You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Captain


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Oct 19 2.44pm

Although I am a fan of LM, there is no doubt in my mind that Cahill is a born leader and did a great job yesterday. That was a very competent team performance led by Cahill.
I dare say its a sensitive issue for Roy, but in my view GC is head and shoulders above LM in that role. it could be that it would relieve LM of a pressure which may suit his play.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Oct 19 2.52pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Although I am a fan of LM, there is no doubt in my mind that Cahill is a born leader and did a great job yesterday. That was a very competent team performance led by Cahill.
I dare say its a sensitive issue for Roy, but in my view GC is head and shoulders above LM in that role. it could be that it would relieve LM of a pressure which may suit his play.

Think you’re right. Captaincy doesn’t seem to be helping Luka’s game and Cahill is a natural so let’s capitalise while we have him.

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 06 Oct 19 3.15pm

Fully agree with this, I feel he'd be more respected by refs, he did a great job yesterday. The Benteke penalty against Bournemouth made me lose confidence in LM as a captain, he may get to focus on his game rather than passing it backwards and taking 'one for the team' every so often and picking up so many yellows

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 06 Oct 19 3.39pm

Never going to happen. What does anybody on here know about professional football leadership anyway?

Do you really think everyone in the dressing room is going to nod and be happy if Roy takes Luka aside and tells him Cahill's a better leader.

We deservedly won yesterday, partly because West Ham couldn't capitalise and looked shoddy at 1-1.
If we'd have lost no one here would be shouting for Cahill to be captain.

He did a great job but Cahill's been here for five minutes. The last thing Luka wants after signing a well earned contract extension is for him to be told he's not worthy of the captaincy.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 06 Oct 19 4.30pm

Originally posted by EaglesEaglesEagles

Never going to happen. What does anybody on here know about professional football leadership anyway?

Do you really think everyone in the dressing room is going to nod and be happy if Roy takes Luka aside and tells him Cahill's a better leader.

We deservedly won yesterday, partly because West Ham couldn't capitalise and looked shoddy at 1-1.
If we'd have lost no one here would be shouting for Cahill to be captain.

He did a great job but Cahill's been here for five minutes. The last thing Luka wants after signing a well earned contract extension is for him to be told he's not worthy of the captaincy.

Think you are right. However whether Luka should be in the team at all based on performances is another question. He has looked a liability with a couple of rash challenges a couple of times this season. Thought we looked fairly solid in both midfield and defense yesterday.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

VinceHilaire Flag London 06 Oct 19 6.06pm

Strange one this.... I personally thought McCarthy and McArthur looked a very strong partnership. They complimented each other very well and certainly gave us a new dimension in Midfield.

I guess the decision is whether you can play Milivojevic with McArthur and Mccarthy? Who would you drop? Kouyaté?

 

deetee Flag 06 Oct 19 7.54pm

Cahill seems a more natural skipper. He talks a lot which Luka doesn't appear to. However Roy should NOT take the armband away this season.

 

PA Flag Bedfordshire 06 Oct 19 8.02pm

Defo leave the armband with LM even if GC is more betterer. Would cause a rumpus we don’t need

That said, I wouldn’t change a winning team so LM should wait for his next start. Might make him think twice about needless yellows.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 06 Oct 19 8.40pm

Think Cahill would be a better skipper, but wouldn’t change it this season. He can still have a big influence without the armband.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 06 Oct 19 8.52pm

Lets not get carried away . We could quite easily have been done yesterday had the hapless hammers taken their chances and VG hadn't been in the right place at the right time .
Not that it wasn't a decent performance and 3 well earned points in the end but changing the dressing room is one way of destroying the ,well dressing room .

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 06 Oct 19 9.56pm

Cahill is an extremely experienced player and he brings that to the game in terms of his play. I'm not sure he's a talker though. But then I don't see it in Luka either. Maybe captaincy in this era is rare /otherwise overrated.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Uphill Flag Bedford 08 Oct 19 2.50pm

Cahill may not be a 'good talker' but his organisational skills are patently obvious.

If anyone is going to improve Gaita's shaky liaison with his defenders it could be him.

Luka is not the player many think he is and to collect 5 yellows in 7 matches shows up both his ability and temperament. Along with others he was absent in the 0-4 against Spurs.

I would make Cahill the captain and keep James McCarthy
in as he has shown in a short while he has ability and ball playing skills.

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 09 Oct 19 11.14am

For me, at the moment, its not so much whether Luka should pass the captaincy to Cahill but whether he comes straight back into the side for the next match.

We saw against the Hammers that we can perform well without him. I think his performances of late have not been anything special and all too often his passing is poor. And sometime soon he is going to be sent off.

Having said that I suspect Roy will put him straight back into the team.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 09 Oct 19 12.23pm

LM should go straight back into the team and as Captain but this will not affect the influence of Cahill as he is a born leader and is a more than able deputy. The last thing Roy would wish to do is rock the boat when there is no need.

 


Bring back Brolin

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Oct 19 1.54pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

LM should go straight back into the team and as Captain but this will not affect the influence of Cahill as he is a born leader and is a more than able deputy. The last thing Roy would wish to do is rock the boat when there is no need.

I feel this will be the case, with LM replacing McCarthy and captaining the team.

 

Pierre Flag Purley 09 Oct 19 3.24pm

Of course Luka should go back into the team and as captain. There is no point in even thinking of stirring the squad up with that one.
He organises the defence when he plays anyway.
There is no doubt that Cahill still possesses many very useful attributes and strange that Chelsea decided to relieve themselves of his services.
Lets hope our London neighbours still think in the same benevolent way when January comes around and we ask them about Batshuayi!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Oct 19 3.51pm

Originally posted by Pierre

Of course Luka should go back into the team and as captain. There is no point in even thinking of stirring the squad up with that one.
He organises the defence when he plays anyway.
There is no doubt that Cahill still possesses many very useful attributes and strange that Chelsea decided to relieve themselves of his services.
Lets hope our London neighbours still think in the same benevolent way when January comes around and we ask them about Batshuayi!

He only made 2 PL appearances last season, he is 34 later this year and they had Rudiger,Zouma,Christensen and Tomori on their books.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 09 Oct 19 4.00pm

Originally posted by Pete53

For me, at the moment, its not so much whether Luka should pass the captaincy to Cahill but whether he comes straight back into the side for the next match.

We saw against the Hammers that we can perform well without him. I think his performances of late have not been anything special and all too often his passing is poor. And sometime soon he is going to be sent off.

Having said that I suspect Roy will put him straight back into the team.

Agree with this assessment. He is a cynical fouler and has poor passing ability. McArthur and McCarthy are more efficient in midfield. His captaincy was exposed over the Benteke penalty incident. Unfortunately for my opinion the manager does not agree and he, not me, is in charge!

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Oct 19 4.15pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Agree with this assessment. He is a cynical fouler and has poor passing ability. McArthur and McCarthy are more efficient in midfield. His captaincy was exposed over the Benteke penalty incident. Unfortunately for my opinion the manager does not agree and he, not me, is in charge!

2019-20 : 5 yellows
2018-19 : 11 yellows
2017-18 : 10 yellows.

Breaks play up so often works in our favour !

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 09 Oct 19 7.06pm

I think there are 2 main areas where Luka could do better. Firstly I have winced several times at his challenges when already on a yellow and am really not sure how he has not got a second in some of those games. I guess you can say that there is a reckless streak that may well come back and bite him.

Then as a leader he doesn’t talk enough to the referee or intervene when a good captain should. When Wilf was working so hard to get himself sent off at Southampton it needed his captain to be in there pulling him away and telling him to shut his gob. I don’t think he shows leadership then

Whether anybody else would do better is however both speculation and academic

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain