had no problem with it.
Btw if you watch the documentary on Citeh on prime, Bernado is probably the most popular bloke at the club.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Sep 19 9.08am

Originally posted by sickboy

Load of fuss about nothing.
Ssn had John Barnes on the other day and he told them ( much to their very obvious disappointment ) that the tweet wasn't offensive or racist.
He also asked why people were offended on Mendys behalf when he himself had no problem with it.
Btw if you watch the documentary on Citeh on prime, Bernado is probably the most popular bloke at the club.

I just found the whole situation pretty funny. If you can't joke with a mate without offending everyone then what next? The chocolate peanut treats would probably not go down well in the UK though.

 


Red and Blue Army!

samprior Flag Hamburg 28 Sep 19 10.09am

I guess the arguement is more that this is public vs private. A joke between friends in private it's up to them and rightly so. A joke in the public domain i.e t***ter which is like shouting that same joke across a busy high street. Someone could well be offended (most likely as it's not meant for them) and then others love to start being offended on behalf of someone else who's been offended etc etc. Once this happens there's a story to be made and some 'clicks' to be had.

The simple solution don't use t***ter.

Haha I thought I was being clever by replacing the I for an A in twitter. Damn algorithm got me...its the end of free speech and the end to society! Don't trust the algorithms

Edited by samprior (28 Sep 2019 10.12am)

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 28 Sep 19 1.06pm

The naked joke by Silva was a bit cringeworthy. Shades of blackness seemed to come into it. I think mates should be able to say what they like though.

 


Red and Blue Army!

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Oct 19 10.16am

Just been charged with misconduct.

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 02 Oct 19 11.16am

Pathetic that he's been charged. Can't even have a laugh with a mate anymore. World is so bloody stupid now!

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 02 Oct 19 11.35am

The world has gone mad.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 02 Oct 19 11.57am

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

The world has gone mad.


Just nosey parker's and do gooders thinking they can rule the world.
Feel sorry on someone else's behalf.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 02 Oct 19 12.57pm

Bureaucratic and tokenistic garbage.

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 03 Oct 19 9.06am

I find it totally bizarre that Mendy wasn't offended by being compared to a picture of a black man!!

Seriously though, why can't Mendy just tell all the do-gooders to mind their own f**king business.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 Oct 19 9.28am

Originally posted by stuckinbristol

I find it totally bizarre that Mendy wasn't offended by being compared to a picture of a black man!!

Seriously though, why can't Mendy just tell all the do-gooders to mind their own f**king business.

Erm, not quite ‘a picture of a black man’ is it?

I think a distinction has to be made between being racially offensive and racially insensitive - this would fall into the latter for me. Bernardo is clearly not a racist, but equally someone of his profile is never going to have a free pass to put things like that in the public domain - him and Mendy obviously have a good enough relationship that jokes like that are fine between them, but approach a black stranger with that cartoon and say you look like him and see what sort of reaction you get - if people see him get away with that on a Twitter, it normalises the behaviour.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Oct 19 10.22am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Erm, not quite ‘a picture of a black man’ is it?

I think a distinction has to be made between being racially offensive and racially insensitive - this would fall into the latter for me. Bernardo is clearly not a racist, but equally someone of his profile is never going to have a free pass to put things like that in the public domain - him and Mendy obviously have a good enough relationship that jokes like that are fine between them, but approach a black stranger with that cartoon and say you look like him and see what sort of reaction you get - if people see him get away with that on a Twitter, it normalises the behaviour.

White people are depicted in cartoons in various ways. If a black player compared a white player to one such cartoon on a crisp packet would this be deemed "Racially insensitive" and would there be a furore to this effect with 'Kick it out' getting involved ?

Perhaps I am not cerebrally blessed sufficiently to understand all the intricacies of such matters and as such don't have the 'Bandwith' mentally to absorb all the arguments.

Edited by Willo (03 Oct 2019 10.39am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 03 Oct 19 10.27am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Erm, not quite ‘a picture of a black man’ is it?

I think a distinction has to be made between being racially offensive and racially insensitive - this would fall into the latter for me. Bernardo is clearly not a racist, but equally someone of his profile is never going to have a free pass to put things like that in the public domain - him and Mendy obviously have a good enough relationship that jokes like that are fine between them, but approach a black stranger with that cartoon and say you look like him and see what sort of reaction you get - if people see him get away with that on a Twitter, it normalises the behaviour.

Nail on head. Close thread

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 Oct 19 10.40am

Originally posted by Willo

White people are depicted in cartoons in various ways. If a black player compared a white player to one such cartoon on a crisp packet would this be deemed "Racially insensitive" and would there be a furore to this effect with 'Kick it out' getting involved ?

Perhaps I am not cerebrally blessed sufficiently to understand all the intracacies of such matters and as such don't have the 'Bandwith' mentally to absorb all the arguments.

Edited by Willo (03 Oct 2019 10.28am)

This cartoon specifically is a caricature of black features - it’s not just any old cartoon of a black man, so there are obvious connotations attached to that.

If one of Gareth Thomas’ teammates put a photo of him next to a charicatured OTT gay bloke, do you think it would get a free pass on Twitter? Of course not.

As I said, if Bernardo and Mendy’s relationship is such that jokes like that are fair game, then crack on in private, but it’s never going to get a free pass in public, and nor should it.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Oct 19 10.57am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This cartoon specifically is a caricature of black features - it’s not just any old cartoon of a black man, so there are obvious connotations attached to that.

If one of Gareth Thomas’ teammates put a photo of him next to a charicatured OTT gay bloke, do you think it would get a free pass on Twitter? Of course not.

As I said, if Bernardo and Mendy’s relationship is such that jokes like that are fair game, then crack on in private, but it’s never going to get a free pass in public, and nor should it.

Black features are black features,nothing to be ashamed about.I have seen handsome black men with such features and the same applies to black ladies pleasing to the eye.

Theresa May has been 'Cartoonised' with a certain facial feature exagerrated for effect.If one compared a white public figure to an image of her in a cartoon, would there be the same furore ? It would probably be deemed crass or insensitive but alas the PC Brigade would,I dare to suggest,not be so active in their condemnation.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 Oct 19 11.06am

Originally posted by Willo

Black features are black features,nothing to be ashamed about.I have seen handsome black men with such features and the same applies to black ladies pleasing to the eye.

Theresa May has been 'Cartoonised' with a certain facial feature exagerrated for effect.If one compared a white public figure to an image of her in a cartoon, would there be the same furore ? It would probably be deemed crass or insensitive but alas the PC Brigade would,I dare to suggest,not be so active in their condemnation.

You understand what a charicature is, right? So we are not talking about real black features.. we’re talking about exaggerating said features for comedic effect.

Conveniently swerved the Gareth Thomas point; nicely done.

The exaggerated features are tied to race - that’s the difference between this and your Theresa May example.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 03 Oct 19 11.20am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You understand what a charicature is, right? So we are not talking about real black features.. we’re talking about exaggerating said features for comedic effect.

Conveniently swerved the Gareth Thomas point; nicely done.

The exaggerated features are tied to race - that’s the difference between this and your Theresa May example.


With respect I have not sought to deflect from any question at all.I believe the arguments I advanced provided an insight into my view on this matter.

Apropos your final paragraph, my view is that exaggerated features are just that irrespective of race but we clearly see this differently.

We will have to agree to disagree but I respect your opinion.

Just to add that over the years I have met many black people and know some to this day.I categorize them as pillars of society and we have had a healthy and cordial relationship with a bellyfull of laughs and banter!


Edited by Willo (03 Oct 2019 11.51am)

 

sickboy Flag Deal or Croydon 03 Oct 19 11.56am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

You understand what a charicature is, right? So we are not talking about real black features.. we’re talking about exaggerating said features for comedic effect.

Conveniently swerved the Gareth Thomas point; nicely done.

The exaggerated features are tied to race - that’s the difference between this and your Theresa May example.

John Barnes mentioned the charicature point the other week while defending Bernados tweet.
He compared it to a caricature of Phil Thompson which would have a huge nose. He then said a charicature of a black person would have oversized lips. Because its a caricature.
He also said Mendy wasnt offended and he didnt find it offensive either and that people should stop being offended on behalf of those involved.
Raheem Stirling has also come out in defence of Bernado too.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 03 Oct 19 12.04pm

Originally posted by sickboy

John Barnes mentioned the charicature point the other week while defending Bernados tweet.
He compared it to a caricature of Phil Thompson which would have a huge nose. He then said a charicature of a black person would have oversized lips. Because its a caricature.
He also said Mendy wasnt offended and he didnt find it offensive either and that people should stop being offended on behalf of those involved.
Raheem Stirling has also come out in defence of Bernado too.

John Barnes has very cleverly positioned himself as the ‘alternative black opinion’ in a lot of the talks around issues like this - he knows there’s huge appetite for ‘anti-PC’ opinions these days, so he exploits it. There are hundreds of examples of black people who did take issue with this, but we’re supposed to just listen to the one who didn’t?

Again, I don’t think this is about racial offence, but more around insensitivity, so this ‘stop being offended on others behalf’ is just more pandering to his audience.

As I said in my original post, I don’t for one minute think Bernardo is a racist bloke, so it’s not surprising Sterling has defended him.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Bernado Silva