This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
Since the introduction of VAR we have really benefited and had some crucial decisions go our way. Is this because we are a fast counter attacking team and refs don't always see what really happened or is it just luck and we will eventually have to suffer some not so happy VAR decisions ? I suspect the latter... both the Villa and Arsenal goals that were disallowed were extremely soft; it either of those got disallowed for us, I’d be fuming.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Supporters were critical of referees decisions on the field of play, insisting they needed help and citing technology.Now criticism has extended to VAR ! I have always maintained that when subjective decisions are made there will always be room for controversy and that it is not a panacea. Edited by Willo (29 Oct 2019 1.42pm) They’re making more correct decisions, and this will improve further as the officials become more experienced with its application. Of course there will always be decisions which divide opinion, but if we can ensure officials are correct more often, it’s a no brainer to use it.
|
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
Since the introduction of VAR we have really benefited and had some crucial decisions go our way. Is this because we are a fast counter attacking team and refs don't always see what really happened or is it just luck and we will eventually have to suffer some not so happy VAR decisions ? I think its luck and it will even itself out over the course of the season (as do normal refereeing decisions), although I always felt we would benefit more than most due to Zaha regularly not being awarded penalties for fouls in the box. Although we're getting the rub of the green currently, I still hate it. The Arsenal 3rd goal was a disgraceful decision and someone should lose their job over it. I said it before and will say it again - too many crucial decisions are subjective and there are not many 'clear and obvious errors'. If each captain was given one review per game to challenge a decision it would cut out this nonsense of checking every goal for 3 minutes. It's over used and fans are having the glory of goal celebrations taken away from them. Can fans even celebrate now being 100% confident of it standing? Edited by Goal Machine (29 Oct 2019 2.01pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by The_Aviator
It does seem to remove some of the big club bias that referees often seemed to bow to, especially when said big clubs were at home. Easier to be dispassionate sitting in an air conditioned room at Stockley Park. It has been well documented that I don't subscribe to this chain of thought and have had a plethora of fiesty contretemps with debates evolving into dastardly 'Willo threads'. VAR has ruled correctly on matters of fact ie marginal offside decisions, but whenever subjective decisions need to be made there will always be differences of opinion.I believe that supporters and others hoped that VAR would eliminate simulation but alas decisions relating to this aspect of the game are still open to debate because of their subjective nature. Finally we have heard about a 'High bar', last weekend it was asserted there was a 'Low bar' and of course there has been some criticism of referees not availing of the pitchside monitors.Debate is more about VAR these days than the actual game! Edited by Willo (29 Oct 2019 3.17pm)
|
|
|
I do agree things will even out just as referees decisions have done in the past. In case anyone is counting, its only one VAR decision we have been fortunate with. I don't think the Villa goal went to VAR as it was a free kick for simulation outside the area. Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I suspect the latter... both the Villa and Arsenal goals that were disallowed were extremely soft; it either of those got disallowed for us, I’d be fuming.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I'm afraid Willo that although big club bias may not be a certitude, inflammatory media will bring any referee trouble should their decisions having bearing on the outcome of games, titles, career, etc, and a referee's fear becomes a exponential part of the game resulting in what appears to be big club bias. It is easy for Clattenberg et al to comment from an armchair, much like us, or indeed Stockley Park, but during a game their mind will always be on the scrutiny they receive based on decisions. Therefore, big club bias should probably read as 'fragile career toeing of the line'. Fear is a big clubs greatest asset, not only against the opposition.
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet. |
|
|
Originally posted by pstrutt
Originally posted by Willo
I'm afraid Willo that although big club bias may not be a certitude, inflammatory media will bring any referee trouble should their decisions having bearing on the outcome of games, titles, career, etc, and a referee's fear becomes a exponential part of the game resulting in what appears to be big club bias. It is easy for Clattenberg et al to comment from an armchair, much like us, or indeed Stockley Park, but during a game their mind will always be on the scrutiny they receive based on decisions. Therefore, big club bias should probably read as 'fragile career toeing of the line'. Fear is a big clubs greatest asset, not only against the opposition. With respect, we are on 'opposite sides of the house' on this matter. Lets' get back to VAR rather than debating the performances of referees.My views on this matter have been well and truly documented on HOL.
|
|
| Tom-the-eagle |
|
|---|---|
|
I’m going for VAR to get young player of the season.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I suspect the latter... both the Villa and Arsenal goals that were disallowed were extremely soft; it either of those got disallowed for us, I’d be fuming. ..you cannot be serious, Grealish went down too easily and had been blown up before they scored and with Arsenal Bentekes clearance hit Milivojevic on the ground setting them up to score, both were rightly chalked off.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, we are on 'opposite sides of the house' on this matter. Lets' get back to VAR rather than debating the performances of referees.My views on this matter have been well and truly documented on HOL. There is no f***ing house? I don't care what is previously documented. I am pointing out that fear factors into decision making and if you don't agree with that your commonsense has waned with age. The performance of referees 'is' the VAR debate or maybe you don't understand refereeing? My point is that VAR alleviates the fear to some degree as referees have 'assistance'.
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet. |
|
|
Originally posted by pstrutt
There is no f***ing house? I don't care what is previously documented. I am pointing out that fear factors into decision making and if you don't agree with that your commonsense has waned with age. The performance of referees 'is' the VAR debate or maybe you don't understand refereeing? My point is that VAR alleviates the fear to some degree as referees have 'assistance'. aha! the old I'm right and your wrong argument, I was wondering where it had gone! I guess mine is on the wane as well, as I certainly don't think that fear is a factor in decision making for Referees. Fear of what? Certainly the Refs are temporarily out of the spotlight, as it not the 'Refs Fault' anymore - it's VARs. But that should not make them void of the same criticism. in fact, If I were a ref it would likely increase my nervousness if VAR kept overriding my decisions - It'd means that the mistake was mine. Id want to make sure that When VAR was called it would back me up, not highlight my mistake. Referees have a tremendously difficult job to do correctly, which due to the application of rules - in Particular the 'subjective' ones and the invention of the Slow motion replay - means that the scrutiny is based on ten times the amount of data that a Referee has at the time of the decision. Are they trying to apply the rules to the best of their ability? Yes.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig
we have had 1 lucky var...arsenal's "3rd". grealish, the ref blew before and whatever happened was outside the box, so not VAR's remit. Ayew was onside Wilf was a pen... Var has done what it should have done for us. has it been abysmal elsewhere? definitely. But don't conflate that with what's happened for us. we've gained a point as far as I can remember Yes,good point, its easy to forget the the Villa game wasn't VAR, so only one lucky, so only 1 point less
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.